St. Paul's rent control policy faces another rollback
Why it matters: The vote is the culmination of a months-long push by Mayor Melvin Carter to exempt new construction from the rent caps permanently.
Supporters have argued the move is necessary to jump-start housing construction in St. Paul — which has stalled since voters passed the ordinance in 2021 — without ditching rent control altogether.
The big picture: The proposal represents a big bet on a minor change to a policy whose current iteration has critics in many corners.
Developers don't like it, and even many rent control advocates have argued St. Paul's policy is a watered-down version of what voters initially demanded.
Catch up quick: The policy voters approved capped annual rent increases at 3%, with few exceptions — until Carter and the council loosened the rules in 2022.
As a result, new construction is now exempt from rent control for 20 years, and landlords can enact much larger rent increases after a tenant moves out.
The latest: The proposal before the council this week would be another relaxation, permanently exempting any new housing built in 2005 or later.
Rent control critics say it's an easy way for the city to make a bad policy more workable.
What they're saying:"What we've done in St. Paul is create the worst of both worlds," Nate Hood, a city Planning Commission member and small-time landlord, told Axios.
"Rent control scares people, so developers just stay away from the city," Hood said. "At the same time, we haven't necessarily protected tenants because there are loopholes that some people could probably drive a semi through."
The other side: Rent control advocates share some of Hood's frustrations but say the solution is to strengthen rent regulations, not weaken them further.
"City officials in St. Paul seem more focused on managing the pushback of wealthy developers and special interests, and not on implementing a strong policy," Elianne Farhat, co-executive director of advocacy group TakeAction Minnesota, told Axios.
With better enforcement and strategy from city leaders, "we wouldn't necessarily be experiencing the 'worst of both worlds,'" added Tram Hoang, who managed the 2021 rent control campaign.
Carter says that if the new proposal passes, rent control will cover more than 90% of St. Paul's rental units.
Stunning stats: Builders pulled permits for 404 housing units in St. Paul, down 80% from the 2,077 units permitted in 2020, according to federal data.
Reality check: Rent control isn't the only cause of this slowdown in St. Paul. Building has sagged nationwide as developers contend with supply chain issues, labor shortages and difficulty securing loans.
Minneapolis, which doesn't have rent control, saw a 90% drop from its pre-COVID-19 development peak, and metro-wide construction is down too.
"The real estate industry is scapegoating rent stabilization and using this time of economic uncertainty … to force the council into making a false choice," said Hoang, now an analyst at think tank PolicyLink.
Yes, but: Rent control critics fear that without further changes to St. Paul's rent control policy, developers will bypass opportunities to build in St. Paul whenever economic conditions rebound.
St. Paul's typical rents have grown at a pace similar to — if not slightly faster than — that of Minneapolis in recent years, according to Zillow estimates.
Zoom in: One reason is that St. Paul's ordinance gives landlords several options to raise rents more than the 3% annual cap.
By the numbers: Since the ordinance took effect in 2023, more than 1,700 landlords have applied to raise rents on vacant units by as much as 8%, plus inflation.
The city granted 1,580 requests in 2023 and 2024, the city's Department of Safety and Inspections tells Axios.
Another 111 applications have been granted to landlords seeking to exceed the rent cap to cover repairs or certain cost increases — like, in Hood's case, insurance.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
27 minutes ago
Las Vegas tourism is down. Some blame Trump's tariffs and immigration crackdown
LAS VEGAS -- Tourism in Las Vegas is slumping this summer, with resorts and convention centers reporting fewer visitors compared to last year, especially from abroad, and some officials are blaming the Trump administration's tariffs and immigration policies for the decline. The city known for lavish shows, endless buffets and around-the-clock gambling welcomed just under 3.1 million tourists in June, an 11% drop compared to the same time in 2024. There were 13% fewer international travelers, and hotel occupancy fell by about 15%, according to data from the Las Vegas Convention and Visitors Authority. Mayor Shelley Berkley said tourism from Canada — Nevada's largest international market — has dried up from a torrent 'to a drip.' Same with Mexico. 'We have a number of very high rollers that come in from Mexico that aren't so keen on coming in right now. And that seems to be the prevailing attitude internationally,' Berkley told reporters earlier this month. Ted Pappageorge, head of the powerful Culinary Workers Union, called it the 'Trump slump.' He said visits from Southern California, home to a large Latino population, were also drying up because people are afraid of the administration's immigration crackdown. 'If you if you tell the rest of the world they're not welcome, then they won't come,' Pappageorge said. Canadian airline data shows fewer passengers from north of the border are arriving at Harry Reid International Airport in Las Vegas. Air Canada saw its passenger numbers fall by 33% in June compared to the same time a year ago, while WestJet had a 31% drop. The low-cost carrier Flair reported a whopping 62% decline. Travel agents in Canada said there's been a significant downturn in clients wanting to visit the U.S. overall, and Las Vegas in particular. Wendy Hart, who books trips from Windsor, Ontario, said the reason was 'politics, for sure.' She speculated that it was a point of 'national pride' that people were staying away from the U.S. after President Donald Trump said he wanted to make Canada the 51st state. 'The tariffs are a big thing too. They seem to be contributing to the rising cost of everything,' Hart said. At downtown's Circa Resort and Casino, international visits have dipped, especially from Canada and Japan, according to owner and CEO Derek Stevens. But the downturn comes after a post-COVID spike, Stevens said. And while hotel room bookings are slack, gaming numbers, especially for sports betting, are still strong, he said. 'It's not as if the sky is falling,' he said. Wealthier visitors are still coming, he said, and Circa has introduced cheaper package deals to lure those with less money to spend. 'There have been many stories written about how the 'end is near' in Vegas,' he said. 'But Vegas continues to reinvent itself as a destination worth visiting.' On AAA's annual top ten list of top Labor Day destinations, Las Vegas slipped this year to the last spot, from number six in 2024. Seattle and Orlando, Florida — home to Disneyworld — hold steady in the top two spots, with New York City moving up to third for 2025. Reports of declining tourism were news to Alison Ferry, who arrived from Donegal, Ireland, to find big crowds at casinos and the Vegas Strip. 'It's very busy. It has been busy everywhere that we've gone. And really, really hot,' Ferry said. She added that she doesn't pay much attention to U.S. politics. Just off the strip, there's been no slowdown at the Pinball Museum, which showcases games from the 1930s through today. Manager Jim Arnold said the two-decade-old attraction is recession-proof because it's one of the few places to offer free parking and free admission. 'We've decided that our plan is just to ignore inflation and pretend it doesn't exist," Arnold said. 'So you still take a quarter out of your pocket and put it in a game, and you don't pay a resort fee or a cancelation fee or any of that jazz.' But Arnold said he's not surprised that overall tourism might be slowing because of skyrocketing prices at high-end restaurants and resorts, which 'squeezes out the low end tourist.' The mayor said the rising cost of food, hotel rooms and attractions also keeps visitors away. 'People are feeling that they're getting nickeled and dimed, and they're not getting value for their dollar,' Berkley said. She called on business owners to 'see if we can't make it more affordable' for tourists.
CNBC
2 hours ago
- CNBC
From dumpling-making to pub quizzes: Gen Z's recipe to making friends in real life
Fatigued by everything virtual, the youngest generation at work are now leaning into in-person networking events to find their tribe. A large number of Generation Z — born between 1997 and 2012 — entered the workforce during the Covid-19 pandemic and were forced to tune in remotely. U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy even declared a loneliness epidemic in the U.S. in 2023, saying it was especially affecting young people. Some Gen Z workers are even returning to the office in a bid to expand their network. One recent Freeman survey of nearly 2,000 U.S. adults in professional jobs found that 91% of Gen Z said it would be nice to have a balance of virtual and in-person events to connect with others at their company and in their industry. "In general, young people seek the social atmosphere because many of them just graduated college or are a few years out and are looking for similar social conveniences," Dan Schawbel, managing partner at Workplace Intelligence, explained. Some employers are catching on and trying to fill this gap. Canary Wharf, London's privately owned financial district, which houses companies like JPMorgan, Barclays, and Morgan Stanley, launched the Wharf Connect networking program in 2024 for professionals in the first 10 years of their career. Part of the area's return-to-office drive, Wharf Connect is accessible via an app and offers free events from LinkedIn workshops to pub quizzes. The initiative gets an average of 36 attendees per event and has seen 1,500 RSVPs since its inception last year. "Part of the return-to-office push is that young people, especially, yearn for those connections, and relative to older generations, they are much more isolated and lonely, so return to office at least partially allows them to meet their coworkers," Schawbel said. Last week, I took a trip to Canary Wharf to attend a Xiao Long Bao (dumpling) masterclass at Taiwanese restaurant Din Tai Fung — an event organized by Wharf Connect. Walking into a dining room nestled at the back of the restaurant where the workshop was taking place, I was stunned to see how busy it was with over 50 young professionals in attendance and chattering away. The event featured a hands-on dumpling-making session with the chef, accompanied by complimentary food and drinks. CNBC Make It spoke with three Gen Z attendees who shared how structured networking events are helping them find community. Twenty-five-year-old Vivek Haria, a senior tax advisor at a financial services firm, has attended 10 Wharf Connect events. Before starting his job in the Canary Wharf area, he was already seeking out social events or communities that would allow him to socialize and mingle outside of the workplace, but they left much to be desired. "In fact, there were hardly any, and the ones I went to were pretty much a bit crap. Then I moved here, and this was the last place that I expected these kinds of events. It's definitely filled that gap. I've made some really good friends that I meet up with on weekends as well," Haria said. For Sinny Wei, a 27-year-old human resources professional, moving from New Zealand to London meant she didn't have an established network or community in the U.K. "For me, personally, it is difficult to make friends, because I've moved over here as well, so you've really got to put yourself out there a lot. I really do like it [Wharf Connect] for that as well," she said. Wei said it's a good way to socialize informally, with free tickets, food and drinks being a great draw to the events. "I've only been to two events, so maybe if you ask me after three events, I'll have made some friends by then," she said. Haria noted that, although he returned to the office, many of his colleagues weren't physically at the workplace. The Wharf Connect events makes going to the office worthwhile, because he has something to look forward to in the evenings, he noted. "So I go into the office as many times a week as I can…working from home after Covid has been a bit s--- like I'll go into the office three or four times a week and most of my team won't be in," Haria said. In fact, a 2023 survey by employee background screening company Checkr, which polled 3,000 U.S. workers, found that 68% of managers were keen to continue remote and hybrid work in 2024, while only 48% of employees felt the same way. Senior professionals have less motivation to be in the office, according to Schawbel. With more established social lives, less of a need for mentorship, and better home office setups, older professionals are less drawn to the in-person workplace. This is creating a social void for younger workers. Organized in-person events, from professional networking to speed dating, are in vogue right now, and they are very appealing for Gen Z — some of whom may have underdeveloped social skills. "Covid, plus over-reliance on technology equals socially awkward," Schawbel said. "I'm not saying everyone is socially awkward. I'm just saying it's a recipe to create socially awkward individuals." Activity-focused events enable young people to socialize in a structured environment, rather than forcing them to spark up conversations at random. Dating giant Hinge is even funding free activity-based social events for young people in London, Los Angeles, and New York to make friends. Another example is social app Time Left, which arranges weekly dinners for strangers to meet up, with over 80,000 strangers brought together in 60 countries each month. Morayo Adesina, a 25-year-old equity research bank analyst, said that London changed after the Covid-19 pandemic, with many restaurants and bars not staying open as late — making it hard to get out of the house spontaneously. "Speed dating has definitely become very popular amongst my friends. I just think in general, there's been, a real push to have different kinds of events," she said. Wharf Connect has been an opportunity for Adesina to meet "a lot of cool people" and try new things. "The events that they put on are quite fun, like it's not every day that I get to go to Din Tai Fung to do dumpling making or sushi making." Schawbel said that for many years, people have over-relied on technology to form connections, such as on dating apps or social media, but the abundance of options has created a sense of overwhelm. The rise of in-person events and the demand for them is a rejection of online culture, he added. "They're resisting this digital age, because the digital age has become very cluttered and unreliable, therefore, they're yearning to connect in person more," Schawbel said.
Business Insider
3 hours ago
- Business Insider
M&A News: Dayforce Stock (DAY) Cheered to the Rafters as PE Group Thoma Bravo Lines up Bid
Shares in human resources management software group Dayforce (DAY) rocketed over 20% higher today on reports that it is set to be bought by private equity firm Thoma Bravo. Elevate Your Investing Strategy: Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence. According to a report in Bloomberg, Thoma Bravo wants to take Dayforce, which is valued at around $8.4 billion, private in a deal that could be announced as soon as the next few weeks. Bidding War Potential However, the Bloomberg report cautioned that while discussions are said to be advanced, they could still be delayed or falter. It is also possible that a bidding war could emerge if another bidder steps forward. Dayforce has struggled to find much light in the last few years. Its shares have fallen about 60% from their peak in 2021. This is despite its revenue racing over 70% higher between 2021 and 2024 and becoming more profitable. The main drag on its shares has been the difficulties faced by the enterprise software market. It has struggled to maintain the momentum it gained while many people were forced to work from home during the Covid-19 lockdowns. During those turbulent times, companies invested in upgrading their systems only to pull back after offices reopened. AI Offering The uncertain economy has also squeezed corporate spending, but in Dayforce's favor is that it is well-placed to take advantage of the relentless rise of AI. That's because it provides AI-powered software for managing recruitment, payrolls and employee career development. Its customers include companies in the health-care, retail and hospitality and financial services sectors. 'We would not be surprised if DAY chose to sell given the lack of appreciation for the stock in the public markets,' Jefferies Financial Group Inc. analysts including Samad Samana wrote in a note to clients after the Bloomberg report. 'It has been tough sledding for DAY the last few years post-Covid highs, not unlike the rest of the HR/payroll coverage universe. However, it has also underperformed the entire group.' This deal would also signal a more aggressive approach from Thoma Bravo in an uncertain environment for private equity firms. It agreed to buy Boeing (BA) Co.'s flight navigation unit and other digital assets for $10.6 billion in April, and in July it struck a $2 billion deal to buy restaurant software maker Olo (OLO). The firm has also reportedly been in talks about a potential takeover of Verint Systems (VRNT). Is DAY a Good Stock to Buy Now? On TipRanks, DAY has a Moderate Buy consensus based on 9 Buy, 4 Hold and 1 Sell ratings. Its highest price target is $95. DAY stock's consensus price target is $68.08, implying a 28.74% upside.
