Campaigners win legal battle against 171-turbine Sutherland wind farm
Resident could be surrounded by 171 turbines if built, with what has been dubbed as a 'ring of steel'. German developer Energiekontor lodged the application in 2022.
The turbines were expected to remain in place for 35 years within the Strath Oykel Forest.
READ MORE: Storm Floris Live: Latest warnings, transport cancellations and road closures
One campaigner from the No Ring of Steel (NOROS) group, Tisi Dutton, told STV News that ministers must now 'reconsider the application'.
She said: 'I believe the legal process is being followed as it should be. It's now up to ministers to reconsider the application.
'The encirclement of the strath is at the forefront of NOROS' thinking. We will request that ministers follow the refusal, as has been recommended by the two reporters.
'We're not against windfarms per se, but you've got to have the right development in the right place.'
The development proposal had faced more than 150 objections, was unanimously rejected by Highland Council, and a public inquiry took place in October 2024, in which councillors did not waver after they were asked to reconsider by the Government.
Reporters working on behalf of the government also recommended that the plans be refused.
However, the government green lit the project, with Highland Council responding with a legal challenge.
Judges have now ruled that ministers failed to provide adequate reasons, with ministers arguing the development will 'provide a contribution to renewable energy targets and carbon savings' and 'will provide economic benefits which also weigh in its favour.'
READ MORE: How war became a route to growth for the west
With Strath Oykel known for its wildlife and fisheries, Dutton said: 'It's endangerment of the significant area of conservation which is the River Oykel and it's there to protect critically endangered freshwater pearl mussels and endangered Atlantic salmon.
'Freshwater pearl mussels are very susceptible to any pollution and any kind of mitigation has been found to be usually and most likely to be unsatisfactory in protecting these creatures.
She added: 'We're, in a way, guardians of this strath – of its biodiversity – but also of its community because if you destroy the river you destroy employment.
'If you destroy the beauty of the place you destroy tourism, and the river and tourism are two key areas of employment here.
'It's heartbreaking and it's constant, but Noros will keep going within the planning framework. It's immensely important that we keep fighting against the developments that threaten this strath.'
Scottish Government ministers now have four options under consideration: they may invite further public comment on the planning application; issue a revised approval; uphold the recommended refusal put forward by two independent public inquiry reporters; or initiate a new public inquiry under the oversight of a different reporter.
The Scottish Government can now:
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
12 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Kate Forbes to quit Scottish Parliament as Deputy First Minister announces shock departure
Forbes was viewed by many in the SNP as a future leader of the party. Kate Forbes has announced she will quit the Scottish Parliament next year instead of seeking re-election. The MSP for Skye and Lochaber was appointed Deputy First Minister by John Swinney last year and was viewed by many in the SNP as a future leader of the party. Forbes, 35, previously quit the Scottish Government Cabinet in 2023 following the election of Humza Yousaf as First Minister following a bitter leadership contest which saw her personal religious views become a major talking point. But she returned to the front bench in April last year after Swinney succeeded Yousaf as party leader and First Minister. In a statement, Forbes said: "I have informed my Constituency Association today that I do not intend to seek re-election in May 2026. It has been a great honour to serve Highland communities for almost a decade. I am grateful to every voter who re-elected me at the last election with the biggest majority in Scotland. 'I have also been privileged to serve in Government, first as Minister for Public Finance, then as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and most recently as Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic. 'As I reflected over recess, I have concluded that I do not wish to seek re-election for another five year term in the Scottish Parliament. 'All politicians face a choice at every election to stay on the same path or not. Quite simply, I've decided on the latter. I remain wholly supportive of the First Minister just as when I backed him to be leader of the SNP and I look forward to campaigning for the SNP at the next election – to lead Scotland to independence. 'I was first elected in my mid-twenties, dedicating my most formative adult years to public service. In that time, I presented multiple Budgets, supported thousands of businesses and workers during Covid-19 and launched Scotland's most ambitious business start up network TechScaler. I now wish to step back from my public duties and focus on new opportunities to serve people. 'I have grown up in the public eye, getting married, having a baby and raising a young family. I have consistently put the public's needs ahead of my family's during that time. I am grateful to them for accommodating the heavy demands of being a political figure. Looking ahead to the future, I do not want to miss any more of the precious early years of family life – which can never be rewound. 'I am very grateful to everybody I've worked with - in my constituency office, the party and Government. It's not an easy environment and I will leave public office with the highest respect for the journalists who hold us accountable, MSPs across the chamber and hard working volunteers in every community.'
Scottish Sun
12 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
SNP's Kate Forbes QUITS parliament as Deputy First Minister hands in bombshell resignation letter
In a letter to Nats leader John Swinney, she said she has given "careful thought" to her future over the summer holidays CALLING IT A DAY SNP's Kate Forbes QUITS parliament as Deputy First Minister hands in bombshell resignation letter Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) KATE Forbes has said she will step down as an MSP after the next Holyrood election. The Deputy First Minister made the bombshell announcement this morning. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 1 Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes has said she will resign after next year's election Credit: Alamy In a letter to SNP leader John Swinney, she said she has given "careful thought" to her future over the summer holidays. Ms Forbes is expected to carry on in her role as deputy FM until the Scottish Parliament election on May 7 next year. In response, Mr Swinney said he understood her decision but added: "I wish it was not the case." The Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch MSP, wrote: "Dear John, After careful thought over the summer recess, I have informed the Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch Constituency Association today that I intend to step down from the Scottish Parliament at the next election. "It has been an incredible privilege to serve the people of the Highlands since 2016 as the Member of the Scottish Parliament for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch. In that time, I have also been grateful for the opportunity to serve in Government, initially as Minister for Public Finance, then as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and more recently as Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic. "I am in no doubt about the scale of my duties as a local representative, an activist and campaigner, and a Government Minister. Quite rightly this job entails long days far from home, constant attention and total dedication. As I consider the upcoming election and the prospects of another term, I have concluded that I do not wish to seek re-election and miss any more of the precious early years of family life. "I remain wholly supportive of you today just as when I backed you to be Leader of the SNP and First Minister of Scotland, and I will continue to serve my constituents and the public with diligence over the next year. "I look forward to campaigning for the SNP at the next election, to return you as First Minister for another term and lead Scotland to independence." First Minister John Swinney said: ' I pay tribute to Kate for her invaluable contribution to public life over the last ten years. The challenges of frontline politics are considerable, and I understand the decision she has made although I wish it was not the case. 'I am pleased that Kate will continue to serve in my government and to make a significant contribution to the work of the Scottish National Party. I wish her and her family well and for every happiness for the future.' Five moments you missed from a weekend with Donald Trump in Scotland Ms Forbes was elected in 2016 and burst onto the frontline political scene four years later when she replaced shamed Derek Mackay to become Scotland's first female finance secretary. In 2023, she ran to succeed Nicola Sturgeon as Nats leader but she narrowly lost out to Humza Yousaf.
Glasgow Times
12 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Hotel protests must not be used to ‘have a pop at the police'
Dame Angela Eagle promised that the Government was 'doing the detailed work' to crack down on small boat crossings, after the Home Office unveiled its plan to pump an extra £100 million into tackling people smuggling. Some of the money will support the 'one in, one out' returns agreement pilot with France, and some will go towards funding extended police powers to seize digital devices. Protesters have gathered outside hotels over recent weeks throughout the country, including in London, Newcastle and Epping in Essex, calling for their closure. (PA Graphics) Conservative shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick has warned that 'the public's patience with the asylum hotels and with the whole issue of illegal migration has snapped', after small boat crossings topped 25,000 for the year so far, a record for this point in the year. Asked on Sky News what her message was to protesters, Dame Angela said: 'Anger doesn't get you anywhere. 'What we have to do is recognise the values we have in this country, the rule of law we have in this country, the work we're doing with the police to protect people. 'We will close asylum hotels by the end of the Parliament. 'We'll do it faster if we can.' Dame Angela also said: 'We are doing all we can to deal with the challenges that the police are facing on the streets to make sure that women and girls are safe, and in fact, that everybody is safe on our streets.' She had earlier told Times Radio: 'Those who are worried and demonstrating have an absolute right to do that, so long as they do it peacefully. 'People don't have a right to then have a pop at the police, which has been happening in some isolated cases outside hotels.' Dame Angela Eagle (Lauren Hurley/PA) Referring to plans to let police seize devices from people suspected of facilitating people smuggling, Dame Angela said the Government does not 'want absolutely every phone'. She told Times Radio: 'But we do want the phones of the people that we think are organising and facilitating, and this extra money will enable us to do much quicker analytics of the phones that we seize. 'But of course, we've got to get the Border Security Bill on the statute book to give us those extra powers.' The Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill has cleared the Commons but must undergo further scrutiny in the Lords before it becomes law. Turning to social media creators who advertise illegal routes into the UK, Dame Angela said: 'We will stop anyone who comes to the UK where we've got evidence, and what happens is that the people smugglers are getting people to say how safe the journeys were and do adverts once they're in the UK. 'We will stop that, and we will also deal with other jurisdictions and ask them to help us deal with this as well, we could certainly do that in the EU with our colleagues in Germany, in France.' Where there is 'evidence that legal routes to visas are being misused', the Government will 'tighten up the rules to stop that abuse happening', the minister added. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has previously said the money, which will also help pay for surveillance capabilities and data analysis tools, will 'turbo-charge the ability of our law enforcement agencies to track the gangs and bring them down, working with our partners overseas, and using state-of-the-art technology and equipment'. She added: 'Alongside our new agreements with France, this will help us drive forward our plan for change commitments to protect the UK's border security and restore order to our immigration system.' The National Crime Agency has 91 ongoing investigations into people smuggling networks affecting the UK, the agency's director general of operations Rob Jones said. Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Mr Jenrick said: 'The public's patience with the asylum hotels and with the whole issue of illegal migration has snapped. 'This is an issue that is beyond party politics. 'It is causing immense harm to communities, and people's lives are being wrecked as a result of it, and we simply have to fix it. 'I respect those people who are peacefully protesting outside hotels this weekend, I understand why they feel so concerned. 'They're seeing their communities damaged, and I'm afraid there is increasing evidence of a serious link between illegal migration, migration generally, and crime, particularly sexual crime, against women and girls.'
