All the signs Love Island's Harrison will couple up with Toni instead of Malisha following new twist

Cosmopolitan

5 hours ago

Love Island dropped another twist last night (Tuesday 17th June), as Toni and Malisha learned that they were at risk of being dumped from the villa and who stayed would be decided by new bombshell Harrison.
Off the girlies went to enjoy their separate dates with the 24-year-old professional footballer.
Malisha was up first and it looked like it was a done deal, as she admitted that he was just her type and they flirted over a glass of bubbly. They made eye contact and Malisha filled him on her time in the villa so far, admitting that the other boys in the Love Island 2025 cast were "boring" and she'd laughed so much on their short date.
But, as soon as Toni arrived for her date, it was pretty clear that Harrison would be bringing her back to the villa later that night.
Viewers will have to wait until Wednesday night's episode (18th June) to see who he chooses, but I'll eat my hat if it isn't Toni tbh.
Here's all the signs he's definitely returning to the villa with Toni...
Perhaps the biggest sign that Harrison and Toni have to couple up is the fact that they both lived in the same place.
What are the chances of Toni, an American, flying all the way to the UK for Love Island to meet someone who lives in the same place she went to college.
During the date, Toni asked Harrison if he'd ever been to America and he revealed that he actually plays football (or soccer for the Americans) there. Toni then asked whereabouts and he revealed that he lives in Boca Raton, Florida.
Stunned, Toni said that she actually went to college there and only moved two years ago.
"It was my dream... it was like the best years of my life," she smiled.
Harrison then said that he needs an American tour guide, to which she replied: "I've got you."
Asked why he should pick her, she smiled: "You said you needed a tour guide, let me be that girl."
While Harrison got on well with both girls, there was just something different about his date with Toni.
"I don't know if I'm happy because I'm going into the villa or because I'm sat here with you," he told Toni immediately after meeting her.
It was clear they were both attracted to one another, with Harrison complimenting her outfit and telling Toni she looked "pretty" multiple times.
And things got a little "sexual" (to quote Harrison), after he told her that her dressed matched the strawberries. She then told him to "have one" and he said "you first", before feeding her.
"I feel like that was mad sexual," he joked afterwards.
Towards the end of their date, Toni gushed that "the signs are there... they're kind of written in the stars."
Prior to entering the villa, Harrison revealed that he has a thing for American girls.
"I do really like American girls. Their personality is slightly different, in general they're more confident and go for what they want. But I like a challenge, I like a bit of the chase," he said.
Could Toni be his American girl? We think so!
New episodes of Love Island air on weekdays and Sundays