
Karna: The Evil Counsel Of A Jealous Master
From his teenage years, Duryodhana had cultivated a Duṣṭa-traya — a Diabolical Triad comprising Śakuni, Duśyāsana, and Karna, which assisted his self-scripted drama of evil that ultimately ruined him and the Kaurava kingdom and the nation.
This is akin to the sinister cabal surrounding Indira Gandhi whose depraved counsel wrecked India and culminated in her assassination and the genocide of Sikhs — all horrors of her own making.
The parallel doesn't stop here. Karna's loyalty was a personal loyalty exclusively reserved for Duryodhana. For him, Duryodhana was Hastinapura, just as DK Barooah had infamously declared that India was Indira.
The iconic Kannada litterateur, journalist and philosopher, DV Gundappa fleshes out Karna's innate character and the nature of his relationship with Duryodhana:
'When Karna was mocked and humiliated for being the son of a Sūta (charioteer in this case; in general, low birth), he was unable to find a convincing counter to it and had to swallow the indignity."
Indignity bred inferiority within Karna, which in turn spawned a lifelong resentment against the whole world, in a manner of speaking. Duryodhana became the perfect vehicle to channelise this misguided bitterness. Unqualified servility to Duryodhana was an agreeable cost to pay for his unceasing war against the world.
Karna's disgraceful conduct on countless occasions is the earliest and perhaps the perfect case study in the theory and practice of Communism. In its ideological scheme of things, you are not a true Communist if you don't first loathe yourself, and then loathe yourself for life. By extension, a self-loather is also a perpetual blame-hunter. Thus, if I am poor, neglected, disrespected and despised, it is always someone else's fault — that someone else is the invisible but the real entity called society. Every notable Communist ideologue from Karl Marx to today's Woke champions has invariably projected their personal pathologies as injuries done to them by society.
In this context, one can recall Dr SL Bhyrappa's memorable reply when he was asked why he did not become a Communist, given his painful childhood and his struggling student life: 'The same society that treated me unkindly in those early days also gave me opportunities to study and become something. The same society continues to respect me as a writer. I should be grateful and not wage war against it."
This is an obvious and rather straightforward truth that anyone can realise if they set aside their ego and self-pity and look inward.
Thus, Karna's ego operated as a self-induced shame for being labelled as a Sūta. It blinded him to the existence of another stalwart, Vidura — one of the most profound characters in the Mahabharata. Vidura too, hailed from Karna's social strata and he held a place of great dignity in the court of Hastinapura.
Two early episodes in the epic reveal how Karna, like Karl Marx, recasts his personal pathology as a war against the world.
In the Vidurāgamana-Parva of the Adi-Parva, this is what Karna says about women in general but his real target is Draupadi: 'women think that it is desirable to possess more than one husband. Draupadi has attained that."
In the same Parva, we notice Karna admitting that the Pandavas are intrinsically Dharmic and that Duryodhana cannot defeat them on the plane of Dharma. He gives a line by line rebuttal to Duryodhana's strategies to wreck the Pandava unity. In this portion of the Parva, Duryodhana operates from pure jealousy while Karna operates at a fouler level: he knows that the Pandavas are innately virtuous, yet he wants to deliberately injure them. For two basic reasons: One, to please Duryodhana, and two, to extract his personal vengeance against Draupadi. His sickening advice to Duryodhana is breathtaking for its sheer evil: 'Duryodhana! O Lord of the Earth! It is impossible to win against the Pandavas through Sāma, dāna, and bhēda. Victory is possible only through valour (Vikrama)."
Here, Karna gives the honourable trait of valour to justify the launch of an unprovoked, Adharmic war to fulfil his itch for spite. We invoke Gundappa once again:
'… Karna was bereft of the ability to distinguish between Dharma and Adharma in his loyalty towards his benefactor. Karna never felt the need to tell Duryodhana: 'this is good for you, this isn't."
Indeed, more than anybody, Karna unerringly knew that wicked counsel would please his master.
To be continued…
(The author is the founder and chief editor, 'The Dharma Dispatch'. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect News18's views)
view comments
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Controversy over singing, dancing at Guru Tegh Bahadur martyrdom centenary event in Srinagar
PATIALA: A significant controversy emerged over an inclusion of dance and musical performances at the event organised by the Punjab govt's Bhasha Vibhag (Language Department) in Srinagar to commemorate the 350th martyrdom anniversary of Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, the ninth Guru of Sikhs. The dance and singing at Sufi Night drew sharp criticism from Sikh religious leaders and institutions, who described the actions as a clear violation of Sikh religious principles and an insult to the sanctity of the Guru's sacrifice. The event, part of a series of govt initiatives to mark the centenary, featured singers and dance performances, provoking outrage within the Sikh community, particularly on social media. The videos of singing and dance during the event has gone viral over the social media along with a symbolic picture comparing the massacre of Sikhs during Mughal period with picture of singing and dance at event organized by government on July 24. Advocate Harjinder Singh Dhami, President of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC), issued a strong statement labeling the event 'deeply painful' and a violation of Sikh Maryada (code of conduct). by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Is this legal? Access all TV channels without a subscription! Techno Mag Learn More Undo He asserted that such solemn commemorations should only take place in Gurdwaras and Sikh institutions and should involve spiritual practices like Shabad Kirtan, Gurbani Paath, and Gurmat Vichar, rather than entertainment. 'This is why SGPC has always maintained that religious commemorations must not be handled by govt bodies, which lack the sensitivity and understanding of Sikh traditions,' Dhami said. He further demanded a public apology from the Punjab govt and urged Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann to prevent similar events in the future. Dhami added that the Language Department's actions confirmed SGPC's long-standing concerns about govt involvement in Sikh religious affairs. 'Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's martyrdom is not a cultural festivity but a spiritual lesson in sacrifice and righteousness,' he stated, calling for strict guidelines to ensure future respect for Sikh sentiments. Former Shiromani Akali Dal MLA Virsa Singh Valtoha also condemned the programme and called on the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib to take religious action against the organisers. Sarabjit Singh Dhotian, Head Pracharak of the Dharam Prachar Committee, criticised the move in a strong Facebook post, questioning the appropriateness of Sufi music in commemorating a martyrdom that symbolised resistance to religious persecution. Dhotian accused the govt of using taxpayer money to send 'atheists and semi-atheists' on official tours while neglecting core Sikh historical values. 'When Aurangzeb was forcibly converting Kashmiri Pandits, which Sufi saint opposed it? The event mocked the essence of Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's martyrdom. When lakhs of Hindus were being massacred, these Sufis were busy dancing and celebrating their beloved. And now, when govts across the world are committing genocide of Sikhs, these govt scholars and singers are 'dancing' to celebrate martyrdom,' he wrote. Punjab Bhasha Vibhag Joint Director Harpreet Kaur stated, 'The programme organised by Punjab govt was scheduled for July 23-24 in Kashmir. Sufi night was also held.' When asked about the controversy over dance and singing during Sufi night, she replied, 'I don't know what happened during the programme as I have not been there nor have I seen any videos. You may speak to Director Bhasha Vibhag.' She declined to comment further. Jaswant Singh Jafar, Director Bhasha Vibhag, could not be contacted despite repeated attempts. Amarinder Singh, one of the organisers of Punjab government organised event in Srinagar, when questioned about the controversy on singing and dancing during commemoration event, declined to comment reasoning network issue and later did not responded. Sikh intellectuals emphasised that even well-intentioned musical performances should not be part of martyrdom commemorations. The controversy highlighted the delicate balance between govt-sponsored cultural outreach and the preservation of religious sanctity.


The Hindu
7 hours ago
- The Hindu
Questions on Siddaramaiah's tenure as CM persist; leaves for Delhi along with DKS
Will he or won't he? This is the million-dollar question hotly debated in Karnataka's political circles over Chief Minister Siddaramaiah completing his term, even as a unique record beckons the veteran, who along with his deputy and another claimant for the CM's chair, D.K. Shivakumar, once again air dashes to Delhi. Siddaramaiah, in his second term as chief minister, is on the cusp of becoming the longest serving elected head of the state, closing in on veteran Devaraj Urs' record as CM for over 2,700 days. Despite his assertions, questions over whether he will complete a full five year tenure in office, or if he will make way for DKS as per a rumoured rotational formula, persists. Shivakumar is addressed as DKS. The two are in New Delhi in their third trip since June, even as an uneasy calm prevails in the state Congress unit where voices from either camps have fallen silent over the CM issue following a high command gag order. During their visit to the national capital, the two leaders are likely to meet the Congress' top brass. Unlike in the past, there have been no open remarks by MLAs on the CM change issue this time, following the diktat from leadership. However, silent strategies and maneuvering are certainly on, as the government is nearing two-and-half years in office, said a senior Congress leader, summing up the atmosphere within the ruling party. Though the Delhi visit is to attend the "Bhagidari Nyay Sammelan" organised by AICC Backward Class unit on Friday, Congress insiders indicate about the CM possibly meeting party leader Rahul Gandhi. A similar meeting could not happen last time, in the second week of July. However there is no official confirmation in this regard so far. High command keeps both sides waiting There has been speculation within State's political circles, especially within the ruling Congress, for some time now about the CM change later this year, citing the power-sharing agreement involving incumbent Mr. Siddaramaiah and Mr. Shivakumar. However, the Congress leadership seems to have adopted a strategy of keeping both sides waiting, until the Bihar polls are over. Mr. Siddaramaiah is the only OBC chief minister the Congress has in the country at present, and many party leaders are of the opinion that any move to replace him will have a bearing on the party's performance in the poll-bound Bihar, where the OBC votes are crucial. It will also be seen as a move contrary to the OBC cause, which Rahul Gandhi has been championing for, by raising issues such as caste census and enhancing reservation quota, a Congress leader said. The party is fully aware of the consequences it will have to face, if it makes any move against Mr. Siddaramaiah, who has a huge support base among AHINDA (Kannada acronym for minorities, backward classes, and Dalits) communities and also enjoys the confidence of majority of the legislators. In fact, Congress wants to utilise Mr. Siddaramaiah's stature as a mass OBC leader and has made him a member of the AICC OBC advisory council, whose first meeting was held under his leadership here recently. Mr. Siddaramaiah's assertion on continuing as CM for a full five-year tenure, while in Delhi earlier this month, was a direct message to the high command, which has, in a way, maintained a strategic silence regarding leadership change and power-sharing issue, a senior Congress functionary said. Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge had not firmly ruled out anything when he recently stated that it is up to the party high command to decide on such matters and that one should not create any unnecessary problem. The CM, in fact, made the assertion about completing the term, preempting the leadership indulging in any talks on change, even as his government completes two-and-a-half years in office in November, a party leader said. Mr. Siddaramaiah in fact was hoping to meet Rahul Gandhi then, but that did not happen. There was stiff competition between Siddaramaiah and Shivakumar for the chief minister's post after Congress emerged victorious in the 2023 state elections. The party then managed to convince DKS and made him the deputy CM. There were some reports at the time that a compromise had been reached based on a "rotational chief minister formula," according to which Shivakumar will become CM after two-and-half years, but they have not been officially confirmed by the party. "In case there was an understanding on the rotational CM formula and Mr. Siddaramaiah had accepted it, he may negotiate for an extension to match or break D Devaraj Urs' record as the longest-serving executive head of the State — till January 2026," said a senior Congress worker. Urs, a two time chief minister, was in office for 2,792 days, which is about 7.6 years, and Mr. Siddaramaiah, who is also in his second term, would match the former's record on January 6, 2026. Mr. Siddaramaiah had earlier led the Congress government of 2013-18. Many party insiders say that Shivakumar wants to be seen as someone who is toeing the party line, without making any move or giving any statement that may precipitate the matter and cause embarrassment to the Congress. The Vokkaliga leader, who is credited for consolidating the community's support towards the party in the old Mysuru region is counting on his loyalty to the party and the Gandhi family to work in his favour. "Shivakumar is a strategist, he plays his cards very closely, he is also a very religious man and has been making visits to temples and maths," pointed out a leader, while indicating that the state Congress chief was not silently taking a backseat.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
7 hours ago
- Business Standard
Revanth Reddy unveils Telangana caste survey, urges national OBC quota push
Telangana Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy unveiled the 'Telangana Socio-Economic Survey - Model and Methodology' at Indira Bhawan in New Delhi, and urged Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge to raise the issue of OBC reservations in Parliament. Presenting the state's comprehensive caste-based socio-economic survey, Reddy stated that the exercise was "not just a caste survey, but a social, economic, educational, employment, and political survey." As per the data, Other Backward Classes (OBCs), including practising Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and Buddhists, constitute 56.4 per cent of Telangana's population. Scheduled Castes (SCs) account for 17.4 per cent, Scheduled Tribes (STs) 10.8 per cent, and forward castes 10.9 per cent. Notably, 3.9 per cent of the population has been categorised under "no caste." The survey identified previously unlisted castes and analysed their socio-economic conditions by name and location. "Education levels showed who was privileged despite landlessness. Even those with assets, if uneducated, remained backwards, while landless but educated families became upwardly mobile," Reddy noted. The survey, which compiled 88 crore pages of self-declared, "foolproof" data, was conducted with meticulous oversight. Reddy outlined the process, "We began with household enumeration, placed stickers on houses, and created 94,113 blocks, each with an enumerator and supervisor. Mandal-level committees, collectors, the planning department, the Chief Secretary, a Cabinet Sub-Committee, the Deputy CM, and I monitored it. For those who didn't participate, we provided an additional 15 days, opened toll-free helplines, and established help counters in every office. Those who still refused were excluded. If you don't want to be part of the system, you won't be counted." Following the survey, the Telangana government passed two reservation bills, one for education and employment and another for political representation, allocating 42 per cent reservation for OBCs. These bills, pending before the President of India for three months, prompted Reddy to appeal to Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha, and Mallikarjun Kharge, Leader of the House in the Rajya Sabha, to advocate for their passage. "We ask Rahul Gandhi ji and Kharge ji to raise this in Parliament, put forward motions, and take the lead. We will protest in the streets if needed," he declared. Additionally, Telangana increased SC reservations from 15 per cent to 17.5 per cent and ST reservations from 6 per cent to 10 per cent, aligning with their population shares. He said, "According to the report, OBCs (including practising Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and Buddhists) make up 56.4 per cent of the population. SCs are 17.4 per cent, STs 10.8 per cent, and forward castes 10.9 per cent--but in that, only 3.9 per cent are no castes. We identified previously unknown castes outside the list. Our expert committee studied them, by name, by location. Education levels showed who was privileged despite landlessness. Even those with assets, if uneducated, remained backward. Meanwhile, even those who are landless and asset-less have developed because of their education and educated families, becoming upwardly mobile. This is not just a caste survey, but also social, economic, education, employment, and political." Reddy took a sharp jab at Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP, accusing them of resisting a national caste census. "For many years, Congress has raised the issue of a caste census, ever since the RSS was formed in 1925. It is now 2025, yet their ideology avoids counting OBCs," he said, referencing a 2020 Supreme Court affidavit where the BJP-led government declined to undertake a caste census. He also questioned Modi's OBC credentials, alleging, "He is a legally converted OBC, adopting the status only after becoming Chief Minister for political advantage." Highlighting Congress's advocacy, Reddy recalled a protest at Jantar Mantar, supported by 16 political parties and 55 MPs, which pressured the Centre to include a caste census in the 2026 national census. "This is a success of Rahul Gandhi ji's movement," he said, drawing parallels to the repeal of the controversial farm laws after Gandhi's sustained campaign. He added, "When Rahul bhaiya told Modi ji to repeal them, they were repealed. Modi ji even apologised. Why? Because Rahul Gandhi speaks for the people. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)