The Disgrace Of The Hospice Care Funding Scandal
This was primarily because much of the argument in support seemed to me to centre on difficulties in accessing palliative care, including in hospices.
My view was that the priority was to improve accessibility to palliative care. I would have felt better if palliative care access had been improved but sadly it has further deteriorated to the point of crisis and tipping point.
Understanding palliative care and hospices
Palliative care is a branch of medicine regulated by the Medical Council. It improves the quality of life of patients and that of their families who are facing challenges associated with life-threatening, including terminal, illness. When a person receives a terminal diagnosis, they can choose to receive hospice care.
Annually hospice services in New Zealand provide palliative and holistic wrap around care to over 10,000 people who die, as well as another 9,000 living with terminal illness, and their whānau.
Although hospices are not statutory health authorities, everything they provide is free of charge. Roughly there is a 50:50 split between government funding and hospice fundraising. Hospice New Zealand is the national representative organisation of these 32 hospices.
Hospice health professionals include doctors, nurses, therapists (physical, occupational and speech) and social workers. Consequently, even more so than hospitals, they are labour intensive.
Hospices provide medical care designed for the end of a person's life. The purpose of this care is to improve the quality of the life that these patients have left. It includes pain and other symptom relief, along with emotional, psychosocial, and spiritual help for both patients and their families.
Hospice care operates at four levels depending on circumstances – routine home care, continuous home care, general inpatient care, and respite care.
Most patients under hospice care are able to stay in their own homes, with brief admissions to hospice for respite or to adjust pain medication.
Hospice funding crisis reaches tipping point
Unfortunately, despite the invaluable work for the terminally ill that only they as institutions can provide, the funding crisis that hospices face has reached a tipping point.
This was brought to the fore by Kathryn Ryan's Radio New Zealand Nine to Noon programme (6 June): Hospice funding crisis.
The focus was on one of the largest hospices, Tōtara Hospice, which services the communities of South and South-East Auckland. It has had to formally advise Health Minister Simeon Brown that it is planning to reduce services next month.
This action comes after years of warnings from hospices that their funding was unsustainable. This was reinforced by a recent report by the MartinJenkins consultancy which concluded that for the first time the hospice sector won't be able to raise enough money to break even.
Expanding the tipping point
Radio New Zealand's coverage of the funding tipping point continued three days later on Morning Report in a thorough piece by health journalist Ruth Hill: Collapse of hospices could cost taxpayers millions.
Hill reported the hospices warning that funding shortfalls were putting their critical services at risk. Already they were only available to one out of three New Zealanders who were dying. She provided individual examples of this sorry state of affairs.
The Government's scuttling of the pay equity claim for hospice nurses also had a negative impact. Hospice New Zealand chief executive Wayne Naylor noted that hospice nurses were currently paid up to 35% less than Health New Zealand nurses. He said:
That was a real out-of-the-blue sideswipe for hospices and hospice nurses in particular, to have our pay equity claim, which was almost completed, just stop.
Hospices were being forced to consider two unpalatable alternatives. Naylor described it this way:
That then falls back on community to provide more money to support their local hospice. The alternative is that hospices have to make some staff redundant so that they can increase the salaries of other staff, and that leads to a reduction in services.
Minister Brown has said that Health New Zealand had enough funding for hospice care. However, Naylor reported that the organisation had told Hospice New Zealand something quite opposite to the Minister:
They told us they had no more funding, that they have no contingency that they can call upon, and the people with whom we met said they had no authority to allocate funding from anywhere else. So essentially it's a no to funding from Health NZ right now.
Ruth Hill also tellingly cites the MartinJenkins report which that the 28 partially publicly-funded hospices are returning at least $1.59 in health benefits for every dollar of taxpayer money received, including fewer emergency departments and hospital admissions or rest home stays.
What is to be done
Simeon Brown maintains that he and his government value the services hospices provide. What they provide is as core to the public health system as the services provided in our general practices and public hospitals.
Further, many (probably most) of the terminally ill are people who have invested in the public health system for much longer than those who sit around the cabinet table.
They have done their bit to ensure their health system has been funded for the benefit not just for themselves and their families.
It has also for hugely many more others that are unknown to them. It is only reasonable that hospice care should be available for them in their final weeks or months.
It is not just a question of the hospice service being sufficiently funded. It should not have to be financially dependent on charity to survive, let alone function.
This is fundamentally wrong. Being dependent on charity only makes sense if governments are so cynical to factor into their calculations that the terminally ill don't amount to many votes and not for very long!
It also makes sense if governments are so short-sighted that they can't see the financial return of investing in hospice care!
If hospice care being dependent on charity does make sense, then the words 'disgrace' and 'scandal' have no meaning.
Ian Powell
Otaihanga Second Opinion is a regular health systems blog in New Zealand.
Ian Powell is the editor of the health systems blog 'Otaihanga Second Opinion.' He is also a columnist for New Zealand Doctor, occasional columnist for the Sunday Star Times, and contributor to the Victoria University hosted Democracy Project. For over 30 years , until December 2019, he was the Executive Director of Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, the union representing senior doctors and dentists in New Zealand.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
16 hours ago
- Scoop
Patient-Focused New Zealand Health Plan Tabled
Minister of Health Health New Zealand's New Zealand Health Plan was tabled in Parliament this afternoon. Developed by Health New Zealand, the plan is a requirement under the Pae Ora (Healthy Futures) Act 2022. 'The plan outlines how Health New Zealand will deliver on the Government's health priorities over the period 2024–2027,' Health Minister Simeon Brown says. 'It sets the direction for how we will improve health outcomes and ensure all New Zealanders can access the care they need, where and when they need it. 'It gives effect to the Government Policy Statement on Health 2024–2027, with a clear focus on the Government's five health targets and five mental health targets: Health targets: faster cancer treatment improved childhood immunisation shorter stays in emergency departments shorter wait times for first specialist assessments shorter wait times for elective treatment. Mental health and addiction targets: faster access to specialist mental health and addiction services faster access to primary mental health and addiction services shorter mental health and addiction related stays in emergency departments increased mental health and addiction workforce development strengthened focus on prevention and early intervention. 'The plan is focused on achieving the Government's health targets, ensuring the health system delivers real results for patients and communities. These targets are backed by clear accountability and transparent reporting, so the public can track progress on a regular basis. 'Reducing wait times is a key priority for the Government. Too many New Zealanders have been left waiting far too long for the care they need. Under the last Government, waitlists ballooned – with the number of Kiwis waiting more than four months for elective procedures like hip, knee, or cataract surgeries increasing by over 2,500 per cent. 'Health New Zealand is focussed on delivering the Elective Boost programme, which will deliver 21,000 additional procedures over the 2025/2026 year to help clear the backlog of patients needing care.' The plan also sets out how the Government will grow and support the health workforce; improve clinical leadership with continuous quality improvement and innovation; invest in essential hospital infrastructure; ensure services are delivered more consistently across the country; and strengthen primary care across New Zealand so that people can receive timely, quality care in the community. 'Our focus is clear: putting patients back at the centre of the health system. We're building a system that delivers real results, and this plan is a key part of that,' Mr Brown says. Note:
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Government touts scholarships as nurse workforce strike over pay and lack of staffing
Health Minister Simeon Brown. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER The government is taking expressions of interest for nurse practitioner scholarships as the nursing workforce strike over pay and lack of staffing. The coalition is funding up to 120 nurse practitioner training places in primary care each year from 2026. Health Minister Simeon Brown said the scholarship applications are part of a coordinated plan to boost the workforce and ease pressure on doctors. "Too often, patients wait longer than they should to see a health professional. Expanding the nurse practitioner workforce means faster, more consistent care for those who need it most." It comes as thousands of nurses walked off the job over deadlocked contract negotiations. Brown said there were currently 897 nurse practitioners registered in New Zealand, including 339 working in primary care. "We're committed to growing this workforce and enabling more nurses to work in the nurse practitioner advanced scope of practice." Primary care scholarships will open for nurses who want to undertake advanced practice education, such as registered nurse prescribing, next month. Applications were also open for primary care employers to recruit and support up to 400 graduate nurses each year. Funding includes $20,000 for each graduate registered nurse employed by rural primary and community health providers and $15,000 for those employed by urban providers. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Thousands across New Zealand strike over nurse pay and lack of staffing
By RNZ reporters Not enough nurses and not enough money - that is the diagnosis of the Nurses Organisation for what ails the health system. Thousands of them walked off the job at 9am Wednesday for 24 hours over their deadlocked contract negotiations, which have dragged on since September. Health Minister Simeon Brown insists the pay offer on the table is fair, and accuses the union of hurting thousands of patients with its hard-line tactics. On the picketline in Wellington today, Pip Cresswell told RNZ she quit her job as a charge nurse because she was sick of not being allowed to fill vacancies and working more than 60 hours a week to cover. "We've got 7000 staff in Capital and Coast Hutt Valley and we've got 1000 positions empty. But we're being replaced at the rate that people left last week, so we're never going to get the 1000 people back." Four bus-loads of nurses, midwives and healthcare assistants from Wellington joined forces with colleagues from Hutt Hospital to march past Parliament to offices shared by the Health Ministry and Te Whatu Ora at the top of Molesworth Street. Hutt emergency department nurse Seteli Pelasio said the risk to patients was the worst she had seen in 30 years. Nurses and healthcare assistants strike outside Britomart Station in Auckland. Photo: Wallace Chapman "Bloody scary, it is so scary at the moment. Not just the lack of staffing, but the experience, the staff mix on the floor." Specialist diabetes nurse prescriber Anne-Marie Frew said the nurse shortage meant there was a two-year wait list for patients to get insulin pumps in the region. "I'm scared, I'm really worried about risk. I'm working in diabetes where we've had no increase in our nursing resources for 16 years, despite the exponential growth in people with diabetes, and the technology." Labour's health spokesperson Dr Ayesha Verrall joined the march past the Beehive. "Some of the nurses here today I worked with when I was a specialist at Wellington Hospital. I'm really concerned about some of the things they have to say about understaffing in public hospitals. We can all see that things are getting worse rather than better." Brown blamed the Nurses Organisation for postponing care for 4300 patients. "These are patients who've been waiting far too long on wait lists, who have now been told they have to wait longer. That's the unfortunate reality of the nursing union deciding to strike today." Nurses Organisation chief executive Paul Goulter, who was among the 500-strong picket outside Waikato Hospital today, blamed the government for short-changing the public health system. Nurses protest about dangerous staffing levels at the Hamilton Gardens. Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod / RNZ "The issue is it's all about the money and funding and the government has to stump up to restore safe staffing at our hospitals." However, Health NZ chief executive Dale Bramley said he was confident that Health NZ employed enough nurses to staff its hospitals safely. The agency had employed 3000 extra nurses since 2023, with another 2000 in the in the recruitment pipeline, while the number of beds had only gone up by 175 over the last few years, he said. Objective measures of patient safety - including deaths among inpatients, pressure sores and cardiac arrests - had all improved. Protesters in Wellington. Photo: Samuel Rillstone / RNZ "There's a difference between a subjective measure of how you're experiencing the day, and an objective measure of a clinical outcome. "And on most of those objective measures, we would say that patient safety in the last five years is stable or improving." Wait times for elective procedures had also improved in the last five months - but the industrial action this week was going to increase wait times for thousands of patients, putting them at risk, he said. "The more people have to wait for essential care, the more risk sits in those lists." Yet nurses on the front-line say the pressure has increased. Waikato nurse Kristi Barthel gets multiple texts a day asking for her to work extra shifts. "We're all burned out because we're doing extra hours, over-time and we're not getting paid for our over-time, and having to pick up extra shifts." Nayda Heays had just come off a 12-hour shift at Hastings Hospital's intensive care unit. Nurses and supporters protest at Waikato Hospital, Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod If she were a construction worker instead of a nurse, she would "not be having to argue for basic health and safety" measures, she noted drily. "I'm tired now, and I'm going to spend the next four hours with my colleagues getting it out to our community that this has to stop." Te Arohanui Ngarimu, who has been nursing in Hawke's Bay for 20 years, said there were more patients now, and they were sicker. "When they come in, they're really sick and we're really stretched because we're short. It really affects our health because we just keep running, and we're not an Ever Ready battery." Dunedin Hospital delegate Robyn Hewlett was among 200 protesters who marched through the city this morning. She works in a busy surgical ward, where patients can wait up to five days for surgery due to staff shortages. Nurses strike on Auckland's North Shore. Photo: RNZ/Calvin Samuel "They are nil by mouth from 2am and then at 8pm they might get cancelled. So they haven't eaten all day, and then they may get a meal if food has been kept for them. And then they're nil by mouth again from 2am." Registered mental health nurse Mitchell said colleagues on the ward when patient numbers rose, there could be assaults and other problems. "There's more aggression potentially or escalations of sometimes violence in those spaces and when there's less staff to be able to manage and to create a safe environment, it can be quite dangerous for people." Hewlett worried people would be put off nursing as a career. "Why train to be a nurse when ... there's no position for you at the end of your three years training and you pay high fees at the polytechs or the universities and then you've got no job to pay for your student loans?" Final-year nursing student Bailey said she was fighting for her future, with fewer than half of mid-year graduates offered hospitals jobs so far. Staff nurses were flat-out trying to care for patients and teach nursing students like herself, she said. "There's not enough of them, it's such a struggle and it's so hard being a student and seeing that, and knowing that in a few years that will be me - if I get a job." In an interview with Morning Report today, Health NZ's acting chief clinical officer, Dame Helen Stokes-Lampard was asked whether Health NZ had the money to hire the nurses it needed. "We're all in a fiscally constrained environment, Health NZ is in a fortunate position at the moment where we have plenty of nurses willing to work with us, and we're keen to employ them where we can." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
