From the Pocket: Essendon must stop pining for the past after finding a semblance of stability
That all came unglued on Saturday night, when they were trounced by a red-hot Western Bulldogs. Essendon reverted to type and sank back into the pack. Almost immediately, the club was batting away suggestions that Scott's coaching tenure was under threat, and that Bombers great James Hird was the man to replace him.
In response to Caroline Wilson's suggestion that the wolves were circling, the former Essendon chair Paul Little reportedly told the veteran reporter: 'You never say never to anything. It hasn't been an easy time for the club these past few years. There may come a time where there is a need for a restructure. If I felt I could add value to the club, and if they felt I could help, I would consider it.'
That was quickly quashed on Nine's Footy Classified, a program whose entire purpose suddenly seems to be to repudiate what has been reported on Channel Seven an hour earlier. One show says it's on, another says it's off. The dogs bark, the caravan moves on, and the rest of us are left scratching our heads.
Hird came within a whisker of reclaiming the Essendon coaching job in September 2022. Kevin Sheedy, his chief backer, was on Lindsay Fox's luxury yacht, sailing around the world with hundreds of movers and shakers to celebrate the trucking magnate's 85th birthday. He was confident that Hird would be appointed, and that the old Essendon was back. Back on dry land a fortnight later, he was informed his man had missed out.
Essendon is an unusual football club. For years now it has been very political, riven by factions, dictated to by coterie groups and deferential to its past. It has presented as a club that can't let go, and still pines for the glory years. It manifests in many ways. You see it in the axe-grinding columns Allan Hird phones into the Herald Sun. You see it in the former players who run for board positions. You see it in lifers like former list boss Adrian Dodoro, who strutted around like he owned the place, became the king of October, drafted the wrong players, and then took the club to the Fair Work Commission.
To his credit, president David Barham has sought to cut ties with the past. 'Harking back to the 80s, 90s or the 2000s and wishing we could return to that just causes drama and disunity,' he said at the AGM last year. 'The competition is so far removed from those times, it is almost a completely different game.'
Barham has made mistakes and rubbed plenty of people up the wrong way. He sacked a coach, rolled a president, and appointed the shortest tenured CEO in corporate history. But he's honest about what has gone wrong, and what needs to change. He called it 20 years of 'quick fixes and shortcuts'; 20 years of scandals, sugar hits, false dawns, bad trades, draft busts, and schadenfreude; 20 years of Stephen Dank, Andrew Thorburn, Hird and Dodoro.
Sign up to From the Pocket: AFL Weekly
Jonathan Horn brings expert analysis on the week's biggest AFL stories
after newsletter promotion
On Footy Classified on Tuesday night, striking the right balance between bewilderment and defiance, Scott sat next to the man who was said to be in line to replace him. Scott spins a good game. But he and the people who employ him are right. For the first time in a long time at Essendon, there is clarity and a semblance of stability and sanity. To defer to the past, to pine for once what was, and to jump at shadows would rank among the biggest mistakes in recent times at a club that has made more than most.
This is an extract from Guardian Australia's free weekly AFL email, From the Pocket. To get the full version, just visit this page and follow the instructions
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
8 hours ago
- The Independent
England coach John Mitchell: Being World Cup favourites is irrelevant to us
England head coach John Mitchell insists the tag of being Women's Rugby World Cup favourites is 'irrelevant'. The Red Roses kick off this year's World Cup at the Stadium of Light against the United States on Friday and also face Samoa and Australia in Pool A. England enter the tournament ranked number one in the world, but head coach Mitchell believes talk of being favourites is 'irrelevant'. When asked what challenges that title presents, Mitchell replied: 'It doesn't really matter. We start the tournament equal like everyone else. 'Being favourites is irrelevant to us. It might be relevant to your section of the world. We've just got to be where our feet are and earn the right each week.' England are currently on a 27-game winning run and recorded warm-up victories against Spain and France earlier this month. Friday's opponents the USA are ranked 10th in the world and Mitchell believes that while his side are likely to be 'hunted' by teams during the tournament, they are ready to embrace that. 'It's really important to basically focus on ourselves,' he said. 'We understand their threats – it's not that we don't look at their threats – but ultimately at the end of the day it's really important to focus on what we do and how we improve our margins, make sure that we perform above our standards. 'I'm sure if we take care of that, then that will take care of the threats. 'Every team will rise 10 or 15 per cent in this tournament because they're playing against England, that's just what we expect. 'From that point of view, we realise we're hunted but we also look forward to that as well.' Mitchell has named the same starting 15 from the 40-6 warm-up victory over France for the opening game. Skipper Zoe Aldcroft leads the squad at blindside flanker, with number eight Alex Matthews and openside Sadia Kabeya alongside her in the back row and Abbie Ward and Morwenna Talling lining up in the second row. Hannah Botterman, Amy Cokayne and Maud Muir complete the forwards. Vice-captain Megan Jones continues at centre alongside Tatyana Heard, while Jess Breach, Abby Dow and Ellie Kildunne make up the back three, Natasha Hunt starts at scrum-half and Zoe Harrison is at fly-half. World Cup debutants Kelsey Clifford, Maddie Feaunati and Emma Sing are named as replacements and veteran Emily Scarratt is also on the bench. Speaking about team selection, Mitchell added: 'Ultimately, we've tried to build cohesion. We've come out of a pre-season, we're not like the Southern Hemisphere teams which have had a lot of rugby. 'We're just building, so it's really important to make sure that you create combinations that players are familiar with. 'We do have history together in the squad that's selected, a number of minutes over the last three years – I think something like 1200 caps amongst that group of girls. 'That's a lot of experience and a lot of belief. You've got to play those cards in a tournament like this.'
Daily Mail
8 hours ago
- Daily Mail
AFL star reveals one of the league's top clubs was so broke they made their players bring their own FOOTBALLS to training
Footy great Sam Blease has revealed that Melbourne were forced to ask their players to sensationally bring their own footys to training during their catastrophic 2009 season. Blease joined the club in the 2008 AFL Draft and saw first-hand the turmoil the club had been in, with Melbourne also suffering from severe financial difficulties. The Demons were also accused of 'tanking', after the club won only four matches during the 2009 season under Dean Bailey, going on to win the club's 12th wooden spoon. The former midfielder, meanwhile, endured a torrid few months after joining the club. He suffered a broken leg while at school, which ruled him out of action for his first full year at the footy club. Despite the difficult start to life at Casey Fields, Blease would go on to make 33 appearances, making his debut two years later in 2011. And reflecting on his time at the footy club, Blease explained that cash was so tight, that players had to buy their own Sherrins and bring the balls to training. During an episode of Channel 7's What Could've Been podcast, Blease was asked by Theo Doropoulos: 'You go to the Dees in what has to be one of the worst times in the history of the Melbourne Football Club?' 'It was pretty awful,' the former Melbourne player responded. 'I think in our first year we were paying for our own footys,' the two-time rising star nominee said. 'That's how dire it was - the financial position of the footy club.' Co-hosts Doropoulos and Harrison Reid were both left stunned by the revelation, seemingly confused as to why a club of Melbourne's stature could find itself in such bother. Harrison Reid said: 'You got the guys from Rebel sport and said: "Give us 10 footys?"' Blease opened up on the situation further, stating that the players had to look after their own footy. 'It's $150 out of your own pay. And you had to take them home,' he added. 'You were paying for them yourself?!' Reid said, shocked 'Every player was,' Blease replied. 'And they had your number on. Not a lot of people probably know that... 'You had to bring it and that would be used in training.' He added: 'One footy, and if you lost it you'd have to pay for another one.' Doropoulos quipped: 'This doesn't even happen at local footy!' Blease would later leave the club in 2014, joining up with Geelong where he would play for a season, but struggled to get a regular run of games in the first grade side. He was released from the footy club at the end of the season after making just one appearance for the Cats. He'd announce his immediate retirement from footy after failing to recover from a serious head injury he suffered during a VFL match. Despite the difficulties he experienced at Melbourne and the way his career was cut short prematurely, he still looks back on life in footy with fond memories. 'The thing is, we go into this not knowing (anything different); that's what we know. You don't know what it's like to be somewhere else,' he said. 'I got drafted from Eastern Ranges with Liam Shiels; I think he played in three flags, I think I played in three wins. 'But it all happens for a reason, right? You can't pick and choose. You go into that knowing that's all you know. 'But going back to the draft, that was a really special thing. 'It's just such a cool day. When you're at the draft and waiting for your name to get called out. 'Typically you sort of know the top 20. 'I think I met with every club but Essendon and Carlton leading into the draft, so I sort of had a bit of an idea where I was going.'
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘The world betting game': is football more susceptible to match-fixing in Australia?
Australian football faces a significant and ongoing threat given what is known about the recent A-League match-fixing case, which returns to court this week. Yet two of Australia's most prominent sport integrity voices are concerned that an even greater peril lies in the opaque pit that is the illegal international online bookmaking market, and that local laws are not doing enough to mitigate the risk. Former Western United player Riku Danzaki and his friend Yuta Hirayama pleaded guilty last week to charges related to a scheme in which the pair bet on Danzaki receiving yellow cards in the A-League Men competition. They will be sentenced this week and face hefty fines. According to court proceedings, Danzaki and Hirayama used Australian-licensed bookmakers Bet365, Sportsbet and Tabcorp and won more than $20,000 in the scheme, but were undone when Tabcorp rejected their final bet and reported them to police. The case appears to be an endorsement for the cooperation between bookmakers, sporting codes and police that underpins gambling licence-fee agreements in Australia. In this instance, Tabcorp's trading staff detected the suspicious behaviour and notified its investigation team, which referred it to the sporting integrity intelligence unit of Victoria police. While police will work across borders, this kind of cooperation between sports betting partners is weaker overseas, especially on the shady black market providers that evade regulation and enforcement. At the same time, the volume of betting is much larger on these platforms. The UN estimated in 2021 that up to US$1.7tn (AU$2.6tn) was wagered on illicit betting markets each year. The head of strategy and international policy at Sport Integrity Australia, James Moller, says football 'could also be known as the world betting game, such are the volumes wagered on the sport across the globe'. 'The quality of our sporting competitions and our closely aligned time-zone with Asia makes Australian sport particularly popular for betting in that part of the world,' he says. Football Australia says the Danzaki matter is one example that shows measures against match-fixing 'have proven to be effective' in its mission to protect the sport. 'Our aim is to prevent behaviours that threaten sport integrity from occurring in the first place, however, we have measures to detect and act where required.' Yet Dr Catherine Ordway, a sports integrity consultant, says catching those who benefit through offshore betting remains challenging. 'People change their web domains very quickly, and the technology is changing to using cryptocurrencies and so on to make it very difficult to use the traditional forms of traceability and accountability that crime-fighters have been using over decades,' Ordway says. She highlighted where athletes are underpaid, or have not received integrity education, or are exposed to traditional corruption risks such as around drugs or sex work, the vulnerability grows. 'Once you get down below that first league, then that's where the risks present,' she says. The federal government has pledged to introduce commonwealth legislation to specifically address match-fixing, as part of the process to ratify the Macolin Convention, the international treaty aimed at combating sports corruption. There is currently a mishmash of state legislation, including a reluctance by governments in Tasmania and Western Australia to introduce specific laws to combat match-fixing, even as the other states followed through with a 2011 national agreement. But there is no clear timeline for the arrival of new powers. The temptation of match-fixing has lured Australians from sports other than football. Oliver Anderson, who won the 2016 Australian Open boys singles tennis title, is perhaps the highest-profile local athlete outside football to succumb to its temptations. And Australia's other major codes are not without integrity concerns. The AFL has sought to increase licensing fees with bookmakers in order to improve detection of gamblers' use of inside information. Former NRL player Ryan Tandy received a lifetime ban from the NRL in 2012 over a spot-fixing scandal. Sign up to Australia Sport Get a daily roundup of the latest sports news, features and comment from our Australian sports desk after newsletter promotion Like tennis, football's appeal is global, and bettors are interested even in amateurs playing in Australia. Log on to one of the many offshore bookmakers beyond the reach of local regulators and investigators, and markets are available on 21 separate Australian football competitions, including second-tier leagues in several states. But Ordway says next year's Women's Asian Cup matches in Perth – where the state government has deemed its general wagering and criminal code provisions 'sufficient' to effectively prevent match-fixing – is a 'massive vulnerability'. 'We've got people coming in that are not paid properly, that are not given the adequate training and education, whether it's referees or players or team officials,' she says. 'And they're coming into an environment where, on the other side, we don't have the legislation that's as strong as it could be.' FA's spokesperson said: 'Football Australia would be supportive of legislation designed to uphold and protect the integrity of football and sport more generally.' A spokesperson for WA attorney-general Tony Buti said the state's criminal code has 'some of the strongest criminal laws in Australia' with a 'range of offences relating to fraudulent behaviour'.
