Australia murder case court filings include fake quotes and nonexistent judgments generated by AI
The blunder in the Supreme Court of Victoria state is another in a litany of mishaps AI has caused in justice systems around the world.
Defense lawyer Rishi Nathwani, who holds the prestigious legal title of King's Counsel, took "full responsibility" for filing incorrect information in submissions in the case of a teenager charged with murder, according to court documents seen by The Associated Press on Friday.
"We are deeply sorry and embarrassed for what occurred," Nathwani told Justice James Elliott on Wednesday, on behalf of the defense team.
The AI-generated errors caused a 24-hour delay in resolving a case that Elliott had hoped to conclude on Wednesday. Elliott ruled on Thursday that Nathwani's client, who cannot be identified because he is a minor, was not guilty of murder because of mental impairment.
"At the risk of understatement, the manner in which these events have unfolded is unsatisfactory," Elliott told lawyers on Thursday.
"The ability of the court to rely upon the accuracy of submissions made by counsel is fundamental to the due administration of justice," Elliott added.
The fake submissions included fabricated quotes from a speech to the state legislature and nonexistent case citations purportedly from the Supreme Court.
The errors were discovered by the Elliot's associates, who couldn't find the cases cited and requested that defense lawyers provide copies, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation reported.
The lawyers admitted the citations "do not exist" and that the submission contained "fictitious quotes," court documents say.
The lawyers explained they checked that the initial citations were accurate and wrongly assumed the others would also be correct.
The submissions were also sent to prosecutor Daniel Porceddu, who didn't check their accuracy.
The judge noted that the Supreme Court released guidelines last year for how lawyers use AI.
"It is not acceptable for artificial intelligence to be used unless the product of that use is independently and thoroughly verified," Elliott said.
The court documents do not identify the generative artificial intelligence system used by the lawyers.
In a comparable case in the United States in 2023, a federal judge imposed $5,000 fines on two lawyers and a law firm after ChatGPT was blamed for their submission of fictitious legal research in an aviation injury claim.
Judge P. Kevin Castel said they acted in bad faith. But he credited their apologies and remedial steps taken in explaining why harsher sanctions were not necessary to ensure they or others won't again let artificial intelligence tools prompt them to produce fake legal history in their arguments.
Later that year, more fictitious court rulings invented by AI were cited in legal papers filed by lawyers for Michael Cohen, a former personal lawyer for U.S. President Donald Trump. Cohen took the blame, saying he didn't realize that the Google tool he was using for legal research was also capable of so-called AI hallucinations.
British High Court Justice Victoria Sharp warned in June that providing false material as if it were genuine could be considered contempt of court or, in the "most egregious cases," perverting the course of justice, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison.
The use of artificial intelligence is making its way into U.S. courtrooms in other ways. In April, a man named Jerome Dewald appeared before a New York court and submitted a video that featured an AI-generated avatar to deliver an argument on his behalf.
In May, a man who was killed in a road rage incident in Arizona "spoke" during his killer's sentencing hearing after his family used artificial intelligence to create a video of him reading a victim impact statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
Scott Wolf claims estranged wife planned 'false allegations' against him in contentious divorce proceedings
Scott Wolf is breaking his silence after announcing he filed for divorce from his estranged wife, Kelley Wolf. The 57-year-old "Party of Five" star told People he hopes to keep "this most difficult chapter of our family's lives" private, but he has chosen to speak out because "the well-being of my children is at stake" and keeping them safe "will always be my priority." "There are some significant challenges that are making our situation incredibly difficult and contentious, and it is tragic for all involved," he told the outlet. "I was informed of some deeply disturbing and entirely false allegations that were made about me by my estranged wife." Scott claimed that Kelley told him in a series of text messages that she planned to "make claims" against him which included "psychological abuse, child abuse, child endangerment, stealing with passports." "I am now choosing to come forward and share that she has described to me her plans to 'make claims' about me, although she also admitted, 'I do not believe they're true,' in order to gain an advantage in what she sees as a 'battle' in court, and in the court of public opinion," Scott said in his statement. "In order to protect my kids, I am providing the text messages she sent to me where she describes this plan, so there are no questions about her intentions, or the malicious intent behind her false allegations made and/or planned for the future." Scott said that also in the messages, Kelley wrote that she "was advised to make claims that are possible, even though I do not believe they're true nor would I ever say them to anyone." "When you accused me of all the things you put in the restraining order, you made me into a villain," the alleged text messages read, per People. "The only way I can fight back is to produce claims that are either the same as yours or greater." She allegedly explained that she was trying to "create more urgency to get the kids back. Or at least get back joint custody." She went on to make several of these claims in a July 26 911 call to the police, the outlet reported. A new agreement was reached in the estranged couple's divorce proceedings on July 15, which granted Scott temporary sole physical custody of their three children, Jackson, 16, Miller, 12, and Lucy, 11. Kelley was given supervised visitation. "Although her claims are completely baseless and incredibly dangerous, the worst part is that they are traumatic for our children," the actor said. "I hope that anyone who might speak publicly or report on such things, will consider this before spreading any further information from a clearly unreliable and completely compromised source." He continued, "I continue to ask for privacy and respect for our family, and give thanks all those who have shown their love and support." Per People, under the terms of the July 15 agreement, Kelley is allowed supervised visits with the children, as well as three phone or video calls with the kids a week, with the ultimate goal of the agreement being that Kelley will no longer need supervision. The former couple announced they were splitting after 21 years of marriage on June 10, with Kelley sharing on Instagram they "are moving forward with the dissolution of our marriage." Just days after announcing their divorce, Kelley was detained by police in Utah County and taken to the hospital, after she made "some comments to people that are concerning."
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Australia grants asylum to former Hong Kong lawmaker and pro-democracy activist
By Jessie Pang and Lewis Jackson HONG KONG/BEIJING (Reuters) -Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former lawmaker said in a Facebook post on Saturday, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his hometown?" he said in the Facebook post. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their hometowns to visit relatives at any time; Exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing last month as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party lawmaker, Hui left Hong Kong late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put HK$1 million ($127,782) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is currently on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition. ($1 = 7.8258 Hong Kong dollars) Solve the daily Crossword
Wall Street Journal
6 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
San Francisco Has Embraced a New Tool to Clear Homeless Camps
Last year, the U.S. Supreme Court granted cities more power to penalize people for sleeping outside, handing city leaders a new tool with which to clear homeless people from the streets. Since then, San Francisco has been among the most aggressive in wielding it.
