From the editor: David Lammy's 'clickbait' jibe won't silence us
I remember Anas Sarwar claiming we blamed the SNP's poor Rutherglen by-election result on poor weather ... which was absolute nonsense. It was pretty amusing for those of us staying up until the wee hours covering the count, though. I can recall Michael Gove saying we were the worst newspaper in the world, which was quite entertaining. A newspaper hated by Michael Gove is a newspaper I'd like to be a part of, and I reckon plenty Scots feel the same way. That's why we put up the billboards.
Then there's all the usual suspects having a go at us on social media. Murdo Fraser always seems to be personally victimised by whatever we're covering. There's historic beef with Alex Cole-Hamilton. Politicians of all colours in the Better Together rainbow have had their say, and we've never been massively troubled by it.
However this week, I was genuinely infuriated by the words of a senior UK Government figure. There was nothing to laugh about here. In describing a news story we broke as "clickbait", David Lammy attempted to discredit us and silence us on the most important story of our times – Israel's genocide in Gaza.
The story was about how the Labour Government, in the last quarter of 2024, exported more weapons to Israel than the Tories did from 2020-23. We broke this news last Thursday and it was widely shared, including by independent MP Zarah Sultana. She brought the figures (which came from the UK Government themselves) up to Lammy in the Commons this week, and he accused the MP of sharing "clickbait" online.
The official Oxford Languages definition of "clickbait" is: "Content whose main purpose is to attract attention and encourage visitors to click on a link to a particular web page." Labour would know plenty about this. For instance, many years ago Keir Starmer shared his infamous 10 pledges website, hoping to attract attention from potential voters within the Labour membership pool before swiftly backtracking on all of his promises and deleting it when it became politically awkward. Labour also shared fancy graphics promising cheaper energy bills, hoping for clicks and engagement, before doing precisely nothing as energy bills continued rising when they came to power.
What is not clickbait, however, is well-researched stories, based on official verified figures. Even when it is shared by a news outlet that you don't like because it actually bothers to hold you accountable. We at The National stand by our story. How many of Labour's claims can they stand by?
To dismiss such a serious matter as the export of arms to a state which is clearly breaching international human rights law as "clickbait" shows us how intellectually lazy this class of government ministers is, and how morally bankrupt they are.
You can say "clickbait" as many times as you want, Dave. It doesn't change the facts. You exported more weapons in three months than the Tories did in three years. If you want to be complicit in Israel's assault on Gaza, at least have the guts to own it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
29 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Take them to the tower: As Scotland's NHS is on its knees nationalist MSPs want to end oath of allegiance to King
Senior Nationalists have sparked outrage after demanding an end to MSPs swearing allegiance to the King – while public services 'collapse around them'. The move would require rewriting the Scotland Act which underpins devolution and votes in the House of Commons, House of Lords and Holyrood. The Scottish Conservatives said voters crying out for improvements in the NHS, education and policing would be repelled by the 'constitutional navel gazing'. Tory MSP Murdo Fraser called it 'the worst sort of petty student politics'. He said: 'Scots will be outraged SNP MSPs are focusing on this issue while our public services collapse around them. 'Parliament should be holding this failing SNP government to account on so many issues such as the ferry scandal, Scotland's record level of drug deaths and our flagging economy, rather than wasting time discussing this. 'It is typical Nationalist MSPs are yet again putting their obsession with the constitution above everything else and things that really matter to people.' Statistics this week showed worsening A&E waits, with more than a third of patients waiting more than the four-hour target to be seen, and growing numbers of cancer deaths. Recent weeks have also revealed a 15 per cent surge in drug overdoses, a stubborn attainment gap between rich and poor schools pupils, and growing numbers of crimes going unsolved. The annual GERS report also indicated a £26.5billion gap between public spending in Scotland and what is raised in tax, driven in part by a runaway welfare budget. Scotland is also still stuck in a cost of living crisis that has seen bills continue to soar. The row was triggered by former SNP minister Kevin Stewart calling for Scotland to follow the example of one of the smallest nations in the Commonwealth. The Caribbean island of Grenada last month agreed to change its oath of allegiance to remove the words 'His Majesty King Charles the Third, His Heirs and Successors'. In future, parliamentarians will simply swear allegiance to 'Grenada'. Mr Stewart tabled a parliamentary motion on Tuesday. The Aberdeen Central MSP said Holyrood should 'commend' Grenada for dropping 'the oath of allegiance to the British crown'. Urging MSPs to recognise 'the people of Scotland are sovereign', he said Holyrood 'should have the power to follow Grenada's lead and have its members pledge allegiance to the people of Scotland and not an unelected monarch'. By Wednesday night, the motion had been signed by another 11 SNP MSPs, including former housing minister Paul McLennan and ex-minister for parliamentary business George Adam. Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer and Labour left-winger Mercedes Villalba also supported the call, as did SNP-turned-independent MSP John Mason. A host of MSPs have complained about the oath since the Scottish parliament was revived in 1999. Within minutes of the devolution era beginning, then SNP leader Alex Salmond stated his 'primary loyalty lies with the people of Scotland' before being sworn in as the third ever MSP. Then Scottish Socialist Party leader Tommy Sheridan was sworn in 'under protest' in 1999, saying it was at odds with his 'vision for Scotland' as a 'democratic socialist republic'. In 2003, fellow Scottish Socialist Rosie Kane famously made her affirmation with 'my oath is to the people' written on her upraised palm. Hitting out at the latest bid to undermine the oath, Mr Fraser added: 'This is a shameless bid from an Nationalist MSP to try and pander to republican voters inside and outside of his party. 'The reality is the King and the monarchy remain one of the most loved and respected institutions across Scotland. 'Most people will wonder why Nationalist MSPs are focusing on this constitutional navel gazing when they should be tackling the real priorities of Scots... rather than engaging in the worst sort of petty student politics.' Alastair Cameron, chair of Scotland in Union, said: 'It's typical of the SNP to focus on trivial matters when so much else is going wrong. It's a waste of time and effort, and shows more than ever why Scotland must vote for change next May.' Labour peer George Foulkes, a former MSP, said the SNP habitually obsessed about 'trivia' and 'vanity projects' and voters were 'increasingly fed up with them'. He said: 'The papers are full of stories about people being let down by the NHS and schools and the justice system, yet the SNP is focused on irrelevancies. 'These strange diversions only play into the hands of the people who want to abolish Holyrood.'
Telegraph
29 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Government issues urgent appeal for 5,000 homes to house 20,000 migrants
The Home Office has issued an urgent appeal for 5,000 properties to house up to 20,000 migrants amid an accommodation crisis caused by a landmark High Court ruling. Asylum accommodation contractors working for the Home Office 'reached out' to property specialists earlier in August, seeking 5,000 residential units. Insiders suggested each flat would have two bedrooms on average, with space to house four migrants. The move emerged on Wednesday, a day after Epping Forest district council was granted a temporary injunction by the High Court to shut down the Bell Hotel in Essex over alleged planning breaches after it became a focus for anti-immigration protests. The hunt for alternative accommodation is part of Labour's pledge to end the use of hotels for asylum seekers by the close of this Parliament in 2029. However, some 200 hotels are still being used by the Home Office to house more than 32,000 asylum seekers, a similar number to summer 2024 – after Labour was forced to find accommodation for the record 27,997 migrants to have crossed the Channel so far in 2025. The Epping council ruling threatens to spark similar legal challenges by other councils seeking to shut asylum hotels in their areas. Two dozen have already signalled that they will consider following suit which, if successful, could worsen the asylum accommodation crisis. Ministers are seeking to partner councils to buy, lease or rent houses and vacant properties in which to place asylum seekers as an alternative to hotels. Officials are also targeting disused tower blocks, student accommodation and old teacher-training colleges for use as 'medium-sized' accommodation sites. The new appeal is understood to have been seeking shorter-term leases or rents, where migrants would be accommodated for 90 days with an additional 30 days' notice. Similar 'contingency' accommodation has also been commissioned at the former Wethersfield RAF base near Braintree, Essex, where the Home Office has raised the cap of 800 migrants to allow 1,225 to live on the site. Residents were told at a meeting on Tuesday that the numbers had already risen to 890, with two intakes of 50 more asylum seekers scheduled every week. Wethersfield is the only 'large' site that Labour inherited from the Tories and kept open, despite Sir Keir Starmer saying before the election that it 'needs to close'. The two other major sites identified by the Tories – the Bibby Stockholm barge and RAF Scampton in Lincolnshire – have both been abandoned by Labour. On Wednesday, Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, called on the Government to guarantee that none of the asylum seekers removed from the Bell Hotel would be transferred to hotels or any other accommodation 'much needed for British people'. He also urged Sir Keir to call an emergency Cabinet meeting to draw up plans to deport all illegal migrants on arrival. 'The previous government established alternative accommodation on current or former military sites and an accommodation barge, which are all alternative options while deportation plans are put in place,' he said. Robert Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, has launched the campaign Lawyers for Borders, which has already attracted top-flight barristers to advise councils on legal challenges to close asylum hotels. 'Every patriotic council, whether Conservative, Reform, whatever, should follow Epping's lead and seek an injunction. And if you are a council or a community group and you need our help, contact my office. If you're a lawyer and you want to join the fight, contact me,' he said in a video on X. 'Let's create a new movement, Lawyers for Borders… We need to put as much pressure as possible on Keir Starmer to change the law, to deport every single illegal migrant who's here, and to close all the hotels.' A Home Office spokesman said: 'This Government has consistently said the use of hotels to house asylum seekers is neither sustainable nor suitable as a long-term approach. 'We remain committed to working with our partners to identify more suitable and cost-effective alternatives.'
Times
43 minutes ago
- Times
Failure to study languages ‘damages Britain's reputation'
The refusal of Britons to speak another language damages the country's reputation as a global player, according to the former schools minister. Nick Gibb said the government should consider making languages compulsory at GCSE, reversing a decision taken two decades ago. On Thursday hundreds of thousands of teenagers will receive their GCSE results in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. About a fifth are expected to achieve at least a grade 7 or A. Spanish is expected to have overtaken French for the first time but language entries in general — particularly German — have plummeted in recent years. Gibb helped oversee GCSE reform in the 2010s alongside Michael Gove, a decade after languages became optional. He told The Times: 'It's regrettable and very bad for Britain's reputation that we seem to refuse to speak other people's languages. Businesses will always want these people [who speak foreign languages], they will employ people from elsewhere or from private schools. It's damaging to our reputation as a global player.' Gove and Gibb introduced the English baccalaureate (EBacc) grouping, which was supposed to drive up language entries by measuring schools on how many pupils took English, maths, a science, humanities and language at GCSE. The target was for 90 per cent of children to be taking all five EBacc subjects by this year but it has stalled at about 40 per cent, mainly because of the lack of language entries. • What to do now if you didn't get the GCSE results you wanted Gibb said: 'There was an initial jump in languages [after the EBacc introduction] then it tailed off although we have seen a big surge in history, geography and individual sciences.' He said the reason that his government had not initially made languages compulsory was that low numbers meant it was not possible overnight. 'But if the EBacc is not working then the government should consider whether, over a period of time, it makes it [a language] compulsory over a long lead-in time. You could say for example, the intent is that the compulsion at GCSE would return by 2030, for Year 7 students starting this September.' Gibb said caution was needed with policy changes to ensure there were enough language teachers. Provisional figures for England indicate German will suffer the biggest annual fall in any GCSE subject this year, of 7.6 per cent, down to about 32,400. French fell 1.9 per cent to just over 128,000 while nearly 43,000 took other modern languages — a total of about 335,000 out of 5.7 million entries. Spanish is up 1.6 per cent to nearly 132,000. In 2004, the last year that a language was compulsory at GCSE, in England 118,000 pupils took German, 296,000 took French, 59,600 took Spanish and 28,600 took other modern languages — a total of more than 502,000 out of 5.35 million entries • The Times view: Culture and horizons of young Britons limited without language While only 40 per cent of pupils entered the EBacc combination of GCSEs in 2023-24, 86 per cent took four of the five subjects. Eighty-nine per cent of these were missing languages, up from 86 per cent in 2019. Gibb, who has co-written a book called Reforming Lessons about the changes he introduced, also criticised schools for starting to teach GCSE-type questions too early, in Years 7 and 8. This can put children off reading for pleasure at the start of secondary school, he said. 'Some teach the text for five years, it's terrible. You shouldn't be analysing text you will cover at 15 at the age of 12. If I had been in office longer I would have done something about that.' Gibb said schools should introduce pupils to more challenging books as a class, showing them how to tackle harder material to prepare them for GCSEs. 'It would give them the confidence to read Dickens on their own,' he said. 'I think there's no age limit for being read to. We were read to until sixth-form when at school. It's easier to understand text that is read to you.' Gibb praised schools in the David Ross Education Trust, which have teachers reading aloud to pupils each day during tutor time. Kai Veitch is bucking the trend of falling language study by choosing to study German for a specific reason: he wants to race for Mercedes. The 15-year-old karting talent has set his sights on Formula 1, and one day hopes to drive for the German team (Georgia Lambert writes). 'When I first decided to take the subject, I did it because I wanted to try and drive for Mercedes one day,' he said, adding that his other choices in computer science and geography would also benefit his career. As he heads into Year 11 this September, Veitch is not only preparing for his GCSEs next year but also racing full-time across Europe in the Senior Rotax class, competing against adult drivers in elite karting championships. A student at Minerva Virtual Academy, an online school offering one-to-one mentoring and flexible pacing for Send learners and others requiring adaptable options, the teenage chose a more adaptable educational path after mainstream schooling proved unable to meet his needs. 'I'm aiming to race in Formula 4 next year, and I know a lot of the top teams are based in places like Germany and Italy. Even just understanding some of the language helps with communication. If you want to go far in motorsport, it's not just about speed; it's also about how well you work with your team. Language plays a part in that,' Veitch said. 'Now that I'm racing across Europe, I see how languages help in real situations, talking to engineers, teams, or even just showing respect in another country. In a sport like this, it gives you an edge.' Kai began karting at 11 and moved to the senior class at 14 to challenge himself againstadult competition. He races most weekends and trains between events. Despite the traveldemands, he continues his full academic study through the online school. 'It means I can keep learning while I'm away racing. I log into classes from hotels or trackside, and I have deadlines like everyone else. It's not easier, it's just more flexible.'
