Revealed: Edinburgh engulfed by 'frightening' £1.7bn sea of debt
The Herald can reveal that the debt incurred by the City of Edinburgh Council has risen by over £300m since before the pandemic and now exceeds what was actually spent on city services in 2023/24 by nearly half a billion pounds.
Concerns about how the capital will run vital services have surfaced as the council admits in one recent analysis that "radical change" is needed "to achieve organisational financial sustainability".
Financial papers show that its overall debt, the vast bulk of which is short-term and long-term borrowing has soared by £309.7m (21.8%) since the pre-pandemic year of 2018/29 to stand at £1.732bn.
And internal council predictions indicate that end of year debt mountain could soar as high as £2.877bn in 2029/30.
The latest level of debt is £450m more than the £1.279bn that the city was spending in 2023/24 on services, which ranges from the provision of education, social work and waste management to the provision and maintenance of housing, roads, libraries and parks.
The escalating debt in Glasgow, Scotland's biggest city serving over 620,000 people to Edinburgh's 510,000, by contrast, was £242m lower than the £1.85bn it had to spend on services.
And the interest payments on borrowing and loans by the Edinburgh council over the six years since the pre-pandemic year of 2018/19 amount to £553m - enough to provide over 2600 settled affordable homes for the homeless who are left to live in temporary accommodation in the capital's housing emergency declared in November 2023.
Edinburgh is preparing to implement a tourist taxThat servicing of debt has shot up by £23.4m (30%) in recent years from £76.773m in 2021/22 to £100.212m in 2023/24.
The issues have arisen while the council has seen the grant it gets from the Scottish Government rise from £363.757m before the Covid pandemic in 2018/19 to £552.075m in 2023/24.
It comes as the minority Labour administration controversially plans to implement a 5% tourist tax on overnight accommodation, capped at seven nights from July, next year. The levy is expected to generate up to £50m annually.
Critics have raised concerns about its potential impact on affordability, visitor numbers, and the hospitality sector as the tax will affect hotels, bed and breakfasts, self-catering accommodation and properties listed on platforms like Airbnb.
READ MORE:
And the council has said it believes that tourist tax will help bankroll its world-famous Hogmanay celebrations.
It says it has already suffered a decade of "chronic underfunding" which has necessitated £400 million in savings over ten years - which amounts to around a third of what it was spending on services in 2023/24.
Edinburgh-born Alba Party leader and former Scottish justice secretary Kenny MacAskill said the state of Edinburgh's finances was "both staggering and frightening".
Kenny MacAskill"Scotland's capital city is in danger of drowning in a sea of debt. A visitor levy won't cover it and, in any event, requires to be used for tourist related purposes to justify it.
"Nor will it address the homelessness problem that's now endemic and hurting individuals, families and the city. The council administration needs to come clean on the extent of the problem and the Scottish Government needs to assist not stand idly by. Citizens are entitled to no less."
The council's own overview of its financial state states that it predicted a funding gap of over £94.2m by 2029/30.
And it said there was "therefore a risk that the council is unable to perform financial planning; deliver an annual balanced budget, manage cash flows; and confirm the ongoing adequacy of its reserves, meaning that it is unable to continue to deliver services and implement change in line with strategic objectives...and/or be at risk of an adverse external audit opinion".
And their auditors in preparing an analysis of the council's financial performance in 2024/25 in February said that financial sustainability "remains a risk" because of the huge funding gap by 2029/30 alone with associated "challenges" including "pressures for frontline services".
But a longer term council projection has revealed a darker picture which predicts an average funding black hole of over £22m each year till 2034/34. That is based on a conservative assumption that there would be a 3% annual increase in staffing and other costs and 'flat cash' levels of grant funding settlement from government.
And the study warns that this "reinforces the need for radical change, prioritisation and adoption of a prevention-led operating model".
Internal service risk assessments show that with the city in the midst of a homelessness emergency, the housing pressures are almost certainly critical with organisational financial sustainability and financial control seen as "likely to be critical".
But new end of year debt estimates show that it is expected to escalate to £2.4bn in 2026/27 and 2.877bn in 2029/30.
(Image: Damian Shields) Its annual Treasury Management Strategy approved in March 2024, noted that the council had reached the limit in resources for funding for major capital projects by dipping into short-term investments and "requires to undertake significant external borrowing".
The council has admitted to its auditors that the levels of borrowing "will bring significant financing risks".
Local government finance scrutineers, the Accounts Commission has told the council: "We do not underestimate the major infrastructure challenges facing Edinburgh, in particular around housing and the school estate, but such levels of borrowing bring risks that could impact future financial sustainability."
According to council sources, it has borrowed £290m during the 2024/25 financial year alone- with £170m going toward the management of its social housing stock.
That came before the council at the end of April suspended its housing policy amidst a homelessness emergency.
The unprecedented move saw all available council-owned housing stock immediately redirected toward people experiencing homelessness until at least June 13, 2025.
It was part of Edinburgh's plan to get its worsening housing crisis under control, and it comes after Shelter Scotland raised concerns in 2024 over the council 'not showing the desire' to tackle legal breaches in the right to have a roof over your head.
A council housing study showed that the council has failed to accommodate people on 3,263 occasions in the past year – a 115% rise from 2023/24.
And as of 31 March 2025 there were 970 homeless households in what it admits is unsuitable temporary accommodation. It had approved a programme to purchase up to 270 properties for use as suitable temporary accommodation.
The council is now planning to 'build, build, build', but it is at a price.
Future projects include the building of 847 new homes, including 387 affordable, energy efficient homes, as part of a Granton area regeneration project.
With capital investment of £220.797m planned for 2025/26, it has meant that the council needs to borrow £127.667m. That loan alone over a 30-year period will incur interest of £99.893m, The Herald has learnt.
The council's own auditors have already highlighted to them that the scale of the shorter-term budget gap to 2028/29 will mean the council would find it "increasingly difficult to achieve financial balance in future years".
"Members will need to make difficult decisions about spending priorities, service levels and income generation whilst ensuring the results of public consultation exercises are taken into account," they said.
Auditors highlighted a risk that "operating in a challenging financial context without medium-term financial planning can compromise financial resilience and sustainability."
Princes Street (Image: Colin Mearns) The council's latest financial planning says that while it has a "strong track record of balancing our budget, the funding and income we receive has increasingly been insufficient to meet the rising cost and demand for services, such as homelessness and social care costs".
The council's own risk assessments for the final quarter of 2025 shows that housing pressures are almost certainly critical with organisational financial sustainability and financial control "likely to be critical".
A February overview from Richard Lloyd-Bithell, a finance and procurement director said that the council does not have medium term financial plans "consistent with sustainable service plans".
He said: "This will result in sustainable aspirations including transformation being unobtainable."
Edinburgh set ambitious targets and strategies for sustainable development, including achieving net zero emissions by 2030 and a climate-ready future. The City Plan 2030 guides future development, emphasizing green spaces, climate action, and sustainable practices. This plan aims to create sustainable neighbourhoods, reduce carbon emissions, and protect and enhance the city's natural spaces.
Its transformation strategy has a vision of providing an "exceptional city centre that is for all, a place for people to live, work, visit and play".
"Finance must support services to create sustainable plans and proposals to deliver services within an affordable financial envelope," said Mr Lloyd-Bithell.
"Finance must provide reports and effective challenge to hold service managers to account to ensure services do not overspend their agreed budgets."
The Liberal Democrats' Edinburgh council group leader Ed Thornley said the state of the city finances "show there is a titanic gulf between what the SNP have provided and what councils say they actually need to maintain basic local functions".
Ed Thornley (Image: Lib Dems) He said: "Local authorities have had a raw deal from the SNP over many years and that has had a knock-on impact on the provision of vital local functions.
"The SNP have demanded councils do more with less. As a result, we have ended up with school cuts, bin strikes and shortages of elderly care packages.
"Local government deserves long-term central government funding deals which adequately meet its needs and provide locally delivered public services. That is what people rightly expect.'
The Scottish Government said individual local authorities are responsible for deciding the level of their affordable borrowing, having regard to the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy's Prudential Code, which has been given legislative backing.
They said that it was for each local authority to have "effective arrangements" in place to ensure that capital expenditure and investment plans are "affordable and proportionate and that all external borrowing and other long-term liabilities are within prudent and sustainable levels".
A Scottish Government spokesman said: 'In 2025-26, City of Edinburgh Council will receive over £1 billion to support day to day services, which equates to an extra £60 million or an additional 5.9% compared to 2024-25.
"Local authorities are required by law to ensure borrowing is affordable, prudent and sustainable. Regulations require a local authority to set an authorised limit for external debt."
Edinburgh council's finance and resource convener Mandy Watt accepted that savings were needed and more revenues were required and said: "While Edinburgh has a long track record of strong financial management and delivering a balanced budget year after year, the challenges are increasing."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
4 hours ago
- NBC News
How RFK Jr. is quickly changing U.S. health agencies
WASHINGTON — In just a few short months, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has begun to transform U.S. health policy: shrinking staff at health agencies, restructuring the focus of some regulators and researchers, changing Covid vaccine regulations and reshaping the mission of his department to focus more on alternative medicine. The directives are all part of the same issue set that drove a slice of health-conscious, left-leaning Americans to eventually vote for a Republican president whose favorite meal is from McDonald's, Trump and Kennedy catered to a type of voter who has grown distrustful of America's health care establishment — but possibly fomented a new type of distrust in federal health policy along the way. Bernadine Francis, a lifelong Democrat who backed Joe Biden for president in 2020 before supporting Donald Trump in 2024, told NBC News in an interview that she approves of Kennedy's efforts so far, despite his 'hands being tied' by entrenched forces in the administration and in Congress. 'From what I have seen so far with what RFK has been trying to do,' she said, 'I am really, really proud of what he's doing.' Francis is among the voters who left the Democratic Party and voted for Trump because 'nothing else mattered' apart from public health, which they — like Kennedy — felt was going in the wrong direction. Concerns about chemicals in food and toxins in the environment, long championed by Democrats, has become a galvanizing issue to a key portion of Trump's Republican Party, complete with an oversaturation of information that in some cases hasn't been proven. It's wrapped up, as well, in concerns about the Covid vaccine, which was accelerated under Trump, administered under Biden and weaponized by anti-vaccine activists like Kennedy amid lockdowns and firings in the wake of the devastating pandemic. 'We knew in order to get RFK in there so he can help with the situation that we have in the health industry, we knew we had to do this,' said Francis, a retired Washington, D.C., public school administrator, who said she left her 'beloved' career because she had refused the vaccine. 'It seemed to me, as soon as [Biden] became president, the vaccine was mandated, and that was when I lost all hope in the Democrats,' Francis told NBC News, referring to vaccination mandates put in place by the Biden administration for a large portion of the federal workforce during the height of the pandemic. There are not currently any federal Covid vaccine mandates. There have been 1,228,393 confirmed Covid deaths in the United States since the start of the pandemic, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. How RFK Jr.'s picks are changing public health agencies Dr. Marty Makary, Kennedy's hand-picked commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration and a John Hopkins scientist and researcher, told NBC News in an interview that he wants to transform the agency, which he said faced 'corruption' over influence from the pharmaceutical and food industries. 'I mean, you look at the food pyramid, it was not based on what's best for you, it was based on what companies wanted you to buy,' he said, referring to the 1992 and later iterations of official government nutritional guidance. He said there would be 'entirely new nutrition guidance' released later this year, as soon as this summer. He praised the FDA's mission of research and regulation, saying the agency is 'incredibly well-oiled, and we've got the trains running on time.' He also highlighted the 75-page 'Make America Healthy Again' commission report — which focused on ultraprocessed foods and toxins in the environment — as having set 'the agenda for research' at the FDA, HHS and agencies overseeing social safety net programs such as Medicare and food stamps moving forward. (The MAHA report initially cited some studies that didn't exist, a mistake that Kennedy adviser Calley Means said was a 'great disservice' to their mission.) 'I think there's a lot we're going to learn. For example, the microbiome, which gets attention in the MAHA report, needs to be on the map. We don't even talk about it in our medical circles,' Makary said. 'The microbiome, food is medicine, the immune response that happens when chemicals that don't appear in nature go down our GI tract.' Pressed on other areas of the administration, like the Environmental Protection Agency, making decisions that run counter to the pro-regulatory ideas presented in the MAHA report, Makary said he can 'only comment on the FDA' where they are 'committed to Secretary Kennedy's vision.' But Kennedy's public health agenda goes beyond looking at the food supply and chemicals. Recently, Kennedy said in a video posted on X last month that the Covid vaccine is no longer recommended for healthy children and pregnant women, a change in CDC guidance that skipped the normal public review period. Days later, after critics questioned the decision and raised concerns over a lack of public data behind the move, the administration updated its guidance again, urging parents to consult with their doctors instead. Pressed about the confusion and whether Americans are now trading one side of public distrust in the health system for another, Makary defended Kennedy, who has been criticized for spreading misinformation. 'My experience with Secretary Robert F. Kennedy is that he listens. He listens to myself, he listens to Jay Bhattacharya, listens to Dr. Mehmet Oz, he listens to a host of scientists that are giving him guidance,' Makary argued, referring to the director of the National Institutes of Health and the administrator for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, respectively. 'So he may have big questions, but the questions he's asking are the questions most Americans are asking.' The intersection of medicine and healthy lifestyle choices Dr. Dawn Mussallem, a breast cancer oncologist and integrative medicine doctor — a physician who combines conventional treatments with research-based alternative therapies — has tried to help her patients wade through medical misinformation they encounter online and in their social circles. Mussallem has an incredible story of personal survival: While in medical school, she was diagnosed with Stage IV cancer and, after conventional therapies like chemo saved her life, was diagnosed with heart failure. After undergoing a heart transplant, Mussallem ran a 26-mile marathon just one year later. 'I learned a lot in medical school, but nothing compared to what I learned being a patient,' said Mussallem, who dedicates, on average, 90 minutes each in one-on-one sessions with her patients. 'This is not about any one political choice. But we know lifestyle matters.' For example, a new study from the American Society of Clinical Oncology that finds eating food that lowers inflammation in the body may help people with advanced colon cancer survive longer. Mussallem's mission, along with her colleagues, is to elevate the modern medicine that saved her life, as well as encouraging her patients to live healthy lifestyles, including regular exercise, minimally processed foods, less screen time, more social connection and better sleep. But politics do get in the way for millions of Americans who are inundated daily with social media influencers and 'nonmedical experts,' as Mussallem puts it, who stoke fear in her patients. 'Patients come in with all these questions, fears,' she said. 'I've heard this many times from patients, that their nervous system is affected by what they're seeing happening in government.' Mussallem acknowledges that 'a lot of individuals out there' have questioned traditional medicine. For her, it isn't one or the other — it's both. 'We have to trust the conventional medicine,' she said. 'With the conventional care that marches right alongside more of an integrative modality to look at the root causes of disease, as well as to help to optimize with lifestyle, is where we need to be.'
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
FBI director Kash Patel reveals bombshell breakthrough that'll have Anthony Fauci trembling: 'We're on to him'
The Trump administration has allegedly 'found' the cell phone Dr Anthony Fauci used during the Covid pandemic, the president's intelligence head revealed. FBI director Kash Patel revealed on the latest episode of the Joe Rogan Experience that he and leaders like Senator Rand Paul have been on the hunt for any devices Fauci used while advising Americans during the pandemic. Patel said while Paul and health secretary Robert F Kennedy 'are doing a great job' finding the origins of Covid, the team had struggled for years to find Fauci's phone and other devices. But this week, the team 'had a great breakthrough.' Patel told Rogan the FBI had just found a phone Fauci used at the time, mere days before the podcast was filmed. It's unclear exactly when the phone was used and how they verified it belonged to Fauci. Patel did not specify how they seized it or what the team's 'multiple investigations' thus far on the origins of Covid have found. He also cautioned Americans 'shouldn't jump to the conclusion that everything's in there' and that incriminating data could have been deleted. However, he called the bombshell 'a victory for the American people' and said his team is immediately working to comb through any data on the device. Patel said: 'We found it, and at least we can tell the American people we've been looking because it is of public importance to figure out, did that guy lie? Did he intentionally mislead the world and cause countless deaths? 'We owe those answers to the American people, and the best evidence ever is always the people's evidence who created it. So now we're going to go and exploit those hard drives.' 'We did find it, we're not done, we're still looking and we're on the case.' Patel did not specify how his team got the old phone or how they verified it was Fauci's. Generally, a warrant is required to seize a cell phone, even for a government official. There are no publicly available warrants out against Fauci currently. Mounting evidence has suggested Covid may have originated in a lab in Wuhan, China, with some reports estimated '80 to 95 percent certainty.' The Chinese government has always denied the lab-leak theory and maintained Covid was the product of an animal spillover. American agencies like the FBI and CIA believe a lab leak is the most likely possibility. Patel did not say on the podcast what he thinks. Dr Richard Ebright, a professor of chemical biology at Rutgers University, previously told 'The main points are clear: All informed persons - without exception - knew by early 2020 that SARS-CoV-2 likely entered humans through a research-related incident in Wuhan. 'But most chose to lie or to stay silent.' Fauci has denied all accusations of Covid being 'covered up' or originating from a lab. Patel said: 'My mission has always been to put out the truth, whatever the consequences, whoever it's against.
Channel 4
5 hours ago
- Channel 4
Scottish Labour secures by-election win over SNP and Reform
Labour's been celebrating after winning a surprise victory over the SNP in a fiercely contested by-election. The result in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse will come as a relief for their Scottish leader, Anas Sarwar, who's hoping to become First Minister in the Scottish Parliament elections next year. It was also the first big test for Reform UK in Scotland, after their recent success in English local elections. They came a close third – a rise they've described as 'truly remarkable.'
