Dutch Museum Removes 'Priceless' Benin Bronzes For Return To Nigeria
The artefact is a "Benin Bronze", a priceless cultural object looted from modern-day Nigeria more than 120 years ago, now being removed from display and returned to its rightful home.
The Wereldmuseum (World Museum) in Leiden is restoring 113 of the ancient sculptures, the latest single return, as pressure mounts on Western governments and institutions to hand back the spoils of colonial oppression.
"These don't belong here. They were violently taken, so they need to go back," museum director Marieke van Bommel told AFP in an interview.
"This is a typical example of looted art," added the 50-year-old.
The story of the Benin Bronzes is one of violence and tragedy. It began when nine British officers were killed on a trade mission to the then independent kingdom of Benin, in the south of present-day Nigeria.
The British reaction was fierce. London deployed a military expedition to avenge its officers. The troops killed several thousand locals and torched Benin's capital city.
They looted the royal palace, stealing hundreds of artworks, including the Benin Bronzes.
Most of the ornate bronzes were then sold to finance the expedition, auctioned off or sold to museums across Europe and the United States.
This was in 1897 and 128 years later, Nigeria is still negotiating the bronzes' return around the world -- with mixed results.
The Netherlands has agreed to return 119 bronzes in total -- six more are coming from Rotterdam -- and Germany has also begun handing back its loot.
However, the British Museum in London has refused to return any of its famed collection.
A law passed in 1963 technically prevents the museum from giving back the treasures.
Museum director Van Bommel hopes the Dutch example will be picked up around the world.
"I think we all agree that this collection doesn't belong in European museums. We do hope that other countries will follow this example," she said.
The collection is priceless, said Van Bommel. "It's a cultural value, so we never put a price on it."
The museum in Leiden has also restored hundreds of pieces of colonial loot to Indonesia, a former Dutch colony, Mexico and a community in the United States.
Van Bommel said they had struck a deal to keep four of the bronzes on loan, so visitors can continue to learn their story.
"We want to talk about the expedition, but also about the whole subject of restitution," she said.
In the meantime, the museum will replace their collection with a display of contemporary art.
As for the bronzes, they will be shipped to Lagos in mid-June.
Former Nigerian president Muhammadu Buhari declared in 2023 that the returned works would be given to the Oba -- the traditional ruler -- and not to the Nigerian state.
There are plans to build a museum in Benin City in southern Edo state, where the bronzes will have pride of place.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
20 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Dutch Divers Still Haul Up Debris Six Years After Container Spill
Volunteer Dutch divers are still fishing debris from the North Sea six years after a disastrous shipping accident. They are trying to clear the shallow Wadden Sea where the MSC Zoe -- one of the world's largest cargo ships -- lost hundreds of containers of car parts, televisions, light bulbs, furniture and toys in a 2019 storm. Despite clean-up efforts, debris still litters the seabed of the UNESCO-listed tidal wetland, which spans the coasts of the Netherlands, Germany and Denmark. On a grey summer day they "salvaged a set of nets and debris and also I think it was electrical cables, probably from the MSC Zoe," volunteer Harold Batteram, 67, told AFP, his diving suit covered with little wriggling crustaceans. The spill also released organic peroxide, a toxic and highly flammable chemical used in plastics manufacturing. "In a split second, the whole Wadden Sea beaches were like a heap of junk," said Ellen Kuipers, the director of the CleanUpXL project. Set up in 2021 by four Dutch environmental groups, CleanUpXL sends rescue boats and divers to clear the 800 tons of waste still on the seabed. Kuipers said the Dutch government led much of the initial clean-up, but efforts have faded in recent years. "They did a lot of cleaning but it became more and more difficult at the end, because the things they cleaned up were only the things" traceable to the MSC Zoe, she said. In April 2024, the government published a previously confidential list revealing 6,000 locations where debris and waste might still be found. Kuipers said the focus should be not only on the MSC Zoe debris but on all waste on the seabed, since the sites are protected UNESCO World Heritage areas. "We do this to also pressure the government so that they move and clean up," she said. "And it's also for a lot of people to be aware that everything we have in our house -- furniture and that kind of stuff -- has travelled by container ship. Under a choppy sea, the divers recovered a pink child's down jacket, bringing with it dozens of baby crabs and starfish. "It's a noble goal, right?" said Batteram after spending nearly three quarters of an hour 22 metres below the surface. "There's a lot of trash at the sea bottom, not too many people are aware of that," said the retired data scientist. While part of what was lost on the MSC Zoe will float, "the majority will still be at the bottom". "It's out of sight, out of mind," he said. "So we try to bring that to (people's) attention."
Int'l Business Times
20 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
City Girls Snub Traditional Hindu Face Tattoos In Pakistan
Grinding charcoal with a few drops of goat's milk, 60-year-old Basran Jogi peers at the faces of two small Pakistani sisters preparing for their first tattoos. The practice of elder women needling delicate shapes onto the faces, hands, and arms of younger generations stretches back centuries in the Hindu villages that dot the southern border with India. "First draw two straight lines between the eyebrows," Jogi instructs her friend poised with a sewing needle. "Now insert the needle along the lines - but slowly, until it bleeds." Six-year-old Pooja barely winces as dotted circles and triangles are tattooed onto her chin and forehead. On the outskirts of the rural town of Umerkot in Sindh province, her seven-year-old sister Champa declares eagerly beside her that "I am ready too". In recent years, however, as rural Hindu communities in Muslim-majority Pakistan become more connected to nearby cities, many young women have opted out of the "old ways". "These signs set us apart from others," said 20-year-old Durga Prem, a computer science student who grew up in the nearby city of Badin. "Our generation doesn't like them anymore. In the age of social media, young girls avoid facial tattoos because they think these marks will make them look different or unattractive." Her sister Mumta has also refused to accept the tattoos that mark their mother and grandmothers. "But if we were still in the village, we might have had these marks on our faces or arms," she reflects. Just two percent of Pakistan's 240 million people are Hindu, and the majority live in rural areas of southern Sindh province. Discrimination against minorities runs deep and Hindu activist Mukesh Meghwar, a prominent voice for religious harmony, believes younger generations do not want to be instantly identified as Hindu in public. Many Muslims believe tattoos are not permissible in Islam, and even those who have them rarely display them in public. "We can't force our girls to continue this practice," Meghwar told AFP. "It's their choice. But unfortunately, we may be the last generation to see tattoos on our women's faces, necks, hands, and arms," he said. Few Hindus that AFP spoke with recalled the meaning behind the practice of tattoos or when it began, but anthropologists believe it has been part of their cultural heritage for hundreds of years. "These symbols are part of the culture of people who trace their roots to the Indus civilisation," anthropologist Zulfiqar Ali Kalhoro told AFP, referring to a Bronze Age period that pre-dates modern religion. "These 'marks' were traditionally used to identify members of a community" and to "ward off evil spirits", he adds. Admiring the work on the grinning faces of the two little sisters, elder Jogi agreed that it was an ancestral tradition that enhanced the beauty of women. "We don't make them for any specific reason - it's a practice that has continued for years. This is our passion," she told AFP. The marks that begin dark black quickly fade to a deep green colour, but last a lifetime. "They belong to us," said Jamna Kolhi, who received her first tattoos as a young girl alongside Jogi. "These were drawn by my childhood friend -- she passed away a few years ago," 40-year-old Jamna Kolhi told AFP. "Whenever I see these tattoos, I remember her and those old days. It's a lifelong remembrance." Artist Guddi Manthar inks a tattoo onto the face of seven-year-old Champa AFP Aklan Jogi shows off her tattoos -- a dying art in a Hindu-majority district of Pakistan AFP The tattoo ink is made by grinding charcoal powder into goat milk AFP
Int'l Business Times
2 days ago
- Int'l Business Times
HK Scientist Puts Hope In Nest Boxes To Save Endangered Cockatoos
Above the teeming shopping streets of Hong Kong's Causeway Bay district, a fight to save one of the world's most endangered species is unfolding high in the branches of a decades-old cotton tree. Nestled among its sprawling boughs is a nest box designed for the yellow-crested cockatoo, of which only 1,200 to 2,000 remain in the world. Although the birds are native to East Timor and Indonesia, one-tenth of those left are found in Hong Kong -- the "largest cohesive remaining wild population" globally, according to Astrid Andersson, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Hong Kong. Their future now hangs in the balance, due to habitat loss and, some suspect, a black market for the rare birds. The cockatoos' numbers have stagnated, with far fewer juveniles than when Andersson began monitoring almost 10 years ago. The birds don't make their own nests but depend on natural cavities in trees -- about 80 percent of which have vanished in recent years, because of typhoon damage and government pruning. The nest boxes set up by Andersson are an attempt to rectify this, designed to resemble the hollows sought out by the birds. She plans to place about 50 around the city. "Without the nest boxes, I believe that the cockatoos will have fewer and fewer opportunities to increase or replace individuals that die in their population," she said. The boxes will also allow observation of their reproductive behaviour, which has never been comprehensively studied. The cockatoos' existence in Hong Kong has been "a very positive story about human-wildlife coexistence", said Andersson. The population in Hong Kong is an introduced one, with one urban legend recounting they originated from an aviary set free by the British governor of Hong Kong before surrendering to the Japanese in 1941. There is no evidence to support that story, however -- the modern flock's ancestors are in fact believed to be escaped pets. Hong Kong's urban parks, full of mature trees bearing fruit, nuts and other food, became a "sanctuary" for them, Andersson said. The cockatoos are now part of the city's fabric, their loud squawks echoing through the sky at nightfall. Perched on streetlights, they sit calmly observing the humming traffic along city flyovers. Many people don't realise they are looking at an endangered species in their neighbourhood. "We genuinely thought they were just like an average parakeet," resident Erfan, who lives near a flyover, told AFP. Yellow-crested cockatoos are often mistaken for sulphur-crested cockatoos, commonly found in Australia rummaging through bins. The two are genetically distinct though, and the Australian species is not endangered. Merchants at Hong Kong's bird market certainly know the difference. When AFP visited, sulphur-crested cockatoos were openly displayed, while yellow-crested ones were only shown upon request. A one-year-old bird was being sold for a whopping HK$56,000 ($7,000), while a two-month-old chick could sell for HK$14,000. It has been illegal since 2005 to trade wild-caught yellow-crested cockatoos. Selling ones bred in captivity is allowed, but the breeders must have valid licences under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). There are no such registered breeders in Hong Kong. Sharon Kwok Pong, founder of Hong Kong Parrot Rescue, believes there may be a "black market". "There have been people that find out where these birds are, they raid them," she told AFP. Captive-bred cockatoos should have a ring on their leg and documentation proving their origin, but these can be falsified. "I think we need a crackdown," Kwok said. "If you want to protect a species, so unique in this environment, I think a lot of things need to fall into place." Andersson has developed a forensic test that analyses a cockatoo's diet to determine whether it was recently taken from the wild. She hopes this will help enforce the ban on illegal sales. In their native habitats, poaching, rapid habitat loss and climate change have devastated the cockatoos' numbers. The financial hub's birds may one day be able to help revive them. "Hong Kong's population could have genetic lineages that are now gone," she said. It could function "as a backup population for the wild Indonesian counterparts". Sharon Kwok Pong, founder of the Hong Kong Parrot Rescue, showing a leg ring bearing the birth date of "Winnie", a rescued yellow-crested cockatoo AFP Sharon Kwok Pong, founder of Hong Kong Parrot Rescue, believes there may be a "black market" for yellow-crested cockatoos in Hong Kong AFP Inforgraphic map showing the habitat of the critically endangered yellow-crested cockatoos AFP Several yellow-crested cockatoos resting atop a light pole in the Sai Ying Pun neighbourhood in Hong Kong AFP Yellow-crested cockatoos don't make their own nests but depend on natural cavities in trees -- about 80 percent of which have vanished in recent years, because of typhoon damage and government pruning AFP Two yellow-crested cockatoos resting atop a statue in Hong Kong Park AFP
