Hong Kong must be ‘very careful' before banning lawyers from meeting clients in jail
In an interview with the Post, senior counsel Jose-Antonio Maurellet added that some members of the professional body had also expressed concerns over the revised prison rules, which will tighten visiting criteria for specific lawyers.
At the centre of contention is an amendment which allows correctional authorities to apply for a court warrant to ban a particular legal representative from meeting an inmate on the grounds that such connections may endanger national security, inflict bodily harm or pervert the course of justice. Similar provisions are applied to medical professionals and religious personnel.
Maurellet expressed confidence that the court would serve in its gatekeeping role in issuing such warrants. But he questioned the argument made by authorities and some supporters of the amendment that a prisoner's right to legal advice and choice of lawyers would not be undermined by the rule changes, as the defendant could still consult other legal representatives.
Maurellet warned that having to switch lawyers would not only be undesirable to a defendant going through protracted criminal proceedings, but could also be disruptive to the help the court was receiving.
'In serious cases, it's in the interest of everybody, both the prosecution and the defence, that not only is there a fair trial, but the matter moves on as expeditiously as possible,' he said.
'So we certainly hope and believe that the government will be very careful before such steps are taken.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
37 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
South Korean court approves arrest of ex-president Yoon Suk-yeol's wife amid bribery probe
A South Korean court on Tuesday ordered the arrest of the wife of jailed former President Yoon Suk-yeol as investigators seek to charge her over various suspected crimes, including bribery, stock manipulation and meddling in the selection of a candidate. In granting a special prosecutor's request for an arrest warrant near midnight, the Seoul Central District Court said Kim Keon-hee poses a risk of destroying evidence. The investigation into Kim is one of three special prosecutor probes launched under Seoul's new liberal government targeting the presidency of Yoon, a conservative who was removed from office in April and rearrested last month over his brief imposition of martial law in December. While Yoon's self-inflicted downfall extended a decades-long run of South Korean presidencies ending badly, he and Kim are the first presidential couple to be simultaneously arrested over criminal allegations. Former South Korean president Yoon Suk-yeol (left) and his wife, Kim Keon-hee, arrive at a polling station in Seoul to cast their ballots in the presidential election in June. Photo: dpa Yoon's surprising yet poorly planned power grab on December 3 came amid a seemingly routine stand-off with the liberals, whom he described as 'anti-state' forces abusing their legislative majority to block his agenda.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong DSE pupils ‘not affected by rising number of private candidates'
The performance of local students in Hong Kong's university entrance exams has not been affected by an influx of private candidates, authorities have said, even though the number of mainland Chinese participants has grown substantially and includes some whose eligibility has been questioned. The Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority's defence coincides with calls from lawmakers for more stringent regulations over collaboration between local private secondary schools and mainland institutions. Some have speculated that mainland students taking the Hong Kong exams had been drilled at tutorial schools across the border. The Legislative Council is expected to discuss possible abuses in the operations of some private schools early next month, with the development of such institutions offering a formal curriculum on the agenda. Tsung Tsin Middle School's operations have been suspended Photo: Jelly Tse According to the authority, an additional 764 day school candidates – Hong Kong students – met the general entrance requirements for admission to the city's eight public universities this year, a 0.1 percentage point increase over 2024. 'This indicates that the performance of day school candidates was not affected by the increase in the number of private candidates,' an authority spokeswoman said. She added that all 2025 Diploma of Secondary Education (DSE) candidates had met the registration requirements for taking the exams. The DSE adopted standards-referenced reporting to indicate candidates' performance and exam results, which did not involve comparing their performance with others, she said.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
What do we know about the collision between 2 ships in disputed South China Sea?
Two Chinese ships were involved in a collision during a confrontation with Philippine ships near the disputed Scarborough Shoal on Monday. The incident, in which Beijing claimed it had expelled a number of vessels from the area, was the latest in a series of confrontations between the two countries in the South China Sea. Here is what we know about the incident so far. Which vessels were involved? Two Philippine coastguard vessels – the BRP Teresa Magbanua and BRP Suluan – were in the area escorting the government-owned fishing carrier MV Pamamalakaya and 35 local fishing vessels as part of a government initiative to support fishing communities. The coastguard said its ships were also delivering fuel and other supplies to the fishing boats at the time. The Philippine coastguard said its ships were confronted by the China Coast Guard (CCG)'s cutter 3104 and a PLA Navy Type 052D guided-missile destroyer, the Guilin. 03:09 Chinese ships collide during clash with Philippine coastguard in contested South China Sea Chinese ships collide during clash with Philippine coastguard in contested South China Sea It added that the two vessels collided around 10.5 nautical miles (19.5km) east of the Scarborough Shoal, a reef that has seen numerous confrontations between the two sides.
