Scots primary school head under fire after branding Union flag 'offensive or sectarian'
The letter which leaked on social media showed the head raising concerns about the UK's national flag being displayed at an event for parents and guardians.
A major row has erupted at a Scots primary school after its headteacher branded the Union flag"potentially offensive or sectarian" i n a letter to parents.
The letter which leaked on social media showed the head raising concerns about the UK's national flag being displayed at an event for parents and guardians.
As the Scottish Daily Express reports, the incident unfolded at Cross Arthurlie Primary School in East Renfrewshire with the correspondence signed by the headteacher Fiona MacDonald.
The official school communication has now gone viral sparking a response from Scots Tory politicians who branded the letter"daft".
The criticism has forced council chiefs into an apology over the letter, with education bosses sorry for any "offence and upset" that has been caused.
In the letter, the head told families of P7 leavers that the use of a Union flag in images may have been a "mistake." Writing. "Thank you for coming along last night to make the P7 leavers a special event in the life of the school. The children looked fantastic and had a great time.
'Unfortunately the use of the Union flag with staff images on caused some upset at the beginning of the evening. As a school we promote inclusion and acceptance, actively working against potentially offensive or sectarian messaging. Although we recognise this was not the intent we are concerned that others within or beyond the school community may consider that this is something we would encourage.
'I hope this helps everyone understand where mistakes have been made and we can move on enjoying the rest of the end of term celebrations.' East Renfrewshire Council confirmed that the letter is genuine.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Former Scottish Tory leader Jackson Carlaw, who represents Eastwood in East Renfrewshire, blasted the comments as "deeply offensive." He said: "Let me be clear – to equate the Union Flag with sectarianism is totally unacceptable and deeply offensive to people both locally and across Scotland.
'Having spoken with a senior official at @EastRenCouncil this morning, I expect an urgent response, resolution, and retraction. As a start, the council must issue an unconditional apology. Our national flag is not up for debate – it is a symbol of our tradition, unity as a nation and hope for so many.'
A East Renfrewshire spokesperson said: 'It was not the school's intention to imply the Union flag is sectarian and both the Head Teacher and the council apologises for any offence and upset that has been caused to pupils, parents and carers and the wider community.
'All educational establishments in East Renfrewshire should be spaces that are focused on learning, unity, and pride in a diverse British society. We expect our schools to foster an ethos of respect for diverse perspectives and national identity.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
John Swinney is resetting Scotland's public services - but why has he waited 18 years?
Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... It has been a hard ten days for John Swinney. Not only did his party lose a key by-election to Labour, but he has faced repeated calls to step aside as SNP leader. He insists he is going nowhere and has now announced a massive overhaul of public services. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Modern, accessible, flexible, responsive and seamless'. This is the First Minister's vision for Scottish public services and it will be hard to find anyone who does not share this dream. First Minister John Swinney spoke at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow. | Robert Perry/Press Association Mr Swinney set out his hopes going forward in a speech at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow on Monday. Despite the speech being 30 minutes long, there was not a lot of specific detail on what will be changing on the back of this reset. What we do know is the Government will be placing a greater emphasis on technology in public services, particularly AI. Let us take the NHS as an example. Mr Swinney said the Government will use technology to make it easier to manage appointments, make it simple to access test results, and give patients digital tools to lead a healthier life. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He said: 'Scotland's public sector should have a digital doorway that matches the very best in the commercial world - that ambition will drive our actions ahead.' Despite the lack of clear detail, he made a big deal out of this speech. Around 100 people were invited along to listen, his deputy Kate Forbes officially introduced him to the podium, and almost all of Mr Swinney's Cabinet secretaries were in tow in a show of strength. However, after 17 years in government, the nationalists have a stumbling block - people are struggling to believe him. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The audience in Glasgow seemed to be fans of what Mr Swinney had to say, agreeing with him that a reset was essential for the nation's future. The problem is they also indicated they had heard it all before. One said she was 'delighted' with the contents of Mr Swinney's speech, but questioned how all of it would be funded as her organisation had bared the brunt of funding gaps before. Another said his speech was 'music to my ears', but was concerned about how it would all actually work in reality. A third audience member said: 'I welcome everything you've said today, but would echo comments made by others that the reality is feeling quite different.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad This is the key challenge the SNP Government will need to grapple with over the next 11 months if they are to convince Scottish voters to re-elect them for an unprecedented fifth time. Despite this, Mr Swinney insists this reset of how the Government manages public services is not a panicked reaction to losing the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election. When asked by The Scotsman after his speech if this was all just a knee-jerk reaction, he said: 'No - it's about setting out the policy direction, which will shape a number of documents the government has always got to put to Parliament.' Mr Swinney added: 'What I wanted to do today was set out the factors that have got to be addressed, which is about creating long-term sustainability in public services.'
Edinburgh Reporter
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Scotland 2050 – First Minister to address conference in Edinburgh
At the Scotland 2050 conference on Tuesday First Minister, John Swinney, will outline his vision for an independent Scotland. Addressing a mixed audience of public, private and third sector, academia and politicians, the First Minister is expected to say: 'It is only by taking charge of our own destiny, with our own hand on the tiller, that we are better able to ride the waves of change, that we are better able to shape our own future. 'I have long believed that Scotland is an afterthought to successive UK governments. Scotland is not on Westminster's radar in the same way, say, as London, the Midlands or the Southeast. 'It holds us back in ways big and small, leaving us waiting and praying, hoping that decisions taken at Westminster are not too damaging. 'We are prey to a broken system and a failing economic model – a system that delivers for a very few at the very top, while living standards stagnate and real wages are squeezed for the vast majority. 'All this when we have the capacity to stand and flourish on our own two feet. 'Independence is the defining choice for this generation, have no doubt. Because the UK status quo has proved itself incapable of delivering on the hopes and ambitions of the people of Scotland. That is why, like a clear majority of Scots, I believe that our nation should have the right to choose. 'A Scotland that is modern, dynamic and forward-looking, living in anticipation of what more can be done, what else can be achieved. Moving forward as one, moving forward with hope and self-belief. 'Such a Scotland is within reach, I have no doubt. But if we want it, we have to work for it, we have to vote for it, we have to actively, purposefully, and I hope also joyfully, make it happen.' The First Minister will be accompanied by the Deputy First Minister, Kate Forbes who is also Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic. Other political leaders including the Scottish Labour leader, Anas Sarwar, Alex Cole Hamilton MSP, Leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats will also attend as well as Cherie Blair, KC, Founder of the Cherie Blair Foundation for Women. The conference aims to 'foster an ambitious and forward-thinking atmosphere, allowing participants to dream big and set out challenging and credible paths towards the future of Scotland. 'By bringing together leading thinkers from civil society, industry, academia, and policy, Scotland 2050 will provide a space for creative and informed debate on the big ideas of today and the road to tomorrow.' The conference is sold out and will take place at Assembly Rooms. © 2025 Martin McAdam Like this: Like Related
The National
an hour ago
- The National
While Gaelic is lauded, why have the SNP Government ignored Scots?
However, while this momentous occasion has been lauded by the Scottish Government's communications team, the focus has been largely on the bill's implications for Gaelic. Statements about its importance were published by Gaelic poet Peter Mackay and Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes. While, perhaps unsurprisingly, Mackay's focus was on Gaelic, Scots had also been entirely left out of the equation by Forbes. As a Scots language author and advocate, this was of huge personal concern. As famously noted in Iain Crichton Smiths' poem, The Beginning of a New Song, which was read at the Scottish parliament in 1999 and more recently by Billy Kay in 2022, we are a "three-voiced" country. This needs to be at the forefront of public consciousness ahead of the new bill hopefully becoming an act. Broadcaster Billy Kay (Image: NQ archive) While Scots and Gaelic have both been supported by the Government, Gaelic has received significantly more funding. A Freedom of Information request published in March showed that while Gaelic initiatives had a budget of at least £28 million between 2021 and 2023, Scots initiatives received just £448,000 of support – a figure that was increased to £553,500 in the year 2023 to 2024. This discrepancy was also reflected in the Government's most recent press release about the need to strengthen Gaelic and Scots legislation. Despite it mentioning both languages, the focus was almost entirely on Gaelic, and the bill giving Scottish parents the option to put their children into Gaelic schools. But what about Scots-medium schools? While they have been considered as part of the bill, this information has been absent from reports, even though the most recent Scotland census had the highest-ever number of people reporting an understanding of the language – a whopping 2.4 million compared to the 136,000 people who reported an understanding of Gaelic. READ MORE: 5 lost Gaelic words and phrases rediscovered by linguists in Scotland Unfortunately, I think we are a long away from Scots schools existing, as much as I think support for schools in both languages is ultimately needed. But it is a point worth making – as is the need for a Scottish Higher and National Five, which will hopefully be finally made a reality by the bill. Formal qualifications in Gaelic have existed for years, but this has notably not been the case for Scots, potentially preventing millions of Scottish children from getting a qualification in their native tongue. Even in the Government's overview of the bill, the focus remains on Gaelic, which is notably placed above Scots even in order. This sadly emphasises the status of Scots even within Scotland's indigenous languages – because it is a sister language to English, and therefore characterised by a degree of mutual intelligibility, it has struggled to be taken seriously as a language in its own right. That is despite having every characteristic of an independent language and not a dialect, as it is wrongfully often classified. READ MORE: Tories rage as Scottish primary head suggests Union flag is 'sectarian' Any talk of the potential introduction Scots language road sign, for example, has been met with horror online, despite Gaelic signage being commonplace in Scotland. The protection of indigenous languages might seem trivial amid issues like the cost of living crisis and, more recently, the widespread onset of artificial intelligence, I'm here to stress that this only makes them more important. Languages connect communities, past and present, especially in a wee country, and protecting Scotland's indigenous languages will hopefully give us more opportunities and a sense of identity that has been historically denied, especially to Scots speakers. While I have been critical of the Government's public focus on Gaelic, it is worth noting that the press releases about the Scottish Languages Bill were written in our nation's three native languages – English, Gaelic and Scots. Now, we can only hope that such practices become normalised, which will ensure our tongues are finally moving towards an equal footing.
