Cities have failing infra and poor crowd management SOPs say Urban planners
Urban planners told ET that not just Bengaluru, but many civic agencies in Indian cities fail to have robust standing operating procedures (SOPs) for crowd management.
'We tend to employ very ad hoc measures to manage crowds, poor fencing, lack of proper pathways, poor lighting and lack of emergency services,' said Ujjvala Krishna, urban researcher at WELL labs. She added that there is a clear lack of foresight in building long-term infrastructure that anticipates such scale.'Bengaluru doesn't have an active master plan. The Regional and Metropolitan Area Master Plan for 2031 is still a draft. It's more like a reference. Other major metros like Mumbai, Delhi, and Chennai have active master plans,' Krishna said.
The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), which makes rules for handling disasters in India, released a guide in 2014 to help state governments, local bodies, event organisers, and police manage large crowds safely. The guideline titled 'Managing Crowd at Events and Venues of Mass Gathering' suggests that before any big event, authorities should do a Rapid Venue Assessment to check preparedness.
This includes an 11-point checklist evaluating aspects such as disaster preparedness, stakeholder coordination, crowd flow, safety, emergency response, ability to manage complexity, and potential for crowd growth, all rated on a scale from poor to best in class.Another urban planner from Bengaluru with over 30 years of experience in architecture and urban design said civic bodies are supposed to have SOPs. 'It's a combination problems of law and order, traffic management, and civic bodies. I don't think they have individual SOPs or even a common one,' he said, suggesting that such celebrations can be delayed by a day or two and organised with proper planning. The NDMA has also issued Guidelines on the Incident Response System (IRS), to ensure that there is a structured and coordinated emergency response. The guideline emphasises the need to encourage research on crowd behaviour and psychology to better inform planning and risk mitigation at mass gatherings.Another urban planner said mismanagement of crowds is not an isolated incident. 'We've had enough of these events to actually learn from them. The answer lies in capacitating our governance systems to deliver better,' the expert said, requesting anonymity.This is not the first time a stampede has claimed lives. Earlier this year on February 15, a stampede at the New Delhi Railway Station resulted in 18 people losing their lives. During Maha Kumbh in Prayaraj on the occasion of Mauni Amavasya, where lakhs arrived to take a holy dip at the Sangam, 30 died and over 60 were injured despite advisories and emergency preparations.Urban policy advisors also highlighted that cities continue to build for lower capacity than needed. They pointed out that metro cities have inadequate road infrastructure, pavements barely exist, and public mobility services are congested and worn down.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Special arrangements in Gujarats Dwarka for Janmashtami
Dwarka (Gujarat) [India], August 16 (ANI): Special security and logistical arrangements have been put in place in Gujarat's Dwarka for Janmashtami, with dedicated facilities for senior citizens, differently abled devotees, and mothers, along with provisions for clean drinking water and enhanced sanitation. Dwarka SDM Lt Col (Retd) Amol Awate said on Friday that special provisions have been made for senior citizens and differently abled people. 'Keeping Janmashtmi in mind, the district administration has taken many steps. From Kirti Stambh, a single-point entry has been made for all the devotees. Special provisions have been made so that e-rickshaws can drop senior citizens and differently abled persons directly to the door of the temple, from where, the staff will assist them in wheelchairs for darshan. For mothers, five baby feeding centres have been established inside the temple," Awate told ANI. He added that dedicated teams have been assigned for cleaning bathrooms and temples. 'From Hathi Gate to Sudama Setu, we have assigned a dedicated team to ensure that all toilets and bathrooms are thoroughly cleaned and well-maintained. The water management has been done through almost 5 water tanks and the cold and clean water from these water tanks will be distributed to the devotees all over the road and since last 2 days…almost 10 JCBs and 15 tractors and trolleys are used in cleaning all the temples in our Dwarka taluka i.e. Dwarka, Bet Dwarka, Nageshwar, there is a dedicated programme for their cleaning, we have been doing this since last 2 days and will continue this for the next three days," he said. He further said, 'We expect that whoever works well in the service of Dwarkadish should do it well, and all the devotees who come from outside should have a good experience and should go from Dwarka with good memories."Meanwhile, in Uttar Pradesh's Mathura, in a remarkable display of patriotism, the Krishna Janambhoomi temple has unveiled a board to honour the bravery of the Indian Armed Forces for their success in 'Operation Sindoor" on the occasion of the 79th Independence Day. This operation was a significant cross-border strike that showcased the military's prowess and strategic capabilities. The display of the board at the Krishna Janambhoomi temple highlights the intersection of patriotism and faith in Indian culture. It reflects the deep respect and admiration for the armed forces and their role in safeguarding the country. This gesture is a powerful way to acknowledge the military's contributions and reinforce national pride. On the eve of Janmashtmi, the devotees at the Krishna Janmsthan carried 'Poshak'– the decorative attire for Lord Krishna — over their heads in a heartfelt act of devotion. (ANI)
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Does milk really make bones stronger? Experts debunk the myth but with a catch
The Calcium Connection And Its Limits You Might Also Like: Can a desi proposal to girlfriend with ghee and milk be romantic? Actor Jaideep Ahlawat did it and won her love Milk and Fractures iStock For years, milk was promoted for strong bones. Now, research questions this claim. Milk contains calcium and nutrients. But its impact on bone health is debated. Who Might Benefit More from Milk? You Might Also Like: Indian milk vs American milk: Which one tastes better? American woman shares surprising discovery Milk's Broader Nutritional Punch Why Moderation Matters For decades, school posters, TV commercials and celebrity 'milk mustache' ads told us one thing — a tall glass of milk was the secret to strong bones. But as modern research pours in, the once-unshakable narrative is now under experts say milk does contain valuable nutrients, but its role in bone health may not be as clear-cut as dairy marketing has made it seem. The conversation is no longer about whether milk has calcium — it's about whether you actually need it from milk at is essential for strong bones, healthy teeth, and crucial body functions like nerve signaling and muscle movement. A cup of whole milk offers roughly 300 milligrams, and U.S. dietary guidelines recommend adults get 1,000 to 1,200 milligrams Dr. Walter Willett, professor of epidemiology and nutrition at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, told The New York Times that the belief in high milk intake for bone strength was largely built on short-term studies — many funded by the dairy increasing calcium intake in those deficient can raise bone density by up to 3 percent, Willett notes the gains are often too small to significantly lower fracture risk. And without ongoing high intake, these benefits tend to some populations with the lowest milk consumption also have the lowest rates of hip fractures, according to a 2020 review cited by The New York Times. Other studies have found no clear link between milk consumption and reduced fracture René Rizzoli, former head of the bone diseases department at the University Hospitals of Geneva, cautions that proving milk prevents fractures would require long-term, large-scale clinical trials — and those haven't been agree that certain groups may have more reason to reach for the milk carton — notably children between 9 and 18, when bones are rapidly developing, and adults over 50, when bone density one 2021 Australian clinical trial, older adults in care facilities who increased dairy intake to 3.5 servings per day saw a 33 percent reduced risk of fractures and an 11 percent drop in falls over two years. However, researchers couldn't confirm whether stronger bones alone explained these calcium, dairy milk delivers protein, potassium, magnesium, vitamin B12, vitamin K2 and, when fortified, vitamin D. Registered dietitian Julia Zumpano from the Cleveland Clinic calls it 'a nutritional rock star,' noting its 18 of 22 essential also a complete protein source, meaning it contains all nine essential amino acids your body can't produce. This makes it especially useful for people who struggle to meet protein needs through other isn't for everyone. Over a third of Americans struggle with lactose digestion, and symptoms like bloating or cramps can worsen with higher research also links high dairy intake to increased risks of certain cancers, likely due to hormones found in milk fat. Whole and 2% milk are also high in saturated fat, which can raise LDL ('bad') cholesterol and increase heart disease flare-ups, such as acne, have also been reported by some when dairy is removed from their diet, though the link remains unclear. If milk doesn't agree with you, experts point to other calcium-rich foods like tofu, leafy greens, bony fish, fortified plant-based milks, and even fermented dairy products like yogurt and cheese. These not only offer calcium but also may be better tolerated by those sensitive to lactose.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Next round of India-Asean goods pact review in Oct
New Delhi: The next round of review talks for the Asean-India Trade in Goods Agreement (AITIGA) will be held on October 6 and 7 in Jakarta, the government said Friday. The 10th round of the negotiations were held in New Delhi from August 10 to 14. Independence Day 2025 Modi signals new push for tech independence with local chips Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose gave India its own currency The commerce and industry ministry said the joint committee focused on advancing the ongoing review of the pact to enhance its effectiveness, accessibility and trade facilitation capabilities . "The discussions built on the progress achieved through eight active rounds of negotiations," it said, adding that delegates from all 10 Asean member states participated. Asean, or the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, comprises Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. "Bilateral trade reached $123 billion in FY25, reflecting the strong economic ties between the two sides and creating opportunities for enhanced cooperation in the years ahead," it said. Singapore trade, investment In a separate statement, the ministry said India and Singapore reviewed the ongoing collaboration in semiconductor sector and digitalisation of trade, and explored potential partnerships in skills development and capacity building. The issues were taken up at the fourth meeting of the India-Singapore Joint Working Group on Trade and Investment (JWGTI) held on August 14 in New Delhi. "The discussions focused on identifying priority sectors for greater alignment, improving logistics and supply chains, streamlining regulatory frameworks and exploring ways to facilitate cross-border trade," the ministry said. Singapore is India's largest trading partner within Asean, with total bilateral trade of $34.26 billion in FY25. It is also India's second-largest source of foreign direct investment with equity inflows of $163.85 billion between April 2000 and July 2024, accounting for about 24% of India's total inflows.
