When brilliance is not enough: What it takes for an outsider to become one of the political greats
Vaclav Havel, the poet and political prisoner who became the first democratically elected president of Czechoslovakia, in 1989, went on to steer his country – and later, the Czech Republic, after Czechoslovakia separated from Slovakia – through the painful transition from communism to capitalism. Over 13 years as president, he drove the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact – the defence treaty that tied it to the former Soviet Union – and his country's entrance into NATO and the European Union.
'With the collapse of communism was a real sense of moral uncertainty about, right, all the old values are gone, what are we being offered?' says University of Sydney emeritus professor Graeme Gill, an expert on Russian and Soviet politics, of the period when Havel was voted in, mere weeks after having been jailed for championing human rights.
'[So] there's something in [his] past that gave him increased capacity, when he was a leader, and it was the sort of moral authority he had, both as a former dissident because he'd been locked up by the communists at some stage, certainly been suppressed; his plays weren't allowed to be shown.' This enabled him to operate on the moral high ground, and accomplish great things. And be repeatedly re-elected by his people.
Then there's Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky, whose only preparation before being elected in 2019 was starring in Servant of the People, a satirical television show about a history teacher who unexpectedly is elected as the president of Ukraine.
He has shocked many by his transition into a courageous statesman who has rallied his people to hold off the Russian army, against all odds, for three years.
'[But] I mean, he's in a crisis, which gives him a lot more power, and there's a lot less scrutiny that he would otherwise have had,' says Professor Rodney Smith, an expert in parliamentary democracies at the University of Sydney. 'And crises allow you to mobilise people around you who otherwise wouldn't be co-operative with you. It's more difficult to criticise the leader, if the crisis isn't of your making, and you seem to be doing the right things.'
Loading
But experts point out that Havel and Zelensky are the rare exceptions. American President Donald Trump, is, for many, an illustration of what is more likely – the failures that can result, when a person comes to the job equipped only with renown in an entirely different arena.
'When we see someone who is clearly a good leader in some other field, you know, there's an assumption, 'Wow, if only we could get that person into politics, wouldn't it be great?' And that's not the case,' says Smith. 'Because they're a great thinker, or a great orator, or a great businessperson, or a great whatever. But, you know, even a great head of a public sector agency, if they don't have the full skill set [they will not be an effective political leader].'
Smith says there are five key skills in that set: being able to manage a party and rival factions, understand how the public service works, manoeuvre through the partyroom and parliament to get legislation passed, navigate the demands of lobbying and advocacy groups, and being able to bring the public along with you.
Think of Michael Ignatieff, the Booker Prize-shortlisted author and Harvard professor of human rights, who became leader of the Canadian opposition in 2008.
He was 'a complete disaster', says University of Sydney Emeritus Professor Rodney Tiffen, author of Disposable Leaders. Media and Leadership Coups from Menzies to Abbott. 'He was a very, very bright guy, but didn't really know how to operate in Ottawa.'
Ignatieff, who wrote an 8000-word policy manifesto before entering politics, in which he advocated for ways to improve the lives of Indigenous Canadians, and improve productivity through investments in higher education, didn't disagree.
'If a politician cannot succeed in convincing voters he is in it for them, he cannot win standing … without it, no message can get a hearing,' Ignatieff wrote in his memoir, Fire And Ashes: Success and Failure In Politics, after he'd resigned as leader of the Liberal Party, following the loss of his seat in the 2011 federal election, the Liberal Party's worst showing in its history. (The Liberals won only 34 seats in parliament, marking the first time since Confederation that the party failed to finish first or second.)
His rivals, building on the fact that Ignatieff spent 30 years in the United States before returning to Canada to run for office, attacked him in ads that read: 'He didn't come back for you.'
Even leaders who come to the top job with considerable political experience end up failing to become effective when they lack 'the full skill set', says Smith.
Think of former Australian prime minister Malcolm Turnbull, says Smith. He was an incredibly astute lawyer, merchant banker and venture capitalist who was turfed by his own party. 'You might be brilliant, but if the party doesn't like you, you're in trouble,' he says. Think of Malcolm Turnbull, says Smith. He was an incredibly astute lawyer, merchant banker and venture capitalist who was turfed by his own party. 'You might be brilliant, but if the party doesn't like you, you're in trouble,' he says. The same can be said of former prime minister Kevin Rudd, an accomplished diplomat, ex-political staffer and one-time head of Queensland's cabinet office; he lost the support of his party in his first term after being unable to manage relationships within it.
'And you've got to convince the public [of your vision], so, you know, that's [former Liberal Party leader] John Hewson's story,' says Smith. 'He put up a complete tax package. It made perfect sense to him as an economist with a PhD in economics. But it didn't make sense to a majority of voters.'
It's no wonder that the late Queen Elizabeth II once quipped about prime ministers: 'I don't know why anyone would want the job.'
So, does Mark Carney, if he wins on Monday – and the latest polls from The Economist give his Liberal Party an 86 per cent chance of winning the most seats in parliament – have a decent shot at becoming a Zelensky or a Havel?
Loading
'I think this is one of those situations where it depends a lot on the team he has,' says Smith. 'I think he's got some of these skills already, but he's never had to keep a party together before, a political party, at parliamentary level. Never had to really deal directly with MPs who are worried about their constituents in their ridings, or their provinces. He seems a very smart guy, very personable, very confident. But, you know, it's unlikely to get easier for Canada, I would've thought, in the next little while, given the situation with the southern neighbour. I think there is a certain level of risk there.'
Perhaps he'll personify the theory of renowned German sociologist Max Weber – himself a failed politician – who believed that the only outsiders well suited to becoming politicians were lawyers or journalists, as both had been taught the ruthlessness and adaptability necessary to lead. Or maybe not.
Because Carney's first action as prime minister was to repeal the consumer carbon levy. This was the Liberal Party's signature climate policy, which Carney had fiercely defended, so much so, that Carney's rival Poilievre previously dubbed him 'Carbon Tax Carney'.
'This demonstrates a willingness to slaughter a sacred cow of the pro-climate progressive movement which the Liberal Party had been the proud leader of, until the moment he took it out the back and cut its head off; a determination to win power, regardless of any policy sacrifice,' says Herald and Age columnist Peter Hartcher.
Maybe the banker with a heart of gold has a ruthless side after all.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


West Australian
34 minutes ago
- West Australian
Russia and Ukraine swap more prisoners of war
Russia and Ukraine have exchanged more prisoners of war, both sides say, without giving details of the numbers involved. The exchange was agreed between the two sides at talks in Istanbul last week and an initial swap of prisoners under the age of 25 was conducted on Monday. The defence ministry in Moscow said the Russian soldiers freed in the latest handover were currently in Belarus, which borders both the warring countries, and would be returned to Russia for medical treatment and rehabilitation. The group of Ukrainian prisoners consisted of seriously ill and severely injured soldiers, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy wrote on social media. They will all receive immediate medical assistance, he said. Among them were members of the army, the National Guard, transport services and border guards, Zelenskiy said. Earlier, the Kremlin said it had been ready for several days to start handing over the bodies of Ukrainian soldiers killed in the war but that Ukraine was still discussing the details. The planned transfer of thousands of war dead was the other tangible result of the Istanbul talks, which resumed last month after a gap of more than three years but have made no progress towards a ceasefire. Russia has said it is ready to hand over the bodies of more than 6000 Ukrainian soldiers and receive any bodies of Russian soldiers which Ukraine is able to return. But Kremlin aide Vladimir Medinsky said on Saturday that the Russian side had shown up at the agreed exchange point with the bodies of 1212 Ukrainian dead soldiers only to find nobody from Ukraine to take them. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has accused Russia of "trying to play some kind of dirty political and information game" around the issue of the exchanges. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Tuesday: "There is no final understanding. Contact is being made, numbers are being compared. As soon as there is a final understanding, then we hope this exchange will take place." Russian state media has broadcast images of long white refrigerated trucks, containing bodies sealed in individual white bags, parked up near the border. Ukrainian officials said on Tuesday Russia launched one of its largest air strikes on Kyiv in the war and struck a maternity ward in the southern city of Odesa in attacks that killed at least three people. The overnight strikes followed Russia's biggest drone assault of the war on Ukraine on Monday and were part of intensified bombardments in what Russia says is retaliation for attacks by Ukrainian forces on Russia. with DPA


Perth Now
35 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Russia and Ukraine swap more prisoners of war
Russia and Ukraine have exchanged more prisoners of war, both sides say, without giving details of the numbers involved. The exchange was agreed between the two sides at talks in Istanbul last week and an initial swap of prisoners under the age of 25 was conducted on Monday. The defence ministry in Moscow said the Russian soldiers freed in the latest handover were currently in Belarus, which borders both the warring countries, and would be returned to Russia for medical treatment and rehabilitation. The group of Ukrainian prisoners consisted of seriously ill and severely injured soldiers, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy wrote on social media. They will all receive immediate medical assistance, he said. Among them were members of the army, the National Guard, transport services and border guards, Zelenskiy said. We continue the return of our people, as agreed in Istanbul. Today marks the first stage of the return of our injured and severely wounded warriors from Russian captivity. All of them require immediate medical attention. This is an important humanitarian act. Warriors from… Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) June 10, 2025 Earlier, the Kremlin said it had been ready for several days to start handing over the bodies of Ukrainian soldiers killed in the war but that Ukraine was still discussing the details. The planned transfer of thousands of war dead was the other tangible result of the Istanbul talks, which resumed last month after a gap of more than three years but have made no progress towards a ceasefire. Russia has said it is ready to hand over the bodies of more than 6000 Ukrainian soldiers and receive any bodies of Russian soldiers which Ukraine is able to return. But Kremlin aide Vladimir Medinsky said on Saturday that the Russian side had shown up at the agreed exchange point with the bodies of 1212 Ukrainian dead soldiers only to find nobody from Ukraine to take them. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has accused Russia of "trying to play some kind of dirty political and information game" around the issue of the exchanges. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Tuesday: "There is no final understanding. Contact is being made, numbers are being compared. As soon as there is a final understanding, then we hope this exchange will take place." Russian state media has broadcast images of long white refrigerated trucks, containing bodies sealed in individual white bags, parked up near the border. Ukrainian officials said on Tuesday Russia launched one of its largest air strikes on Kyiv in the war and struck a maternity ward in the southern city of Odesa in attacks that killed at least three people. The overnight strikes followed Russia's biggest drone assault of the war on Ukraine on Monday and were part of intensified bombardments in what Russia says is retaliation for attacks by Ukrainian forces on Russia. with DPA


Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Ambassador to talk trade amid renewed EU negotiations
Increasing trade ties with Australia will be front and centre in a major address by the European Union's leading diplomat. EU ambassador Gabriele Visentin will speak to the National Press Club on Wednesday, as Australia and the trading bloc revive negotiations for a sweeping free-trade agreement. Long-stalled talks have resumed following the global uncertainty caused by US President Donald Trump's tariffs on exports to America, which have up-ended long-standing relationships. While negotiations began in 2018, they stalled over the EU's issues with geographic indicators. The trading bloc had been concerned by Australian producers using terms like prosecco or feta for products that didn't come from specific regions in Europe. Trade is expected to be a key point of Mr Visentin's speech, which will centre on the EU as a crucial world power. The EU is Australia's third-largest trading partner, with 450 million people in the European bloc, and is worth more than $150 billion a year. Trade Minister Don Farrell met with his European counterparts while in Paris for the OECD summit last week. He said he was confident a deal could be reached. "We've got lots of things that we can sell to the Europeans," he said. "I believe now that there's an appetite to reach an agreement on both sides. The world has changed."