Another challenge to EC's Bihar electoral revision order in Supreme Court
PUCL president Kavita Srivastava said that its constitutional challenge to the SIR order is based on the argument that this process 'represents a direct assault on India's constitutional democracy, violating the grundnorm of popular sovereignty enshrined in 'We, The People'.'
'By abandoning statutory house-to-house surveys for arbitrary document-centred exclusions, creating impossible timelines, and systematically disenfranchising marginalised communities, the Election Commission has perverted the constitutional mandate, and inverted the principle of inclusion to that of exclusion,' the PUCL said.
The petition was filed on Saturday through PUCL national general secretary V Suresh.
Terming it an 'illegal exercise', the PUCL said that such an exercise being hastily conducted to cover a population of almost 8 crore is likely to result in exclusion of voters and thereby defeat democracy using the very tools of democracy.
Earlier, citing 'lack of due process' and 'unreasonably short timeline' for the revision electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar, Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), an NGO, had approached the Supreme Court, challenging the EC exercise by calling it unconstitutional and warning that it will 'disenfranchise lakhs of voters'.
In its petition, the PUCL contends that Bihar has a massive migrant population, who work across India and return home to exercise their democratic rights. They face systematic exclusion through this 'malicious' SIR process, the human rights organisation said.
'Migrant workers lack local address proofs, cannot navigate complex form-based procedures from distant locations, and miss compressed timelines due to work commitments. This timing appears deliberately calculated to disenfranchise Bihar's mobile workforce during crucial electoral periods,' the PUCL said.
In the petition, the PUCL has prayed that the ECI Order and letter dated June 24, 2025, deserves to be quashed for being manifestly arbitrary and that it is also contrary to Article 327 – which grants Parliament the power to make provision with respect to elections to legislatures – read with the relevant Act and Rules.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
29 minutes ago
- First Post
High drama over EC's SIR: Rahul Gandhi detained, Akhilesh Yadav jumps police barricade
A protest by the INDIA bloc outside the Election Commission of India turned dramatic as Akhilesh Yadav jumped over police barricades and Congress leaders Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi were detained by Delhi Police. read more Advertisement Dramatic scenes unfolded at the INDIA bloc protest outside the Election Commission of India on Monday, as Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav jumped over a police barricade while Congress MP Rahul Gandhi and his sister Priyanka Gandhi were detained by Delhi Police. The police stopped the leaders from marching from Parliament towards the Election Commission. Rahul Gandhi was among several opposition leaders and MPs detained during the protest against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls being carried out in Bihar and planned in other states. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Videos circulating on social media showed Akhilesh Yadav leaping over barricades as other opposition leaders continued their march from Parliament House to Nirvachan Sadan. The INDIA bloc protest march was organised in response to the SIR of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar amid allegations of 'voter fraud' during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. Delhi Police met the INDIA bloc leaders with barricades soon after they began the march from Parliament, which was led by Congress MP and Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi. Ahead of the march, Delhi Police stated that no permission had been sought to hold the protest. Over 300 MPs from both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha took part in the march, which started around 11:30 am. To maintain order and prevent any untoward incidents, Delhi Police deployed personnel and erected barricades at multiple points along the route. Additional security vehicles and quick reaction teams were stationed near the Election Commission office and surrounding roads to ensure smooth traffic flow. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD This protest follows Rahul Gandhi's press conference last Thursday, where he described his evidence of alleged poll fraud as an 'atom bomb' of proofs, accusing the poll body of resorting to 'vote chori'.
Hindustan Times
29 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
‘EC's own interests lie in addressing vote theft allegations': Shashi Tharoor
Congress' Member of Parliament Shashi Tharoor said on Monday that the Election Commission of India should address the issued raised by the Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi in order to maintain its credibility. Shashi Tharoor's remarks come as several Oppostion MPs marching towards the EC office were stopped and detained by the Delhi Police.(File/ANI) He said that as long as people have doubts in their minds regarding the fairness of elections, it will harm the credibility of the poll body. Follow live updates of Parliament's monsoon session here. "As long as there are doubts in the minds of people about the fairness of the elections, that is harming the credibility of the Election Commission. As long as those doubts are removed, then the Election Commission's credibility can be regained. The Election Commission's own interest lies in addressing these questions," Tharoor told news agency ANI as several Opposition MPs protested against the alleged 'voter fraud' as claimed by Rahul Gandhi on Monday. Opposition MPs march towards EC office Hundreds of MPs of the opposition INDIA bloc took out a march from Parliament to the Election Commission office on Monday to protest against the poll body after Gandhi's 'vote theft' allegations against the ECI and also the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the voter rolls in Bihar. During the march, Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra and her party colleague and fellow MP Mitali Bagh fainted mid-way and were assisted by their party members. The MPs marching towards the EC office were stopped by the Delhi Police. Several leaders including Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi and Sanjay Raut were also detained during the march. This unfolded as the Election Commission wrote to Congress leader Jairam Ramesh scheduling a meeting with 30 opposition leaders over the issue at 12 pm on Monday. However, it later said that the MPs found ways to run away from the poll body. The Congress has said that the party leaders would have met the Election Commission, had their march been allowed to go to the Nirvachan Sadan.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
29 minutes ago
- Business Standard
EC can restore credibility by addressing election fairness doubts: Tharoor
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said on Monday that the Election Commisisons credibility can be "regained" as long as those "doubts" about the fairness of the elections are removed as the INDIA bloc leaders march to Election Commisison to protest the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and allegations of vote theft. Tharoor, who joined the march, told ANI, "As long as there are doubts in the minds of people about the fairness of the elections, that is harming the credibility of the Election Commission. As long as those doubts are removed, then the Election Commission's credibility can be regained. The Election Commission's own interest lies in addressing these questions. Delhi Police were seen stopping the MPs who were raising slogans of "vote chor" as they marched towards the office of the poll body at Nirvachan protest march began from the Makar Dwar of the Parliament under the leadership of Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi. The MPs began their march to urge the EC to address their concerns on the alleged "voter theft". Samajwadi Party MP Dimple Yadav who was part of the protest march said, "Questions are being raised on our democracy. In UP, by-elections were held on 10 Vidhan Sabha seats; not only were votes stolen, but booths were captured. Why didn't the Election Commission take action against the officers who were working on orders of the state government." RJD MP Manoj Jha said that SIR is a "fraud" and accused EC of not providing a classified data."If you cannot meet MPs citing the excuse of space, then that in itself is a comment on what kind of work you are doing... This (SIR) is a fraud; you are not providing classified data. Despite the Supreme Court's instructions, your (Election Commission) stubbornness is not going away," Jha said Meanwhile, Delhi Police has said that the Opposition MPs have sought no permission for the march. Responding to the Police statement, Congress MP Imran Pratapgarhi said, "They never give permission. They are using political language on the directions of the government. Entire Opposition will take out the march under the leadership of Rahul Gandhi. They will try to stop us, but we will try our best to reach EC's office." Earlier, Congress MP Pramod Tiwari, speaking about the march, said, "Rahul Gandhi is walking on Gandhi ji's path. He held a press conference, but the Election Commission is not ready to consider it; instead, it is asking for an affidavit. Everyone knows the Election Commission is under whose pressure. Like Gandhi did, the Dandi march for independence, we are marching to save democracy. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
