Labour should allow debate about racism
I was Channel 4's commissioning editor, co-conceiving the format and mission of Devil's Advocate. It set out to challenge Black nationalism, which Darcus spent his life opposing, in his dedication to the postcolonial development of multi-ethnic Britain.
As Jason contends, Diane simply pointed to the fact that the racism the Black population of Britain faces through skin colour is different from the undoubted discrimination experienced by other communities. Her suspension is a mystery. Diane has in fact pointed to something that Labour needs to address urgently. What precisely is the distinction between anti-Netanyahu-Zionism and antisemitism? What precisely do Black youths on the streets being challenged by the police face that white youths don't?
The work of the Darcus Howe Legacy Collective continues Darcus's championing of social justice, equality and representation to provide a framework for debate and understanding of current racial and social issues. Is the Labour government unable to recognise the distinctions, formulations and policies that should follow what Diane has so modestly pointed out?
If Devil's Advocate were still broadcast today, we'd invite Diane and Keir Starmer to examine why pointing out an obvious truth entails suspension from the very party that keeps us from the disaster of the Tories and the death wish of Reform. Farrukh DhondyThe Darcus Howe Legacy Collective
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
21 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Pressure on Australia as allies to recognise state of Palestine; Thorpe condemns deaths in custody; and a big stick insect
Good afternoon. Pressure is growing for Australia to recognise a Palestinian state, after Canada announced it would join key allies France and the UK to formally recognise Palestine at the next UN general assembly meeting in September. The Canadian prime minister, Mark Carney, told reporters that the planned move was predicated on the Palestinian Authority's commitment to reforms, including fundamentally reforming its governance and holding general elections in 2026 in which Hamas can play no part. Carney also said Hamas must release all hostages. The UK's announcement was also conditional, with Keir Starmer saying recognition would occur by September unless Israel held to a ceasefire, calling for the nation to commit to a two-state solution. Jim Chalmers, said he won't put a timeframe on Australian recognition of Palestine but said it's 'a matter of when, not if' it happens, while the Greens called for recognition as soon as possible. The Liberal senator James Paterson said Australia should not follow other countries based on an 'artificial measure of momentum'. Bruce Lehrmann claims police destroyed exonerating evidence and pending rape trial should be abandoned, court hears After-school carer charged with producing child abuse material at six facilities across northern Sydney Sam Groth's wife Brittany publicly defends couple's relationship as they threaten legal action against minister Helen Garner praises 'serious and sensitive' Dua Lipa after musician adds Australian author to her book club FBI opens first office in New Zealand 'to counter China and cybercrime' Fears for South Australia's annual cuttlefish gathering amid deadly algal bloom A newly discovered stick insect which weighs slightly less than a golf ball may be the heaviest insect in Australia, scientists say. The new species, named Acrophylla alta, was found in the high altitudes of the Atherton tablelands in north Queensland – and scientists said the habitat could be part of the reason for its large size. Watch the video here 'These are not just statistics. They are sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, cousins, siblings, grandchildren – lost to a system that continues to harm our people.' – Lidia Thorpe The Victorian independent senator condemned the 'shameful' number of Indigenous deaths in custody, including 17 this year, as the latest figures show just four of 19 Closing the Gap targets are on track to be met. Thorpe moved a condolence motion in the Senate, supported by Labor and the Greens, extending sympathies to the families of the 17 First Nations people who have died in custody this year and urging all parliamentarians to prevent further deaths in custody. Guardian Essential report: Albanese starts second term with solid approval, but Trump presidency looms – Australian Politics podcast As Anthony Albanese readies his second‑term reform agenda, Guardian Australia's Josh Butler speaks with Essential Media's Peter Lewis about the elephant in the room: Australia's dependence on the US and how its high‑stakes defence gambles could shape both his leadership and the nation's strategic future. Listen to the episode here Sign up to Afternoon Update Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Cloudbreak, near the island of Tavarua in western Fiji, is one of the best waves in the world. For decades, the long, hollow left-hand reef break has drawn surfers from around the globe; but until 2010, local surfers were forbidden from surfing the wave due to an exclusivity deal with a nearby surf resort. A decade and a half since Fiji's cabinet made all surfing areas open to the public, 16-year-old James Kusitino has just become Fiji's first professional surfer. Today's starter word is: IFF. You have five goes to get the longest word including the starter word. Play Wordiply. Enjoying the Afternoon Update? Then you'll love our Morning Mail newsletter. Sign up here to start the day with a curated breakdown of the key stories you need to know, and complete your daily news roundup. And follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. If you have a story tip or technical issue viewing this newsletter, please reply to this email. If you are a Guardian supporter and need assistance with regards to contributions and/or digital subscriptions, please email
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Andrew Bailey rests between us and reckless Reeves
The Chancellor and the governor of the Bank of England have had several disagreements over the past year. But their latest bust-up has crossed the line into intervention. Andrew Bailey shut down a meeting that Rachel Reeves had attempted to procure between the Treasury, the Bank's Prudential Regulation Authority and burgeoning challenger bank, Revolut, to try to hurry the authorisation of its banking licence. People familiar with the matter said the move to cancel the meeting was made over concerns the Bank's regulation should be independent from political interventions. They are absolutely correct, and this flagrant attempt from Reeves to force her 'growth at all costs' agenda at the expense of independence should be admonished. Despite its relative novelty, central bank independence is sacrosanct to the Western world. Even Donald Trump, who has persistently shown disregard for financial markets, has so far been forced to renege on his various attempts to replace the Federal Reserve chair, Jerome 'Mr Too Late' Powell, for fear of bond vigilante retribution. Here in the UK, it was Gordon Brown who finally brought about operational independence for the Bank of England, a policy that arrived surprisingly late in 1997. Ever since, it has been one of the few sacred cows of British politics, with parliamentarians of all stripes understanding the value of a credibly independent central bank. Given the policy's architect, it is all the more surprising that it is Rachel Reeves, who famously had a framed picture of Brown in her university bedroom, launching so many skirmishes against her former employer. I've written recently on Reeves's susceptibility to promises of growth, but this latest personal attempt to strong-arm the regulator into rushing its processes is a worrying step. This has nothing to do with my opinion on Revolut, but it is not a good look for the Chancellor to be seen to be effectively lobbying on the behalf of a private business. It will likely wind up an embarrassing and futile moment for Reeves, who has clearly made the move in a last-ditch effort to get Revolut to pick London when it eventually lists on a stock exchange. The bank has already expressed its preference to list in the US, with its co-founder expressing that he did not 'see the point' of listing in London. The news comes the same month that Bailey told the Treasury Select Committee in no uncertain terms that he disagreed with Reeves's assertion that regulation is 'the boot on the neck' of business. The FT reported his opinion was a touch stronger away from the cameras, with a colleague of his saying he was 'really p----d off' over the comments. There is certainly room for reforming the regulatory landscape in this country, but Reeves seems to be taking the Elon Musk approach of pulling out plugs and hoping it doesn't break. Bailey is not without his faults, but currently he seems to be the only person who remembers why we put some of this regulation in place to begin with. Another example is the huge clamour from the major UK banks to do away with ring-fencing, the regime that separates their retail operations from their investment banks. Reeves seems once again to have listened to whatever the City says it wants, and is open to such a move. But this regulation was imposed with good reason after the global financial crisis and should not be trifled with lightly. There may well be elements that can be improved, or even cause to scrap it, but this should be investigated from a more sensible standpoint than 'any regulation stifles growth'. I don't envy Reeves. The country has stagnated since 2010, and has been hit with several once-in-a-generation events. At each attempt to cut spending, she has been forced into a climbdown by a fearful Sir Keir Starmer, which has forced her hand into looking for a way to improve the nation's lot elsewhere. But while Starmer has been wrong to stand in her way on many occasions, Bailey is proving to be a rare voice of reason. Yes, Britain is stagnating and has been for a long time. We need to spur growth in this country, and regulations from planning to finance need to be tweaked. But tearing down the guardrails because nobody's fallen off the edge since you put them up isn't a plan for growth – it's a recipe for disaster.
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Khan under pressure after slump in London's new homes
Sir Sadiq Khan is facing calls to water down his affordable housing targets amid a slump in the number of new homes in London. Figures from the National House Building Council (NHBC) showed that just 904 new homes were registered in London in the second quarter, down by 59pc from the same period last year. That marks the weakest second-quarter performance for at least 15 years. Registrations stood at just under 7,000 in the same period a decade ago. The NHBC blamed mounting costs required to fix fire safety defects on high-rise buildings after new laws came into effect to prevent a Grenfell-style cladding disaster. It also cited a depressed level of activity from housing associations. However, developers are understood to be concerned that the Mayor of London's strict affordable homes quotas are fuelling the problem and are lobbying Sir Sadiq to water down the targets. The Mayor has set private housebuilders a target of ensuring 35pc of homes within each development are affordable, which in itself was a climbdown from an initial manifesto pledge of 50pc. Housebuilders say the 35pc target is too high and makes it difficult to turn a profit. Housebuilders argue that overly ambitious and inflexible targets have stymied building, with many developments not getting off the ground at all. Bosses are understood to be pushing for the affordability quota to be lowered to 25pc, according to sources close to the situation. One source said: 'If the Mayor continues to insist on 35pc, he'll get 35pc of nothing, so surely it's better to get a lower percentage of something.' Developers are also frustrated with a rule that means the Mayor can take the majority of profits made at developments where less than 35pc of homes are affordable. Affordable home starts last year were at their second-lowest level since 2008. Construction began on 3,991 affordable homes in the year ending March 2025, showing improvement from the previous year's record low of 2,358, but still well below average. In 2023, Sir Sadiq promised a 'golden era of council housebuilding' after being handed £4bn by the previous Conservative government for his affordable homes programme. This was topped up with £100m from Rachel Reeves in last year's Budget and another £60m earlier this year. But the Mayor has come under fire for the sluggish progress, with Kevin Hollinrake, the shadow housing secretary, branding the pace of construction 'catastrophic'. Official figures show work began on just work began on just 1,100 new homes in London during the first three months of the year. Sir Sadiq has an overarching target to build 88,000 homes a year in the capital.
