South Africa building collapse that killed 34 was 'entirely preventable', minister says
A newly released report into the 2024 tragedy revealed that serious safety concerns had been raised well before the partially-built five-storey apartment block came crashing down.
Public Works Minister Dean Macpherson said the collapse was the result of multiple failures including the use of substandard materials, structural cracks, and visible gaps.
"There were a number of red flags that were continually raised about this project," said a visibly angry Macpherson.
Some of the defects in the building were detected a year before the building collapsed. The health and safety officer even resigned in protest but work continued the report found.
"The work should have stopped" Macpherson said.
Macpherson added that these signs were a chance to turn back but instead, problems with the building were "covered up".
Workers reported feeling vibrations in the partially built structure, and being told to cover up holes with sand and substandard concrete, the report revealed.
Following what the minister described as an "emotional and painful" private meeting with survivors and families of victims, he called for criminal accountability for those found to have been negligent.
A police investigation is still ongoing but no arrests have been made.
Many survivors are still facing trauma, medical bills and struggling to put food on the table, Macpherson said.
One survivor of the disaster, Elelwani, tearfully told local media, that her life had changed dramatically in the last year.
She lost many of her teeth, struggles to eat and has been the subject of bullying. She appealed for money from well wishers.
Macpherson pledged to introduce regulations to improve oversight in construction and reform outdated legislation.
The probe was conducted by the Council for the Built Environment and a parallel investigation by the Engineering Council of South Africa.
Go to BBCAfrica.com for more news from the African continent.
Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica
BBC Africa podcasts
Africa Daily
Focus on Africa
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
One dead, one critical following partial roof collapse in Kansas City
One person is dead and another is in critical condition following a partial building collapse at a Family Dollar in Kansas City. The collapse was reported around 2:40 p.m. Sunday in the 3700 block of Broadway. Two other people were injured and treated on scene, but did not request to be taken to the hospital. Solve the daily Crossword
News24
17 hours ago
- News24
KZN cops arrest three suspected poachers found with rhino horn and two unlicensed rifles
Three suspected poachers were arrested in Paulpietersburg on Saturday. They allegedly accosted and tied up security guards and robbed them of a shotgun. They are expected to appear in court on charges of armed robbery, rhino poaching, and possession of unlicensed firearms and ammunition. Police in KwaZulu-Natal have arrested three suspected poachers who were found in possession of two unlicensed rifles and a rhino horn in Paulpietersburg on Saturday. It's alleged that the men, aged between 34 and 50, entered a game reserve and stormed up to two security guards while wearing face masks. They tied up the guards and robbed them of a shotgun, an R5 assault rifle, as well as their cellphones in the early hours of Friday morning. They then proceeded to shoot a rhino and remove its horn. They fled the scene, leaving behind the shotgun, next to the rhino carcass. According to KZN police spokesperson, Lieutenant Colonel Paul Magwaza, when they arrived at the scene, the suspects had already fled the game reserve. 'Police members, together with private security personnel, worked tirelessly throughout the day looking for the suspects. With assistance from community members, the suspects were eventually arrested as they took refuge in the bush,' he said. The suspects were found with an R5 rifle, a 303-calibre rifle, and a rhino horn. Magwaza added that the vehicle in which they were traveling was also seized by the police. The suspects were charged with armed robbery, rhino poaching, and possession of unlicensed firearms and ammunition. They are expected to appear at the Vryheid Magistrate's Court on Monday.
News24
a day ago
- News24
What's in City Press: Mkhwanazi's allegations ‘surprised' Mchunu
SAPS South African men arrested in Ukraine after promised medical roles turn to military training Two South African men, lured to Ukraine with enticing promises, now find themselves embroiled in legal trouble after being arrested in the war-torn country for alleged desertion. US sends more violent criminals and terrorists to Eswatini The Eswatini government has agreed not only to house five of the US's 'most barbaric' criminals in its prisons, but also to take custody of more than 150 terrorists. 'Mkhwanazi took me by surprise' - Senzo Mchunu Suspended police minister Senzo Mchunu has informed the Constitutional Court that KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi caught him off guard by publicly alleging that he was involved in protecting criminal syndicates. Nobuhle Nkabane: The face of the ANC's ugly cadre Introducing the Ugly Cadre, that ANC leader who typifies the worst character of the party that has dominated SA over the past three decades, writes Mondli Makhanya. R269m road project becomes a dust bowl amid Free State graft scandal The Free State government has spent more than R269 million on a failed road maintenance project, the R709 between Tweespruit and Excelsior near Thaba Nchu. Family feud erupts over renovations to Nelson Mandela's Houghton home More drama has erupted in the house of Nelson Mandela, which has hogged headlines for all the wrong reasons, as the late struggle hero's grandchildren clash over his estate. Gospel star Benjamin Dube owes company R1m, risks losing assets Legendary gospel musician Benjamin Dube has been accused of reneging on a verbal agreement and could have his assets auctioned to pay off a R1 million debt. Desiree Ellis: Do yourself a favour, leave now and don't wait to be pushed With nearly a decade at the helm and a slew of achievements, is now the right time for Banyana Banyana's coach to pursue opportunities beyond SA football? asks Timothy Molobi SA military revives controversial Cuban technician deal The military, despite past challenges with contracts involving Cuba, is determined to proceed with a new plan to use Cuban technicians for vehicle maintenance. Tariff wars: SA hoping for deadline extension Government hopes that the US will extend Thursday's deadline for new trade tariffs, as no formal negotiations have yet taken place. Silent cries: SA's escalating youth suicide crisis With suicide now the second leading cause of death among the country's youth, experts emphasise the urgent need for destigmatising mental illness and increasing access to care, particularly for young people in schools and rural communities. ANC considers Lynne Brown, Ebrahim Rasool to lead charge in Western Cape According to ANC sources, the party's national leadership is contemplating disbanding its Western Cape structures and electing new leaders for the province. Pastor Enock Phiri bares all in book after heartbreak, alcoholism and redemption After an 18-year failed marriage and a short-lived four-month public relationship that left him heartbroken and battling alcoholism, renowned leader of the Restoration House Ministries in Soweto, Enock Phiri, has laid bare his struggles in a deeply personal book. Criticism after Mandela Foundation lauds initiatives tackling 'Christian Zionism' The Nelson Mandela Foundation has announced a prize of R150 000 for initiatives aimed at challenging 'Christian Zionism'. Will Gauteng's Integrity Pact deal with corruption in public governance? SA's procurement system is so riddled with multiple improprieties that it has even attracted sanctions from law enforcement agencies in countries such as the US, the UK and Germany. It is time to fix it, if democracy is to survive and thrive, writes Thuli Madonsela. Cosatu@40: Losi insists a lot has been achieved amid alliance tension as SACP pushes for ballot breakaway As cracks begin to show within the tripartite alliance, Cosatu finds itself walking a political tightrope. The union federation is facing renewed pressure to clarify its stance on the decision of the SA Communist Party (SACP) to contest the elections independently, a move that could deepen rifts within the alliance. Matjhabeng's EPWP payroll still feeds ex-councillors and ANC officials Former ANC ward councillors and a sitting party secretary are earning inflated salaries of more than R31 000 a month under the Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP) in Matjhabeng in the Free State, despite the programme being intended for short-term work opportunities for unemployed and low-income South Africans. The harrowing journey to 'manhood' While other boys in the village, including myself, were playing with half bricks as cars and makeshift soccer balls from rolled-up plastics, 12-year-old Jeffrey Rakabe was getting ready to transition from a boy to a man. Cape Town Spurs make final push to challenge relegation With only a few days remaining before the start of the 2025/26 season on Saturday, Cape Town Spurs, who were relegated from the PSL at the end of last season in May, are still challenging their relegation. Coach Pogiso Makhoye and Orbit Tvet College principal Dika Mokoena have come a long way with the educational institution, with the pair having helped build the football club into a professional outfit. The North West has become the second province where a court order has stopped the start of a Safa women's league.
