Judge doubles jail term for trespasser who asked for lesser sentence
The appeal court heard Gerry Cash (33), with an address at Tombrack, Ferns, Co Wexford, left the vulnerable pensioner, who has short-term memory loss, in a distressed state after entering his Co Kildare house.
Cash was convicted in the District Court of trespassing on a building in a manner that causes or is likely to cause fear contrary to section 13 (1) of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act, 1994. He was sentenced to nine months in custody with the final six months suspended.
His defence counsel, Asma Saleh, on Monday informed the court the appeal related to the severity of sentence imposed.
READ MORE
Judge Dara Hayes said the court has the power to increase or decrease an appellant's jail sentence. He said the original sentence of nine months in custody with the final six months suspended was 'lenient under the circumstances'.
He maintained the original nine-month sentence but halved the suspended portion to cover the final three months.
Garda Padraig Murphy told the District Court Appeals Court that gardaí got a report on February 22, 2023 from the daughter of the injured party. He said a neighbour alerted her that they saw a white van outside her father's house and that a man knocked on the window and the door of the house.
Garda Murphy said the man was heard shouting 'I've got you that' before entering the house. He said the neighbour saw the man in the sitting room and he later left the property in his van.
Garda Murphy said the victim was left 'very shaken and pale' after the incident. He said the man was in the care of his daughters, who left him alone for one hour a day. He said the man had no memory of the incident due to his memory loss difficulties.
Cash admitted in a Garda interview to being at the scene and leaving a calling card. He was charged with trespassing and was convicted in the District Court.
Ms Saleh said Cash is 'extremely remorseful' for his actions and is aware it was bad behaviour. She said her client's doctor reports that he suffers from anxiety, depression and low mood swings. His wife is currently pregnant after a long time undergoing IVF treatment, she said.
The daughter of the injured party told the court her father did not know what had happened and was very pale after the incident. She said he shook as she showered him and he was very upset.
'That man took every bit of independence from my father,' she said.
Judge Hayes said it was clear from the injured party's reaction that he was put in a position of some distress. The judge said whatever independence the man had was taken away and he was entitled to be unmolested in his own home.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Sisters of rapist Richard Brennan want witnesses in trials to get paid leave from work
The sisters of a man who sexually abused them have called for reform of the legal system over leave for witnesses in trials. At the Central Criminal Court earlier this month Richard Brennan was given a sentence of eight years for offences against his three sisters in the 1970s and 1980s in Dublin . Brennan, with an address in Montana in the US, admitted days into his trial last March to 24 offences against Yvonne Crist, Paula Fay and Catherine Wrightstone. Now Ms Fay and Ms Wrightstone have called for witnesses to be given paid leave, the same as jurors, in trials. READ MORE Speaking on RTÉ Radio 1's Oliver Callan show, Ms Fay said when she told her employer she was going to be a witness in a trial and that it could take three weeks she was told all she was entitled to was annual leave or unpaid leave. 'There was nothing in law to protect me as a witness,' she said. 'I was completely committed to this process from the very beginning, and I feel that we need to be treated differently.' Ms Fay said witnesses, like jurors, were also doing their civic duty and as such should be treated the same as them. The abuse was committed by Brennan in the family home in Rathfarnham when he was aged between 16 and 24 and included four offences of rape against Ms Fay and two of rape against Ms Wrightstone when both women were minors. Following the trial the sisters voiced their 'deep disappointment' over the 'leniency' of his eight-year sentence. Speaking on the show, Ms Wrightstone said: 'I think Irish courts seem to have broad discretion over such cases as ours and lenient sentences, especially in historical sexual abuse cases, are sometimes justified on the basis of remorse, time elapsed. 'In terms of reform, I would love to see an introduction of mandatory binding sentencing guidelines that treat sexual abuse and rape as serious offences regardless of the time elapsed and create a statutory offence under sexual assault for sibling sexual abuse.' During sentencing, Mr Justice David Keane said among the mitigatory factors were Brennan's 'very late' plea of guilty, his apology to his sisters, his expression of remorse, his lack of previous convictions, that the offences occurred 40 years ago and that he was considered at low risk of reoffending. Ms Wrightstone told the radio show that 'one of the things that I find a little bit disturbing is the offender's recent good character as stated in character references provided by family and friends, who only know what that person allows them to know'. She said she and her sisters were trying to 'give voice' for those who could not come forward. 'We understand that it's a really challenging thing to do. We want to provide hope, that our legal system will help and that the gardaí will help and that hopefully other changes will happen,' she said. 'But we do recognise that there have been some that have lost their life under the weight of trauma, so we're here to give voice to those and we thank all of those brave women that came before us.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Numb': Woman's life ‘changed forever' after being tortured by five men in a Dublin flat
A woman who was falsely imprisoned and tortured during a three-hour ordeal in a Dublin city centre flat has said she feels 'numb' following the sentencing of five men. Natalie Ennis (38) was taken to a flat in Henrietta House, Dublin 7, over a false accusation about missing drugs, was beaten around the head and body with metal poles, burned with a makeshift blow torch and a heated hammer head, cut with a knife, kicked and punched, had her hair cut off and was threatened with rape. The men took running jumps at her during the assault last September, threatened to make her drink ammonia and threatened to rape her teenage daughter. The men were jailed for terms ranging from eight-and-a-half to 14 years on Wednesday. READ MORE After the sentencing hearing at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, Ms Ennis, accompanied by her mother, and by David Hall and Siobhan Ferguson of the Sonas domestic violence charity, stood outside the court building as Mr Hall read a statement on her behalf. After the statement was read, Ms Ennis, asked by a reporter how she felt, replied: 'Numb' and became upset. In the statement, Mr Hall said Ms Ennis was 'lured, trapped and subject to a level of violence and cruelty that defies belief'. 'This was not an assault, it was torture, deliberate, sustained and devastating.' Ms Ennis, the statement said, wanted to thank Judge Codd 'for her compassion towards me and her understanding of the horror I was subjected to and for imposing sentences that recognised the gravity of the crimes inflicted upon me'. She thanked gardaí for their 'incredible' support, noting many believed she would not have survived the assault had gardaí not attended at the flat that same day to serve a warrant by coincidence, 'a fortunate event that most certainly saved Natalie's life. 'Natalie is a survivor but survival comes at a heavy price. Physically, mentally and emotionally. Her life and that of her family has been changed for ever.' Sonas has supported and worked with Ms Ennis although her case 'does not neatly fit into its purview of domestic violence services', Mr Hall said. Ms Ennis 'has had to fight again and again' for 'basic core supports' to rebuild her life, injury repair, dental care, somewhere safe to live. The system is 'a patchwork of services that often leave women like Natalie behind', he said. Judge Pauline Codd said Ms Ennis was terrified throughout and thought she was going to die, she said . The assault ended only when gardaí entered the flat with a search warrant. The men's 'evil' and 'vile' offences against the woman, including 'violent, sadistic and brutal' assaults occurred against a background of drug criminality, she said. 'There has to be general deterrence to this type of torture,' Judge Codd said. All of the men were on bail at the time and all had drug abuse issues, including two who were born addicted to drugs, the sentencing hearing was told. In text messages, one boasted to a friend during the incident they had a 'hostage' and had 'cut her up', to which his unidentified friend replied: 'quality'. Mobile phone video footage taken inside the flat that day was played, showing the woman bloodied and distressed and a hammer being heated up on a hob. Ms Ennis was left with a broken eye socket, broken cheekbone, broken nasal bone, broken elbow, burns, dislocated teeth, bruising and lacerations across her head and scalp, among other injuries. She required skin grafts, staples to her scalp, and later had surgery to remove a disc in her back. She spent three weeks in hospital in the immediate aftermath of the assault. Five of the eight men present that day entered guilty pleas. Another man and a juvenile are still before the courts and the eighth person is not before the courts. Mark McMahon (55) and his son Mark Keogh (33), along with Braxton Rice (21), all of Henrietta House, Henrietta Place, Dublin 7, along with Sean Conroy (21) of Sillogue Road, Ballymun, and Kian Walshe (22) of Constitution Hill, Dublin 7, pleaded guilty to false imprisonment and assault causing harm to the woman at Henrietta House on September 26th, 2024. A number of other counts against each man relating to the production of articles in the course of an offence were taken into consideration. Having heard mitigation submissions on behalf of the five men, Judge Codd imposed an effective 12-year sentence on McMahon and nine years on his son, Mark Keogh. Conroy, whom the judge described as one of the main movers of what was happening in the flat, 'eclipsed only by the actions of Rice', was jailed for an effective 12 years. Rice, whom the judge noted was identified by the victim as the 'main ringleader or instigator', with Conroy to a lesser degree, was jailed for 14 years. He had questioned the victim about missing drugs, threatened to rape her daughter, beat her, burnt her repeatedly on the legs with a heated hammer and also burned her face and legs. The judge jailed Walshe for an effective eight-and-a-half years.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Five who tortured woman in Dublin flat jailed for between eight and 14 years
Five men who falsely imprisoned and tortured a woman during a three hour ordeal in a Dublin city centre flat have been jailed for terms ranging from eight and a half to 14 years. 'There has to be general deterrence to this type of torture,' Judge Pauline Codd said. The men's 'evil' and 'vile' offences against the woman, including 'violent, sadistic and brutal' assaults occurred against a background of drug criminality, she said. The woman, aged 38, was taken to a flat in Henrietta House, Dublin 7 over a false accusation about missing drugs, was beaten around the head and body with metal poles, burned with a makeshift blow torch and a heated hammer head, cut with a knife, kicked and punched, had her hair cut off and was threatened with rape. READ MORE The men took running jumps at her during the assault last September, threatened to make her drink ammonia and threatened to rape her teenage daughter. She was terrified throughout and thought she was going to die, she said. The assault ended only when gardaí entered the flat with a search warrant. All of the men were on bail at the time and all had drug abuse issues, including two who were born addicted to drugs, the sentencing hearing was told. In text messages, one boasted to a friend during the incident they had a 'hostage' and had 'cut her up', to which his unidentified friend replied: 'quality'. Mobile phone video footage taken inside the flat that day was played, showing the woman bloodied and distressed and a hammer being heated up on a hob. The woman was left with a broken eye socket, broken cheekbone, broken nasal bone, broken elbow, burns, dislocated teeth, bruising and lacerations across her head and scalp, among other injuries. She required skin grafts, staples to her scalp, and later had surgery to remove a disc in her back. She spent three weeks in hospital in the immediate aftermath of the assault. Five of the eight men present that day entered guilty pleas. Another man and a juvenile are still before the courts and the eighth person is not before the courts. Mark McMahon (55) and his son Mark Keogh (33), along with Braxton Rice (21), all of Henrietta House, Henrietta Place, Dublin 7, along with Sean Conroy (21) of Sillogue Road, Ballymun and Kian Walshe (22) of Constitution Hill, Dublin 7, pleaded guilty to false imprisonment and assault causing harm to the woman at Henrietta House on September 26th, 2024. A number of other counts against each man relating to the production of articles in the course of an offence were taken into consideration. Having heard mitigation submissions on behalf of the five men, Judge Codd imposed an effective 12 year sentence on McMahon and nine years on his son, Mark Keogh. Conroy, whom the judge described as one of the main movers of what was happening in the flat, 'eclipsed only by the actions of Rice', was jailed for an effective 12 years. Rice, whom the judge noted was identified by the victim as the 'main ringleader or instigator', with Conroy to a lesser degree, was jailed for 14 years. He had questioned the victims about missing drugs, threatened to rape her daughter, beat her, burnt her repeatedly on the legs a with heated hammer and also burned her face and legs. The judge jailed Walshe for an effective eight and a half years.
