Keir Starmer rules out new Scots independence vote - and says FM Swinney hasn't even asked for one - as poll warns PM Nigel Farage is threat to union
Keir Starmer effectively ruled out a new Scottish independence vote while he is Prime Minister today - suggesting it wasn't even a priority for the SNP government at Holyrood.
The Labour leader said he could not imagine a vote happening during his time in power, even if the nationalists win a majority in the 2026 Holyrood election.
And he said that First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney had not raised the issue with him during their recent talks.
It came after a weekend poll suggested support for a breakaway has risen amid a surge for Reform north of the border.
A Norstat poll found 54 per cent backed the separatist cause, the joint highest ever detected by the firm.
The eight-point lead - excluding don't knows - swelled to 16 points if people were asked to imagine Nigel Farage was PM.
The Prime Minister was asked by the BBC's Good Morning Scotland programme, if he could imagine another independence referendum during his time as Prime Minister.
Sir Keir said: 'No, and nobody's raising that with me as their first priority.
'Certainly, in the discussions I'm having with the First Minister, that is not – we're talking about jobs, energy, security and dealing with the cost-of-living crisis.'
Scots voted in an independence referendum in 2014, with the 'No' side securing 55 per cent of the vote.
Since then, successive UK governments have rejected the SNP's pleas for a second referendum.
Last month Mr Swinney said a 'democratic majority' of pro-independence MSPs following the next Scottish Parliament election should result in another referendum.
The Prime Minister said that whatever the outcome in May, an independence referendum is 'not a priority'.
The most recent figure of support rose from 50 per cent in the last Norstat poll in January.
The highest that support for independence has reached in recent years is 58 per cent, in an Ipsos Scotland poll for STV News in the early months of the pandemic, as Nicola Sturgeon received plaudits for her handling of Covid-19.
The figures come ahead of a by-election in Lanarkshire this week, after the death of Scottish Government minister Christina McKelvie.
According to polling expert Professor Sir John Curtice, in projections for the Sunday Times, John Swinney was on track to win an unprecedented fifth term in office for his party next year, securing 54 seats.
Labour would drop to 20 seats, while Reform would win 18 in their first full political test in Scotland.
Meanwhile, the Tories would drop from being the second biggest party to the fourth, with just 17 MSPs, followed by the Lib Dems on 11 and the Greens on nine.
Speaking to Good Morning Scotland, Sir Keir also discussed the defence sector in Scotland.
He said there are around 25,000 defence jobs in Scotland and the strategic defence review announcements would 'build on that'.
The Prime Minister said: 'I would like to see many, many jobs in Scotland.
'Scotland has an incredible heritage and skilled work people in Scotland.
'We've just been looking at some of the frigates which have been built and are being built in Scotland.'
He insisted the SNP is 'wrong' in its opposition to nuclear weapons and said 'we're entering a new era on defence and security'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
9 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Tories will ‘never again' put economy at risk like Liz Truss did, Mel Stride to say
The Conservatives will 'never again' risk the economy with unfunded tax cuts like those in Liz Truss's mini-budget, the shadow chancellor is to say in the party's clearest repudiation yet of the former prime minister. Making a speech on the economy, Mel Stride is expected to go beyond any comments made by the Tory leader, Kemi Badenoch, thus far to accept that Truss's September 2022 fiscal plans, which involved about £45bn in unfunded tax cuts and quickly unravelled, badly dented the reputation of the party. 'For a few weeks, we put at risk the very stability which Conservatives had always said must be carefully protected,' Stride will tell an event in London on Thursday morning, according to extracts released in advance. 'The credibility of the UK's economic framework was undermined by spending billions on subsidising energy bills, and tax cuts, with no proper plan for how this would be paid for. As a Conservative, of course I want taxes to be as low as possible. But that must be achieved responsibly through fiscal discipline.' Stride will argue that while the Tories moved swiftly to limit the damage – the main tax cut was reversed in little more than a week, Kwasi Kwarteng was sacked as chancellor within three weeks, and Truss quit six days later – the party's standing has taken a long-term hit. 'Back then mistakes were recognised and stability restored within weeks, with the full backing of our party,' he said. 'But the damage to our credibility is not so easily undone. That will take time. And it also requires contrition. So let me be clear: never again will the Conservative party undermine fiscal credibility by making promises we cannot afford.' Expressing a dim view of Truss's record is not a particularly risky stance to take, with polling shortly before she resigned showing just 11% of voters thought she was doing a good job as prime minister. But previously Badenoch and her shadow team have avoided much direct criticism of Truss. When asked about Truss, Badenoch has generally said the party needs to move on from debates about her premiership, although in January it emerged that she had told her shadow cabinet 'it would be best if Liz would shut up for a while'. In his speech, Stride is to say that, however misguided, Truss's keenness for an economic reset was 'in part born of exasperation with the failure of successive governments to put us on a path back to sustained growth and rising living standards'. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion He will say: 'The fact is for a large swathe of the population our economy simply has not been working for them for some considerable time. Incomes have stagnated. Many feel that the system only works for the benefit of others, for large corporations, or people from other countries, but not for them and their families.' Insisting the answer is not the 'magic money tree' populism of Reform, Stride will call for restrictions to public spending, particularly on social security, and supply-side changes to boost productivity.
The National
9 minutes ago
- The National
John Swinney in final Hamilton by-election pitch as polls open
The vote sparked by the death of Scottish Government minister Christina McKelvie in March will take place on Thursday, and is widely considered to be a three-horse race between the SNP, Labour and Reform UK. One of the major talking points of the campaign has been the criticism levelled at Reform UK after an attack advert published by the party claimed Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar prioritises people from Pakistan over those in Scotland. READ MORE: POLL: How would you vote in the Hamilton by-election? The ad, which has now been seen around one million times on Facebook, includes selected clips from a video spread by far and alt-right agitators on social media in a bid to claim that Europe was under threat from 'multiculturalism' and mass immigration, specifically of Muslims. It has been condemned as 'racist' by both the SNP and Scottish Labour. (Image: PA) Speaking ahead of polls opening at 7am on Thursday, Swinney (above) again claimed the contest is between the SNP and Reform UK, saying: 'Today, people in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse can reject the politics of Nigel Farage and elect a local champion by voting SNP. 'Farage doesn't care about Scotland – he wants to cut our budget, undermine our Parliament and introduce charges for the NHS. READ MORE: Anger as TWO Scottish Labour politicians get key BBC slot on by-election eve 'Labour have given up on the campaign and have barely even bothered to defend their record of scrapping the Winter Fuel Payment and cutting support for disabled people. 'So this by-election is a two-horse race between the SNP and Farage. And today, people in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse can unite behind the SNP and defeat the gutter politics of Nigel Farage by voting for Katy Loudon.' Anas Sarwar pictured with Scottish Labour candidate Davy Russell (Image: PA) Meanwhile, Scottish Labour leader Sarwar (above) said the choice facing voters is 'more failure with the SNP or a local champion' with Scottish Labour's Davy Russell, accusing the nationalists of talking up Reform to 'distract from their own failures'. He added: 'Time and time again, the SNP has failed Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse. 'From our overstretched NHS to our declining education system to our crisis-hit housing system, almost all of what is broken in Scotland is run by the SNP. 'They don't deserve to win, but only Scottish Labour can beat them. 'The SNP wants to talk up Reform to distract from their own failures, but Scots will see through the spin. 'This is a chance to put this failing Government on notice and chart a new direction for all of Scotland – let's seize that opportunity.'
The National
9 minutes ago
- The National
Most people in the UK support sanctions against Israel, new poll finds
The new polling, commissioned by human rights organisation Global Justice Now and carried out by Yonder Consulting, found that 62% of people in the UK would support sanctions being imposed on Israel as a means to exert pressure on it to stop its brutal attacks on Gaza. Just 11% of respondents said they would oppose sanctions. The polling also found that 65% support banning all arms sales to Israel until it ends its assault on Gaza (with 11% in opposition), while 60% would support suspending the existing trade deal between the UK and Israel (with 13% in opposition). READ MORE: POLL: How would you vote in the Hamilton by-election? The poll, which surveyed 2109 UK adults between May 28 and 29, also showed that support for sanctions against Israel is higher in Scotland than the UK as a whole. It found that 66% of people in Scotland support sanctions on Israel (9% oppose), while 66% support a ban on arms sales to Israel (10% oppose), and 61% support a trade deal suspension (12% oppose). The Scotland-specific results are based on the 177 people in Scotland who were surveyed out of the 2109 total. While the UK Government said last month that it was suspending negotiations on a new free trade deal with Israel, its existing trade agreement with Israel is still in place. Despite branding the Israeli government's actions as "egregious", the UK Government sent its trade envoy to Israel just days after the suspension to "promote trade" between the two countries. It was also revealed that the Labour Government licensed exports of more military equipment to Israel in the final three months of 2024 than the Tories did for all of 2020-2023. READ MORE: 'Brave and powerful' documentary on Gaza protests to have Scottish premiere The National also reported how a group of Labour MPs visited Israel on a lobbying trip reportedly just last week, organised by the party's most prominent pro-Israeli group, Labour Friends of Israel. Global Justice Now called on the UK Government to impose sanctions, arguing that it has "a duty to prevent genocide". Tim Bierley, a campaigner with Global Justice Now, said: 'As Israel erases Gaza before our eyes, today's polling makes clear that across all regions, age and income groups, the British public wants our government to take far stronger action against Israel's genocidal attacks. 'Just as the UK has placed comprehensive sanctions on Russia over its invasion of Ukraine, it must urgently exert meaningful pressure on Israel. 'Despite issuing stronger rebukes in recent weeks, the government continues to license key exports for arms used to massacre Palestinians and offer Israel privileged trade terms, as if war crimes should have no effect on business-as-usual. 'Under international law, the UK has a duty to prevent genocide – and any MPs who ignore public sentiment would do well to remember their duty to represent the voice of ordinary people.' The Foreign Office has been contacted for comment.
