Another win for Algonquin community in fight against nuclear waste dump
In January, the Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) received approval to construct the "near-surface disposal facility" at the Chalk River research campus, about 190 kilometres northwest of Ottawa and one kilometre from the river.
In that same announcement, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) determined the project "is not likely to cause significant adverse environmental effects," and that Indigenous groups were adequately consulted.
The Kebaowek community, among other advocate partners, challenged both of those rulings through separate judicial reviews.
On Friday, in addressing the latter judicial review, federal court Justice Russel Zinn acknowledged that construction of the facility would in fact be a threat to endangered Blanding's Turtle and two bat species in the area.
"We were absolutely elated because it's a victory for us, but again, it's a victory for those species at risk that are there," said Chief Lance Haymond of Kebaowek First Nation.
According to the ruling, CNL failed to properly assess other reasonable locations for the site.
Nicholas Pope, the legal counsel for Kebaowek First Nation, told CBC there are two other viable sites that were overlooked.
"Under the law, you can't put the waste facility somewhere that's worse for species at risk when there are other places that would work just as well," he said.
"Now the decision is being sent back to the government for redetermination and for right now, the project can't go ahead," Pope said.
As of Sunday evening, the CNSC had not responded to the court decision.
'We were completely ignored'
In a press release, Pope said the court's latest decision "is a landmark moment for environmental law in Canada."
Haymond agrees, but says getting to this point should not have required so much legal pushback.
"We were completely ignored, and for us, the two wins that we've won in the courts is validation that we have a voice, we have an understanding of our territory and that [what] we have to say is important," Haymond said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
2 hours ago
- National Observer
Tensions rise as Quebec government plans meeting about forestry blockades
The Quebec government is trying to ease rising tensions between forestry workers and Indigenous protesters who oppose a new bill they say threatens their way of life. Natural Resources Minister Maïté Blanchette Vézina and Indigenous Affairs Minister Ian Lafrenière announced Tuesday they were meeting with three Atikamekw communities in Quebec's Mauricie region, roughly 200 kilometres north of Montreal. The region has been the site of recent tense confrontations between protesters and industry workers over a series of blockades that have disrupted operations for some in the forestry sector. 'I am very concerned about the situation,' Blanchette Vézina said Tuesday on X. 'It is essential that we speak calmly and respectfully.' The Assembly of First Nations Quebec–Labrador is expected to meet with the office of Premier François Legault on Wednesday. The conflict stems from a bill tabled in the Quebec legislature this spring that aimed to protect communities dependent on the forestry industry. The legislation would divide public forests into zones designated for conservation, multi-purpose use or forestry. According to the bill, actions that "restrict the carrying out of forest development activities" would be prohibited in the forestry zones, as would conservation measures. The Quebec government is trying to ease rising tensions between forestry workers and Indigenous protesters who oppose a new bill they say threatens their way of life. Indigenous leaders were quick to criticize the bill, saying it infringed on their rights. In July, the AFNQL announced it was walking away from discussions with the government, who it said had not shown 'genuine political will' to collaborate on the forestry reform. After the bill was tabled, an organization called MAMU First Nation, which describes itself as a group of hereditary chiefs and land defenders, began organizing blockades of forestry roads in the province. The group says the proposed legislation threatens caribou, forest sustainability and traditional Indigenous ways of life. A spokesperson declined an interview request from The Canadian Press. The blockades have led to hostile exchanges between the group's members and forestry workers, both in person and online. Daniel Paré, the owner of a forestry business based in the Saguenay–Lac-St.-Jean region, said he's barely been able to work since the spring and has no money coming in. 'It's really catastrophic,' he said in an interview. 'We're imprisoned in our houses and we can't do anything about it. … We're powerless.' On Saturday, Paré put out a call on Facebook for other affected workers to join him and confront the Indigenous group on Monday at a blockade near La Tuque, Que., though the plan didn't materialize. 'Our goal isn't to wage war,' he said. 'It's just to get along and go to work.' Amid the growing tension, Lafrenière and the Wemotaci Atikamekw Council published statements over the weekend calling for calm. But some are asking the government to do more to end the blockades. "While these actions paralyze our forest economy, isolate families, and threaten the stability of an entire region, the government chooses to remain inactive," La Tuque Mayor Luc Martel said in a social media statement last week. "Allowing the situation to deteriorate is not only a political error, but also a clear abandonment of the people who live and work in this forest." In an interview, AFNQL Chief Francis Verreault-Paul said he's concerned about tensions spilling over into violence. But he said the Quebec government has the power to defuse the situation by working with First Nations leaders to modify the bill. Verreault-Paul said the government reached out to the assembly to arrange Wednesday's meeting, and has shown a "general openness" to addressing its demands. Among other things, the assembly has called for the bill's zoning strategy to be scrapped. "It's hard to understand why this process has to be so polarizing and the solution so slow in coming," he said. "So now, it's really about speeding things up. That's the message we're sending."
Winnipeg Free Press
5 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Quebec government tries to ease growing tension over forestry blockades
MONTREAL – Two Quebec ministers are meeting with First Nations communities amid rising tensions around forestry blockades in the province. Natural Resources Minister Maïté Blanchette Vézina and Indigenous Affairs Minister Ian Lafrenière are meeting with three Atikamekw communities in Quebec's Mauricie region, roughly 200 kilometres north of Montreal. Blanchette Vézina says she's 'very concerned' about the situation in the region, where there have been tense standoffs between protesters and forestry workers in recent days. An Indigenous rights group has organized a series of blockades in recent months that have disrupted operations for some in the forestry industry. The group is protesting a new bill that would divide public forests into zones designated for conservation, multi-purpose use or forestry. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. Some Indigenous leaders say the bill infringes on their rights and the Quebec government has not addressed their concerns. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 19, 2025.
Winnipeg Free Press
17 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Tory byelection candidate sorry for residential schools comments
BRANDON — A Progressive Conservative candidate in an upcoming Manitoba byelection has apologized for comments she made in the past about residential schools. Colleen Robbins, the Tory candidate for Spruce Woods, wrote on X in July 2021: 'I don't believe for once that any human ever started the residential school to abuse children. 'I agree it was what they thought at the time to help the Indigenous, which didn't happen.' On Monday, the 61-year-old said she never learned about residential schools while she was in school. 13082025 Colleen Robbins of the PC Party of Manitoba speaks during the Souris & Glenwood Chamber of Commerce byelection debate with Ray Berthelette of the NDP and Stephen Reid of the Manitoba Liberal Party at the Avalon Theatre in Souris on Wednesday evening. (Tim Smith/The Brandon Sun) 'I apologize for my ignorance,' she said in an interview with the Brandon Sun. 'I believed — honestly at the time — that they were just like a regular school that people moved to, to be educated,' she said. 'But since the truth and reconciliation has come to light, and all of this, we're all learning and reading about it more and more. I just didn't think that they started it out to be like that. But in fact, residential schools were to take the culture out of them, and that is just so wrong in every which way. And I apologize.' Kelly Saunders, a political science professor at Brandon University, said the optics of this are bad for the PCs. 'I don't think this is good for the party, because it's only going to remind Manitobans of the fact that the party has had a troubled record when it comes to Indigenous issues,' she said. Earlier this year, the PC party apologized for its stance during the 2023 election to not fund the search of a Winnipeg-area landfill for the remains of Indigenous women murdered by a serial killer. 'Those issues have been a bit of an albatross around the party's neck,' Saunders said. 'This statement made by a candidate, even given the fact that it was made a few years ago, this is not the kind of bad press that the party is looking for these days.' Robbins also defended comments she made earlier this year regarding U.S. President Donald Trump, when he imposed tariffs on Canada and Mexico, citing drugs going into the U.S. from both countries. 'I am so sorry you have to do this to us … Thought our countries were friends,' she commented in early February. Phrasing it that way was both sarcastic and a bad choice of words, she clarified on Monday, especially when readers don't know who she is as a person. Robbins said she was mad at the American president in that comment. 'Friends don't put tariffs on or hurt each other,' she said, calling herself a patriotic Canadian. 'And I was being sarcastic there. That was not me apologizing for anything.' She said that comment, along with others regarding U.S. politics, are being taken out of context by the people reposting them. Robbins said those people are 'fear mongering' and running a 'smear campaign.' Wednesdays Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences. Stephen Reid, the Liberal candidate for Spruce Woods called Robbins' comments 'terrible' and hopes she learns from the experience. 'When someone shows you who they are, listen,' he said. 'That's something that people need to keep in mind.' The Sun reached out to NDP candidate Ray Berthelette, but a campaign manager said he was door-knocking and wasn't available for an interview. The byelection is set for Aug. 26 — Brandon Sun
