Which is Better for Adults with ADHD: Strattera or Adderall?
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is not just a childhood condition; it affects millions of adults worldwide, impacting their ability to focus, manage time, stay organized, and complete tasks. When it comes to treatment, medication often plays a central role. Two commonly prescribed medications for adults with ADHD are strattera vs adderall. Each of these drugs works differently and carries unique benefits and risks. This article will compare Strattera and Adderall to help you understand which may be a better choice for adults managing ADHD.
When it comes to treating anxiety and depression, patients often face the decision between different medications. Among the most commonly prescribed are lexapro vs zoloft, both selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs). While Lexapro (escitalopram) is often praised for its tolerability and simplicity with fewer drug interactions, Zoloft (sertraline) may be more suitable for certain anxiety disorders. Individual responses vary, making it important to work closely with a healthcare provider. Factors like side effects, dosage, and coexisting conditions influence the choice. Ultimately, the most effective treatment is the one tailored to the patient's unique mental health needs.
ADHD in adults can manifest differently than in children. While hyperactivity may decrease with age, difficulties with attention, executive functioning, and impulsivity often persist. Many adults struggle with procrastination, forgetfulness, restlessness, and difficulty sustaining focus. These symptoms can interfere with professional responsibilities, relationships, and daily life.
Treatment plans for adult ADHD often involve a combination of behavioral therapy, lifestyle adjustments, and medication. Among medications, stimulants like Adderall and non-stimulants like Strattera are the most commonly used.
Adderall is a stimulant medication that contains two types of amphetamine salts: dextroamphetamine and levoamphetamine. It works by increasing the levels of dopamine and norepinephrine in the brain—neurotransmitters that play a crucial role in attention and executive function.
Adderall is known for its fast-acting effects, typically beginning to work within 30 minutes to an hour of ingestion. It's available in both immediate-release (IR) and extended-release (XR) formulations, allowing flexibility in dosing and symptom management.
Strattera, on the other hand, is a non-stimulant medication that contains atomoxetine. It is a selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (NRI), meaning it increases norepinephrine levels in the brain without affecting dopamine to the same extent as stimulants.
Unlike Adderall, Strattera doesn't provide immediate relief. It often takes several weeks to reach full effectiveness. However, its non-stimulant nature makes it a valuable alternative for individuals who can't tolerate stimulants or have a history of substance abuse.
When comparing the effectiveness of Adderall and Strattera, research consistently shows that stimulants like Adderall are generally more effective at reducing core symptoms of ADHD. Adderall's impact is often more pronounced and immediate, making it a preferred first-line treatment.
However, Strattera still provides significant symptom relief for many patients. Its effectiveness may be particularly noticeable in individuals with comorbid anxiety disorders, as stimulants can sometimes exacerbate anxiety symptoms. While it may take longer to see results with Strattera, it remains a viable option for those who do not respond well to stimulants.
Adderall's onset of action is rapid, with effects beginning within an hour and lasting 4-6 hours for the IR form, and up to 12 hours for XR. This makes it easier for users to see immediate improvements in attention and productivity.
In contrast, Strattera requires consistent daily dosing for several weeks before benefits are fully felt. It does not have the same 'on-off' effect as Adderall, providing a more stable, round-the-clock control of symptoms without noticeable peaks or crashes.
Each medication comes with its own set of side effects. Adderall's side effects commonly include insomnia, loss of appetite, increased heart rate, dry mouth, and elevated blood pressure. There is also a potential for dependency, misuse, and withdrawal symptoms due to its stimulant nature.
Strattera's side effects tend to be milder but may include nausea, fatigue, dizziness, mood swings, and sexual dysfunction. It does not have the same risk for abuse or dependency, making it safer for individuals with a history of substance use disorders.
Both medications carry warnings about cardiovascular risks, particularly for those with pre-existing heart conditions. Additionally, both have potential psychiatric side effects, such as mood swings or increased risk of suicidal thoughts, especially in younger users. Regular monitoring and communication with a healthcare provider are essential.
Choosing between Strattera and Adderall often depends on an individual's medical history, lifestyle, and personal preferences. Adderall might be the better option for those who need fast and powerful symptom relief and do not have a history of substance abuse. It is often the first choice for adults who require strong focus for work or studies.
On the other hand, Strattera is better suited for adults who prefer a non-stimulant option, have co-occurring anxiety, or have conditions that make stimulant use risky. It's also ideal for those who prefer once-daily dosing without the potential highs and crashes associated with stimulants.
Long-term use of Adderall requires careful oversight due to the potential for tolerance and dependence. Some users may find that the medication becomes less effective over time, requiring dosage adjustments.
Strattera, with its non-stimulant profile, does not pose the same risk for addiction or tolerance, which makes it more appealing for long-term management. However, some patients may find its delayed onset and milder effects less satisfactory over the long haul.
Adderall, particularly the generic versions, is generally less expensive and more widely covered by insurance than Strattera. Strattera, being a brand-name drug for a long time, has historically been more expensive, though generic atomoxetine is now available, which helps reduce the cost burden.
That said, the true cost of treatment also includes factors like side effects, missed work due to unmanaged symptoms, and the time it takes to find the right medication and dosage. A cheaper medication that doesn't work well is not necessarily the more affordable option in the long run.
So, which is better for adults with ADHD—Strattera or Adderall? The answer is: it depends. If you're looking for fast, effective relief and don't have contraindications for stimulant use, Adderall is typically more effective. If you have a history of substance abuse, struggle with anxiety, or are sensitive to stimulants, Strattera may be the safer and more sustainable choice.
The best course of action is to work closely with a healthcare provider, ideally one experienced in treating adult ADHD. A trial-and-error approach is often necessary to find the most effective medication with the fewest side effects. In some cases, combining medication with therapy or coaching provides the best outcomes.
ADHD in adults can be a challenging condition to manage, but the right medication can make a significant difference in quality of life. Both Adderall and Strattera offer unique benefits and drawbacks, and the best option depends on individual circumstances. Whether you opt for the fast-acting power of Adderall or the steady, non-stimulant support of Strattera, a thoughtful, informed approach will help you make the best decision for your mental health and productivity.
TIME BUSINESS NEWS
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
7 Relationship Habits That Secretly May Be Signs Of ADHD
Do you find it difficult to focus on a task when your partner is talking to you? Do you go to bed much later than your partner? Do you take comments from your partner personally, even when they don't mean to criticize you? While everyone in relationships may experience these scenarios, when they happen often or to an extreme, they can be signs of ADHD (attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder). ADHD 'is not just a deficit of attention or someone being hyperactive … [it's] very much about self-management.' said Dr. Lidia Zylowska, associate professor at the University of Minnesota School of Medicine and author of 'The Mindfulness Prescription for Adult ADHD.' 'It's really a different way of experiencing … or reacting to the world.' ADHD affects a person's executive functions, which are skills in the brain that help plan, organize, prioritize, complete tasks and regulate emotions. 'All of these play into relationships and … dynamics between couples,' explained Sharon Saline, a clinical psychologist who specializes in ADHD. '[And] sometimes the partner who doesn't have ADHD assumes that the partner who does have ADHD is doing things on purpose that they're not [intentionally] doing.' It's important for both partners to understand each other so they can have compassion and build a strong relationship, Zylowska added. We talked to therapists about habits in relationships that could be signs of ADHD — and tips for both partners for working through their differences: You may have 'challenges with emotional regulation, [such as] losing your temper, being overwhelmed by anxiety [or] having big feelings that you struggle to rein in,' Saline said. This includes a 'low frustration tolerance,' explained Terry Matlen, psychotherapist, founder of ADDConsults and author of 'The Queen of Distraction.' For example, you may have a tantrum about something that seems trivial, like losing the TV remote. 'This can … cause … friction and anger in the [other] partner and embarrassment in the person with ADHD,' she said. It's important to recognize what your triggers are and how you respond to them, she advised. 'Instead of acting … out in ways that can hurt others, give yourself a timeout,' she said. 'Head to the bathroom or other quiet space, [and] talk it out to yourself: 'I'm really angry/upset/hurt because ….'' Deep breathing, taking a warm bath or journaling also can help you calm down. 'If it's too late and you've lost control, apologize to your partner and make a plan for how to manage this moving forward,' she said. A lot of people who have ADHD may experience rejection sensitive dysphoria, which is a 'hypersensitivity to rejection or negative feedback like criticism,' explained Billy Roberts, founder and clinical director of Focused Mind ADHD Counseling. 'You may be actually quite sensitive to how you are scanning and noticing what's happening in the relationship,' Zylowska said. The person with ADHD may perceive that someone is trying to hurt or reject them, even when that's not necessarily happening, Matlen added. The person who doesn't have ADHD may 'tiptoe around their partner' because they're afraid of hurting their feelings. The person with ADHD may shut down because they're anticipating rejection or overact when their partner really isn't trying to criticize, Roberts said. Just being aware of the fact that this can happen when you have ADHD and being able to talk about this with your partner can make a difference, he advised. You could say something like, 'I got the impression that you were mad at me when I said that I couldn't pick up the laundry. Can we talk through that?' Roberts explained. Also ask yourself, 'Am I inferring tone here … or did [my partner] explicitly criticize me?' While it can come from impulsivity, 'people with ADHD [may also] interrupt because they got really excited about something that they just heard,' said Marcy Caldwell, clinical psychologist and founder and director of The Center For ADHD. But the other partner may be thinking, 'You didn't care about what I had to say.' It can be helpful when the person with ADHD owns their behavior and says something like, 'I know I interrupt a lot, and I'm really sorry. … How does it feel to you?' she said. And explain the reason behind the behavior, whether you are wanting to add to what they're saying or don't want to forget something. There also are behavioral tips that work for some people to help them not interrupt, like sitting on their hands or writing a thought down instead of saying it verbally, she said. Matlen also recommends looking at the person's lips while they are talking to hold their attention. 'It engages more than one of our senses: visual and audio,' she said. 'Using a fidget can also work wonders to keep your mind sharp and attentive.' If the partner with ADHD is hyper-focused on something, they may have a difficult time being pulled away from that, Caldwell explained. 'Let's say the ADHD person is writing or working on something and the partner comes in to ask a quick question, that can lead to some irritability or … [the partner feeling completely ignored],' Caldwell said. 'It just is really hard for an ADHD brain to be taken off task.' She recommends that the person with ADHD use a visual cue when they need to focus, such as wearing headphones or closing the door. Explain to your partner that's a sign to please not interrupt you unless it's an emergency or something time-sensitive. Someone with ADHD may have a hard time feeling internally motivated to do a task or goal if it's not interesting or feels particularly overwhelming, Roberts explained. Their partner may perceive it as that they are intentionally not doing a task, but in reality, their brains are just processing it differently. 'A neurotypical brain tends to be motivated by important things and by priorities, [like] it's important to do the dishes at the end of the night,' Caldwell said, adding that someone with ADHD tends 'to be motivated by competition, novelty, interest and pressure.' For example, someone may wait until 'there are no clean dishes and then it feels important to clean.' Have a conversation with your partner about what they like to do and do well, and take that into account when you're both deciding how to divide up household tasks, Saline said. For instance, maybe one partner likes to cook while the other prefers to handle maintenance of the house. Using apps that gamify chores and setting reminder notifications also can help both partners stay on track, Caldwell added. Someone with ADHD often feels 'like evening is the time … to catch up on everything,' Zylowska said. 'When they do get in bed … they may have trouble unwinding and listen to music, scroll through their phone or watch TV.' This can cause issues if their partner goes to bed earlier and is a light sleeper or really cares about going to bed at the same time as their partner. 'The … partner may feel isolated and lonely, [and] sexual relations may become sporadic,' Matlen said. 'The noise of an active, awake partner [also] can create sleep issues for the [other person].' Matlen recommends setting time before bed to cuddle together, even if each partner goes to sleep at a different time. If the night owl is disturbing the sleep of the other person, some couples may decide on separate bedrooms and connect other times throughout the day. Or if it's important for them to be in bed at the same time, one person could use headphones or a reading light while the other sleeps, Zylowska said. 'Finding ways to accept each other's rhythms versus trying to force them out of it is the way to go,' Matlen said. 'The spontaneity, intensity and fun that [a person with ADHD] can bring to you as a couple can be incredibly refreshing,' Matlen said. For example, the person with ADHD may always be looking for creative date ideas or new hobbies to try with their partner, Caldwell said. Or maybe they suggest spontaneous ways to spice up their romance, like a foot massage or taking a bubble bath, Matlen added. '[Usually] we partner with people who bring something different than what we [do],' Caldwell said. And having an appreciation for this and how your strengths complement each other is an important foundation for a healthy relationship. 'Tossing' Could Be A Potential Sign Of ADHD. Do You Do It? 12 Things Not To Say To Someone Who Has ADHD We Have ADHD. These Are The Apps We Swear By.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Is Learned Helplessness Preventing You from Overcoming Trauma? A Therapist Explains
Learned helplessness. I'd heard the term before, but conflated it with weaponized incompetence, a phenomenon where someone (usually the male partner in a hetero relationship) exerts little or no effort in a task to avoid completing it and/or not being asked to do it again. (Think: the husband who 'doesn't know where the spoons go.') The more I read about learned helplessness, the more I realized these two concepts are the same. Learned helplessness is actually a body's response to trauma—not your toxic masculinity scheming to get out of dishwasher duty. So I spoke with a licensed social worker with over a decade of experience supporting individuals with PTSD, anxiety, depression and other conditions, to better understand what learned helplessness actually is and how to move past it to heal. Lesley Broff is a licensed social worker who graduated from The University of Pittsburgh with her Masters degree in Social Work. She has over 10 years of experience working in community mental health settings with adults with severe mental health diagnoses, adults with disabilities, and children, adults and families with conditions including anxiety, depression, PTSD, ADHD and Autism. Learned helplessness, Broff explains, 'stems from repeated experiences of perceived failure or adversity where nothing [a person has] tried seemed to make a difference.' Essentially, the social worker expands, it's when a person comes to believe they have no control over a situation, even when change is possible: 'In everyday life, it presents in things like giving up easily, not speaking up in challenging situations or assuming efforts won't lead to success—like a student who stops studying because past attempts didn't help, or someone who stays silent in meetings because they believe their voice won't matter.' Learned helplessness can sound like this: Trauma can teach the nervous system to give up. 'Trauma—especially the kind that's prolonged or feels inescapable—can literally rewire the nervous system to believe safety isn't possible,' Broff explains. 'Over time, disengagement or submission becomes a survival strategy.' For survivors of childhood abuse, domestic violence or chronic injustice, learned helplessness can settle in early. You try to fight back. You try to speak up. But when nothing changes—or worse, things escalate—your brain associates effort with futility. So, to survive, you must submit or disengage. 'Learned helplessness is the nervous system's way of saying, 'Survive now, heal later,'' says Broff. While staying small, quiet and helpless may be adaptive in the moment, 'problems arise when this protective strategy continues even after the threat is gone, making it harder to pursue change, growth or connection.' Everyone has rough weeks (or months). But learned helplessness is a pattern. 'If you're noticing a chronic belief that nothing you do will make a difference, across many parts of life—that's a signal,' says Broff. You may find yourself withdrawing from support, brushing off opportunities, or assuming the worst before you even try. It's not a failure of character—it's a conditioned response. Unlearning helplessness isn't about flipping a magical confidence switch. 'In therapy, we work on both thoughts and behaviors,' says Broff. 'We examine the beliefs that keep someone stuck, and we gently test them with small, manageable actions.' One of the most powerful disruptors to learned helplessness, she stresses, is also connection. 'Safe relationships help mirror back your capacity and your value,' says Broff. That could be a therapist, a friend, a support group—or even a familiar object that offers a sense of being held when people don't feel accessible. Broff mentions Percy the 3 Lb. Hug Bear , a sensory bear, which can offer grounding for those whose bodies still feel on high alert. Know this: it's not your fault. 'This way of thinking doesn't come from who you are—it comes from your nervous system, which was trained by your past to expect threats,' says Broff. 'But your past doesn't dictate your future.' Calling All People Pleasers: Here's Everything You Need to Know About Fawn Trauma Response, According to a Therapist
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
B.C. mom picks up her son's ADHD medication, is given an opioid instead
A mother on Vancouver Island is warning people to double check their prescriptions after she was accidentally dispensed the powerful opioid hydromorphone instead of her son's regular ADHD medication. Comox, B.C., resident Sarah Paquin, 31, says she still shudders to think about what could have happened to her nine-year-old son had her husband not noticed the medication looked different before he gave it to him. "It was terrifying," Paquin said, standing in her front yard and playing with one of her three boys. "One simple little mistake like that could have ended horribly." WATCH | 9-year-old dispensed opioid in pharmacy mix-up: Paquin says she didn't think too much of it when she went to pick up her son Declan's medication last week and the staff member at her local Shoppers Drug Mart pharmacy didn't check her ID or take out the prescription from the bag. The next day, her husband was about to give Declan his medication when he saw the pills were a different colour and shape than normal. Her husband looked at the bottle and noticed the prescription was for someone else, and that it was for hydromorphone. Right away he returned the pills to the pharmacy. "Immediately your mind goes to the worst case scenario," Paquin said. "The results could have been catastrophic and it just makes my heart sink to think about what could have happened." Hydromorphone is a powerful opioid that is two to eight times stronger than morphine and is often used to treat acute pain or chronic cancer pain. According to the Mayo Clinic, it can cause serious unwanted effects or fatal overdose in children. Human error CBC News reached out to Loblaws, the company that owns Shoppers Drug Mart. In a written statement, the company said the incident was a case of "human error" that never should have happened. "We have controls in place to minimize risks like this — where the patient was handed the wrong prescription bag — and the associate will review these with employees to avoid a similar situation in the future," the company said. Paquin says she has since heard from the pharmacist, who was very apologetic. She says he acknowledged that steps were missed and standards were dropped, and told her the employee who dispensed the medication has been suspended pending an internal investigation. Asking for accountability Despite his reassurances, Paquin has filed a complaint with the College of Pharmacists of B.C. "The pharmacy needs to take responsibility, be held accountable for what happened," she said. In an email, the college told CBC News it takes these types of errors very seriously. "We have legal requirements in the Health Professions Act bylaws in place to prevent these occurrences, including mandatory standards for prescription preparation to ensure accuracy of the prescription product and consultations for all prescriptions, to make sure clients understand their medication, how to take it properly, and address any questions," the college said. As part of pharmacists' consultation with clients, they are required to confirm the person's identity, name and the strength and purpose of the drug, it added. In 2023-24, the college says it received a total of 990 concerns through its intake process. Of those, 54 became formal complaints and investigations, 16 of which were medication related. Paquin decided to share her ordeal on social media, to warn others to check their prescription before taking it. "It's scary that it happened to us, but I'm also in a way kind of thankful that it happened to us and we caught it because it could have been given to somebody who didn't notice and got hurt," she said.
