Influencer drops lawsuit alleging rival creator copied her videos
Influencer Sydney Nicole Gifford said in a TikTok video on Thursday that she has withdrawn her lawsuit against fellow content creator Alyssa Sheil, ending a case that had become closely watched over its possible ramifications for the broader internet content ecosystem.
The move comes more than a year after Gifford first sued Sheil, claiming that Sheil had not just stolen the look and style of her videos but sometimes copied them down to the shot.
'She would change her hair soon after I changed mine and even got a similar tattoo after I posted mine, so in mirror photos where our faces were covered, it all of a sudden looked even more similar to me with that tattoo,' Gifford said in her TikTok video. 'I believe her intention was to look so similar to me and copy my posts so similarly so she could profit off my business.'
She also clarified her intention was not to sue simply over aesthetics, but rather over alleged 'copyright infringement, Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) violation, trade dress infringement, misappropriation, and vicarious copyright infringement.'
Arguments between influencers copying or stealing content from each other typically play out in the digital court of public opinion and rarely, if ever, make it to the actual judicial system. Aesthetics on social media are recycled and reinterpreted so often that it's nearly impossible to lay claim to owning a look or style online.
Gifford's lawsuit sought to take the issue into the courtroom, attempting to apply laws typically used by traditional media to the relatively lax world of influencer content.
The look at the heart of the now-dismissed suit is a minimalist, polished style that is sometimes referred to as the 'clean girl' aesthetic. Gifford, whose videos touch on everything from being a mother to fashion and shopping, has amassed more than 956,000 followers between her Instagram and TikTok accounts.
Sheil, who posts similar content, has more than 162,000 followers across her Instagram and TikTok.
Gifford said she sent many requests for Sheil to stop — from emails to cease-and-desist letters — before suing Sheil in April 2024.
Shahmeer Halepota, an attorney for Sheil, said Gifford walked away from the case with no settlement or financial compensation.
'Ms. Gifford's surrender and settlement for $0 confirms that her allegations were meritless and her claims of inventorship were worthless,' Halepota said.
Thomas Frashier, another attorney for Sheil, said his client has set a 'major precedent' for influencers and social media personalities.
'This is a huge win for content creators everywhere who shouldn't have to fear about being bullied out of the industry by the threat of meritless lawsuits like this one,' he said.
However, Gifford's attorney Kirsten Kumar said her client's case was not without merit, but that she simply didn't have the bandwidth to continue with the litigation.
'I have been working with Sydney since nearly the beginning of this case,' Kumar said. 'I know how strongly she feels about her claims and that the decision to stop litigating is not a reflection of their merit. But priorities can change: Since filing suit, she has gotten married, welcomed her first child and moved out of state.'
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
16 minutes ago
- The Hill
A quiet Tiananmen Square anniversary displays China's ability to suppress history
BEIJING (AP) — For most Chinese, the 36th anniversary of a bloody crackdown that ended pro-democracy protests in China passed like any other weekday. And that's just how the ruling Communist Party wants it. Security was tight Wednesday around Beijing's Tiananmen Square, where weeks of student-led protests shook the party in 1989. Under then-leader Deng Xiaoping, the military was sent in to end the protest on the night of June 3-4. Using live ammunition, soldiers forced their way through crowds on the streets that tried to block them from reaching the square. Hundreds and possibly thousands of people were killed, including dozens of soldiers. The party has tried, with some success, to erase what it calls the 'political turmoil' of 1989 from the collective memory. It bans any public commemoration or mention of the June 4th crackdown, scrubbing references from the internet. In recent years, that ban has been extended to Hong Kong, where a once-massive annual candlelight vigil is no longer permitted. A former district council member, Chan Kim-kam, said customs officers questioned her at her shop on the eve of June 4 after she advertised small white candles for sale in an Instagram post titled, 'June, we don't forget.' It is only in Taiwan, a self-governing island that is claimed by China but runs its own affairs, that large June 4 gatherings can still take place. Tiananmen Square is a vast open space in the center of Beijing with monumental, communist-era buildings along two of its sides and the mausoleum of Mao Zedong, who founded the communist era in 1949, on the south end. University students occupied this symbolically important site in the spring of 1989. Their calls for freedoms divided the party leadership. In retrospect, the decision to send in the troops marked a decisive turning point in the evolution of modern China, keeping the party firmly in control as it loosened economic restrictions. Chinese officials have said the country's rapid economic development since then proves the decisions made at the time were correct. 'On the political turmoil that happened in the late 1980s, the Chinese government has already reached a clear conclusion,' Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said Wednesday. He added that China would continue along its current path of what it calls 'socialism with Chinese characteristics.' Tiananmen Mothers, a group formed by relatives of the victims, made an annual online appeal to the government. Signed by 108 members, it called for an independent investigation into what happened on June 4, 1989, including a list of all who died. The group also demanded compensation for the families and a legal case against those responsible for the deaths. The British and German Embassies in Beijing posted videos commemorating the anniversary on Weibo, a Chinese social media platform, but they were later taken down, presumably by censors. The Canadian and German Embassies displayed images of a single lit candle on large screens facing the main street. In Hong Kong, a carnival showcasing Chinese food and products was held in Victoria Park, where tens of thousands of people used to gather in the evening for a candlelight vigil to mark the anniversary. Hong Kong authorities first shut down the vigil during the COVID-19 pandemic and arrested the organizers in 2021. The moves were part of a broader crackdown on dissent following monthslong anti-government protests in 2019 that turned violent and paralyzed parts of the city. 'You know, Hong Kongers have become silent lambs after 2019,' said King Ng, who was at the park on Wednesday. Police were out in force to try to prevent any protest. Activist Lui Yuk-lin was stopped at a subway station in Causeway Bay and brought to a police van. It wasn't clear if she had been arrested. Jailed vigil organizer Chow Hang-tung said she would go on a 36-hour hunger strike to remember the events of the day. The British and Canadian consulates posted social media messages about not forgetting June 4. Hong Kong was a British colony until 1997. The American consulate posted a message from U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio on its website. 'The CCP actively tries to censor the facts,' Rubio said, referring to China's Communist Party. 'But the world will never forget.' Taiwan's President Lai Ching-te used the anniversary to position the island he leads on the frontline of defending democracy against authoritarianism. In a Facebook post, he drew a distinction between Taiwan's multiparty democracy and China's one-party rule. 'Authoritarian governments often choose to remain silent and forget about history, while democratic societies choose to preserve the truth and refuse to forget those who have contributed to the ideals of human rights and the dreams they embrace,' Lai wrote. Taiwan transitioned from authoritarianism to democracy in a process that began in the late 1980s. It relies on support principally from the U.S., along with other democratic partners, to deter China from an invasion. The Communist Party says it favors peaceful reunification but doesn't renounce the use of force. A commemoration and candlelight vigil remembering June 4 was planned for Wednesday evening. ___ The year in which British colonial rule ended in Hong Kong has been corrected in this story to 1997. ___ Leung reported from Hong Kong.
Yahoo
21 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex shares rare photos of Lilibet in birthday post
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex has shared rare photos of her daughter, Lilibet, to mark the princess' fourth birthday. In one black-and-white picture, posted on Instagram on Wednesday, Meghan can be seen cuddling Lilibet, whose face is partially visible behind her mother's hand and arm. 'Happy birthday to our beautiful girl! Four years ago today she came into our lives – and each day is brighter and better because of it. Thanks to all of those sending love and celebrating her special day,' wrote Meghan in the caption. A second photo in the post shows Meghan cradling Lilibet, whose face is visible in profile, shortly after her birth. The princess was born on June 4, 2021, a year after the Duke and Duchess of Sussex stepped back from their roles as senior royals and moved to the United States. Meghan and husband Prince Harry are known to fiercely guard the privacy of Lilibet and older brother Prince Archie, 6. The couple did release a Christmas card last year that featured a rare photo of both children, but their backs are to the camera as they run towards their parents. Five other images appeared on the card, all depicting engagements from the year. It marked the first time since 2021 that Harry and Meghan released a Christmas card featuring their children. In April, Meghan revealed that she had suffered from postpartum preeclampsia, calling the potentially fatal condition 'so rare and so scary.' 'The world doesn't know what's happening quietly,' Meghan said on the debut episode of her 'Confessions of a Female Founder' podcast. 'And in the quiet, you're still trying to show up for people… mostly for your children, but those things are huge medical scares.' Most cases of postpartum preeclampsia develop within 48 hours of childbirth, but it can develop four to six weeks postpartum, according to the Mayo Clinic. Postpartum preeclampsia can cause seizures and other serious complications if left untreated. CNN's Issy Ronald contributed to this report.
USA Today
23 minutes ago
- USA Today
Online, young female OnlyFans stars make their lives look aspirational. Is it problematic?
Online, young female OnlyFans stars make their lives look aspirational. Is it problematic? Show Caption Hide Caption Bids for TikTok pile up, with Amazon and OnlyFans founder in the race As a weekend deadline to find a buyer for TikTok approaches, bids for the short video site are piling up. Among the latest to throw their hats in the ring are Amazon and a group lead by Tim Stokely, founder of adult content site OnlyFans. Reuters Inside a sprawling six-bed, five-bath property overlooking Miami's Biscayne Bay, a new legion of OnlyFans creators is taking hold. In a May 14 TikTok that's since racked up 4 million views, the house's residents dance in barely-there bodycon dresses in front of brightly lit signs spelling out "BOPS." In another, they don matching cheetah-print lounge sets over the soundtrack of Lil Elt's 'Get The Gat.' They fly on private jets to the Super Bowl, own Porsches and Lamborghinis and rack up $4,000 dinner bills on a night out. It's all in a month's work at the Bop House, a content creator mansion where eight Gen Z OnlyFans creators produce content for their combined following of nearly 90 million users across social media platforms. 'I love what I do, and it's so much fun,' says Sophie Rain, the 20-year-old who co-founded the Bop House in December 2024. After launching an OnlyFans two years ago, she quickly became one of its top earners, bringing in $43 million in her first year. 'It gave me so much freedom." The content creators, who say they collectively brought in $250 million last year, feel their lifestyle offers them financial stability and freedom. But teenagers, particularly young girls, who see TikToks showcasing the content creators' opulent lifestyle, may get the impression that being an OnlyFans star is aspirational. While creators in the Bop House spoke openly with USA TODAY about their hardships growing up — and say they're not trying to be anyone's role model — their online content rarely touches on their complex backstories. Intentional or not, those omissions create a disconnect with viewers who don't see the challenges that lead women to seek out careers in adult entertainment, says child psychiatrist and Yale School of Medicine Professor Yann Poncin. 'I do think it creates an unrealistic sense of reality,' Poncin says. 'This just really presents as an exciting lifestyle. These girls seem to have it together. They have things, they have money, they have the shining objects.' More: OnlyFans, AI and 'sexy selfies' are impacting girls. This author wrote a book about it. Who are the members of the Bop House? Rain founded the content creation house with Aishah Sofey, and other creators between the ages of 19 to 25 have since joined, including Camilla Araujo, Alina Rose, Summer Iris, Ava Reyes and Julia Filippo. They split the house's monthly $75,000 rent and use the space to film OnlyFans and social media content. Their posts toe the line between sensual and sexually explicit but never involve full nudity. The name 'Bop House' nods to the Gen Z slang term "bop," meaning a woman who has had many sexual partners. Many of their videos poke fun at the term, and they respond to commenters saying they should 'get a real job.' It was, in part, the critics that inspired Rose to move into a house with other content creators. "They're going to call us bops no matter what," she says. So they leaned into it. Rain grew up in a family of six that relied on food stamps. She's now their primary breadwinner. Fans pay $4.99 a month for her content, with the option to pay more for daily photos and messages. She paid off her parents' mortgage and $15,000 in property taxes and gifted her older brother his dream car, a BMW M2, with her salary. 'It's honestly very stressful,' Rain says of supporting her family. 'It's such a blessing in disguise, though, because they can come to me if they need anything.' Rain considers herself a feminist, and hopes the Bop House will help de-stigmatize adult entertainment creators. Still, every now and then, she hesitates to press 'post' knowing how young girls might interpret her videos. 'I definitely think heavy on that,' Rain says. She wants young girls to pause before jumping into OnlyFans, because it's a "big life change with a lot of stigma around it." Still, she hopes the Bop House will help decrease that stigma around being an adult content creator for future women. How the young people interpret social media, influencers Poncin says teenage years are a critical time when girls start developing their identity and determining who they are in relation to their larger peer group. Influencers and celebrities now play a part in shaping how teenagers perceive themselves. 'This is a time when you try on essentially different outfits of identity. 'Who am I? What am I? What am I becoming?'' Poncin says. Now, when he asks young people who they want to be when they grow up, 'influencer' is a common answer. Some of the commenters on the Bop House's TikTok account agree. 'I wanna be like you when I get older,' one follower wrote under a video of the women dancing. "I need to join the bop house,' said another. The hormonal and biological changes young women experience throughout their youth make them more attuned to social comparison, something social media can heighten as teens count their followers and likes. What the viral Bop house videos are leaving out Rose attributes her start on OnlyFans to a lack of options. After her mom kicked her out at 18 years old, she was paying her cousin $300 a month to sleep in a room she was sharing with two other people Los Angeles. She scraped by making $800 a month working dishwashing jobs but eventually took up stripping at a nude club, where she made better money. 'I didn't have money to pursue anything else. It was very depressing,' Rose says. When the strip club closed during the pandemic, she turned to OnlyFans. She says the platform provides a safer work environment than the strip club, where she faced daily sexual harassment. Still, it's not a field she would ever want her younger sister or any other young girl to get involved in. 'I'm not somebody that they should be influenced by or look up to, because I don't think OnlyFans is something that they should want to do,' Rose says. 'OnlyFans should only be a thing because they lack the resources, and they really need money.' Reyes says she considers her audience demographics when posting for that reason – on Instagram and Twitter, where her audience is largely men, she frequently posts photos in bikinis and lingerie but keeps her content more PG on TikTok, where she knows younger girls are seeing her videos. She tries not to spend too much time in her comment section and doesn't concern herself with online discourse about her work. 'I just don't even really think about it that deep,' Reyes says.' 'I don't really care about if other people think that it's wrong or right, I just live my life and make the money.' More: An OnlyFans model's viral documentary and why it sparked a major conversation about sex 'I want them to know that we're human' Since its founding in 2016, the market for OnlyFans has exploded. The platform brought in $6.63 billion in revenue and boasted 4.12 million creator accounts by the end of 2023, a 29% increase from the year prior, according to regulatory filings from its parent company. The platform is unique in that it doesn't have an explore page function. It requires fans to type in an OnlyFans creator's user in a search bar to find their content, posing a challenge to unknown creators looking to get their start on the platform. It's nearly impossible to gain new subscribers without already having a strong presence on Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter and TikTok. This shift marks a generational change in how adult content is consumed. Millennials and Gen Xers didn't get to know adult entertainers unless they were watching porn, but social media has peeled back the division between creators and their viewers. Rain considered herself a 'nobody' in high school who kept to herself, and is adjusting to the changes that came with being in the limelight. Before she started an OnlyFans, she had never traveled by airplane. One of her most exciting moments was using her OnlyFans profit to fund a two-week trip to Japan with her older brother. 'It's a sex website, but it's so much more than that,' Rain says. 'It's a way to get connected to people and try new things and see new things.' Rose doesn't want to be on the platform forever. Eventually, she plans to use her OnlyFans salary to take up professional gaming and singing full time. 'People really think that we're not real humans, just because we have OnlyFans, and they see us as less than a person,' Rose says. 'I want them to know that we're human.' Rachel Hale's role covering Youth Mental Health at USA TODAY is supported by a partnership with Pivotal Ventures and Journalism Funding Partners. Funders do not provide editorial input. Reach her at rhale@ and @rachelleighhale on X.
