Vatican hardens tone on Israel after Gaza parish strike
An Israeli army strike on the only Catholic church in Gaza last week has pushed the Vatican to change its tone on Israel and blame it more directly in the dragging war -- a break from its traditional diplomacy strategy.
The strike killed three people in the Holy Family Church in the centre of Gaza City -- prompting condemnation by politicians and by religious leaders of various denominations.
Pope Leo XIV on Sunday slammed the 'barbarity' of the war and the blind 'use of force,' denouncing 'the attack by the Israeli army.'
It was a change of language after two years of tireless, repetitive calls for peace by the Vatican under former Pope Francis, who died in April.
Francois Mabille, an analyst at France's Geopolitical Observatory of Religion, said the statements represent an increasingly critical view of Israel in the Catholic world.
Beyond growing anger worldwide at the human cost of the Gaza war, he cited 'the fact that it's happening on holy ground.'
It is leading to 'at least a temporary shift in Catholic opinion in general,' he told AFP.
On Friday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called Pope Leo -- who became pontiff in May -- and said his country 'deeply regrets' the strike, blaming a 'stray missile' and vowing an investigation.
Netanyahu's spokesman said the conversation was 'friendly' and that the two men agreed to meet soon.
But on the same day, in an interview with Italian broadcaster Rai 2, the Vatican's second-in-command -- Cardinal Pietro Parolin -- implied the strike may have been intentional.
He called on Israel to publicise the findings of its investigation to find out 'if it really was an error, which we can legitimately doubt, or if there was a will to directly attack a Christian church.'
The Vatican also sent the cardinal of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, on a rare visit to Gaza Friday, where he visited the wounded and conducted a mass at the Holy Family Church.
The visit was meant to show that Catholic authorities were determined to stay in Gaza.
'We are not a target. They say it was a mistake, even if everyone here does not believe that is the case,' the cardinal told Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera.
'Tyrant'
Mabille, the analyst, said the Holy See is now also using 'more precise vocabulary based on legal categories.'
On Sunday, the American-born pope called for the international community to 'observe humanitarian law and respect the obligation to protect civilians, as well as the prohibition of collective punishment, the indiscriminate use of force, and the forced displacement of populations.'
Mabille said that constituted four fundamental rights under humanitarian law that are being violated by Netanyahu's government.
Some Catholic officials are going much further.
In an interview to Italy's La Stampa newspaper, Cardinal Augusto Paolo Lojudice -- who also serves as a judge at a Vatican tribunal -- said Netanyahu is 'not stopping because he is a tyrant pursuing a dark and bloodthirsty plan for power'.
Lojudice -- who worked with Leo for several years before was made pope -- accused Israel of 'evil without logic' in Gaza.
The Vatican, which since 2015 has recognised the state of Palestine, supports a two-state solution in Israel.
It has also called for a special international status for Jerusalem, with free and safe access to religious sites there.
Already strained ties with Israel degraded further after Israel launched its assault following Hamas's deadly October 7, 2023 attack.
Diverging from the Vatican's official line, Pope Francis questioned whether Israel's heavy handed military response amounted to 'genocide' in Gaza.
The current tense diplomatic exchanges also come after a small Christian village in the central occupied West Bank was burnt down in early July and during heightened criticism of Israeli settler attacks.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Pressure on Netanyahu intensifies as Israeli military chief opposes Gaza war expansion
Social Sharing Israel's military chief has pushed back against Benjamin Netanyahu's plans to seize areas of Gaza it doesn't already control, three Israeli officials said, as the prime minister faces increasing pressure over the war both at home and abroad. During a tense, three-hour meeting on Tuesday, military chief of staff Eyal Zamir warned the prime minister that taking the rest of Gaza could trap the military in the territory, which it withdrew from two decades ago, and could lead to harm to the hostages being held there, according to sources briefed on the meeting. The Israeli military says it already controls 75 per cent of Gaza after nearly two years of war, which began when militant group Hamas attacked southern Israeli communities in October 2023. It has repeatedly opposed imposing military rule, annexing the territory and rebuilding Jewish settlements there — policies advocated by some government members. Netanyahu is under intense international pressure to reach a ceasefire in the coastal enclave, which has been reduced to rubble in the fighting. Most of its two million people have been displaced multiple times, and aid groups say residents are on the verge of famine. WATCH | UN official says full occupation would be 'catastrophic': Israel expanding Gaza operations risks 'catastrophic consequences,' UN official says 3 hours ago The UN has called reports about a possible expansion of Israel's military operations in Gaza "deeply alarming" if true. The military, which accuses Hamas of operating among civilians, has at times avoided areas where intelligence suggested hostages were held. Former captives have said their captors threatened to kill them if Israeli forces approached. Netanyahu told Zamir that so far the military had failed to bring about the release of the hostages, the officials said, speaking on the condition of anonymity. Most of those freed so far came about as a result of diplomatic negotiations. Defence Minister Israel Katz wrote on X Wednesday that the military chief has both the right and the duty to voice his opinion, but said that the military would carry out the government's decisions until all war objectives are achieved. The prime minister's office confirmed the meeting with Zamir on Tuesday but declined to comment further. The military did not respond to a request for comment. The prime minister is scheduled to discuss military plans for Gaza with other ministers on Thursday. A fourth source said Netanyahu wants to expand military operations in Gaza to put pressure on Hamas. Netanyahu, who in May said that Israel would control all of Gaza, leads the most right-wing coalition government in Israel's history. Some of his key partners have in the past threatened to quit if the government ended the war. Following a 40-minute meeting with the prime minister on Wednesday, opposition leader Yair Lapid told reporters he had advised Netanyahu that the public was not interested in continuing the war and that a full military takeover would be a bad idea. Emaciated hostages There are 50 hostages still being held in Gaza, of whom at least 20 are believed to be alive. Videos released last week by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, another militant group in Gaza, showed two extremely emaciated captives and triggered international condemnation. Nearly 200 Palestinians have died of starvation in Gaza since the war began, about half of them children, according to Gaza's health ministry. More than 20 died on Wednesday when a truck believed to be carrying food overturned as it was swarmed by a desperate crowd, according to local health authorities. Salim Asfour, 85, said he's lost upward of 50 pounds due to a lack of food in the enclave. He said he's too weak to walk the 20-kilometre round trip from Khan Younis to Rafah for aid. "I can't even walk a metre. I lean on my son to go to the bathroom," he told CBC News freelance journalist Mohamed El Saife in Khan Younis. "Even if I got to the aid, how am I supposed to carry it? How can I carry a bag of flour?" WATCH | Aid drops into Gaza on Monday: Military plane drops food aid into Gaza 2 days ago A freelance videographer working for CBC News was on the ground in central Gaza Monday at the same time as a Canadian military plane was dropping aid from above. Mohamed El Saife ran with his camera alongside Palestinians trying to reach the falling parachutes, witnessing the chaos as people rushed to grab whatever they could get. The latest ceasefire talks in Qatar broke down last month. Hamas insists any deal must lead to a permanent end to the war, while Israel accuses the group of lacking sincerity about giving up power afterward and must be defeated. An expansion of the military offensive in heavily populated areas would likely be devastating. "I wish I could get treatment and go back to normal like I was before, and we end this war that destroyed our families, destroyed our lives and left us without any desire to live," said Asfour. "We just want to be done with it." The war in Gaza has also overextended Israel's military, which has a small standing army and has had to repeatedly mobilize reservists. It is not clear if more reservists would be needed to expand operations and take more territory. The military continued to carry out air strikes across Gaza on Wednesday, killing at least 135 people in the past 24 hours, the Gaza health ministry said, with the death toll since the beginning of the conflict now at more than 61,000, mostly civilians, it says. About 1,200 people were killed, including more than 700 civilians, and 251 hostages taken to Gaza after the Hamas-led attack on Israel, according to Israeli tallies.
Edmonton Journal
2 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Israeli President decries Hamas 'manipulation' after German media exposes 'staged' Gaza photography
Article content A historian and visual documentation expert interviewed by Süddeutsche Zeitung added that while not all such images are outright fakes, they are often 'positioned a certain way or paired with misleading captions that tap into our visual memory and emotions.' Article content Herzog urged the international community to resist falling for such distortions. 'We do not deny the humanitarian need in Gaza,' he said, 'but we ask the world not to fall for Hamas' lies. Condemn Hamas and tell them: You want to move forward? Release the hostages.' Article content He emphasized that Israel has drastically increased its humanitarian aid efforts, saying: 'In the last week alone, we've brought in 30,000 tons of aid — 30 tons by air yesterday alone. The UN has almost 800 trucks they could distribute — and failed to do so. So a lot could have been done.' Article content A special report by The Press Service of Israel on Thursday found that according to the UN's own numbers, a staggering 85 per cent of the aid entering the Gaza Strip by truck since May 19 has been stolen. The investigation found that a combination of black market profiteers and inflation have made much of the aid in Gaza markets unaffordable for most Palestinians. Article content Article content Palestinian sources inside Gaza told TPS-IL that much of the food in the markets originated from international aid for months — including American shipments — but is resold at inflated prices, sometimes 300 per cent. Basic staples like flour and rice, originally meant for free distribution, are reportedly diverted to private vendors. Article content One Palestinian in Gaza City told TPS-IL: 'The flour — when it enters Gaza, they steal it. And now they're going to raise the price from 30 to 60 shekels ($8.80 to $17.70). It's unbelievable.' Article content Professor Eytan Gilboa, an expert in international relations and media at Reichman University in Herzliya, told TPS-IL, 'There is some hunger in Gaza, and it exists only in places Hamas is pursuing it, not in other areas.' Article content In 2024, experts told TPS-IL that two Gaza-based Palestinian freelance journalists committed war crimes by entering Israel during Hamas's October 7 massacres.
National Post
2 hours ago
- National Post
Israeli President decries Hamas 'manipulation' after German media exposes 'staged' Gaza photography
Article content Herzog urged the international community to resist falling for such distortions. 'We do not deny the humanitarian need in Gaza,' he said, 'but we ask the world not to fall for Hamas' lies. Condemn Hamas and tell them: You want to move forward? Release the hostages.' Article content He emphasized that Israel has drastically increased its humanitarian aid efforts, saying: 'In the last week alone, we've brought in 30,000 tons of aid — 30 tons by air yesterday alone. The UN has almost 800 trucks they could distribute — and failed to do so. So a lot could have been done.' Article content A special report by The Press Service of Israel on Thursday found that according to the UN's own numbers, a staggering 85 per cent of the aid entering the Gaza Strip by truck since May 19 has been stolen. The investigation found that a combination of black market profiteers and inflation have made much of the aid in Gaza markets unaffordable for most Palestinians. Article content Palestinian sources inside Gaza told TPS-IL that much of the food in the markets originated from international aid for months — including American shipments — but is resold at inflated prices, sometimes 300 per cent. Basic staples like flour and rice, originally meant for free distribution, are reportedly diverted to private vendors. Article content One Palestinian in Gaza City told TPS-IL: 'The flour — when it enters Gaza, they steal it. And now they're going to raise the price from 30 to 60 shekels ($8.80 to $17.70). It's unbelievable.' Article content Professor Eytan Gilboa, an expert in international relations and media at Reichman University in Herzliya, told TPS-IL, 'There is some hunger in Gaza, and it exists only in places Hamas is pursuing it, not in other areas.' Article content In 2024, experts told TPS-IL that two Gaza-based Palestinian freelance journalists committed war crimes by entering Israel during Hamas's October 7 massacres.
