NUMBERS GAME: India have given 17 debuts in women's ODIs since December 2023 – what does it mean in the lead up to a World Cup?
Playing for your country at the highest level is a dream every cricketer harbours, the feeling of making a debut is unmatched, but how many is too many? On Sunday in Colombo, India captain Harmanpreet Kaur said something at the toss that has now become a regularity: there was a debutant in the playing XI for the Women's ODI Tri-series final, with Madhya Pradesh pacer Kranti Goud getting her first international cap. It was the fourth different debutant for India just in this tri-series in Sri Lanka alone, continuing a trend we have seen over the past year or so.
Picking India's three-match ODI series against Australia that started on December 28, 2023, as a starting point, India have handed debuts to a whopping 17 players in the 23 matches they have played to date. From Saika Ishaque and Shreyanka Patil in that series to Kashvee Gautam, Sree Charani, Shuchi Upadhyay and Kranti Goud in the Tri-series in Colombo, the Indian selectors and management have been generous in fielding newcomers. While it could be seen as an indication of the widening talent pool, and injuries have played a part too, the bigger concern is the lack of continuity.
In comparison, during this same period, Australia – the benchmark in women's cricket – have had one debutant across 18 matches, to exciting young batter Georgia Voll. The other top World Cup title contender England have played 18 matches in this duration and handed 6 debuts. But even all of those came in the September 2024 series against Ireland when Kate Cross led a much-changed side.
India's 17 debuts since December 2023 is by some distance the most across the 8 teams who will be playing at the ODI World Cup starting end of September in India. While each of those cricketers would have their own journeys to the top of the international game, and there is nothing to take away from their efforts, the lack of consistency in selection leading up to a home World Cup makes for worrying reading.
In his stint as India's head coach, Amol Muzumdar, along with captain Harmanpreet, seems to be searching for the right bowling combination. India have used 32 different players in ODIs since that series in Mumbai against Australia 17 months back.
A majority of the newcomers have either been spinners or medium pacers.
The full list of India's debutants in women's ODI since December 27, 2023 reads like this: Saika Ishaque, Shreyanka Patil, Mannat Kashyap, S Asha, Arundhati Reddy, Tejal Hasabnis, Saima Thakor, Priya Mishra, Titas Sadhu, Minnu Mani, Pratika Rawal, Tanuja Kanwar, Sayali Sathgare, Kashvee Gautam, Sree Charani, Shuchi Upadhyay, Kranti Goud.
The clear pattern is India's search for a potent bowling unit. Renuka Singh Thakur (now injured) and Deepti Sharma have perhaps been the only two consistent picks, while the remaining spots have witnessed musical chairs. Among the debutants, only Saima and Pratika have featured in at least 10 matches, most of them out of reckoning after a few games. Each new debut is a question mark over a player who was picked and dropped without too many games to feature in. And given the lack of transparency in Indian women team selections, with barely any information on the reasoning for players getting overlooked, it is tough to understand what the thought process is heading towards a World Cup.
With only 15 slots available ultimately, and the batting unit appearing largely settled, the big question is what have the Indian selectors, coach and captain actually learned from using this vast pool of players? And additionally, are the players aware where they stand and what they need to do to seal a spot in the squad once they get selected? Just five months away from the World Cup, and only scheduled series left to play, there are more questions than answers around India's squad composition.
Vinayakk Mohanarangan is Senior Assistant Editor and is based in New Delhi. ... Read More
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
27 minutes ago
- Mint
India Tour of England 2025: A tightrope walk awaits Shubman Gill
Has Shubman Gill been thrown into the deep end with nothing more than a rubber duckie as flotation aid? The clean-cut, square-jawed, calm-eyed, close-shaved 25-year-old with 8% body fat has been given the highest honour in cricket, that of leading his country in Tests, and he begins his tenure with one of the toughest, most keenly watched assignments in Indian cricket—a five-match Test tour of England beginning 20 June. If the importance of the series is not enough of a challenge, Gill will be leading a team not so much in transition as it is in radical overhaul. Also read: 'You can't fight it": Steve Waugh on the rise of T20s and the future of Test cricket This is the first Test series post the retirements of three of India's biggest names in Test cricket in the past decade—Virat Kohli, Ravichandran Ashwin and Rohit Sharma. That leaves a team with a largely unproven batting order: opening duties will fall to the young Yashasvi Jaiswal, all of 19 Tests old, but in tremendous form, and Abhimanyu Easwaran, who is yet to make his debut. The rest of the batters include Gill himself, who averages in the middling mid-30s, and just over a year back was struggling to justify his place in the squad; a first-time call-up for Sai Sudharsan not for First Class credentials but courtesy his white-ball breakthroughs; and a callback from the wilderness for Karun Nair who has been unceremoniously ignored for nearly a decade despite becoming India's second triple-centurion in only his third Test in 2016 (he would play only three more Tests that year before being forgotten). That leaves Gill with only two batters with experience—K.L. Rahul and Rishabh Pant, who is still on the path to rediscovering his old form after a terrifying car crash in 2022 left him out of the game for over a year. The bowling department fares a little better, but only because in Jasprit Bumrah, Gill has the services of the best fast bowler in the game right now, and one of the best in the history of cricket. Beyond Bumrah, the bowling department comes with the same uncertainties as the batting—a bunch of tyros in the form of Arshdeep Singh, Prasidh Krishna and Akash Deep, Mohammed Siraj, who is searching for the lost magic that made him so lethal from his debut in 2020 till 2023, and only one true spinner in Kuldeep Yadav. The England series then, is a delicious prospect to observe how Gill's personality as a leader stands up in the face of uncertainty and a team that needs some serious building, offering the same thrills as a survival-themed reality show. Gill has long been seen as a potential leader in Indian cricket's corridors of power, even though he was not a captain in his Under-19 days, has led India only once on an easy assignment—an ODI series in Zimbabwe which India won—and has led the IPL team Gujarat Titans for just two seasons with quiet competence but not radical success. On the field, Gill carries himself with an unassuming air—he is mostly silent, his celebrations are subdued, and his body language is calm to the point of being placid. If you did not look for him, you would not know he is there. Will that change as he grows into his captainship? The Indian cricket team, especially in Tests, has always been influenced heavily by the personality of the captain. Saurav Ganguly's tenure marked the first major shift. India went from being a team with great individual batting talent but an overly gentle, easily rolled over unit without a strong identity to a combative, daring, fractious team that used both cricketing skills as well as mind games to try and win games. It signalled the rise of India as a serious Test-playing nation, one that could beat the very best on some days. Ganguly, with his Jekyll & Hyde personality—soft spoken, if imperious, with perfect manners on the one hand, ruthless, scheming, and unruly on the other (remember his shirt-off celebrations on the hallowed Lords' balcony?)—was very much the face of this new identity that gave no importance to established hierarchies in the cricketing world. Also read: Women's Premier League: Breaking barriers one season at a time M.S. Dhoni's tenure as captain encapsulated a wider shift in Indian cricket culture. A game that was once dominated by the rich and the royal, and then by the resolutely urban, had finally spread across the length and breadth of the country, bringing players from small towns and villages on to the big stage. Dhoni's colourful, off-kilter personality, his complete lack of fear and extreme self-belief was reflected more in his white-ball captaincy (in this regard, by winning the inaugural T20 World Cup, he changed not just Indian cricket, but the course of international cricket) than his Test leadership, where he tended to be more cautious and defensive. But he did build on Ganguly's legacy by taking India to the top of the Test world rankings for the first time in its history. All of this was leading, with an air of inevitability, to the phenomenon known as Virat Kohli. Kohli took over as the leader of the Indian Test side in much the same circumstances as Gill is doing now. Kohli was just a few months older than Gill is, averaged in the mid-30s with the bat, was struggling to establish himself in the team after a disastrous tour of England, and had to deal with a team in transition after Dhoni announced he was stepping down as captain to the surprise of everyone. But from the moment Kohli led India out to the Test arena for the first time, there was no doubt—this was a captain with a capital C rendered in bold. If Ganguly introduced fighting spirit and Dhoni added grit to the mix, Kohli transformed the team into battle-hardened unit charging into war. Everything was amped up under Kohli—aggression, mind games, verbal spats, glaring confrontations like you would expect in boxing weigh-ins, brutal press conferences, sledging, fearless, dominating batting displays, and most importantly, the totally unlikely rise of India as the world's finest fast-bowling nation. Not surprisingly, Kohli is India's most successful Test captain (40 wins in 68 matches), with an unbeaten record in Test series at home (31 wins, two losses), the first ever series win at that final frontier, Australia, and with a long reign at the top of the Test rankings. There is not much to say about Gill's immediate predecessor Rohit Sharma, since he took over the team almost as an accident—he was the only senior player when Kohli stepped down—and had a short stint marked with heavy defeats, except that after Kohli's high-octane years, maybe the management felt that the team needed someone with the laidback, everyone's 'bhaiyya" kind of vibe that Sharma is known for (which is not to take anything away from his tactical nous, which was always on display in the IPL where he tasted unprecedented success with Mumbai Indians, as well as in ODIs and T20s). All this is to say that Gill has plenty of history to live up to, and what he brings to the field in terms of his mindset may be transformative for Indian cricket. If there's one thing he has already shown us, it's this: in this age of T20, he is a player who has the necessary diligence for Tests—the patience, the body language, and the classical batting style, in the mould of Rahul Dravid, that makes for a great Test batter—and the ability to explode into frenetic action that brings success in the shortest format. And that's a mean tightrope to walk. Rudraneil Sengupta is the author of The Beast Within, a detective novel set in Delhi. Also read: Why Rafael Nadal will forever remain the greatest star of French Open
India.com
29 minutes ago
- India.com
Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma's absence instantly felt as Team India arrives in England
Shubman Gill-led Indian Test team arrived in London on Saturday New Delhi: India's upcoming Test tour of England will be the first since 2011 without Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, who recently retired from the format. The team, now captained by Shubman Gill, arrived in London to a low-key reception, highlighting the absence of the two veteran batsmen. Kohli's arrival in Adelaide last November for India's Australian tour generated significant media and fan excitement. The anticipation surrounding what was potentially his last Test series in Australia was immense, leading to a closed-door practice session that didn't deter enthusiastic fans from seeking a view of the renowned cricketer. Following the arrival of the Indian cricket team in London for a five-match Test series beginning June 20, no public appearances were made by the team on Saturday. A social media video from Indian journalist Vimal Kumar drew attention to this. 'I did not get to see that hype. Not a single fan or media personnel was seen,' said Vimal in the video. No kohli no hype , I am here for long time to witness the downfall of indian Test cricket. Empty airports , stadiums …get used to it . — Raj 🐺 (@the__choosenone) June 7, 2025 When BCCI announced Captain is Gill the Test Aura gone there itself — Srikar Rebel (@SrikarRebel8) June 7, 2025 No King Kohli, no hype. — Sports syncs (@moiz_sports) June 7, 2025 Some cricket fans believed the retirement of Kohli and Rohit Sharma signaled the end of an era for Indian Test cricket, even predicting its decline. Others, however, expressed confidence that Shubman Gill's future performances would restore the team's prestige. At a Mumbai press conference, Gill was questioned about the absence of Kohli and Rohit and the resulting pressure on the younger team members. He confidently responded that this challenge was comparable to others the team had previously overcome. 'Pressure is always there in every tour. Definitely, two very experienced players who played for such a long time and won so many times, very difficult to fill their space. But it is not a different kind of pressure, all of us players are used to it,' he said in the pre-tour presser on Wednesday.
India Today
29 minutes ago
- India Today
South Africa's chokers-tag one for the past: Mark Boucher ahead of WTC Final
Former South Africa batter and coach Mark Boucher believes it's time to leave the 'chokers' tag in the past. As the Proteas gear up for the ICC World Test Championship Final against Australia, Boucher said this new-look side should not be burdened by labels tied to past to ESPN, Boucher reflected on South Africa's recent near-misses — most notably their T20 World Cup final loss to India — and stressed that it would be unfair to brand the current squad with a term rooted in playing for a trophy, so I guess a lot of people are saying no [we can't win] but I think it's a different feel in Test match cricket. It's played over a longer period of time and you've just got to win big moments in the game as well,' Boucher told ESPNcricinfo. 'Yes, there will be that tag [chokers] that gets thrown our way until we win a trophy. You're not going to get rid of the tag. Is it deserving on these youngsters coming through? No, it's almost like they're carrying the burden of what happened in previous years, which is always going to be tough on them but they're the ones in control of their futures at the moment,' he Africa's much-anticipated clash with Pat Cummins' Australia begins on June 11. For Temba Bavuma's men, it presents not just an opportunity to win their first ICC title in over two decades, but also to set a fresh narrative for Test cricket in a nation traditionally known for its white-ball Proteas booked their place in the final with solid performances against the likes of West Indies and Pakistan, while Australia arrive high on confidence after a home Border-Gavaskar Trophy triumph over the stakes high in this ultimate red-ball showdown, all eyes will be on whether South Africa can hold their nerve and finally break free from the shadows of the past.
