Labour's AI plans are ‘an act of cultural suicide'
Government plans to weaken copyright laws for the benefit of AI companies are 'a cultural act of suicide', according to Britain's leading literary agent.
Jonny Geller, chief executive of the Curtis Brown agency, said that the publication of an AI-generated bestseller was inevitable and would spell catastrophe for the creative industries.
Under new proposals, big tech companies would be allowed to use copyrighted material to train AI software unless the rights holder explicitly opted out.
Mr Geller, whose authors include Marian Keyes, Anthony Horowitz and William Boyd, and who manages the estate of John le Carré, said the publishing industry must fight the plans.
Writing in The Bookseller, he said: 'The publishing and agency world may be sleepwalking into its own dangerous and dark period. Not so much a democratic threat as a cultural act of suicide.
'Under the banner of, 'how can you stop progress?', we are being invited to reward the companies who stole our authors' work by doing deals with those very same companies.'
AI-labelled content
Mr Geller said that 'no organisation should have the right to take image, creative talent or copyright without permission and that permission should not be obscured by an 'opt-out' only option'.
He also argued that AI-generated fiction and non-fiction should be labelled as such, and AI content must provide attribution and pay for its sources.
'Of course, there will be a number-one, bestselling novel that is purely AI-generated and we will talk about it and bewail (again) the death of the novel,' he said.
'But it will herald a period of disruption so catastrophic for the creative industry that we will forget this simple, inalienable truth: that all creativity comes from humans who have either lived or imagined extraordinary worlds, not a programme that has recycled older ideas and juggled words around,' Geller said.
His intervention on behalf of the publishing industry follows last month's release of a silent album by more than 1,000 musicians, including Kate Bush, Damon Albarn and Hans Zimmer, in protest at the Government's planned changes.
Sir Paul McCartney has also sent a message to the Government, saying: 'You're supposed to protect us. That's your job. So if you're putting through a Bill, make sure you protect the creative thinkers, the creative artist, or you're not going to have them.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
AI plundering scripts poses ‘direct threat' to UK screen sector, says BFI
Artificial intelligence companies are plundering 130,000 film and TV scripts to train their models in a raid on copyrighted material that poses a 'direct threat' to the future of the UK screen sector, according to the British Film Institute. In a wide-ranging report analysing the benefits and threats posed by AI to the UK's film, TV, video game and visual special effects industries, the BFI also raises fears that automation will eliminate the entry-level jobs that bring in the next generation of workers. It says the 'primary issue' facing the £125bn industry is the use of intellectual property (IP) to train generative AI models without payment to, or permission from, rights holders. The UK creative industries want to see an 'opt-in' regime, forcing AI companies to seek permission and strike licensing deals before they can use content, and the government is currently in the process of considering what legislation to put in place. 'AI offers significant opportunities for the screen sector such as speeding up production workflows, democratising content creation and empowering new voices,' said Rishi Coupland, director of research and innovation at the BFI. 'However, it could also erode traditional business models, displace skilled workers, and undermine public trust in screen content.' While the report acknowledges the technological benefits of AI – such as being able to de-age actors and improving the authenticity of accents, as was used controversially in Adrien Brody's Oscar-winning film The Brutalist – it also cites fears of job losses. Tasks such as writing, translation and some technical visual effects and character animation can now be automated, 'prompting fears of obsolescence among professionals' amid concerns that AI could take over the jobs once done by the sector's youngest workers. 'AI's ability to automate tasks raises fears of job losses, particularly for junior or entry-level positions,' the report says. 'Training and upskilling are seen as essential to prepare the workforce for AI integration.' However, the report, published in partnership with Goldsmiths, Loughborough and Edinburgh universities, warns of a 'critical shortfall' in AI training provision. 'AI education in the UK screen sector is currently more 'informal' than 'formal',' the report says. 'And many workers – particularly freelancers – lack access to resources that would support them to develop skills complementary to AI.' More than 13,000 creative technology companies are based in the UK, including more than 4,000 businesses focused on applying emerging technologies across film, games and other creative subsectors. London is the world's second largest hub after Mumbai for visual effects professionals globally, home to leading businesses including Framestore, whose credits include Avengers: Endgame and the BBC's adaptation of His Dark Materials. The report also acknowledges that AI is likely to significantly benefit the industry by lowering barriers for creators 'regardless of budget or experience'. Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion 'This could empower a new wave of British creators to produce high-quality content with modest resources,' it says. The 45-page report makes nine recommendations including establishing a market for IP licensing and training, the development of 'market-preferred, culturally inclusive AI tools' and more investment in the sector and skills training. The report was also produced in conjunction with the CoStar Foresight Lab, the £75.6m national network of laboratories that is developing new technology for the industry. 'AI offers powerful tools to enhance creativity, efficiency, and competitiveness across every stage of the production workflow,' said Jonny Freeman, director of CoStar. 'From script development and pre-production planning, through on-set production, to post-production and distribution. However, it also raises urgent questions around skills, workforce adaptation, ethics and sector sustainability.' Last week, the BBC director general and the boss of Sky criticised proposals to let tech firms use copyright-protected work without permission, while Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, tried to reassure the creative industry that it would not be harmed by future AI legislation. 'We approach you with no preferred option in mind,' she said, delivering a keynote speech at the Deloitte Enders conference. 'We are a Labour government, and the principle [that] people must be paid for their work is foundational. You have our word that if it doesn't work for the creative industries, it will not work for us.'
Scotsman
8 hours ago
- Scotsman
‘Significant challenges' in use of AI within UK screen sector
Hans Lucas/AFP via Getty Images Scottish researchers were among those to create the report Sign up to our Arts and Culture newsletter, get the latest news and reviews from our specialist arts writers Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The use of artificial intelligence (AI) within the UK screen sector raises 'significant legal, ethical, and practical challenges' such as the use of copyrighted material being used without the permission of the rights holders, a report has warned. Other issues highlighted by the British Film Institute (BFI) report include the safeguarding of human creative control, the fear of jobs being lost as positions are replaced through the use of AI, and investment in training in new skills. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad High energy consumption and carbon emissions, and the risks to creative content around biased data, are also described as being of concern. The report, which has been carried out in partnership with CoSTAR universities Goldsmiths, Loughborough and Edinburgh, analyses how the screen sector is using and experimenting with rapidly evolving generative AI technologies. It warned that the 'primary issue' was the use of copyrighted material – such as hundreds of thousands of film and TV scripts – in the training of generative AI models, without payment or the permission of rights-holders. 'This practice threatens the fundamental economics of the screen sector if it devalues intellectual property creation and squeezes out original creators,' the report said. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad But it added that the UK's strong foundation in creative technology – as it is home to more than 13,000 creative technology companies – means that the UK screen sector is well positioned to adapt to the technological shift. Getty Images The report – titled AI in the Screen Sector: Perspectives and Paths Forward – said generative AI promises to democratise and revolutionise the industry, with the BBC, for example, piloting AI initiatives. Meanwhile, projects such as the Charismatic consortium, which is backed by Channel 4 and Aardman Animations, aim to make AI tools accessible to creators regardless of their budget or experience. It said this could empower a new wave of British creators to produce high-quality content with modest resources, though concerns about copyright and ethical use remain significant barriers to full adoption. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The report sets out nine key recommendations it suggests should be addressed within the next three years to enable the UK screen sector to thrive in using AI. These include establishing the UK as a world-leading market of IP licensing for AI training, and embedding sustainability standards to reduce AI's carbon footprint. It also calls for structures and interventions to pool knowledge, develop workforce skills and target investments in the UK's creative technology sector, while it urges support for independent creators through accessible tools, funding and ethical AI products. The BFI's director of research and innovation, Rishi Coupland, said: 'AI has long been an established part of the screen sector's creative toolkit, most recently seen in the post-production of the Oscar-winning The Brutalist, and its rapid advancement is attracting multimillion investments in technology innovator applications. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'However, our report comes at a critical time and shows how generative AI presents an inflection point for the sector and, as a sector, we need to act quickly on a number of key strategic fronts. 'Whilst it offers significant opportunities for the screen sector such as speeding up production workflows, democratising content creation and empowering new voices, it could also erode traditional business models, displace skilled workers, and undermine public trust in screen content. 'The report's recommendations provide a roadmap to how we can ensure that the UK's world-leading film, TV, video games and VFX industries continue to thrive by making best use of AI technologies to bring their creativity, innovations and storytelling to screens around the globe.' Professor Jonny Freeman, director of CoSTAR Foresight Lab, said: 'This latest CoSTAR Foresight Lab report, prepared by the BFI, navigates the complex landscape of AI in the screen sector by carefully weighing both its transformative opportunities and the significant challenges it presents. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The report acknowledges that while AI offers powerful tools to enhance creativity, efficiency, and competitiveness across every stage of the production workflow – from script development and pre-production planning, through on-set production, to post-production and distribution – it also raises urgent questions around skills, workforce adaptation, ethics, and sector sustainability.' CoSTAR is a £75.6 million national network of laboratories that are developing new technology to maintain the UK's world-leading position in gaming, TV, film, performance, and digital entertainment.
Daily Mail
8 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Katie Price becomes first British star to trademark her own AI image in six-figure deal as she resurrects 1990s alter ego to declare 'Jordan is back!'
Katie Price is becoming the first British star to trademark her own Artificial Intelligence image in a huge six-figure deal. The former glamour model, 47, has signed a lucrative contract with American firm OhChat to revive and trademark her old alter-ego Jordan - as an AI version of her. In the deal she recorded 30 phrases to say so that company could make the model of her. The chosen phrases include 'I like going horse riding,' and 'this week for dinner I've got beef burgers'. Katie told The Sun of the deal: 'The Jordan days were the best days of my life. This AI move is so clever. It's a genius move. It's also a way for me to feel like her again. From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the Daily Mail's new Showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. 'Jordan's back and now I'm in competition with Jordan. I love it and they've really captured my voice and personality — you see me moving and everything. 'It's scarily weird but fascinating.' Promotional videos shared on social media show Jordan saying in a voice similar to Katie's: 'It's Jordan here. No more looking at those cheeky mags.' OhChat, which describes itself as 'the leading platform to live out your uncensored dreams through AI-powered text, voice and images.' Ahead of the launch on Monday she reassured fans: 'You can have me all for yourself.' A source told The Sun that the deal was 'a brilliant, game-changing bit of business from Katie'. It comes just after Katie sparked concern at Portsmouth Pride as the ex-glamour model took to the stage to headline the event despite the lashing rain. Katie was the main act for this year's Pride, with Girls Aloud Nadine Coyle also performing on Saturday night. Despite the bad weather, hundreds turned out to watch mum-of-five Katie perform a selection of songs. Taking to the stage, she showed off her slimmed down physique as she wore a pink jacket and tassels with a statement sparkly hat that spelled out the word 'Pricey'. Katie then stripped off to reveal a racy black leotard underneath, while showing off her tiny, heavily tattooed legs. The ex-glamour model has left fans concerned over her slimmed down figure for months, and previously addressed her drastic weight loss in May. Speaking to fans on Snapchat, she said: 'Yes I've lost weight. 'Yes that what I've wanted to do, I've wanted to lose weight. 'Because the past three, four years ago when I broke my feet and I was in a wheelchair for 10 months because they said I'd never walk again, and obviously you put weight on being in a wheelchair. 'And then I did all the IVF stuff, that also puts on weight. 'So yeah I did put on weight and I hated it, I felt uncomfortable and it wasn't me.' Towards the end of her set, Katie brought on Married At First Sight star Ella Morgan on stage - the ex-girlfriend of her current boyfriend JJ Slater. As the women complimented each other's bodies, Katie said they both had a 'lot in common'.
