Centre's Caste Census will have no bearing on Karnataka Survey, says CM Siddaramaiah
The Caste Census announced by the Centre will not have a bearing on the Socio-economic and Educational Survey carried out by the state government, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah said Thursday.
He dismissed the criticism raised by Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw regarding the sanctity of the caste enumeration carried out by the state governments.
The chief minister said the Cabinet would discuss the findings of the Survey report in its meeting scheduled for May 9. 'I have sought opinions in writing from the Cabinet ministers. Based on that, we will discuss it at the next Cabinet (meeting). We will take a decision after that,' he said at a news conference.
Responding to Vaishnaw's remarks that the caste enumeration exercises carried out by the state governments were just 'surveys' and were done in a non-transparent manner, Siddaramaiah said that it was just the opinion of the minister. 'They have done it in Bihar, where the BJP is an alliance partner (in the state government). What does he have to say for that?' he asked.
'The Constitution does not say that the states do not have the right to carry out a Socio-economic Survey. Is there any provision barring the states?' he said, adding that the Caste Census announced by the Centre does reduce the significance of the exercise carried out by the state.
'Once we take a decision (on the findings of the Socio-economic Survey), we will send the recommendations to the Central government,' he said. The Survey findings will be used as the basis for the next budget, according to the chief minister.
The state government will implement all the recommendations of the Survey report submitted by the Karnataka State Backward Classes Commission, except the one regarding increasing the reservation limit. 'That should be done by the Centre,' Siddaramaiah said, noting a 50 per cent ceiling currently was in place due to a Supreme Court decision.
The Commission in its Survey report has recommended increasing reservation for Other Backward Classes from the existing 32 per cent to 51 per cent, noting that the communities comprise 70 per cent of the state population. Though the Karnataka Cabinet held a special meeting to discuss its findings a week after it was placed before it, the meeting was 'inconclusive'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
29 minutes ago
- India Today
Groom is theirs, but shirt is ours: MK Stalin's Rajinikanth movie jab at Amit Shah
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin on Thursday hit back at Union Home Minister Amit Shah for his recent remarks, questioning the state's fund utilisation and accusing the DMK of diverting central scheme Chief Minister ridiculed Shah's accusations by invoking a famous scene from superstar Rajinikanth's film Padayappa, where the superstar gives his shirt to a friend going to see a bride, and later jokes: 'He's the groom, but the shirt he's wearing is mine.'advertisementMK Stalin compared the movie scene to what he says is the situation of Tamil Nadu, and said that for centrally sponsored schemes bearing the Prime Minister's name, the Tamil Nadu government contributes up to 50 per cent of the funds. 'In what way are we diverting funds?' Stalin asked, adding that it is, in fact, the Union government that has failed to release several promised in Madurai, Amit Shah on June 8 accused the ruling party of large-scale corruption, failure to fulfill 90 per cent of poll promises, and allowing caste-based violence, crimes against women and children, and drug mafias to thrive. Shah alleged that the DMK diverted Rs 400 crore meant for the Stalin, in turn, asked what had become of the AIIMS hospital announced for Tamil Nadu nearly a decade ago. 'Is AIIMS a medical hospital or a space station that it takes 10 years to construct?' he asked, challenging Shah to name a single scheme introduced specifically for Tamil Nadu in the past 11 years of BJP also took aim at Union Jal Shakti Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat for allegedly disrespecting Madurai by suggesting that the archaeological findings at Keezhadi be 'corrected'. 'Did the Centre appreciate Tamil Nadu for proving we had the earliest iron-age civilisation?' he asked. He said the BJP-led Centre had failed to acknowledge Tamil heritage and the Leader of the Opposition in Tamil Nadu, Stalin accused him of acting like a 'puppet' and not defending the state's interests despite BJP's growing claims of being part of the future government in the state. 'Earlier, you formed alliances only to protect your post. Did you raise any concern for the state?' he said, 'Thamizhar have self-respect. We will not allow anyone from Delhi to rule us. People will support the Dravidian Model government.' IN THIS STORY#Tamil Nadu
India Today
29 minutes ago
- India Today
Karnataka Cabinet orders caste re-survey within 90 days citing 10-year gap
The Karnataka Cabinet has unanimously decided to conduct a fresh Socio-Economic and Education Survey report, often referred to as the 'Karnataka caste census', citing the expiry of the ten-year period since the last such exercise. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah confirmed the decision following a Cabinet meeting that deliberated exclusively on the recommendations of the state's Backward Classes Commission, which had submitted its final report earlier this explained that the original survey was launched during his previous tenure as Chief Minister in 2015 and was carried out between April 11 and May 30 of that year. 'On 57 grounds we visited the houses and conducted the survey and submitted the survey,' he said, noting that around 1.6 lakh personnel were involved. The survey covered 5.98 crore people, a figure close to the projected population of 6.3 crore for 2015, up from 6.11 crore in the 2011 added that the recommendations were finalised by 2018, but due to a change in government and subsequent political decisions, the report was not accepted. 'In 2018, our party lost and I tendered the resignation. There was a coalition government. JDS chief Kumaraswamy was the new Chief Minister. The report was completed by then. C Puttarangashetty was then commissioner. Kumarswamy insisted not to take the report,' Siddaramaiah After the tenure of H Kantharaj, who chaired the earlier commission in 2015, Jayaprakash Hegde was appointed to lead the body, with BJP-appointed members forming the rest of the panel. The final recommendations, based on the Kantharaj report, were submitted on February 29, 2024. However, with the Model Code of Conduct in force due to the Lok Sabha elections, the Cabinet could not take it up until after the said that senior Congress leaders, including Mallikarjun Kharge, Rahul Gandhi, KC Venugopal and Randeep Surjewala, held consultations with him and Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar on the matter. 'They suggested the report was prepared and ready in 2015. It's been 10 years already. According to the Backward Classes Act 1995, it's very clear that a new survey is to be conducted after 10 years,' he Section 11 of Clause 1 of the Act, Siddaramaiah said the Cabinet decided that the time had legally come to undertake a new exercise. 'We did not bow down to the high command. We are taking this decision according to the law,' he said. He also reiterated that Kumaraswamy had previously refused to receive the report and had even threatened Puttarangashetty. The BJP government that followed also did not accept the that the report has formally been received and reviewed, the Cabinet has decided to authorise the commission to conduct a new survey within 90 Chief Minister DK Shivakumar said, 'The Chief Minister has already explained the decision taken in the Cabinet. It's clear—this is about the backward classes section. Once in 10 years, such things need to be revisited. The original survey was conducted from April 11, 2015, to May 30, 2015, and now it's already 10 years old.'He added that the survey would reflect current socio-economic realities, as population patterns, education levels, and public demands had changed. 'We want to do justice to everyone,' he said. Shivakumar also noted that the Backward Classes Commission would be given three months to complete the task and that the process would be made accessible online, allowing participation from Kannadigas residing in other states.'I don't want to comment on anything specific—this is a 10-year-old issue, and it needs to be addressed now,' Shivakumar said. IN THIS STORY#Karnataka
India Today
29 minutes ago
- India Today
Andhra Pradesh explains ban on import of Totapuri mango from Karnataka
The Andhra Pradesh government defended its decision to restrict the entry of Totapuri mangoes from Karnataka, and other states, citing the need to protect local farmers and avoid potential law and order to government sources, the state announced a procurement price of Rs 8 per kg for Totapuri mangoes, in a move aimed at stabilising mango prices and supporting local growers. Additionally, under a price support scheme, a Rs 4 per kg subsidy will be provided to farmers — ensuring they receive a total of Rs 12 per initiative, which comes in the wake of market concerns over excess supply and falling prices, is expected to cost the government Rs 220 crore. Andhra Pradesh has set an ambitious procurement target of 5.5 lakh tonnes this season to ensure farmers benefit directly from the scheme. However, officials have raised alarms over the inflow of Totapuri mangoes from neighbouring Karnataka, where the fruit is being sold at around Rs 5 per kg without any state-backed price support. The Andhra Pradesh government fears that processors may favour the cheaper Karnataka produce, undermining the state's subsidy-driven efforts and leading to significant losses for local also warn that if the influx of these low-cost mangoes is not checked, it could spark unrest among Andhra mango growers and potentially lead to law and order stressed that the restrictions are necessary to ensure the success of the state's farmer-centric policies and to prevent the collapse of local mango clarification comes after Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah wrote to N Chandrababu Naidu requesting that the Andhra Pradesh government rethink the ban on the Karnataka Chief Secretary Shalini Rajneesh, the previous day, wrote to her Andhra Pradesh counterpart and requested the ban be lifted. In her letter, Rajneesh called the decision 'abrupt and unilateral,' and warned that it risked 'triggering retaliatory sentiments.'The petitions were submitted after a Government Order of June 7 restricted all Totapuri mango imports from outside Andhra Pradesh including Karnataka.
