Welshpool air ambulance base campaign group appeal fails
A High Court appeal against the closure of an air ambulance base has been rejected.In April 2024, it was announced that two Wales Air Ambulance bases were set to close in Welshpool, Powys, and Caernarfon, Gwynedd, replaced by a new base in north Wales.Locals against the decision won the right to put their case to save the Welshpool site before the High Court, but on Thursday a judge ruled that the appeal had failed.Campaigners said they were "extremely disappointed", but Wales Air Ambulance said it welcomed the "clear and unequivocal outcome".
Giving his judgement, Mr Justice Turner said he understood the "depth of feeling involved and the disappointment that this decision will bring to many people" but added it was not the role of the High Court to "usurp the decision making function of those to whom parliament has delegated the responsibility".Reacting to the news, the Save Welshpool and Caernarfon Air Ambulance Bases Group said its members were "extremely disappointed", but added "this is not the end".It said it planned to "meet urgently to discuss an appeal process".
The claimant had challenged the move on four grounds, including that the consultation on the decision was not sufficient and that the Joint Commissioning Committee (JCC) had failed to have regard to representations made by Llais - the organisation which represents NHS patients - and the relevant statutory guidance.However Mr Justice Turner said he was "entirely satisfied that the JCC and its predecessor both fully and conscientiously had regard to the contributions from Llais in a way which complied with its statutory obligations and in accordance with the guidance".He added: "The fact that the JCC were not simply paying lip service to the view of Llais is perhaps best illustrated by their decision to accede to its request to embark upon a previously unplanned third phase of engagement in the face of the concerns expressed by the charity over the delay."Dr Sue Barnes, chief executive of Wales Air Ambulance, said: "We welcome this clear and unequivocal outcome."This service improvement is important as lives are currently under threat. It is vital to address the issues of unmet need, inequity and service under-use."Dr Barnes thanked the communities affected for their "incredible passion" for the charity and gave her "heartfelt reassurance that nobody is losing a service".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
MPs switch sides to vote no to ‘drastically weakened' assisted dying Bill
Four MPs have confirmed they are switching their vote on the assisted dying Bill from yes to no, branding it 'drastically weakened'. Labour's Paul Foster, Jonathan Hinder, Markus Campbell-Savours and Kanishka Narayan wrote to fellow MPs to voice concerns about the safety of the proposed legislation. The letter comes on the eve of a crucial vote on Friday which would see the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill either clear the House of Commons and move to the Lords, or fall completely. The MPs wrote: 'The Bill presented to MPs in November has been fundamentally changed. 'This is not the safest Bill in the world. It is weaker than the one first laid in front of MPs and has been drastically weakened. 'MPs were promised the ultimate protection from a High Court Judge but that protection is missing from the final Bill.' They said colleagues with 'any doubts about the safety of this Bill' should 'join us tomorrow and vote against it'. As it stands, the proposed legislation would allow terminally ill adults in England and Wales, with fewer than six months to live, to apply for an assisted death, subject to approval by two doctors and a panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist. While the MPs cited the replacement of a High Court safeguard with the expert panels, Bill sponsor Kim Leadbeater has insisted the change is a strengthening of the legislation, incorporating wider expert knowledge to assess assisted dying applications. But concerns around the panels have also been raised by the Royal College of Psychiatrists (RCPsych), which announced in recent weeks that it has 'serious concerns' and cannot support the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in its current form. The college's lead on assisted dying for England and Wales, Dr Annabel Price, expressed worry there will not be 'enough space or time to carry out proper, holistic assessments', and that the only involvement on a panel being to check decisions made by others 'is deeply troubling'. The relatively narrow majority of 55 from the historic yes vote in November means every vote will count on Friday. While acknowledging there could be some change in the numbers, Bill sponsor Kim Leadbeater has insisted she remains confident it will pass the third reading stage and move on to be considered by peers in the Lords. Speaking on Thursday, she said: 'There might be some small movement in the middle, some people might maybe change their mind one way, others will change their mind the other way but fundamentally I don't anticipate that that majority would be heavily eroded so I do feel confident we can get through tomorrow successfully.' Ms Leadbeater has insisted her Bill is 'the most robust piece of legislation in the world' and has argued dying people must be given choice at the end of their lives in a conversation which has seen support from high-profile figures including Dame Esther Rantzen. Making her case for a change in the law, she said: 'I know that many colleagues have engaged very closely with the legislation and will make their decision based on those facts and that evidence, and that cannot be disputed. 'But we need to do something, and we need to do it quickly.' A YouGov poll of 2,003 adults in Great Britain, surveyed last month and published on Thursday, suggested public support for the Bill remains high at 73% – unchanged from November. The proportion of people who feel assisted dying should be legal in principle has risen slightly, to 75% from 73% in November. MPs are entitled to have a free vote on the Bill, meaning they decide according to their conscience rather than along party lines. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has indicated he will continue to back the Bill, as he did last year, saying earlier this week that his 'position is long-standing and well-known' on assisted dying. Health Secretary Wes Streeting, while describing Ms Leadbeater's work on the proposed legislation as 'extremely helpful', confirmed in April that he still intended to vote against it. Ms Leadbeater has warned it could be a decade before assisted dying legislation returns to Parliament if MPs vote to reject her Bill on Friday.
South Wales Argus
2 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Welsh ambulance bosses won't commit to clarity
During his time in charge, ambulance waiting times have increased fourfold across Wales. Mr Killens said the situation had to be addressed. Mr Killens has been Wales ambulance boss for more than six years, a period which coincides with a fourfold increase in Welsh ambulance waiting times. The Argus contacted the service to ask whether Gwent and the Aneurin Bevan Health Board Area could see an improvement in ambulance services soon. However, the Service was not willing to give any assurances or openly comment or speculate on future services in the area. This week, Mr Killens told BBC news that ambulance waiting times were causing a lot of avoidable harm to patients across Wales, a situation he regrets. However, he claims the service is now in a better position after his time in charge. Speaking out this week, the departing ambulance boss said hundreds of patients come to avoidable harm because ambulances are forced to wait outside A&E departments. This service choke, which has been blamed for agonising ambulance waits, has been dubbed 'handover delays.' These delays occur when hospitals are choked and this can cause things such as long waits in ambulances for patients and a slowing down of ambulance dispatches. The situation is said to be beyond the control of ambulance services and a matter for hospital managers and policy makers. Last year's Wales-wide average monthly loss was more than 29,000 hours. In response to our questions about possible improvements in the Gwent area, the Wales Ambulance Service said: 'As Jason's already set out his position on handover delays, it doesn't make sense for us to issue a comment in response to his views when you've already had it from the horse's mouth, as it were.' Jason Killens began working for the Wales Ambulance Service in 1996 and leaves his Wales-based post in July. The South Wales Argus has approached the Welsh Government for a comment on whether ambulance delays are a matter for Welsh policy makers and hospital managers.
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
BBC News quiz of the week: What's the one-letter codename for MI6's new spy chief?
This week saw further conflict in the Middle East, MPs vote to decriminalise abortion in England and Wales, and another SpaceX rocket go up in how much attention did you pay to what else happened in the world over the past seven days?Quiz collated by Ben Fell. Fancy testing your memory? Try last week's quiz, or have a go at something from the archives.
