Denis Donaldson's family urge inquiry into killing and ‘who may have pulled the strings'
Denis Donaldson
in Glenties, Co Donegal, in 2006, are 'simply not working' and a statutory inquiry is needed, a spokesman for the family has said.
The Donaldsons want a cross-Border process that would identify not just 'who pulled the trigger' but also 'who may have pulled the strings,' said family solicitor Enda McGarrity.
Donaldson was a former IRA member who worked in the Sinn Féin Stormont offices. He was shot dead in April 2006 after public disclosure in December 2005 that he had been an informer for 20 years for MI5 and the Police Service of Northern Ireland Special Branch.
Former Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams last week won a defamation case against the BBC arising from a programme where an anonymous man was quoted as saying the IRA murdered Donaldson and that Mr Adams would have sanctioned the killing, a claim Mr Adams denied.
READ MORE
The killing occurred nine months after the IRA issued a public statement saying it had instructed its members to cease violent activity and henceforth only engage in peaceful political activity.
The Garda investigation into Donaldson's death is ongoing. A coroner's inquest has been adjourned repeatedly because of the ongoing inquiry.
The family wants a statutory inquiry with a cross-Border element because they are concerned about not just who killed Donaldson but also why he was not better protected after it had become known he was an informer, said Mr McGarrity.
'At present, as far as the family are aware, the Garda are focused on the individual or individuals who pulled the trigger and not the broader circumstances around who may have pulled the strings. And that is an issue that is inextricably linked to the murder of Denis Donaldson,' he said.
The family is concerned about how Donaldson came to be exposed as an agent and the 'divergence' in what happened to him thereafter, when compared with other well-known state agents, he said.
'The family would say Denis Donaldson was thrown to the wolves while Stakeknife was shepherded away,' said Mr McGarrity, referring to the late Fred Scappaticci, a senior IRA member who was moved to Britain after he was exposed as an informer.
'The precise format of how the death and circumstances surrounding the death of Denis Donaldson are to be investigated is up for debate and discussion. What the family are saying is that the current status quo, the Garda investigation and the coroner's inquest, are simply not working,' he said.
The State, he said, has a statutory duty to investigate the death and suggested that a statutory inquiry in this jurisdiction could have cross-Border engagement to 'fill any holes' in terms of investigating the circumstances surrounding the murder.
Mr McGarrity said the family considers a claim of responsibility made by the so-called Real IRA three years after the murder to be opportunistic and unreliable, and that they had an open mind as to who carried out the murder.
Donaldson admitted to Sinn Féin in 2005 that he had been acting as an informer after charges against him and several others for having material that could be of use to terrorists were dropped. The charges arose from a police inquiry into intelligence gathering in Belfast by the IRA.
The Garda Press Office, in a statement, said their investigation into the murder was ongoing and asked that anyone with information get in contact with the station in Glenties, or with any Garda station.
In a statement, the Department of Justice said: 'Inquiries and/or investigations related to the death of Mr Donaldson have been undertaken both in this jurisdiction and in Northern Ireland.
'With regard to the criminal investigation, the Garda authorities are conducting an ongoing investigation into the killing of Mr Donaldson. Extensive inquiries have been carried out in this regard. That investigation is open and active. The inquest into the death currently stands adjourned to ensure that the criminal proceedings are not compromised by the conduct of an inquest.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Intel warned senior Government figures about high energy costs and planning issues
Tech giant Intel has warned a series of senior Government figures about high energy costs and planning issues threatening Ireland's competitiveness. Semiconductor chip manufacturer Intel is a big employer in Ireland with almost 5,000 staff here and its lobbying on these issues is shown in Government records released under the Freedom of Information Act. Maintaining Ireland's attractiveness to multinational companies is a priority for the Coalition amid the economic uncertainty over last week's trade deal with a 15 per cent tariff imposed on EU goods entering the US. The records include a note of a May 1st meeting between Intel representatives and Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke . READ MORE The document says Intel referenced a recent call between chief executive Lip-Bu Tan and Taoiseach Micheál Martin 'where the energy cost issue was discussed' and 'noted the need for Ireland to take demonstrable actions on this issue'. The Government side said forthcoming plans on competitiveness and large energy users 'would chart a pathway forward on this crucial issue'. Intel also raised issues with Ireland's planning permission regime and how 'unpredictability was a major business-planning obstacle'. The company was told by Mr Burke and an official that legislative changes and investment in resourcing An Coimisiún Pleanála 'should aid on that matter'. Mr Tan's call with the Taoiseach took place on April 14th. Intel described it as an 'introductory meeting' in a Register of Lobbying return, which set out how the company's boss 'reaffirmed Intel's steadfast commitment to Ireland' during the conversation. Separate records show Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers took a tour of Intel's Leixlip campus on the same day. 'Intel highlighted a number of areas that have proved challenging when justifying further investment,' a departmental note said, including the 'complexity and length of the planning process' and the 'comparatively high cost of electricity'. Other records show an Intel representative wrote to then-minister for public expenditure Paschal Donohoe in December telling him Ireland's 'competitiveness is currently under threat, particularly in regard to the cost of electricity'. Intel, which has lost market share in recent years, is undergoing a major restructuring internationally and there have been reports that it plans to cut up to 20 per cent of its global workforce. Some 195 mandatory redundancies are expected at Intel's Irish operations Ireland this autumn. The Irish Times understands these expected job losses are linked to Intel's overall restructuring internationally, and not the issues around energy costs and planning it raised with the Government. An Intel statement welcomed the Government's commitment to publishing a competitiveness action plan. 'To sustain growth and remain competitive, it is crucial to prioritise competitiveness, streamline the planning process, and focus on developing long-term sustainable and competitive energy solutions,' it said. 'We appreciate the meaningful steps the Government has taken to address these challenges.' A Department of Enterprise statement said work on the competitiveness action plan has been accelerated and it will be published in the coming weeks. 'Ireland holds a strong global competitive position, currently ranked seventh worldwide,' it said, adding 'we cannot afford complacency.' It also said Silicon Island, the Government's semiconductor strategy 'is a clear signal of Government support for a sector that is economically and strategically vital'. The department said energy prices 'have reduced from their peak in late 2023' but 'they remain too high' and it set out measures being taken to address this. A national energy affordability taskforce has been established 'to identify, assess and implement measures that will enhance energy affordability for households and businesses'. The statement said the Government has 'prioritised implementation' of the Planning and Development Act, which will 'bring greater consistency, clarity and certainty to the planning system'.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, August 4th: On a dangerous time to be a woman, landlords and rent, and President Trump's favour
Sir, – Three times over the past week I have watched news reports on women survivors of physical, sexual, emotional and psychological violence perpetrated by trusted males, some of them close family members. I heard sisters Paula Fay and Catherine Wrightstone describe the lifelong sentence of emotional pain, broken trust, and struggle to reclaim self-worth that their brother inflicted upon them. I heard Niamh Herbert talk about the feeling of giving a piece of herself away on every step of her path to justice. I heard Nikita Hand say that the legal case has retraumatised her over and over again. And I listened as each one of these brave women encouraged others who have experienced similar abuse to speak out, reminding them that they have strength within, that their voice matters and that justice can eventually prevail. READ MORE All this, as the horrific news about the killing of Vanessa Whyte and her two children unfolded over the week. At what stage do we call a halt to the head-shaking, the hand-wringing, the repeated expressions of shock and bewilderment and acknowledge the fact that Ireland is not a safe place to be female? Why are we not collectively howling from the rafters at the violence, the depravity, the pervasive level of threat that is endemic in our society today? How many more women must be traumatised, brutalised or even die, how many more candlelit vigils take place before we take educational and legislative steps to ensure that this stops now? To position ourselves in the world as a liberal democratic state, and to uphold the values of such, presumes a basic equity among citizens. Have we fallen at this first step? – Yours, etc, CAROLANNE HENRY, Churchtown, Dublin 14. Landlords and rental income Sir, – If the article written by Dr Lorcan Sirr was an essay for one of his own economic courses with the title 'What do landlords actually earn?' I think he'd get a D at best. It's a scattergun attack on landlords premised by the claim that we're all part of a secret club milking it. The only actual earnings quoted are general income which include the salary from a job or business. I'm one of the small landlords he's trying to vilify. Not having the luxury of a defined benefit pension from a taxpayer's funded job, the properties are my pension. When the ECB increased rates recently the repayments on one property increased from €1,200 a month to €1,650, while because of rent controls my rent was stuck at €1,100. And yes those figures are correct, a pre-2008 property. There are plenty of landlords who aren't creaming it. – Yours, etc, CHARLES McLAUGHLIN, Portobello, Dublin 8. Is Trump doing us a favour? Sir, – The Department of Finance feels that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created over the next five years as a result of the US tariffs as these tariffs will result in a reduction of economic activity of roughly 1.5 per cent (' US tariffs will mean 70,000 fewer jobs created in Irish economy, Department of Finance warns ,' August 1st). However, we have been informed that our economy is operating at full employment (full employment equates with 4 per cent unemployment), our population has increased by 20 per cent over the past five years resulting in an acute shortage of housing, huge waiting lists for medical treatment, a shortage of school places and lastly our infrastructure is incapable of catering for our expanding population. So perhaps Trump has come to our rescue after all? – Yours, etc, JO TRESTON, Blackrock, Co Dublin. Sir, – The report that Department of Finance officials warned that up to 70,000 fewer jobs will be created in the next five years due to US tariffs should not be a cause for concern. The solution can be found by copying the action of president Trump last Friday when the Bureau of Labour Statistics revealed higher unemployment numbers. He simply sacked the commissioner, to be replaced by someone who will alter the figures in his favour! – Yours, etc, GERARD CLARKE, Dundrum, Dublin. Policing the traffic and gardaí Sir, – Regarding 'S ome frontline gardaí expressed lack of interest in doing their jobs, review finds ,' (August, 1st). Yesterday, I was almost knocked to the ground by a passing scooter on the pedestrianised South King Street, close to Grafton Street. I then noticed the scooter turning left down Grafton Street. As I approached the top of Grafton Street, I noticed two gardaí on duty, observing the throngs of people down along Grafton Street. I brought the matter of the scooter to their attention. Yes, they had seen it go down Grafton Street, and further, scooters are going up and down the street all day. Surprised at this ready acceptance of this situation, there was more to follow; 'And we can't do anything about it,' they said. Startled by this, I reminded them that what they were observing was an act of law-breaking. I got the same answer about not being able to do anything to stop it. In frustration, I terminated the conversation, leaving them to continue their important job of observing the laws of the land being blatantly ignored in front of their eyes. – Yours, etc, EAMON O'FLYNN, Merrion Road, Dublin 4. Bargain cycling lanes Sir, – Rita O Brien (Letters, July 31st) claims that the ¤45 million spent on the Dundrum to Dún Laoghaire cycle lane is a bargain since the users will not be expected to pay a cent in road tax, insurance or licensing. By this reasoning, will all cyclists, pedestrians and EV drivers be exempt from any share in the massive fine coming our way due to massively exceeding our carbon budgets? – Yours, etc, COLETTE McNAMEE, Dublin 19. Sir, – Roads in Ireland are funded by the exchequer. Most taxes in the State are paid into the exchequer (income, VAT, etc). There is no 'road tax', although there is a 'motor tax' levied on most motorised vehicles. These funds also go to the exchequer. Since almost everyone pays some tax, everyone contributes to the cost of road construction (including cycle lanes) even if they don't drive or cycle. Introducing requirements such as motor tax, licensing, etc, for cyclists would dramatically reduce the rate of cycling, with the attendant negative effects on traffic congestion, public health, climate change, traffic congestion and so on. Whether or not the ¤45 million cost represents value for money is a different issue. – Yours, etc, CONALL DORAN, Co Sligo. Sir, – With reference to Rita O'Brien's letter, I wish to inform your correspondent that as a motorist I do not pay a cent in road tax. I do however pay motor tax, based on the CO2 emissions of my car, to offset the environmental impact of my car. As for insurance, that's paid to a private company that has nothing to do with the provision of transport infrastructure. Let's make cycling as difficult as possible to stop the indignity of motorists sitting in a traffic jam having to watch cyclists sail by. – Yours, etc, DECLAN RYAN, Blackhorse Avenue, Dublin 7. A generous offer Sir, –Frank McNally, Irishman's Diary (August 1st), writes about his annual jaunt to Ballybrit, bemoaning the lack of breakfast at his digs. I hereby offer him a bed with the full Irish for 2026 on condition he doesn't write about it! – Yours, etc, ANNE MARIE KENNEDY, Craughwell, Co Galway. Asylum and statistics Sir, – Nick Henderson of the Irish Refugee Council, in rebutting Senator Michael McDowell's suggestion that many asylum applicants are economic migrants, states that 'The data does not support this claim,' (Letters, July 31st). The only statistic he provides is that 60 per cent of asylum applications this year have been refused. He subjectively concludes that these were refused on technicalities such as insufficient paperwork, but that they were genuine asylum seekers. He then partly attributes blame for the IPA accommodation crisis to McDowell himself, as he did nothing about it during his five years as minister for justice. McDowell ceased in that role 18 years ago. I know we ideally want far-sighted politicians, but expecting clairvoyance is not realistic. – Yours, etc, DAVE SLATER, Kilkea, Co Kildare. Not so bonny photograph Sir, – I am in accord with Finn McRedmond's opinions in her Bonnie Blue article – apart perhaps from this being the best time to be alive (' Bonnie Blue: Why the free-sex 'content creator' is nauseating and wrong ,' July 31st) But why on earth is the article illustrated with a large, unavoidable and rather silly picture of Miss Blue? The Irish Times isn't social media and should avoid the 'Oh you are awful, tell me more' redtop vibe. Why publicise this person's image? Please, Irish Times remember your journalistic standards! – Yours, etc, MAIRIDE WOODS, Dublin 13. Filler thriller Sir, – I always smile when I turn over to the Letters page and see a smattering of short ones or 'fillers' as I like to call them. You just can't beat an eclectic and diverse mix of opinions. – Yours, etc, DEE DELANY, Raheny, Dublin 5. Germ supporter Sir, – Recent correspondence on our immune system and germs (Letters, July 31st and August 1st) reminded me of an expression often used by my late mother. When, as children, my brothers and I would often arrive home from an evening exploring in the fields or scrambling through the nearby woods stained from top to toe with soil and any other detritus that came our way and she would smile saying it was just 'clean dirt'. Looking back it's clear she knew the importance of beneficial bacteria and of building a robust immune system. Her philosophy has stood me in good stead to this day. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater in an obsessive desire to cleanse our environment of all germs, be they good or bad. – Yours, etc, PAT MULLEN, Kilkerley, Co Louth.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Moves to revive referendum on joining EU patent court as business groups contacted on timing
There have been tentative moves to revive the delayed referendum on Ireland's participation in the European Union's Unified Patent Court (UPC), with the Government seeking views of business groups on the timing of a rescheduled vote. The referendum on Ireland joining the 18 other EU member states that have signed up to the UPC system was originally pencilled in for June 2024 on the same day as the local and European elections. However, the holding of the UPC referendum was thrown into doubt amid the fallout from the defeat of the family and care referendums three months earlier. Soon afterwards the then-government announced it would be deferring the vote. Peter Burke , then minister for enterprise, said at the time: 'While the government continues to believe that joining the UPC is essential and that the referendum should be pursued, it is clear to me that more time is needed for public discourse and engagement on the matter to help inform the debate.' READ MORE The UPC is designed to provide a one-stop shop court for litigation on patents. The court's decisions will be binding on participating EU member states. Ireland joining in the UPC has been long called for by business groups and sectors such as the pharmaceutical industry. The Department of Enterprise has contacted business organisations and government departments about the referendum. Records released under the Freedom of Information Act include a letter from senior Department of Enterprise official John Newham to the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland (AmCham). The March 28th letter set out how the legislation on the UPC referendum was pending committee and final stages in the Seanad. Mr Newham, the assistant secretary general, wrote that 'once the legislative process has been concluded an order setting a date for the referendum will issue'. He wrote that the timing of any further advancement of the Bill would be subject to a decision by Government and it would decide a referendum date 'in due course'. He noted the last government 'had concluded that a broader public conversation' on the UPC 'was essential before a referendum was held' and he sought feedback 'in order to assess if sufficient engagement is being held on the matter'. Mr Newham asked for information on 'any initiatives undertaken or planned to assist public understanding of this critical issue'. He also sought 'views on the appropriate timing of a referendum'. Enterprise Ireland , IDA Ireland and Research Ireland were among government agencies contacted by the department as it sought feedback on public awareness of the UPC referendum. The Department of Enterprise confirmed that other organisations contacted included Chambers Ireland , Ibec , the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and BioPharmaChem Ireland, all of which, like AmCham sent responses. AmCham, which represents US companies in Ireland, responded on April 30th, saying: 'It is of the utmost importance that an informed discussion occurs to generate public engagement with the topic.' It said it would work with its members to advance discussion and consideration of the UPC. AmCham said a member survey from 2024 showed that 41 per cent of respondents supported Ireland joining the UPC and 58 per cent were neutral on the matter. The organisation said it would be holding a webinar 'outlining the impact for Ireland, with key expert and member perspectives' and it would also be developing a fact sheet on the UPC for dissemination among members. In response to queries AmCham told The Irish Times: 'While we continue to work with members on this topic, a webinar has not taken place.' It said that the timing of the referendum was 'a matter for Government'. A Department of Enterprise statement said: 'While the Government remains committed to holding the referendum, the timing remains under consideration at this juncture.'
