Dependent parents of deceased govt employee entitled to family pension: HC
'We sincerely believe that if dependent parents have to keep their mind, body and soul together, law must ensure that they receive pension for sustenance,' said a division bench of justices Ravindra Ghuge and Ashwin Bhobe, while directing the Maharashtra government to clear the family pension proposal of a septuagenarian couple from Akola, who lost their son in 2008.
In their petition, Vasantrao Deshmukh, 75, and his wife Snehalata, 75, claimed they were denied family pension after their unmarried son died due to a snake bite while working at a tribal school in October 2008.
Two years later, in September 2010, the petitioners approached the project officer of the local Integrated Tribal Development Project (ITDP) for family pension. ITDPs are designated areas where tribal people make up 50% or more of the total population.
However, in November 2010, the authorities informed the petitioners that the biological parents of a deceased state government employee are not eligible for family pension. This prompted the couple to approach the high court.
The advocates for the petitioners pointed out a government resolution (GR) dated January 22, 2015, issued by the state finance department, which said that family pension should be granted to 'wholly dependent parents of a deceased single government servant'.
The state government, however, opposed the petition, contending that the biological parents of a deceased single government employee are not covered under the definition of family under the Maharashtra Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1982. It added that the January 2015 GR could not be applied retrospectively to the case.
After hearing both sides, the bench ruled that the couple was eligible to receive family pension, saying the GR was issued with a laudable objective to achieve social security for helpless aged parents. It added that the GR should be made applicable at least to the dependent parent/s surviving on the date of the GR, even if their single child died prior to its issuance.
The court directed the state government to approve the petitioner's proposal, pay the arrears due and start paying them a regular pension from July 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Dept inquiry gives clean chit to CBI judge suspended on corruption charges
Chandigarh: In a major respite to suspended special CBI Judge Sudhir Parmar -- who was arrested by (ED) in connection with alleged bribery and favouritism in a Rs 400 crore money-laundering scam involving real estate developers -- a departmental committee has given him the clean chit in the case. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now However, the report of the inquiry officer, which cleared him of the charges, is yet to be accepted by the high court administration. Judge Parmar was facing charges of alleged misconduct, involving abuse of his position to benefit the accused in ED and CBI cases under his jurisdiction. Highly placed sources in the high court administration confirmed to TOI that Nirbhow Singh Gill, Jalandhar district and sessions judge, who was appointed the enquiry officer by Vigilance Disciplinary Committee (VDC) of the HC administration, did not find much against Parmar. The report of the enquiry officer has already been submitted to HC. Now, it will be considered by VDC before being finally taken up before the full court for a final decision. The regular departmental enquiry against Parmar was handed over to Gill on Oct 3, 2024, by VDC. While Gill was the enquiry officer, Dharminder Paul Singla, additional district judge, Jalandhar, was the presenting officer. On Oct 19, 2024, both officers started the enquiry, examining several witnesses and evidence related to the controversy. The proceedings were conducted in accordance with Haryana Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 2016. The rules, however, provide that the inquiry report is submitted before the disciplinary/punishing authority, which is obliged to take action after supplying a copy of the report to the accused employee. Once the order of exoneration or penalty is imposed, disciplinary proceedings come to an end. The clean chit to Parmar, if accepted by HC administration, would also come as a setback to Haryana state vigilance and anti-corruption bureau that first reported to the high court administration about the alleged involvement of Parmar, who was then posted as special judge-Panchkula and hearing high-profile cases related to CBI and ED. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The FIR was registered against him in Panchkula by the bureau under Sections 7, 8, 11, and 13 of Prevention of Corruption Act, read with Section 120-B of IPC. The criminal case is currently pending against Paramar. On April 27, Punjab and Haryana high court administration suspended him. Parmar also remained behind bars from Aug 10, 2023, to Nov 2, 2023, after ED arrested him in connection with this case. ED claimed that its investigation revealed that Parmar, then posted as special judge for CBI and ED cases at Panchkula, was showing favouritism to some accused persons. The suspended judge's brother, Ajay Parmar, was also arrested by the central agency in this matter. The allegations against Parmar had come as a rude shock in judicial circles, as he was considered an upright officer of Haryana Superior Judicial Services. He was appointed as special CBI judge-Panchkula after clearance of his record / antecedents by several agencies. Even several district bar associations across the state of Haryana suspended work to protest when Parmar was arrested by the ED. MSID:: 123386254 413 |
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Birth control programme only way to control stray dog population: Centre
NEW DELHI: The central government has said that it intends to control street dog population only through its animal birth control (ABC) programme that mandates civic bodies to catch and release strays to their original locations post-sterilisation. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The ABC rules, framed under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, align with global standards set by the World Organisation for Animal Health and promote the "Capture-Neuter-Vaccinate-Release method" for humane and effective stray dog population management, Union minister of state for fisheries, animal husbandry and dairying, SP Singh Baghel, informed Parliament on Tuesday. The government's stand validates the viewpoint of protesting animal rights activists who have described the Supreme Court's Aug 11 order to remove all Delhi-NCR stray dogs to shelters in far-off places as "inhumane, unscientific" and "one that violates the established ABC rules". Though the issue of stray dogs falls under the purview of state governments, the minister, in a written reply to Lok Sabha, said, "To ensure humane and effective dog population management, the central government has framed the Animal Birth Control (ABC) Rules, 2023." "Under the Rules, local bodies are responsible for implementing sterilisation and vaccination programmes in collaboration with animal welfare organisations," he said. In fact, only last month, the minister said, "...the Secretaries of the Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, and Ministry of Panchayati Raj jointly issued an advisory reiterating that sterilisation of stray dogs is central to dog population management." "The advisory urged urban local bodies to establish Animal Birth Control units and undertake large-scale sterilisation programmes, covering at least 70% of stray dogs," he said in his written reply to Lok Sabha. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Moreover, to bolster its ABC efforts, the government has revised the existing Scheme for Birth Control and Immunisation of stray dogs and stray cats, which is being implemented through the Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI) from the current financial year. Under this scheme, for sterilisation, the government has earmarked financial assistance of up to ₹800 per dog and ₹600 per cat for Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCAs) and local bodies to conduct ABC programmes. "A one-time grant of ₹2 crore is provisioned for state-run veterinary hospitals to develop facilities such as surgical theatres, kennels, and recovery units," the minister told Lok Sabha. Also, financial support of up to ₹15L and ₹27L for small and large animal shelters will be made available to urban local bodies and recognised animal welfare organisations. In addition, states will be given financial support for the procurement of anti-rabies vaccines, the minister told Parliament.
The Print
7 hours ago
- The Print
Centre backs sterilisation as ‘key to stray dog population mgmt' even as Delhi govt says it's not enough
A three-judge bench of the apex court has reserved its order on interim pleas seeking a stay on its 11 August ruling which directed authorities to round up all the stray dogs in Delhi-NCR and shift them to shelters. While many sections of society had lauded the 11 August order, the animal welfare community has been continuously protesting against it. This comes days after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Delhi government, told the Supreme Court that although sterilisation was initially an option, it wasn't enough to curb the 'stray dog menace'. 'Sterilisation does not stop rabies,' Mehta had said. New Delhi: The central government informed the Lok Sabha Tuesday that in the past year, it has issued two advisories 'reiterating that sterilisation is central to stray dog population management'. Minister of State for Fisheries, Animal Husbandry and Dairying S.P. Singh Baghel, in a written reply to a question by Congress's Amritsar MP Gurjeet Singh Aujla, also submitted that between 2022 and August 2025, a total of 12 advisories had been issued regarding the implementation of Animal Birth Control (ABC) Rules. Notably, the latest advisory on a 'Revised Animal Birth Control (ABC) module for street dogs population management, rabies eradication and reducing man-dog conflict' was issued on 11 August, the day of the SC ruling. The issue of stray dogs falls under the purview of state governments, the Centre emphasised, adding that local bodies are mandated to manage related matters. Of the two advisories with focus on sterilisation, the first was issued by the Secretary (Animal Husbandry and Dairying) to all Chief Secretaries on 11 November 2024. The second one, sent out on 16 July this year, directed Urban Local Bodies to establish ABC units and undertake large-scale sterilisation programmes, covering at least 70 percent of stray dogs. The Centre's response further said that the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, under the National Rabies Control Programme (NRCP), is implementing the National Action Plan for Dog-Mediated Rabies Elimination (NAPRE), launched in September 2021. The plan involves multiple initiatives aimed at achieving rabies elimination across the country. The Centre also said it has revised its scheme for birth control and immunisation of stray dogs and cats, which is being implemented through the Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI). Under the revised plan, financial assistance of up to Rs 800 per dog and Rs 600 per cat will be given to local bodies for conducting sterilisation, read its reply to Aujla. However, these rates were revised in 2022. According to an advisory issued by the AWBI on 5 April 2022, the new rates were fixed at Rs 200 per dog for catching, admission to the ABC centre and relocation to the area from where the animal was captured, and Rs 1,450 per dog for pre-operative care, including medicines and feeding, surgery, and post-operative care with medicines and feeding. 'These revised minimum rates will remain applicable until individual state governments decide to fix their own rates for carrying out the ABC programme,' the advisory read. The Centre's reply also mentions that a one-time grant of Rs 2 crore is earmarked for state-run veterinary hospitals to strengthen infrastructure such as surgical theatres, kennels and recovery units. In addition, the AWBI is extending support for the establishment of animal shelters, providing up to Rs 15 lakh for small animal facilities and up to Rs 27 lakh for large animal facilities to urban local bodies, societies and recognised animal welfare organisations. However, according to the AWBI website, no shelter homes in Delhi have been allotted any grants since 2007, except JBF India Trust in 2014-15. ThePrint reached AWBI chairman Dr Abhijit Mitra for comment via calls. This report will be updated if and when a response is received. (Edited by Gitanjali Das) Also Read: Stray dogs debate divides BJP & RSS—shelters vs sterilisation & 'gau mata apathy'
