Swinney apology to Gypsy Travellers ‘significant milestone', campaigner says
John Swinney made the formal apology at Holyrood on Thursday over 'unfair and unjust policies' that caused 'trauma' in what was known as the 'tinker experiment'.
Between 1940 and 1980, the so-called experiment – supported by councils and the UK Government – attempted to strip away the nomadic lifestyle of Gypsy Travellers, providing rudimentary and often cramped huts for people to live in.
A report published by the Scottish Government stated that 'the context within which the TE (tinker experiment) occurred is best understood as cultural genocide'.
Ms McPhee, whose family was among those settled in Pitlochry on the former Bobbin Mill site, had grown up in a prefabricated Second World War-style Nissen hut which had no electricity and used candles for light.
She welcomed the First Minister's apology, but said more needed to be done to stop the discrimination that her community continues to face.
First Minister @JohnSwinney has apologised in @ScotParl for historical policies affecting Gypsy/Traveller communities, acknowledging they were unacceptable and caused enduring harm.
More information here: https://t.co/hG5NqF1Br8 pic.twitter.com/B84NTjpmPn
— Scot Gov Fairer (@ScotGovFairer) June 25, 2025
She told the PA news agency: 'It's a milestone that we have reached in our long, long campaign, with no resources and just two or three generals and few food soldiers, really, because most people want to hide.
'I think the fact we managed to achieve that apology from the Government is a significant milestone.
'We're hopeful that discussions shall move forward, and perhaps something may be done about the general level of racism which we suffer, particularly in relation to public bodies.'
Ms McPhee said the apology could have been 'more robust' and expressed disappointment that Mr Swinney did not label the Tinker Experiment as 'cultural genocide', the description used in the report published by the Government.
'Cultural genocide is a crime against humanity,' she said. 'They did not name the offence. They did not say they took full responsibility of the offence.
'However, it's a positive step on the road towards the discussion around restitution and just satisfaction.'
Asked if she believed the Scottish Government should offer redress to affected families, she said: 'I absolutely believe it.
'If you'd been kept in degrading conditions as long as I have, with 16 health conditions and prevented from working with a joint-honours degrees and two post-graduates I think you might see some reason to have redress too.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
10 minutes ago
- Reuters
South Africa nears decision on steel tariffs amid import influx
GQEBERHA, South Africa, Aug 15 (Reuters) - South Africa's government will release the preliminary findings of its review of steel tariffs next week, moving a step closer to protecting the local industry from increased imports. The review was initiated by the International Trade Administration Commission (ITAC) in March, following a ministerial directive. South Africa's steel industry faces numerous challenges, including an influx of low-priced imports due to overcapacity, primarily in China. U.S. President Donald Trump's tariffs have also disrupted trade flows this year, while depressed demand and energy and logistics challenges have added to the problems in South Africa. "We've got a gazette coming next week. That gazette will include preliminary findings of the review," ITAC Chief Commissioner Ayabonga Cawe told Reuters on Thursday on the sidelines of an auto parts conference. The review comes as the government is locked in talks with ArcelorMittal South Africa (ACLJ.J), opens new tab, which has said it plans to close its loss-making long steel operations that are crucial for the local automotive, mining equipment and construction industries. Among its complaints is a flood of cheap imported steel from China. Cawe said ITAC had received around 150 responses for the review. More than 600 tariff codes are under review. ITAC needs to determine whether its various current steel duties are providing appropriate protection, whether more steel products need to be under import control and whether to declare an emergency to trigger broader safeguard measures.
The National
38 minutes ago
- The National
Nicola Sturgeon defends Kate Forbes over Fringe venue ban
The former SNP leader told reporters in Edinburgh that she disagreed with cancel culture. It comes amid a row over the Summerhall venue's decision not to have Forbes back at any future events following a fringe show organised by The Herald. The venue has reportedly suggested that John Swinney's deputy posed a safety and wellbeing risk to its staff over her views on trans rights. READ MORE: Bold plans to save Scottish BBC studios from 'fading into history' unveiled Forbes is a devout Christian and a member of the socially conservative Free Church of Scotland. She was criticised during her SNP leadership battle for her stance on gay marriage, abortion and trans rights. Sturgeon, who appointed Forbes as finance secretary while she was first minister, was asked whether she agreed with Summerhall's decision. (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire) 'I don't agree with cancel culture and I don't agree with that,' she said. She added that she took no responsibility for the venue's decision. Summerhall, which has received more £600,000 in government funding, previously held Herald Unspun live events with Swinney and Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar, the latter of whom has U-turned over his stance on gender self-ID. Forbes expressed disappointment at the venue and said she 'fervently' believes in freedom of speech. 'Any effort to cancel people, especially politicians, undermines democracy,' she said. 'Many people attended the Herald event and it is important that we could freely discuss and debate matters in a respectful manner. 'I respect and acknowledge the fact that, in a liberal democracy, there are people who will agree with me and others who will disagree with me. 'That is all the more reason to create events where the audience and journalists can question politicians openly, as the Herald did.' In a statement, the Summerhall venue said: 'This event was booked as a series of long-form interviews prior to the guest list being confirmed. 'Summerhall Arts primary concern is the safety and wellbeing of the artists and performers we work with, and going forward we will be developing robust, proactive inclusion and wellbeing policies that would prevent this oversight in our bookings process happening again.' Shona Robison, who succeeded Forbes as Finance Secretary, also defended her colleague, calling Summerhall's decision 'unwise and unnecessary'.
BreakingNews.ie
40 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Japan marks 80th anniversary of Second World War surrender
Japan is paying tribute to more than three million war dead as the country marks its surrender 80 years ago, ending the Second World War, as concern grows about rapidly fading memories of the tragedy of war and the lessons from the era of Japanese militarism. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba expressed 'remorse' over the war, which he called a mistake, restoring the word in a Japanese leader's August 15 address for the first time since 2013, when former premier Shinzo Abe shunned it. Advertisement Mr Ishiba, however, did not mention Japan's aggression across Asia, or apologise. 'We will never repeat the tragedy of the war. We will never go the wrong way,' Mr Ishiba said. 'Once again, we must deeply keep to our hearts the remorse and lesson from that war.' Prayers were offered at the Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo (Louise Delmotte/AP) In a national ceremony on Friday at Tokyo's Budokan hall, about 4,500 officials and bereaved families and their descendants from around the country observed a moment of silence at noon, the time when the then-emperor's surrender speech began on August 15 1945. Just a block away at Yasukuni Shrine, seen by Asian neighbours as a symbol of militarism, dozens of Japanese right-wing politicians and their supporters came to pray. Advertisement Mr Ishiba stayed away from Yasukuni and sent a religious ornament as a personal gesture instead of praying at the controversial shrine. But Shinjiro Koizumi, the agriculture minister considered as a top candidate to replace the beleaguered prime minister, prayed at the shrine. Mr Koizumi, the son of popular former prime minister Junichiro Koizumi whose Yasukuni visit as a serving leader in 2001 outraged China, is a regular at the shrine. Right-wing politicians, including former economic security ministers Sanae Takaichi and Takayuki Kobayashi, as well as governing Liberal Democratic Party heavyweight Koichi Hagiuda, also visited the shrine Friday. Advertisement Visitors release doves at the Yasukuni Shrine on Friday (Louise Delmotte/AP) The shrine honours convicted war criminals, among about two and a half million war dead. Victims of Japanese aggression, especially China and the Koreas, see visits to the shrine as a lack of remorse about Japan's wartime past. Japanese emperors have stopped visiting the Yasukuni site since the enshrinement of top war criminals there in 1978. Emperor Naruhito, in his address at the Budokan memorial on Friday, expressed his hope that the ravages of war will never be repeated while 'reflecting on our past and bearing in mind the feelings of deep remorse'. The emperor reiterated the importance of telling the war's tragic history and the ordeals faced during and after the war to younger generations as 'we continue to seek the peace and happiness of the people in the future'. Advertisement As part of the 80th anniversary remembrance, he has travelled to Iwo Jima, Okinawa and Hiroshima, and is expected to visit Nagasaki with his daughter, Princess Aiko, in September. Hajime Eda, whose father died on his way home from Korea when his ship was hit by a mine, said he will never forget his father and others who never made it home. In his speech representing the bereaved families, Mr Eda said it is Japan's responsibility to share the lesson – the emptiness of the conflict, the difficulty of reconstruction and the preciousness of peace. There was some hope at the ceremony, with a number of teenagers participating after learning about their great-grandfathers who died in the battlefields. Advertisement Among them, Ami Tashiro, 15, a high school student from Hiroshima, said she joined a memorial marking the end of the battle on Iwo Jima in April after reading a letter her great-grandfather sent from the island. She also hopes to join in the search for his remains. As the population of wartime generations rapidly decline, Japan faces serious questions on how it should pass on the wartime history to the next generation, as the country has already faced revisionist pushbacks under Mr Abe and his supporters in the 2010s. Since 2013, Japanese prime ministers stopped apologising to Asian victims, under the precedent set by Mr Abe. Some politician' denial of Japan's military role in massive civilian deaths on Okinawa or the Nanking Massacre have stirred controversy. In an editorial on Friday, the Mainichi newspaper noted that Japan's pacifist principle was mostly about staying out of global conflict, rather than thinking how to make peace, and called for the country to work together with Asian neighbours as equal partners. 'It's time to show a vision toward 'a world without war' based on the lesson from its own history,' the Mainichi said.
