Lawsuit against Graham James tossed after judge finds evidence 'too unreliable'
A Manitoba judge has dismissed a $6-million lawsuit against disgraced hockey coach Graham James and the St. James-Assiniboia School Division after she found the evidence presented by the plaintiff had inconsistencies, contradictions and was "too unreliable" to prove the convicted sexual offender abused a 10-year-old student in 1983.
"I am satisfied on the evidence adduced by the defendant that there is no genuine issue requiring a trial as to whether James sexually assaulted [the boy]," Court of King's Bench Judge Sarah Inness wrote in her decision.
The lawsuit, filed in November 2023, claimed James placed his hand on the boy's tights, making contact with his genitals, while James was his substitute teacher at the Winnipeg school division.
The statement of claim also alleged James assaulted the student at a relative's home the same year, forcing sexual acts on him and encouraging the boy's sister, who was a girl at the time, to sexually touch him.
Inness said at issue in the lawsuit is whether James was the perpetrator of the alleged sexual assaults.
"[The man's] beliefs that James is the person responsible, even if sincere, are not evidence upon which a finding of liability can reliably rest," the judge's decision said.
The judge said care was taken to assess the claims of the plaintiff, given James is "a notorious child sex offender."
He spent several years in prison for sexually assaulting multiple young players he coached in the 1980s and 1990s.
But the evidence presented by the plaintiff at the lawsuit raised concerns over contradictions and inconsistencies, including the timeline of the events, the judge's decision said.
The man initially claimed in the lawsuit and criminal complaint that the assault happened in May and the summer of 1983.
But following a Winnipeg Police Service investigation that found the man was not a student at the school until later that year, he filed an amended lawsuit claiming the sexual abuse had instead started in September and the fall of 1983.
"I recognize that a mistake as to the time frame of historical sexual abuse allegations alone may be explained by [the man's] age at the time and the number of years that have passed since then," the judge wrote in her decision.
But there were other concerns.
The judge pointed to the physical description the man gave police of the substitute teacher, which matched two photographs of James that were in news articles about the coach's sexual offending. The plaintiff admitted he came across those while doing research for his lawsuit.
"I find the reason he conducted research prior to making a criminal complaint was to assist himself in identifying his abuser. Either he did not know or he was unsure it was James," the decision said.
'Unaware of the identity,' says judge
Through interviews with the man's relatives, police found he never stayed overnight at the house where he said James assaulted him, and he had only been there for a visit over Christmas, where he left shortly after arriving, the decision said.
In the statement of claim, the man also said he saw James talking with another person the morning after the sexual abuse.
At cross-examination, the man identified the person as his uncle. When asked why he hadn't before, the plaintiff said he didn't want to unnecessarily involve his family.
The judge said this was problematic.
"His failure to adduce such evidence, knowing that the defendants were challenging the veracity of those claims, adds doubts to the accuracy of his account," the decision said.
"The fact that he was researching substitute teachers who were convicted, and his reluctance to involve his family as witnesses, suggests he was unaware of the identity of the person."
Records provided by the school division during the litigation show James had no days logged with them between September 1983 and June 1984. The judge said that while that evidence doesn't prove the former coach didn't work for the division after May 1983, it is reasonable to infer it.
James denied sexually assaulting the boy and said he was hired full-time as an assistant coach for the Winnipeg Warriors in or around May 1983. The judge said that if he had worked at the division after, there would have been some record or documentation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
41 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Motorcyclist killed after colliding with pickup truck
A motorcyclist is dead after colliding with a pickup truck in western Quebec, provincial police say. The crash happened at around 6:30 p.m. Saturday on Highway 105 near Kazabazua, Que., according to a news release from the Sûreté du Québec (SQ). The northbound truck apparently made a left-hand turn and the southbound motorcycle couldn't avoid the impact, the SQ said. The motorcyclist, a man in his 60s, was pronounced dead at the scene. An investigation into the crash is underway, the SQ said. As of 8:20 p.m., Highway 105 was still closed near the scene of the collision. Kazabazua is roughly 80 kilometres northwest of downtown Ottawa.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
'So much life left to live': Slaying of 16-year-old in Abbeydale remains under investigation
The 16-year-old Calgary boy found dead in Abbeydale was described by family friends as 'a light to everyone who knew him.' Following his death, which police have deemed to be a homicide, Calgary Search and Rescue teams have been combing through the community in search of evidence linked to his killing. Around 1:20 a.m. on Friday, Calgary police responded to an incident along the 300 block of Abergale Drive N.E. Upon their arrival, officers located a deceased teenage male who was later identified as Carter Spivak-Villeneuve. As of Saturday afternoon, acting Staff Sgt. Derek MacNaughton of the Calgary police operations intelligence group said the investigation is still in its early stages. 'There's no threat to the public, most of the police have left the area, and more updates will come through our media and (public affairs) sections,' he said. Abbeydale residents spoke with Postmedia about the homicide but wanted to remain anonymous in the event the incident was gang-related. 'It's just sad,' one resident said. 'I was born and raised in this community, and I've watched it over the years … but it's sad that someone passed away.' A homeowner in the area where the incident took place said he was out of town when it happened. Upon his return, he was approached by Calgary police for footage from his cameras. 'My grandson said (the victim) was actually in our house when they were younger,' said the homeowner. 'He said he hasn't seen him in three years, and I think he said he lived here in Abbeydale.' On Friday, another neighbour told Postmedia that she heard three gunshots sometime after midnight. An online fundraiser has been started by friends on behalf of the victim's family to support them following the loss of their son, with a goal of raising $22,000. 'Carter was more than just a teenager — he was a son, a brother, a nephew, a cousin, a friend and grandchild and a light to everyone who knew him,' said a written appeal on the fundraising page. 'Carter had so much life left to live and love left to give.' At this point, members of the family were not ready to make any public comment. 'What I can say is that the parents are trying to take this time to navigate this difficult loss,' said one of the organizers of the fundraiser. 'Carter was a sweet boy who just wanted to be loved by everyone.' After enough money has been raised, a private service will be held for Spivak-Villeneuve, the organizer said.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Romance scam costs Calgary woman more than $300K in increasingly common form of fraud
Two years ago, Shawna Nelson sold her house, moved into a motel, and thought she had a plan for where her life was heading next. Nelson, now 63 years old and living in Calgary, sold a house willed to her by her father after spending years caring for him and her grandmother, and quickly found a buyer at the asking price she'd set. The motel was supposed to be a temporary stay as Nelson expected she'd soon be moving in with a man in the U.S. she thought loved her. But instead of taking the next step in a relationship, Nelson said she found out she was the target of a romance scam, an increasingly common method of fraud in Canada. She said she lost her life savings of around $380,000 after sending payments to the man over the course of several years. : "I had been talking to a guy that said we're going to get together, and I kept sending him money. And that's why I was in a motel, because I thought soon I'll be getting out of here. And I just believed him, and I shouldn't have," said Nelson. Nelson said she was open to finding love now that her four children were grown up, and more than three decades after her husband of 12 years had died. "Because my husband died so long ago, and now that my kids were all grown, I wanted to find true love. And that's what I thought I'd found," said Nelson. Their connection first started about five years ago, when the man, who identified himself as Gilbert, contacted Nelson to warn her to cut off contact with a potential scammer she'd been chatting with on WhatsApp. Nelson and Gilbert continued messaging each other for years, while never meeting in person and with Gilbert never sending her a picture. He said he worked for the U.S. government, and wasn't allowed to show his face due to the nature of his job. Three years later, Nelson says she began transferring him money, with plans of starting a life together. But late last year she began to question the frequency of his requests for money, and asked why he wouldn't come to Calgary to help her with her move. "When he kept asking for more money and more money, I'm going, 'What is this all for? Like, I've given you enough already,'" said Nelson. "And he always came up with an excuse." Gilbert sent Nelson a picture of the house they'd move into, but she said it looked fake. That photo along with the repeated requests for cash helped her see through the scam. But by then, Nelson said she had already lost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Not knowing where to turn, Nelson went to Unison at Kerby Centre, a not-for-profit group that supports people aged 50 and older. She's lived in the centre's elder abuse shelter for around six months while trying to put her life back together. Now, Nelson says she feels stuck. She's still trying to process what's happened to her, as she notes the savings she lost would have been enough to buy a small condo with some money left over for her to live off of with her two dogs and one cat. Her only income source is her pension, she's not eligible for some subsidized seniors housing programs that become available at age 65, and she's struggled to find a place to live where she can reunite with her pets. "It was devastating," said Nelson. "People say, well, you shouldn't be so dumb to let somebody do that to you. But it happens." Romance and grandparent scams reported often: Unison Stories like Nelson's aren't unusual, said Unison at Kerby Centre's president and CEO Larry Matheison. He said the organization works on a high number of cases where seniors have experienced financial abuse or fraud. Romance scams, as well as grandparent scams, are examples he said the centre sees often. Mathieson said that it can be hard for people to wrap their heads around how common romance scams can be when they become aware of them. "If people hear about a romance scam for the first time, it's hard to believe that you would need to be alert to that type of situation," said Mathieson. "But also in situations where it's a close family member essentially defrauding a parent or grandparent of their retirement, for a lot of us it's very hard to believe it happens. But unfortunately, the reality is it does." Romance scams can be especially devastating for seniors, Mathieson pointed out, when exacerbated by a lack of affordable housing for them to turn to, as well as inflation raising the cost of groceries and medication. Unison's seniors supports help around 6,000 people most years, Mathieson said, with accessing benefits, housing or government programs. The organization also completes outreach work with partners like seniors lodges or residences, which can be just as important to prevent cases of financial abuse. "We're looking at creating an environment of safety. And in a lot of cases where financial abuse is the case, awareness of the abuse is a great deterrent," said Mathieson. The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, an organization that Nelson reported her case to and which collects information on cases of fraud and identity theft, finds that Canadians lost more than $58 million in romance scams, affecting 1,030 victims, in 2024. The total is more than double the $22.5 million that was reported lost in these cases in 2018. Jeff Horncastle, outreach officer with the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, said the group's mandate is to gather information to assist in investigations, as well as education and awareness efforts. "There's a lot of value in reporting, but with that being said, it's important to understand that we don't investigate and that's why it's so important to report to your local police," said Horncastle.
