The Irish Times view on Hpat: doctoring the sytem
Its creators, the Australian Council for Educational Research, claimed that it was neither possible nor worthwhile to study for the exam. However, they had not reckoned with Irish parents and the grind culture that has taken hold since the establishment of the first 'grind schools' in the 1970s. Middle class families continue to find new ways to game the CAO system.
Hpat preparatory courses cost up to € 800 and would appear to deliver. Medical faculties report that most students who repeat the exam improve their score and a significant number who gain places do so on the basis of a repeated Hpat.
The question as to whether the introduction of the test actually produced better doctors is hard to answer but is clear that the pendulum has swung back in favour of better-off applicants, if it ever truly swung away from them. Over a third of medical students are now from affluent backgrounds, according to the Higher Education Authority. This compares with 18 per cent for the student body as a whole.
READ MORE
Several medical schools now want to reduce the weight attached to the Hpat, which can add 300 points to a candidate's Leaving Cert result, although the average is near half that. Any changes will need to be signed off by their respective universities' academic councils and the Department of Education will no doubt have something to say.
The proposal is worthy of serious consideration. The system as currently designed is not delivering as expected. However, any downgrading of the Hpat should be accompanied by alternative measures to ensure that students from less affluent backgrounds are fairly represented.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gallagher quit Nutribrand after firm decided to change chairman, says presidential hopeful Sheridan
Former presidential candidate Seán Gallagher resigned from his role at Nutribrand after it decided to replace him as chairman, the company's chief executive, Gareth Sheridan , has said. Mr Sheridan, who announced his own bid for the presidency over the weekend, said the company was 'surprised' when Mr Gallagher raised the issue of a basketball corporate box in his January 2022 resignation letter. The 35-year-old pharma businessman from Terenure in Dublin intends to run as an independent candidate, seeking a nomination from local authorities to get on the ballot paper. Mr Sheridan cofounded US-based Nutribrand in 2012, which utilises technology to prevent the abuse of patch medications such as fentanyl. READ MORE Mr Gallagher, another Irish businessman who came second in the presidential race of 2011, became chairman of Nutribrand in 2018. However, according to Mr Sheridan, Mr Gallagher resigned from the role in January 2022 when communications broke down over a change in corporate structure. A spokesman for Mr Sheridan said Mr Gallagher's resignation came shortly after the company decided his role should be filled by 'someone with US capital markets experience'. It was decided that Serguei Melnik, a cofounder of Nutribrand, would be appointed chairman and that Mr Gallagher would 'voluntarily vacate' the role and remain as director on the same remuneration package. 'Communication broke down at this point,' the spokesman said, and Mr Gallagher submitted a resignation in January 2022. The spokesman said the company was 'surprised' when Mr Gallagher referenced a corporate box in his resignation letter. In 2020 the company paid $180,000 for a corporate box from basketball team Orlando Magic at the Amway Arena Stadium in Florida, for a renewable one-year period. The company described it as a 'good fit' because 'it is the NBA's most prominent team in the fight against the misuse of opioids'. Nutribrand retains this corporate box and has extended its contract, the spokesman said. Also declared as presidential contenders are former MEP Mairead McGuinness, selected as Fine Gael's candidate, and Independent TD for Galway West Catherine Connolly, who has support from Oireachtas members. No other parties have announced candidates as yet.
Irish Post
4 hours ago
- Irish Post
€16m allocated to cross-border research partnerships including Parkinson's Disease project
THE IRISH GOVERNMENT has announced it has allocated €16m to cross-border research collaborations between higher education institutions in Ireland and Northern Ireland. Among the projects is one to help those suffering with Parkinson's Disease and another to develop cybersecurity to support cross-border infrastructures. The investment is delivered through the North-South Research Programme (NSRP), a collaborative scheme funded by the government through the Shared Island Fund. "Deepening cooperation between higher education institutions and researchers on a cross-border basis to conduct research of economic and social benefit to the whole island is a key priority of the government's Shared Island Initiative," said Taoiseach Micheál Martin. "I am very pleased to see the Higher Education Authority in this second round of the programme enabling four major new institutional cross-border research partnerships with this focus. "I congratulate all of the successful research teams and institutions and look forward to seeing the outputs and benefits that each project will deliver in the years ahead." Partnerships The projects were chosen following a highly competitive process involving 131 applications from 17 higher education institutions, evaluated by international experts. Co-Create has been developed by the National College of Art and Design and Ulster University. It aims to use art and design to create frameworks, toolkits and models for co-creation in areas like healthcare and community-led services. University of Limerick and Queen's University Belfast have joined forces for the CyberUnite project, which aims to secure cross-border critical infrastructure. Its goal is to enhance cyber-resilience and improve economic and national security, developing a unified cybersecurity research ecosystem. Developed by Trinity College Dublin and Queen's University Belfast, Lifelangs aims to foster a shared understanding of linguistic diversity and promoting social cohesion. It will create a centre dedicated to studying the languages and identities shared across different communities across the island of Ireland. Finally, PD-Life will create an all-island Parkinson's Disease research hub that will look at wellbeing and resilience for people living with the condition. Created by University College Cork and Queen's University Belfast, it will focus on areas such as stigma, mental health and physical activity. Each of the four projects will receive up to €4m over a four-year period. 'Potential' "Since my appointment, I have actively engaged in strengthening North-South collaborations between higher-education and research institutions," said James Lawless, Minister for Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science. "Today's announcement is a clear demonstration of the potential we unlock when we work together at scale. "These projects, spanning cybersecurity, language and identity, Parkinson's Disease research, and inclusive design, demonstrate the potential of what shared research ambition can achieve. "They will foster innovation, inform policy, and enhance quality of life across communities. Crucially, they set the stage for deeper collaboration in the years ahead."
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Glanbia increases full-year earnings guidance despite slump in profit
Nutritionals group Glanbia has increased its earnings forecast for the year while appointing a new chairman. The company, which has been struggling to contend with a spike in the cost of whey proteins, a key input, said headline revenue for the first six months of the year increased by 6 per cent to $1.9 billion. Profits, however, were down by 7.5 per cent to $132 million. The company also announced the sale of its Dutch e-commerce platform Body&Fit for an undisclosed sum while noting there was 'no news yet' on the planned sale of its underperforming dieting brand SlimFast. READ MORE The Dublin-listed group upgraded its full-year earnings guidance to 130-133 cent per share, up from 124-130 cent, as a result of what it described as 'increased revenue momentum' in the second quarter across its performance nutrition (PN) division. The PN element of the business has been the star performer n recent years but it has been hit by a jump in the cost of whey. The company unveiled Paul Duffy, a former chairman and chief executive of Pernod Ricard North America, as chair designate to replace Donal Gaynor who is due to step down from the role at the end of the year. 'Today's results reflect a first half of significant execution and progress as we generated 6 per cent revenue growth in the period, underpinned by strong growth in health & nutrition (H&N) and dairy nutrition (DN) and a sequential improvement in performance nutrition through the period as the group navigated significant macroeconomic volatility,' chief executive Hugh McGuire said. 'We are today upgrading our full year adjusted EPS guidance to 130 to 133 cent as a result of increased revenue momentum in PN and improved margins in H&N,' he said. 'The category trends remain positive, and we expect to see continued improvement in volumes across PN in the second half of the year with continued momentum in H&N and DN,' he said.
