Reaction to the mushroom killer verdict and behind the Erin Patterson story
The triple-murder trial entered its eleventh week on July 7 as the jury returned its verdict to the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court after hearing from more than 50 witnesses.
The 50-year-old was found guilty of murdering Don and Gail Patterson, as well as Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, when she fed the group a fatal dose of death cap mushroom in a beef Wellington lunch in 2023.
Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband, survived the meal after a successful liver transplant.
Wearing a paisley blouse, Erin Patterson blinked but appeared expressionless as a jury foreperson uttered the words "guilty" four times over the murders and attempted murder of her estranged husband Simon's family.
Outside court, her friend, Ali Rose Prior, told the waiting large national and international media throng she was "saddened" by the verdicts, but "it is what it is".
"I didn't have any expectations, it's the justice system and it has to be what it is," she told reporters outside the Latrobe Valley courts, in Morwell.
Ms Prior, who attended the entire trial, confirmed Patterson had told her "see you soon", and that she would visit her friend in prison.
In a statement, Victoria Police said they acknowledged the jury's decision.
"Our thoughts are with the respective families at this time, and we acknowledge how difficult these past two years have been for them.
"We will continue to support them in every way possible following this decision," the statement read.
They also acknowledged the work of Homicide Squad detectives during the "complex investigation" and the support of other areas across their organisation.
A spokesperson for the Patterson family had no comment as they left the court.
Simon Patterson, the killer's estranged husband, declined her invitation for lunch, saying their relationship was too tense for him to comfortably attend.
The prosecution argued that Patterson had planned and carried out a plot to kill her husband's family.
Crown Prosecutor Nanette Rogers said that Patterson had "secreted" a lethal dose of death cap mushroom poison into the home-cooked beef Wellingtons.
She also argued that Patterson told her lunch guests that she had cancer, but that the diagnosis was fabricated.
Dr Rogers told the court that Patterson had attempted to "conceal the truth" with a sustained cover-up after the deaths.
The jury also heard that Patterson pretended to fall sick after the July 29 lunch.
She claimed that foraged death cap mushrooms were in the meal by mistake and maintained her innocence throughout the proceedings.
READ MORE: 'No, that's not true': accused mushroom killer denies deliberate poisoning
Over the course of the trial, the jury heard of a close family relationship between Patterson and her in-laws before the fateful lunch.
Patterson first met her estranged husband's family 20 years ago, in 2005, when the pair started dating after meeting through friends at Melbourne's Monash City Council.
The Pattersons had provided emotional and logistical support to the young couple, the court heard.
While being questioned by her defence lawyer, Colin Mandy, Patterson remembered her relief when Gail and Don came to stay after the couple had their first baby in Perth.
"She taught about settling after a feed and interpreting cries," Patterson said
Patterson also credited pastor Ian Wilkinson with her first spiritual experience at the Korumburra Baptist Church, leading her to convert to Christianity.
She said that while the family had been close, she had started to feel a growing distance after her split with Simon in 2015.
The couple had moved from Perth to Gippsland to be closer to his family after embarking on a number of months-long road trips across the country.
But Patterson was becoming "concerned" that her estranged husband didn't want her involved in the family.
"I had felt for some months that my relationship with the wider Patterson family, particularly Don and Gail, had a bit more distance or space put between us, we saw each other less," she said.
The tension came to a head when Patterson was excluded from Gail's 70th birthday.
By late 2022, interactions between Patterson and her estranged husband had "increased the heat", she said.
Patterson said anger and resentment in the relationship grew after the pair failed to find a resolution over child support payments, including school and medical fees.
Don and Gail were acting as mediators, encouraging the couple to pray together.
"They thought that Simon and I should settle the issue together, but they didn't want to become official mediators," she said.
Evidence extracted from Patterson's Facebook messages showed her growing frustration, the court heard.
"This family, I swear to f--king god," she messaged Facebook friends at the time.
The prosecution did not allege a motive for Patterson to murder three people and attempt to murder another.
READ MORE: 'This family, swear to f--king god': what we learned from Erin Patterson
Before her arrest, Patterson had made plans for the future, including making an appointment to discuss weight loss methods at a Melbourne clinic in 2023.
She had also been accepted into a Bachelor of Nursing and Midwifery at Federation University to begin in 2024.
The convicted killer has been remanded in jail since her arrest in November 2023.
She awaits sentencing.
- with AAP
After almost three months of hearing evidence in a regional courtroom, a jury has found that death cap mushroom killer Erin Patterson poisoned her in-laws.
The triple-murder trial entered its eleventh week on July 7 as the jury returned its verdict to the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court after hearing from more than 50 witnesses.
The 50-year-old was found guilty of murdering Don and Gail Patterson, as well as Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, when she fed the group a fatal dose of death cap mushroom in a beef Wellington lunch in 2023.
Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband, survived the meal after a successful liver transplant.
Wearing a paisley blouse, Erin Patterson blinked but appeared expressionless as a jury foreperson uttered the words "guilty" four times over the murders and attempted murder of her estranged husband Simon's family.
Outside court, her friend, Ali Rose Prior, told the waiting large national and international media throng she was "saddened" by the verdicts, but "it is what it is".
"I didn't have any expectations, it's the justice system and it has to be what it is," she told reporters outside the Latrobe Valley courts, in Morwell.
Ms Prior, who attended the entire trial, confirmed Patterson had told her "see you soon", and that she would visit her friend in prison.
In a statement, Victoria Police said they acknowledged the jury's decision.
"Our thoughts are with the respective families at this time, and we acknowledge how difficult these past two years have been for them.
"We will continue to support them in every way possible following this decision," the statement read.
They also acknowledged the work of Homicide Squad detectives during the "complex investigation" and the support of other areas across their organisation.
A spokesperson for the Patterson family had no comment as they left the court.
Simon Patterson, the killer's estranged husband, declined her invitation for lunch, saying their relationship was too tense for him to comfortably attend.
The prosecution argued that Patterson had planned and carried out a plot to kill her husband's family.
Crown Prosecutor Nanette Rogers said that Patterson had "secreted" a lethal dose of death cap mushroom poison into the home-cooked beef Wellingtons.
She also argued that Patterson told her lunch guests that she had cancer, but that the diagnosis was fabricated.
Dr Rogers told the court that Patterson had attempted to "conceal the truth" with a sustained cover-up after the deaths.
The jury also heard that Patterson pretended to fall sick after the July 29 lunch.
She claimed that foraged death cap mushrooms were in the meal by mistake and maintained her innocence throughout the proceedings.
READ MORE: 'No, that's not true': accused mushroom killer denies deliberate poisoning
Over the course of the trial, the jury heard of a close family relationship between Patterson and her in-laws before the fateful lunch.
Patterson first met her estranged husband's family 20 years ago, in 2005, when the pair started dating after meeting through friends at Melbourne's Monash City Council.
The Pattersons had provided emotional and logistical support to the young couple, the court heard.
While being questioned by her defence lawyer, Colin Mandy, Patterson remembered her relief when Gail and Don came to stay after the couple had their first baby in Perth.
"She taught about settling after a feed and interpreting cries," Patterson said
Patterson also credited pastor Ian Wilkinson with her first spiritual experience at the Korumburra Baptist Church, leading her to convert to Christianity.
She said that while the family had been close, she had started to feel a growing distance after her split with Simon in 2015.
The couple had moved from Perth to Gippsland to be closer to his family after embarking on a number of months-long road trips across the country.
But Patterson was becoming "concerned" that her estranged husband didn't want her involved in the family.
"I had felt for some months that my relationship with the wider Patterson family, particularly Don and Gail, had a bit more distance or space put between us, we saw each other less," she said.
The tension came to a head when Patterson was excluded from Gail's 70th birthday.
By late 2022, interactions between Patterson and her estranged husband had "increased the heat", she said.
Patterson said anger and resentment in the relationship grew after the pair failed to find a resolution over child support payments, including school and medical fees.
Don and Gail were acting as mediators, encouraging the couple to pray together.
"They thought that Simon and I should settle the issue together, but they didn't want to become official mediators," she said.
Evidence extracted from Patterson's Facebook messages showed her growing frustration, the court heard.
"This family, I swear to f--king god," she messaged Facebook friends at the time.
The prosecution did not allege a motive for Patterson to murder three people and attempt to murder another.
READ MORE: 'This family, swear to f--king god': what we learned from Erin Patterson
Before her arrest, Patterson had made plans for the future, including making an appointment to discuss weight loss methods at a Melbourne clinic in 2023.
She had also been accepted into a Bachelor of Nursing and Midwifery at Federation University to begin in 2024.
The convicted killer has been remanded in jail since her arrest in November 2023.
She awaits sentencing.
- with AAP
After almost three months of hearing evidence in a regional courtroom, a jury has found that death cap mushroom killer Erin Patterson poisoned her in-laws.
The triple-murder trial entered its eleventh week on July 7 as the jury returned its verdict to the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court after hearing from more than 50 witnesses.
The 50-year-old was found guilty of murdering Don and Gail Patterson, as well as Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, when she fed the group a fatal dose of death cap mushroom in a beef Wellington lunch in 2023.
Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband, survived the meal after a successful liver transplant.
Wearing a paisley blouse, Erin Patterson blinked but appeared expressionless as a jury foreperson uttered the words "guilty" four times over the murders and attempted murder of her estranged husband Simon's family.
Outside court, her friend, Ali Rose Prior, told the waiting large national and international media throng she was "saddened" by the verdicts, but "it is what it is".
"I didn't have any expectations, it's the justice system and it has to be what it is," she told reporters outside the Latrobe Valley courts, in Morwell.
Ms Prior, who attended the entire trial, confirmed Patterson had told her "see you soon", and that she would visit her friend in prison.
In a statement, Victoria Police said they acknowledged the jury's decision.
"Our thoughts are with the respective families at this time, and we acknowledge how difficult these past two years have been for them.
"We will continue to support them in every way possible following this decision," the statement read.
They also acknowledged the work of Homicide Squad detectives during the "complex investigation" and the support of other areas across their organisation.
A spokesperson for the Patterson family had no comment as they left the court.
Simon Patterson, the killer's estranged husband, declined her invitation for lunch, saying their relationship was too tense for him to comfortably attend.
The prosecution argued that Patterson had planned and carried out a plot to kill her husband's family.
Crown Prosecutor Nanette Rogers said that Patterson had "secreted" a lethal dose of death cap mushroom poison into the home-cooked beef Wellingtons.
She also argued that Patterson told her lunch guests that she had cancer, but that the diagnosis was fabricated.
Dr Rogers told the court that Patterson had attempted to "conceal the truth" with a sustained cover-up after the deaths.
The jury also heard that Patterson pretended to fall sick after the July 29 lunch.
She claimed that foraged death cap mushrooms were in the meal by mistake and maintained her innocence throughout the proceedings.
READ MORE: 'No, that's not true': accused mushroom killer denies deliberate poisoning
Over the course of the trial, the jury heard of a close family relationship between Patterson and her in-laws before the fateful lunch.
Patterson first met her estranged husband's family 20 years ago, in 2005, when the pair started dating after meeting through friends at Melbourne's Monash City Council.
The Pattersons had provided emotional and logistical support to the young couple, the court heard.
While being questioned by her defence lawyer, Colin Mandy, Patterson remembered her relief when Gail and Don came to stay after the couple had their first baby in Perth.
"She taught about settling after a feed and interpreting cries," Patterson said
Patterson also credited pastor Ian Wilkinson with her first spiritual experience at the Korumburra Baptist Church, leading her to convert to Christianity.
She said that while the family had been close, she had started to feel a growing distance after her split with Simon in 2015.
The couple had moved from Perth to Gippsland to be closer to his family after embarking on a number of months-long road trips across the country.
But Patterson was becoming "concerned" that her estranged husband didn't want her involved in the family.
"I had felt for some months that my relationship with the wider Patterson family, particularly Don and Gail, had a bit more distance or space put between us, we saw each other less," she said.
The tension came to a head when Patterson was excluded from Gail's 70th birthday.
By late 2022, interactions between Patterson and her estranged husband had "increased the heat", she said.
Patterson said anger and resentment in the relationship grew after the pair failed to find a resolution over child support payments, including school and medical fees.
Don and Gail were acting as mediators, encouraging the couple to pray together.
"They thought that Simon and I should settle the issue together, but they didn't want to become official mediators," she said.
Evidence extracted from Patterson's Facebook messages showed her growing frustration, the court heard.
"This family, I swear to f--king god," she messaged Facebook friends at the time.
The prosecution did not allege a motive for Patterson to murder three people and attempt to murder another.
READ MORE: 'This family, swear to f--king god': what we learned from Erin Patterson
Before her arrest, Patterson had made plans for the future, including making an appointment to discuss weight loss methods at a Melbourne clinic in 2023.
She had also been accepted into a Bachelor of Nursing and Midwifery at Federation University to begin in 2024.
The convicted killer has been remanded in jail since her arrest in November 2023.
She awaits sentencing.
- with AAP
After almost three months of hearing evidence in a regional courtroom, a jury has found that death cap mushroom killer Erin Patterson poisoned her in-laws.
The triple-murder trial entered its eleventh week on July 7 as the jury returned its verdict to the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court after hearing from more than 50 witnesses.
The 50-year-old was found guilty of murdering Don and Gail Patterson, as well as Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, when she fed the group a fatal dose of death cap mushroom in a beef Wellington lunch in 2023.
Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband, survived the meal after a successful liver transplant.
Wearing a paisley blouse, Erin Patterson blinked but appeared expressionless as a jury foreperson uttered the words "guilty" four times over the murders and attempted murder of her estranged husband Simon's family.
Outside court, her friend, Ali Rose Prior, told the waiting large national and international media throng she was "saddened" by the verdicts, but "it is what it is".
"I didn't have any expectations, it's the justice system and it has to be what it is," she told reporters outside the Latrobe Valley courts, in Morwell.
Ms Prior, who attended the entire trial, confirmed Patterson had told her "see you soon", and that she would visit her friend in prison.
In a statement, Victoria Police said they acknowledged the jury's decision.
"Our thoughts are with the respective families at this time, and we acknowledge how difficult these past two years have been for them.
"We will continue to support them in every way possible following this decision," the statement read.
They also acknowledged the work of Homicide Squad detectives during the "complex investigation" and the support of other areas across their organisation.
A spokesperson for the Patterson family had no comment as they left the court.
Simon Patterson, the killer's estranged husband, declined her invitation for lunch, saying their relationship was too tense for him to comfortably attend.
The prosecution argued that Patterson had planned and carried out a plot to kill her husband's family.
Crown Prosecutor Nanette Rogers said that Patterson had "secreted" a lethal dose of death cap mushroom poison into the home-cooked beef Wellingtons.
She also argued that Patterson told her lunch guests that she had cancer, but that the diagnosis was fabricated.
Dr Rogers told the court that Patterson had attempted to "conceal the truth" with a sustained cover-up after the deaths.
The jury also heard that Patterson pretended to fall sick after the July 29 lunch.
She claimed that foraged death cap mushrooms were in the meal by mistake and maintained her innocence throughout the proceedings.
READ MORE: 'No, that's not true': accused mushroom killer denies deliberate poisoning
Over the course of the trial, the jury heard of a close family relationship between Patterson and her in-laws before the fateful lunch.
Patterson first met her estranged husband's family 20 years ago, in 2005, when the pair started dating after meeting through friends at Melbourne's Monash City Council.
The Pattersons had provided emotional and logistical support to the young couple, the court heard.
While being questioned by her defence lawyer, Colin Mandy, Patterson remembered her relief when Gail and Don came to stay after the couple had their first baby in Perth.
"She taught about settling after a feed and interpreting cries," Patterson said
Patterson also credited pastor Ian Wilkinson with her first spiritual experience at the Korumburra Baptist Church, leading her to convert to Christianity.
She said that while the family had been close, she had started to feel a growing distance after her split with Simon in 2015.
The couple had moved from Perth to Gippsland to be closer to his family after embarking on a number of months-long road trips across the country.
But Patterson was becoming "concerned" that her estranged husband didn't want her involved in the family.
"I had felt for some months that my relationship with the wider Patterson family, particularly Don and Gail, had a bit more distance or space put between us, we saw each other less," she said.
The tension came to a head when Patterson was excluded from Gail's 70th birthday.
By late 2022, interactions between Patterson and her estranged husband had "increased the heat", she said.
Patterson said anger and resentment in the relationship grew after the pair failed to find a resolution over child support payments, including school and medical fees.
Don and Gail were acting as mediators, encouraging the couple to pray together.
"They thought that Simon and I should settle the issue together, but they didn't want to become official mediators," she said.
Evidence extracted from Patterson's Facebook messages showed her growing frustration, the court heard.
"This family, I swear to f--king god," she messaged Facebook friends at the time.
The prosecution did not allege a motive for Patterson to murder three people and attempt to murder another.
READ MORE: 'This family, swear to f--king god': what we learned from Erin Patterson
Before her arrest, Patterson had made plans for the future, including making an appointment to discuss weight loss methods at a Melbourne clinic in 2023.
She had also been accepted into a Bachelor of Nursing and Midwifery at Federation University to begin in 2024.
The convicted killer has been remanded in jail since her arrest in November 2023.
She awaits sentencing.
- with AAP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
10 hours ago
- ABC News
Homicide Squad detectives investigating after baby found dead in Balcatta home
A baby has been found dead in a home in the Perth suburb of Balcatta. Homicide Squad detectives are investigating the death of the infant, who was aged under 12 months. Police say the investigation is in the preliminary stages and family members of the infant are assisting detectives with their inquiries. St John Ambulance sent several crews to the home shortly after 3am on Monday morning. A spokesperson said a woman was taken to Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital.
The Age
12 hours ago
- The Age
Anonymous ‘group' claims responsibility for attack on Israel-linked military parts maker
The individual goes on to threaten violence against Lovitt Technologies employees: 'Every worker in this supply chain is complicit … We will decide your fate as you have decided the fate of millions. 'For the past few months, we have been closely watching you. We have your addresses. All the information we have about you will be distributed to our underground networks.' The video began circulating widely online on Monday after it was uploaded to an anonymous Instagram account, but it was first reported by The Guardian late last week. A Victoria Police spokesperson said on Monday that the investigation into the vandal attack had been escalated to its counterterrorism unit. 'The matter is now being investigated by the Victorian Joint Counter Terrorism Team, which includes personnel from Victoria Police, the Australian Federal Police and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation. 'Investigators are aware of a video which has been circulating where a group has claimed responsibility for the incident. This video is being reviewed as part of the ongoing investigation,' the spokesperson said. Loading Alex Ryvchin, co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, said failing to confront the threat of extremist behaviour would harm Australia. 'Seeing a group resembling an al-Qaeda terror cell openly pledging to carry out criminal acts is chilling and disturbing. It doesn't matter that they think they're doing something just and righteous – Islamist terrorists and neo-Nazis think that too. 'What matters is that we remain a country of laws and not allow bands of zealots to decide what is a legitimate target for violence and criminal acts. ' Dvir Abramovich, chair of the Anti-Defamation Commission described the video as a 'manifesto of violence'. 'The people targeted in this video are ordinary Australians. Parents who pack school lunches. Children who kiss them goodnight. 'They were not just threatened, they were told they were being watched. We now face a chilling question: what happens when a campaign of hate leaves the internet and enters your driveway? What happens when slogans turn to gasoline? This is not an isolated episode.' The vandal attack occurred the same night that Sydney man Angelo Loras allegedly attempted to firebomb an East Melbourne synagogue with children and families inside, and 20 people stormed Israeli restaurant Miznon in Melbourne's CBD. Police have not found a formal link between the three incidents or determined if the firebombing was an act of terror. A Lovitt Technologies spokesperson declined to comment, citing the police investigation. Loading The video footage emerged as Victorian Opposition Leader Brad Battin called on the state's new police chief, Mike Bush, to explain what he planned to do to stop expressions of anti-Jewish hatred at public demonstrations. Bush has officially been in the job for two weeks and attended the first meeting of Premier Jacinta Allan's new anti-hate taskforce. Battin expressed frustration that during last Sunday's regular pro-Palestine rally in central Melbourne, protesters chanted 'Death to the IDF' and displayed swastikas without intervention by police who were monitoring the march. 'Mike Bush, obviously, he is fairly new in the job and we will give him the benefit of the doubt, but he needs to be coming out and explaining what he is doing when it comes to the protests here in this state,' Battin said. 'Is he acting on policy from the Victorian government or is he going to go out and start acting to ensure that we can take back the streets and not have this hate speech on Victorian streets? Battin restated his support for the re-introduction of move-on laws for police and backed a recommendation by Australia's Special Envoy for Antisemitism, Jillian Segal, to withdraw government funding from public universities, broadcasters and other organisations which tolerated antisemitism.
Sydney Morning Herald
12 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Anonymous ‘group' claims responsibility for attack on Israel-linked military parts maker
The individual goes on to threaten violence against Lovitt Technologies employees: 'Every worker in this supply chain is complicit … We will decide your fate as you have decided the fate of millions. 'For the past few months, we have been closely watching you. We have your addresses. All the information we have about you will be distributed to our underground networks.' The video began circulating widely online on Monday after it was uploaded to an anonymous Instagram account, but it was first reported by The Guardian late last week. A Victoria Police spokesperson said on Monday that the investigation into the vandal attack had been escalated to its counterterrorism unit. 'The matter is now being investigated by the Victorian Joint Counter Terrorism Team, which includes personnel from Victoria Police, the Australian Federal Police and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation. 'Investigators are aware of a video which has been circulating where a group has claimed responsibility for the incident. This video is being reviewed as part of the ongoing investigation,' the spokesperson said. Loading Alex Ryvchin, co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, said failing to confront the threat of extremist behaviour would harm Australia. 'Seeing a group resembling an al-Qaeda terror cell openly pledging to carry out criminal acts is chilling and disturbing. It doesn't matter that they think they're doing something just and righteous – Islamist terrorists and neo-Nazis think that too. 'What matters is that we remain a country of laws and not allow bands of zealots to decide what is a legitimate target for violence and criminal acts. ' Dvir Abramovich, chair of the Anti-Defamation Commission described the video as a 'manifesto of violence'. 'The people targeted in this video are ordinary Australians. Parents who pack school lunches. Children who kiss them goodnight. 'They were not just threatened, they were told they were being watched. We now face a chilling question: what happens when a campaign of hate leaves the internet and enters your driveway? What happens when slogans turn to gasoline? This is not an isolated episode.' The vandal attack occurred the same night that Sydney man Angelo Loras allegedly attempted to firebomb an East Melbourne synagogue with children and families inside, and 20 people stormed Israeli restaurant Miznon in Melbourne's CBD. Police have not found a formal link between the three incidents or determined if the firebombing was an act of terror. A Lovitt Technologies spokesperson declined to comment, citing the police investigation. Loading The video footage emerged as Victorian Opposition Leader Brad Battin called on the state's new police chief, Mike Bush, to explain what he planned to do to stop expressions of anti-Jewish hatred at public demonstrations. Bush has officially been in the job for two weeks and attended the first meeting of Premier Jacinta Allan's new anti-hate taskforce. Battin expressed frustration that during last Sunday's regular pro-Palestine rally in central Melbourne, protesters chanted 'Death to the IDF' and displayed swastikas without intervention by police who were monitoring the march. 'Mike Bush, obviously, he is fairly new in the job and we will give him the benefit of the doubt, but he needs to be coming out and explaining what he is doing when it comes to the protests here in this state,' Battin said. 'Is he acting on policy from the Victorian government or is he going to go out and start acting to ensure that we can take back the streets and not have this hate speech on Victorian streets? Battin restated his support for the re-introduction of move-on laws for police and backed a recommendation by Australia's Special Envoy for Antisemitism, Jillian Segal, to withdraw government funding from public universities, broadcasters and other organisations which tolerated antisemitism.
