South Africa building collapse that killed 34 was 'entirely preventable', minister says
A newly released report into the 2024 tragedy revealed that serious safety concerns had been raised well before the partially-built five-storey apartment block came crashing down.
Public Works Minister Dean Macpherson said the collapse was the result of multiple failures including the use of substandard materials, structural cracks, and visible gaps.
"There were a number of red flags that were continually raised about this project," said a visibly angry Macpherson.
Some of the defects in the building were detected a year before the building collapsed. The health and safety officer even resigned in protest but work continued the report found.
"The work should have stopped" Macpherson said.
Macpherson added that these signs were a chance to turn back but instead, problems with the building were "covered up".
Workers reported feeling vibrations in the partially built structure, and being told to cover up holes with sand and substandard concrete, the report revealed.
Following what the minister described as an "emotional and painful" private meeting with survivors and families of victims, he called for criminal accountability for those found to have been negligent.
A police investigation is still ongoing but no arrests have been made.
Many survivors are still facing trauma, medical bills and struggling to put food on the table, Macpherson said.
One survivor of the disaster, Elelwani, tearfully told local media, that her life had changed dramatically in the last year.
She lost many of her teeth, struggles to eat and has been the subject of bullying. She appealed for money from well wishers.
Macpherson pledged to introduce regulations to improve oversight in construction and reform outdated legislation.
The probe was conducted by the Council for the Built Environment and a parallel investigation by the Engineering Council of South Africa.
Go to BBCAfrica.com for more news from the African continent.
Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica
BBC Africa podcasts
Africa Daily
Focus on Africa
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Royal Caribbean cruise boat worker stabs female coworker and then dies jumping overboard
A Royal Caribbean crew member jumped overboard to his death after stabbing his female coworker, according to police. A 35-year-old South African man was working on the Royal Caribbean's Icon of the Seas cruise ship when he stabbed a 28-year-old South African female crew member 'multiple times' just before 7.30 a.m. Thursday, the Royal Bahamas Police Force said. The man then fled the scene and jumped off the ship, authorities said. He was later pronounced dead by onboard medical staff. The female victim suffered stab wounds to her upper body. She was treated and is now in stable condition, police said. It's not immediately clear what prompted the violence. A motive behind the stabbing has not been identified and crew members have not been publicly named. An investigation into the matter is ongoing. An autopsy has been scheduled, police said. A spokesperson for Royal Caribbean described the incident to NBC News as "a personal dispute.' No additional details were mentioned. "Our crew immediately initiated a search and rescue operation, but unfortunately the crew member passed away," the company in a statement to CBS News. "We extend our condolences to the crew member's family and loved ones. To respect their privacy, we have no additional details to share." Passengers recalled crew members rushing after the intercom blasted 'Oscar, Oscar, Oscar" — the Royal Caribbean's code for man overboard, the outlet reported. The ship then slowed before turning around. The Independent has reached out to the Royal Caribbean for more information. The Icon of the Seas was making its way back from the Bahamas to Miami when the incident transpired, CruiseMapper shows. The cruise ship departed Miami on July 19 and then made stops in St. Marteen, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and the Bahamas, before returning to Florida. The Icon of the Seas, the world's largest cruise ship, made its maiden voyage in January 2024. The 1,200-feet-long vessel boasts seven pools, the 'world's largest waterpark at sea,' six waterslides and nine whirlpools. It holds up to 5,610 passengers and 2,350 crew members across its 19 floors.
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Royal Caribbean Crew Member Stabs Colleague Before Jumping Overboard
An alleged attack at sea ends with a crew member's shocking death—investigators are searching for answers. A Royal Caribbean crew member allegedly stabbed a female colleague before leaping overboard to his death. The incident occurred on Icon of the Seas, which is currently sailing a week-long Eastern Caribbean cruise that departed on July 19, according to CruiseMapper. Reports state that the 28-year-old South African female employee was attacked by the 35-year-old South African male crew member, who then jumped into the sea. The ship's crew responded swiftly, and the woman was treated for her injuries. 'Following the incident, the male reportedly fled from the scene and jumped into the water,' police said in a post on X (formerly Twitter). 'He was retrieved unresponsive and pronounced dead by onboard medical staff.' Police did not name the crew members. Royal Caribbean has not publicly commented on the situation, but the company is cooperating with authorities as they investigate the circumstances surrounding the attack. The shocking event has raised alarm among those familiar with the cruise industry, who note the highly unusual nature of the incident. Passengers aboard the ship were reportedly kept informed, though many were understandably shaken by the news. As the investigation progresses, more details are expected to emerge regarding the motive behind the attack and the precise sequence of events that led to the tragic outcome. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Royal Caribbean crew member allegedly stabbed fellow employee, jumped overboard
A Royal Caribbean International crew member went overboard from the Icon of the Seas ship after allegedly stabbing a fellow employee. The South African man, 35, stabbed a South African woman, 28, 'multiple times' around 7:30 p.m. on July 24, according to the Royal Bahamas Police Force. 'Following the incident, the male reportedly fled from the scene and jumped into the water,' police said in a post on X, formerly Twitter. 'He was retrieved unresponsive and pronounced dead by onboard medical staff.' Police did not name the crew members. Cruise overboard incidents: Are ships equipped? "Our onboard security team responded to an incident involving two crew members in a personal dispute,' the cruise line's parent company, Royal Caribbean Group, told USA TODAY in an emailed statement. 'One of the crew members was injured, was attended to by the onboard medical team, and she is now in stable condition. Unfortunately, the other crew member is deceased after he went overboard and was recovered in a search and rescue operation." The Royal Bahamas Police Force is investigating and an autopsy has been scheduled, authorities said. Icon is currently sailing a week-long Eastern Caribbean cruise that departed on July 19, according to CruiseMapper. The incident is not the only one of its kind in recent years. A Norwegian Cruise Line employee was arrested for allegedly stabbing multiple people onboard during an Alaska cruise in May 2024. Nathan Diller is a consumer travel reporter for USA TODAY based in Nashville. You can reach him at ndiller@ This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Cruise employee stabbed fellow crew member, jumped overboard: Police
