Love Island revives conversation about racial bias and misogynoir in dating
'Love Island,'
a widely popular international reality television franchise, is emblematic of the complexities of modern dating. It has also sparked heated discussions among fans about the desirability of Black women and darker-complexioned people both on and off air.
The show, which aired the finale of the seventh season of its U.S. version Sunday and is airing the 12th season of its U.K. version, casts conventionally attractive 'islanders' who are generally in their early to late 20s for a six- to eight-week stay in a luxury villa. Men and women compete for long-lasting relationships and a cash prize.
But as the show's daters face challenges meant to test their bonds, as well as elimination by villa mates or by fans' vote, notions of who is and isn't desirable frequently come up for viewers and contestants alike. In the end, many fans are left with the perception that
racial bias
, colorism and misogyny are especially inescapable for Black women on reality dating shows.
'The diversity in the U.K. one is terrible,' said Oghosa Ovienrioba, a content creator from London. 'It's very anti-Black.'
It's not simply that Black women are picked last for coupling or eliminated first on the U.K. or U.S. versions of the show. Many fans say there's a recurring theme of suitors dumping or ditching Black female contestants when there is a fairer skinned option. Black female contestants have also complained of not doing well on the show when they don't lower their standards for intimacy with a suitor, as though they are lucky to even been considered dating material among more desirable mates.
Even with these viewer frustrations, Ovienrioba said she prefers '
Love Island USA
.'
'I feel like the dark skin Black women on that show always find men who fit their vibe, who respect them, who are attracted to them, desire them, treat them like queens,' she said.
'Love Island' U.K. irks fans over treatment of Black women
In the U.K. version, fans have counted multiple instances where Black female contestants were left as the last choice when couples were picked, or they were first to get eliminated and dumped from the villa. Many have also noted that it took eleven seasons before a darker-complexioned Black woman was declared the winner.
Now in its 12th season, Love Island U.K. is still dogged by allegations of male contestants' bias against Black women. After 23-year-old
Alima Gagigo
, a Black woman, chose to couple up with 26-year-old Blu Chegini, a white man, he said, 'I'll be honest, on paper, you're not my type.'
Gagigo responded, 'Of course,' as if those were words she was not surprised to hear.
There is no evidence that Chegini was referring to Gagigo's race or ethnicity. But the exchange was enough to confirm what some in audience felt was an implicit bias against Black women in the villa.
'Love Island's only stipulation is that applicants are over 18, single and looking for love. Our application and casting process is inclusive to all and we are always aiming to reflect the age and diversity of our audience on the show,' a show spokesperson for 'Love Island U.K.' said.
Black American contestants, too, say their complexion impacts their treatment
JaNa Craig, a contestant on 'Love Island USA's' beloved sixth season, which aired last summer, landed a spot in the final four couples by the end of the competition alongside Kenny Rodriguez, who entered the villa 13 days into the season. Her bubbly personality made her a fan favorite.
Although she initially worried about how viewers felt about her, the positive audience reaction culminated in her being deemed the 'baddest girl in Love Island history,' which means hot or beautiful in slang terms. Still, she felt some male contestants may not have been interested in her and Serena Page, another Black female contestant, because of their skin complexion. Page went on to win that season of 'Love Island USA.'
'The very first time I felt special is when the very first guy picked me because he had three options. Other than that, I always felt like I was getting the short end of the stick,' Craig said. 'Even though we know our worth and we know we're beautiful, we still felt like — not good enough.'
Ultimately, Craig felt proudest when she heard from other Black women who said they appreciated her representation on the show, given the perception that Black women are less desirable on dating shows.
'I felt honored by the amount of Black girls that were like, 'JaNa, you inspire me,'' she said.
'Love Island USA' producer Peacock, which on Sunday debuted a spinoff to its popular Season 6 season, titled 'Love Island: Beyond the Villa,' declined comment for this story.
Desirability concerns reflect real-world anti-Black sentiments
Fans' and contestants' concerns about Black women's representation on the show reflect a real-world anti-Black and misogynistic views of Black women, commonly referred to as
misogynoir
. Scholars describe it as both implicit and explicit contempt for Black women, much of it rooted in racist stereotypes that are perpetuated in popular culture and mass media. While Love Island contestants are not being outright racist to Black female competitors, many viewers feel the interactions Black women have had on the show have been laced with implicit bias.
Few viewers see anything wrong with 'Love Island' contestants being open about the specific traits they look for in potential suitors. Tall over short, fit over average build, tattooed over unmarked.
But contestants' racial preferences, whether real or simply perceived by fans of the show, can't be seen as objective truth about who is or is not desirable in the world, said Alexandria Beightol, host of the podcast 'Apathy Is Not An Option' at the Southern Poverty Law Center, a civil rights and legal advocacy nonprofit.
'You recognizing you have a type should also be you recognizing you are a product of a lot of mass media,' Beightol said.
The show's producers should see the show's popularity as an opportunity to dispel and not reinforce notions of beauty, especially ones harmful to Black women and darker-complexioned people, she added.
'It would behoove you to have some producers that look like some of the women on there who can kind of anticipate some of that drama,' Beightol said. 'They do frame those women as beautiful. In the history of reality programming, they've busted through a lot of the implicit views that the media used to hold itself to.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
18 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Toronto musicians pay tribute to Black Sabbath frontman and 'lord of metal' Ozzy Osbourne
Ozzy Osbourne, legendary frontman of the rock band Black Sabbath, "opened doors" for people who wanted to play heavy metal, Toronto musicians said following news of his death. Osbourne died Tuesday morning at the age of 76, his family said in a statement. No cause of death has been provided, but Osbourne disclosed five years ago that he had been diagnosed with Parkinson's disease. His death comes more than two weeks after his final show on July 5 in Birmingham, U.K., where he performed while sitting on a throne. He and the original members of Black Sabbath reunited for the concert in front of about 42,000 fans. Members of tribute bands and experts on rock music in Toronto said Osbourne had a major impact on music. Jaye Schwarzer, bass guitarist for the Toronto-based punk rock band Cancer Bats said Osbourne had a "distinct and unique" voice that wasn't found in pop music when he came onto the scene, which made him stand out. "He's the lord of metal. He's the prince of darkness. He made it cool to not conform," Schwarzer said on Tuesday. WATCH | Ozzy Osbourne performs in Birmingham: 'A different approach to music' Cancer Bats, using the name Bat Sabbath, have performed as a Black Sabbath tribute band. Schwarzer said it was special to see Black Sabbath twice. Schwarzer said when Black Sabbath was becoming known, pop bands such as the Bee Gees were big. "Nobody sounded dark and evil like they did," he said. "And so, it just opened doors for people with a different approach to music to say, you can do this." Osbourne rose to prominence in the late 1960s with Black Sabbath, becoming known as the father of heavy metal. In the 1980s, he launched a successful solo career. He became infamous for biting the head off a bat on stage and for his drug-fuelled lifestyle. He later reinvented himself as a lovable, but foul-mouthed, reality TV star with his family. 'He championed heavy metal for the masses' Roland Murray, a guitar player for The Ozzy Experience, an Ozzy Osbourne Black Sabbath tribute band based in Toronto, said he was "devastated" to hear that Osbourne had died. "He championed heavy metal for the masses," Murray said. "Rest in peace, Ozzy. I'm going to miss you. People around the world are going to miss you." 'The metal equivalent of Elvis Presley dying' Alan Cross, host of The Ongoing History of New Music, a music history documentary radio program in Canada produced by Corus Entertainment, said Osbourne's legacy cannot be underestimated and his impact on the music industry is undeniable. "This is the metal equivalent of Elvis Presley dying. This is how big a deal it was. Ozzy was this character who has been with us since 1969. He survived a billion things that would have killed anybody else. In the meantime, he and Black Sabbath helped invent a brand new style of music known as heavy metal," Cross said. "That style of music has influenced countless bands over the last 50 years. And Ozzy himself became a star, a solo star, with a sound of his own in the 1980s, 1990s. And then he became this TV star, and really, if you want to look at it, a pioneer of reality television," he added. "One of the things about Ozzy is, no matter where he went, he was adored and people loved him." Osbourne is survived by wife and manager Sharon; five children, including Jack, Kelly and Aimee; and several grandchildren.
New York Times
20 minutes ago
- New York Times
Ozzy Started With Style, and Built From There
His journey from small-time criminal to heavy metal's comic Prince of Darkness started with clothes. Growing up in Birmingham, England, Ozzy Osbourne didn't see much of a future for himself, so he decided to give it a go as a cat burglar. His main target, according to his 2009 memoir, 'I Am Ozzy,' was a clothing shop not far from home. On his third attempt, he recalled, 'I managed to nick some shirts.' But he was arrested soon afterward and sent to Winson Green Prison, a century-old facility that looked like a medieval fortress. His six-week jail stint caused him to reconsider his plan to become a career criminal. He took jobs in an auto parts factory and a slaughterhouse. Inspired by the Beatles, he wanted more than anything to join a rock 'n' roll band. The first step he took toward this unrealistic-seeming goal was to change his appearance: 'I didn't even know anyone who could play a musical instrument,' he recalled. 'So, instead, I decided to grow my hair long and get some tattoos. At least I'd look the part.' He was the same age as many of the young people who wore bright, flowing garments during the so-called Summer of Love, but he detested flower power. When he finally joined up with some old schoolmates to form Black Sabbath, he made his way toward a style that represented a dramatic departure from the cheerful hues favored by the tie-dye crowd. The hippies liked soft fabrics that reflected an innocent view of a world, where peace and love would win out in the end. Ozzy favored capes and heavy boots. He had gone to jail, not college. It took him a while to find a style that worked, especially before the money rolled in. 'I'd walk around in an old pyjama top for a shirt with a hot-water tap on a piece of string for a necklace,' he wrote in his memoir, adding: 'You had to use your imagination. And I never wore shoes — not even in winter. People would ask me where I got my 'fashion inspiration' from and I'd tell them: 'By being a dirty broke bastard and never taking a bath.'' Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Refinery29
an hour ago
- Refinery29
Sterling K. Brown & Ernest Kingsley Jr. Lead A Joyful Rebellion In Washington Black
Washington Black is about joy. That may come as a surprise, since the story (based on the novel by Esi Edugyan) starts on a Barbados plantation where we find the titular character enslaved and shackled by his surroundings. 'Joy' isn't often a word associated with Black period pieces from this era. But Washington Black, affectionately known as 'Wash' (played at different ages by the equally impressive Ernest Kingsley Jr. and Eddie Karanja), is a boy who dares to wonder, to dream, and to soar in spite of the captivity of his circumstances. His defiant curiosity leads him from Barbados to a journey of international escapades where he finds community, love, and freedom. 'It's a globe-trotting exhilarating adventure of a story that is based on the power of the imagination of a young Black boy who finds himself in the worst of circumstances but doesn't allow those circumstances to dictate his possibilities,' executive producer and star Sterling K. Brown said of the series during a day-long Washington Black -themed activation last month. At the Grove Hotel in London, the cast (including Brown, Kingsley Jr., Karanja, plus scene stealers Iola Evans and Edward Bluemel) gathered for an immersive event that conveyed the spirit of Washington Black. There were hot air balloon installations (if you know the story, you know the significance), a spice market, a hand-drawn portrait studio, and themed drinks that all tied back to the whimsy and wonder that pulse through the heart of the series. One of the things I loved about the event — and about the miniseries as a whole — is that it felt like we stepped back in time, transported to a magical world of hope and possibility, one that feels less bleak than our current timelines. But no matter how many 'Ignited Sky' margaritas and 'Ember Isle' old fashioneds Hulu generously offered the journalists and influencers who attended the London trip for Washington Black, the only thing that mattered was this: is the show any good? The good thing is that it is. Washington Black follows the story of Wash, a boy born on a Barbados sugar plantation. When a harrowing incident forces Wash to flee with his 'mentor' abolitionist Titch (Tom Ellis), he is thrust into decades-spanning adventure that challenges and reshapes his understanding of family and liberation. When our timelines are as depressing as they are, filled with news of history being erased, banned, and challenged, a story like this — which is fictional but rooted in real events — is more urgent and necessary than ever. ' Come to Washington Black for Sterling K. Brown, stay for the limitless, magical world he helped build and the captivating young stars he has given his blessing to. ' 'It's important to continue to tell our stories, no matter what year it is or what we're going through,' showrunner and executive producer Kimberly Ann Harrison tells me over Zoom. 'Our stories are important. And this entire series was a history lesson for me.' Harrison was joined by creator, showrunner, and executive producer, Selwyn Seyfu Hinds, who echoed her sentiments. 'The show's about truth [and] authenticity,' he said. 'The show is about living in the skin of who you are versus who the world is trying to tell you you are. That's the writer's job, that's the artist's job, to do the best we can, to put our truth into the world, and the world takes it as it does.' It's not just Wash who is fighting to hold onto who he is while the world tries to dictate who he should be. His love interest, Tanna (played with searing emotional depth by Evans), a biracial woman who refuses to pass for white, is navigating her own journey of self discovery. And for Evans, it was personal: 'I was doing a lot of real-time processing,' Evans says with a laugh, sitting beside Bluemel (who plays McGee, the man Tanna is reluctantly supposed to marry). 'There are challenges and privileges that come with being racially ambiguous [or] light skinned. It kind of depends what race people think I am sometimes, and that can be advantageous,' she continues. 'Tanna has the privilege of pretending to be white and everything that goes with that, but also it's so important to have a sense of home and where you feel like you can be your authentic self and like a grounded sense of your own identity so it was nice that Tanna gets to discover more of that as the story goes on.' As the story goes on, Tanna and Wash fall for each other and running right alongside joy in their narrative is love. The romance plays out quite beautifully and even though the high stakes of a young man coming of age while on the run dominates the tale, the love story is just as important. 'They find relief and joy and hope of a better life [in each other],' Evans explains that when Tanna first meets Wash, he is the first to see her for who she is, and conversely, she gives her the space to be who she is, since 'she's been squashed into being this white person, a Victorian privileged woman, all confined by society.' The restrictions placed on Tanna are different than the ones Wash faces, but they are reinforced by the same system of white supremacy. And as Wash and Tanna fall in love, the grip of those expectations loosen and we see two joyous young people finally being their truest selves. 'In the majority of narratives we've seen about slavery in mainstream cinema, you see a lot of the Black suffering, a lot of it is from the white oppressor's gaze,' Evans says. '[You rarely see] a more fully rounded, human experience of the people who were enslaved at that time. That's one of the things I really like about the show. You see the different enslaved people's religious practices, you see love, and then obviously you get to see Wash and his excellence and his brilliance as it's realized throughout the story.' Washington Black teeters closely into the territory of placing Wash on a pedestal built by his excellence, explaining away his travels with the caveat of his intelligence, but it never tips over into the magical negro or talented tenth tropes. And one of the main reasons it doesn't is because of the richness of the story Hinds and Harrison have laid out (via Edugyan's brilliant novel), but also because of Medwin (played by Brown), a man who becomes like a father figure to Wash while he's in hiding as Jack Crawford. Medwin and Miss Angie (Sharon Duncan-Brewster) provide a safe haven for Wash and other Black folks of the Underground Railroad freedom route in Nova Scotia, and they also give him the thing he's been missing his whole life: a real sense of community and connectivity. ' "We have that shared experience of going through so much hardship and pain, but there are multiple stories throughout history that show the excellence we've achieved in spite of that." ernest kingsley jr. ' Watching the series, it's comforting to see not just Caribbean, African and American Black history on display throughout Washington Black, but the Canadian influence too. As a Canadian, the Black history of Halifax is something I've been fascinated by, and well versed in, for years. It's a reminder that even when the Diaspora Wars are popping off on social media, we need to remember how intertwined our histories are. So as I sit in a hotel room in London — across from Kingsley Jr., who is British and Brown, an American — I have to ask them about the interconnectedness of the Black diaspora and the ways in which the show displays that connectivity. 'Thank you for asking that,' Brown responds. 'It was one of the things that really drew me to the story. We spend so much time thinking, they're not like us, right?' Brown laughs at his own nod to Kendrick Lamar 's takedown of Canadian rapper, Drake. 'But we've got a little bit more in common than one would think. There's a shared history — we're all part of the transatlantic slave trade. There is a connective tissue to us that, I think, if we start to embrace that connection rather than seeing each other separate and distinct, there's power in coming together and recognizing the continuity and continuum that is Blackness and that is the motherland, instead of trying to make each other feel less than, or separate, or subjugated.' Kingsley Jr. agrees: 'We have that shared experience of going through so much hardship and pain, but there are multiple stories throughout history that show the excellence we've achieved in spite of that, and how we've overcome and persevered.' In the series, Medwin delivers a line that I loved and that can sum up the ethos of Washington Black: 'Only way Black folk 'gon climb this mountain is if we pull each other along.' This is said after an epic betrayal, and with the context the audience has of knowing Wash's coming-of-age was tethered to a man (Titch) he never knew if he could trust, with the line between enslaver and mentor getting blurrier and blurrier. Wash's real family is Kit, the woman who raised him, and Medwin and Miss Angie. It's under their protection and through their love that he is able to be free to imagine, to create, and to defy the odds that were never in his favor. Wash's rebellion is in his joy, and it was clear through spending time with the cast and team behind Washington Black, that the joyful rebellion was shared in the creation of this epic action adventure. Sterling K. Brown is an Emmy winner (securing his latest nomination just last week for Paradise) and an Oscar nominee. He could be doing a lot of things with his influence and star power. He chose to adapt a Black Canadian woman's novel about Black boy joy. He has chosen throughout this press run to platform Kingsley Jr. and make sure the world is aware of his excellence and talent. Sterling K. Brown has climbed his mountain and now he's pulling along the next generation, as well as ushering in exhilarating storytelling we rarely get to see on TV. Come to Washington Black for Brown, stay for the limitless, magical world he helped build and the captivating young stars he has given his blessing to. Their joy is just beginning.
