Jury told to find Garda not guilty on five of 22 allegations related to motoring prosecutions
Tom Flavin, (51), Rathkeale Garda Station, Co Limerick, should be acquitted of all of the charges as there is no real evidence against him, his barrister, senior counsel, Mark Nicholas, said in his closing speech to the jury.
Advertisement
Mr Flavin went on trial before Limerick Circuit Criminal Court on May 27th accused of 22 counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice.
Today, senior prosecuting counsel, Fiona Murphy, told the jury they were to find Mr Flavin not guilty of five of the charges and that they would consider verdicts on the 17 remaining counts.
Mr Flavin, who denies all the charges, is accused of attempting to pervert the course of justice by entering false motor insurance details on the Garda Pulse records computer system, in an attempt to frustrate potential prosecutions against persons for driving without insurance.
The drivers involved were stopped at routine Garda checkpoints around the country and asked by the garda present to produce their insurance and licence details at a nominated Garda station within 10 days of the traffic stop.
Advertisement
All of the drivers asked to do this nominated Rathkeale Garda Station.
Later, when the investigating garda in each of the stops carried out follow-up checks of Pulse, they were satisfied that details entered into the system indicated that the driver in each case was insured. However, the court heard the drivers were not insured, and some were even prosecuted in court afterwards after pleading guilty to driving without insurance at the time they were stopped.
In his closing speech to the jury, Mr Nicholas SC, instructed by solicitor Dan O'Gorman, described Mr Flavin as an exemplary garda who had served with dedication in Croom and Rathkeale, Co Limerick, for many years.
Urging the jury to acquit Mr Flavin and not fall into the trap of speculation, Mr Nicholas added there was radically insufficient evidence to support a conviction.
Advertisement
'He served his community without blemish and without any disciplinary blots - you know that from the evidence. When other Gardai came to give evidence, his superiors, they spoke of him very fondly and well - It wasn't far off gushing, and they spoke with knowledge,' Mr Nicholas told the jury.
The defence barrister spoke of the 'unique challenges' Gardai face in Rathkeale as opposed to other jurisdictions.
'People who live down here know it has an enormous population, transient, in and out at various times of the year. One policeman said (the population) quadruples and with that comes its own set of problems and own sets of vehicles - UK car registrations, UK insurance, some not insured, some not being entirely truthful.'
'We know that a certain number of times that people who were pulled up and stopped and asked for their documentation, produced bogus insurance certificates.'
Advertisement
Mr Nicholas said the charge of attempting to pervert the course of justice is an extraordinarily serious allegation to make against a serving Garda.
'That he (Mr Flavin) must have deliberately, knowing the (insurance) certificate to be false, inputted it into the system with the intention that it would frustrate a prosecution. There has been nothing close to this level of proof in this case whatsoever,' added Mr Nicholas.
The court heard evidence of persons providing documents at Rathkeale Garda station, however it was unclear who exactly produced what at the Garda station, and what exactly was produced.
Fiona Murphy SC, prosecuting, said all of the relevant data entries onto Pulse 'were entered under the ID of Thomas Flavin'.
Advertisement
Ms Murphy told the jury that a statute of limitation of 'six months' generally applied in respect of prosecuting offences of driving without insurance.
'It is the prosecution's case that Tom Flavin knew they (the motorists involved) were not covered (by insurance) and that he entered the details onto PULSE to ensure they (appeared) covered,' Ms Murphy told the jury.
Ireland
Priest calls for end to violent feud in Limerick a...
Read More
'Mr Flavin knew what he was doing, and he did so to ensure those persons were insured (on Pulse) when they were not, in order to ensure there was no prosecution,' Ms Murphy alleged.
The prosecuting barrister told the jury that Tom Flavin enjoyed the presumption of innocence and that the burden of proof 'beyond a reasonable doubt' was all on the prosecution while Mr Flavin 'has nothing to prove'.
Ms Murphy told the jury the prosecution's case was 'a circumstantial case, there is no direct evidence, instead the prosecution relies on indirect evidence'.
It is anticipated that the jury will retire to consider its verdicts on each of the 17 counts on Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Watch Frank Caprio's kindest moments after judge known for empathy to defendants dies aged 88
Judge Frank Caprio's acts of kindness for down-and-out defendants made him a star and one of the most beloved justices in the country. Now, as the community mourns his tragic death aged 88, some of his most iconic moments of grace and compassion for the people who entered his courtroom have resurfaced. Caprio had fought a 'long and courageous battle' with pancreatic cancer, his family said in a statement confirming his death on Wednesday. 'His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him... Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond.' His family hope that 'his legacy lives on in the countless acts of kindness he inspired', encouraging the public to 'bring a little more compassion into the world - just as he did every day.' In one particularly moving moment of warmth, Caprio slashed a struggling single mom's fines from $350 to $125, prompting her to ask: 'Can I give you a hug?' Caprio smiled and told the woman to 'come on up here', leading the pair to enjoy a quick hug by the bench as she wiped away tears. The woman had explained that in some of her speeding fines, she was escaping a domestic violence situation and being chased by her abuser with her daughter in the car. Another clip featured a 96-year-old father who rarely drove, but had received a ticket during the course of taking his handucapped son to receive bloodwork for his cancer treatment. 'I take him for bloodwork every two weeks, because he's got cancer,' the man explained. Caprio listened intently and said: 'You're a good man. You really are a good man. You really are what America is all about. 'Here you are in your 90s, taking care of your family,' Caprio added, as the man fought back tears. Time and time again, defendants left Caprio's courtroom singing his praises, sharing their own unique stories of his generosity. In a 2017 interview with Daily Mail, he reflected on the responsibility of holding power as a judge, saying: 'I'm always mindful of the fact that the power of the sovereign, as opposed to the power of the individual, is so disproportionate. 'Shame on me if I represent the sovereign and I give someone something they don't deserve. 'I take it a step further - if I think there are certain circumstances in an individual's life, or it's a close call, I give them the benefit of the doubt. 'I don't subscribe to the theory that because you were charged, you must be guilty.' Caprio's courtroom show Caught in Providence catapulted him to global stardom and earned him a Daytime Emmy nomination in 2021. He dealt primarily with low level crime - parking tickets and speeding offenses - but would work hard to get to know defendants who found themselves in his courtroom, and led with compassion rather than a strict interpretation of the law. In one instance, grieving mother Andrea Rogers, appeared before Caprio with an accumulation of parking fines. She wept as she explained her struggle to keep her life together after her son was murdered. 'I'm going to take into consideration the horrific story you just told us, relative to your son. I don't think anyone in their lifetime would ever want to experience that,' Caprio said, revealing he would dismiss all penalties. 'With our best wishes and hope that things turnaround for you. Good luck to you.' Darrell Kroll, who faced Caprio alongside his eight-year-old son after getting a parking ticket while he delivered a pizza, said: 'I think Judge Caprio is much more than fair - he listens. 'I don't want to say he's lenient, that's not the word I want to use. He's compassionate.' Caprio was particularly sensitive about how he handled cases when defendants brought their children into his courtroom. He went out of his way to include the children and inspire them, hoping that he could serve as an inspiration to disadvantaged kids. 'I make it a practice sometimes to bring the kids up on the bench. I'll ask them some questions about where they go to school and what they want to be,' he told the Daily Mail in 2017. 'I always make a point, particularly with kids who come from under-privileged neighborhoods, to ask if they want to be something professional like a judge or an astronaut or a doctor. 'Maybe I'm placing something in their mind that if the judge thinks I can do this, then I can do this.' In January 2023, Caprio retired from the Providence Municipal Court after nearly 40 years on the bench. In October of that year, the city renamed its municipal courtroom in his honor. Shortly after celebrating his 87th birthday in December 2023, Caprio revealed he had been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. In a heartfelt message, he asked the public for their prayers. 'People ask me, "What can I do for you?" First of all, I can't thank you enough for your friendship and kind messages. But I would ask that each of you, in your own way, please pray for me,' he said. 'I am in need of the power of prayer, which I believe, in addition to the medical treatment I am receiving, is the most powerful weapon to help me survive this.' He completed his final round of radiation treatment in May 2024. Caprio is survived by his wife, Joyce, along with five children, seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren. Funeral arrangements have not yet been announced.
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Frank Caprio, Rhode Island judge who drew a huge online audience with his compassion, dies at age 88
Frank Caprio, a retired municipal judge in Rhode Island who found online fame as a caring jurist and host of ' Caught in Providence,″ died. He was 88. His official social media accounts said Wednesday the he "passed away peacefully" after 'a long and courageous battle with pancreatic cancer.' Caprio billed his courtroom as a place 'where people and cases are met with kindness and compassion." He was known for dismissing tickets or showing kindness even when he handed out justice. Last week, Caprio posted a short video on Facebook about how he had 'a setback," was back in the hospital and was asking that people 'remember me in your prayers.' Caprio's show was filmed in his courtroom and featured his folksy humor and compassion. Clips from the show have had more than 1 billion views on social media. During his time on the bench, Caprio developed a persona at odds with many TV judges — more sympathetic and less confrontational and judgmental. In his bite-sized segments on YouTube, Caprio is often seen empathizing with those in his courtroom. Many of the infractions are also relatively minor, from failing to use a turn signal to a citation for a loud party. Caprio also used his fame to address issues like unequal access to the judicial system. 'The phrase 'With liberty and justice for all' represents the idea that justice should be accessible to everyone. However it is not,' Caprio said in one video. 'Almost 90% of low-income Americans are forced to battle civil issues like health care, unjust evictions, veterans benefits and, yes, even traffic violations, alone.' Caprio's upbeat take on the job of a judge drew him millions of views. His most popular videos have been those where he calls children to the bench to help pass judgment on their parents. One shows him listening sympathetically to a woman whose son was killed and then dismissing her tickets and fines of $400. In another clip, after dismissing a red-light violation for a bartender who was making $3.84 per hour, Caprio urged those watching the video not to duck out on their bills. 'If anyone's watching I want them to know you better not eat and run because you're going to get caught and the poor people who are working hard all day for three bucks an hour are going to have to pay your bill," he said. On social media, his family described Caprio 'as a devoted husband, father, grandfather, great grandfather and friend.' 'Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond,' the family wrote. 'His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him.' State and local politicians mourned his passing and celebrated his life. 'Judge Caprio not only served the public well, but he connected with them in a meaningful way, and people could not help but respond to his warmth and compassion,' Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee said in a statement. 'He was more than a jurist — he was a symbol of empathy on the bench, showing us what is possible when justice is tempered with humanity.' Robert Leonard, who co-owned a restaurant with Caprio, said he was 'going to be sorely missed' and was 'all around wonderful.' 'There is nothing he wouldn't do for you if he could do it,' Leonard said. Caprio retired from Providence Municipal Court in 2023 after nearly four decades behind the bench. According to his biography, Caprio came from humble beginnings, the second of three boys growing up in the Federal Hill neighborhood of Providence, Rhode Island. 'I hope that people will take away that the institutions of government can function very well by exercising kindness, fairness, and compassion in their deliberations. We live in a very contentious society,' he said in 2017. 'I would hope that people will see that we can dispense justice without being oppressive.' ___ LeBlanc, an Associated Press journalist who retired in January, was the primary writer of this obituary. Associated Press writers Michael Casey in Boston and Audrey McAvoy in Honolulu contributed to this report.
Sky News
5 hours ago
- Sky News
Fresh call for UK-wide smacking ban as NSPCC says more young adults believe it's wrong
Campaigners have issued a fresh call to ban smacking across the UK after a poll found more young adults think it's unacceptable. All corporal punishment of children, including shaking, slapping and hitting, became illegal in Wales in 2022. Scotland brought in a similar ban in 2020. However, in England and Northern Ireland, it's unlawful to hit your child except where it's "reasonable punishment" - something that's judged on a case-by-case basis. New NSPCC research suggests 82% of 18-24-year-olds believe any force whatsoever by a parent is unacceptable - an increase on 64% in 2023. For parents specifically, the latest figure is 81%, up from 80% last year and 76% in 2022. Some 3,800 adults were surveyed in England for the latest research; 749 of these were parents with a child under 18, and 198 of them were 18 to 24 years old. When it comes to adults of all ages, 71% said physically punishing a child was wrong - up from 67% in 2023. Health experts have urged parliament to bring in a smacking ban across the UK, with doctors and psychiatrists saying research shows the "detrimental effects of physical punishment". The UK's four children's commissioners also came together in the wake of the Sara Sharif murder to call for a blanket ban, calling the reasonable chastisement defence "outdated and morally repugnant". 10:08 However, Tory peer Lord Jackson of Peterborough has warned a ban in England would be "disproportionate and heavy-handed". He told a parliamentary debate in June that removing the reasonable chastisement clause in the Children's Act could criminalise "good and caring parents, as well as overloading children's services departments". NSPCC chief executive Chris Sherwood said its research was a "wake-up call" and showed parents and young adults "don't want physical punishment to be a part of anyone's childhood". "As parliamentarians continue to debate the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill, we urge them to change the law to better reflect public attitudes to violence against children and ensure no childhood has to be tainted by physical punishment again," he said. Children's charity Barnado's also said the law must change as "children continue to have less legal protection against physical assault than adults". "Physical punishment like smacking is harmful to a child's health and development, and there's strong evidence that it influences their attitudes toward violence," said chief executive Lynn Perry. Professor Andrew Rowland, from the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, added: "Health professionals stand firmly with parents and young people in recognising that physical punishment is not only outdated and unjust, but also harmful to children's health and wellbeing. "We urge the government to listen to parents, young people, health professionals and the wider public and to finally remove the outdated and unfair 'reasonable punishment' defence." A Department for Education spokesperson said: "While we are looking closely at the legal changes made in Wales and Scotland in relation to smacking, we have no plans to legislate at this stage."
