Let's consciously uncouple from unreliable America
To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@theage.com.au. Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.
AUKUS
The AUKUS review is no surprise. We should review it too. AUKUS was a Scott Morrison thought bubble which resulted in a cost of $3.35billion to cancel the French submarines deal. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese kept the AUKUS strategy, so the Coalition could not brand Labor as being soft on defence. The cancelled deal impacted our relationship with France whose presence in the South Pacific make it an obvious partner for Australia.
The cost of AUKUS and the problems of nuclear waste, for which we have no infrastructure, were not considered. Since this decision, we have found the US under Trump is not a reliable ally.
War in the 21st century has dramatically changed. The Ukrainians who have virtually no navy have destroyed a third of Russia's Black Sea Fleet. The economics of war has changed. Cheap drones can destroy multi-million dollar aircraft ships and tanks. It's time to get out of AUKUS and plan for a 21st century war instead.
Peter Ramadge, Newport
Time for Australia to finally grow up
AUKUS: Absurdly Useless Kingsize Unrealisable Scheme. A more than 20 year gap before the highly questionable submarines could potentially arrive, with all their attendant risks, should alone alarm us. The change in military technology in that time is unimaginable. Submarines, nuclear or otherwise, could be obsolete by then. There is no plan B, and we will continue to pour huge amounts of money into a deal that America does not have to honour.
The US, Trump or no Trump, is not interested in our welfare any more, if indeed it ever was. It's high time for Australia to finally grow up, especially in the current world's hostile environment. After looking to Britain last century and then to America since the second world war, we have never seized our own sovereignty. It's time to stop focusing on the US whether in our defence policy or in any other global matter, especially now as we watch it implode. Listening to our 'in denial' politicians, Richard Marles in particular, invites despair.
Jill Toulantas, Clifton Hill
Why didn't ALP review AUKUS?
If, as Defence Minister Richard Marles says, it is normal for a new administration to review a big program such as AUKUS, why didn't he do that in 2022 when the ALP came into government?
Denny Meadows, Hawthorn
Trump is a symptom of America's decline
Emma Shortis (Opinion, ″ For Trump, LA is just the beginning. Soon, he'll monitor every move Americans make ″, 11/6) joins a growing group of observers calling for a rethink of our relationship with the US. Breaking up is hard to do, and most former partners accept that there are no cost-free breakups, but it is still possible to maintain a reasonable relationship. Of course there would be costs in reducing our traditional, but hazardous independence on America for security. However, any competent risk analyst would surely find that they were modest compared with our present course.
AUKUS submarines, expansion of Tindal airbase for strategic US bombers and upgrade of HMAS Stirling to host US nuclear submarines, for example, subordinate Australia to US foreign policy goals. A major goal is to contain China, our major trading partner, that has currently almost no incentive to attack Australia. If our experiences in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan have not demonstrated that today's US is not the country of the 1940s, then Donald Trump's reelection should.
He is a symptom of US decline, not a cause—and damning evidence that warnings from leaders such as Malcolm Fraser of an uncritical US alliance were prescient.
Norman Huon, Port Melbourne
Aukus savings
Perhaps Donald Trump might do us all a favour and kill the AUKUS agreement. It would free the government to invest in more conventional submarines for defending our coastline. Any savings could be used to mass produce and deploy missiles and drones.
The Ukrainian war demonstrates how effective drones can be as a weapon of war. The government could also use any savings from the AUKUS cancellation to invest in cybersecurity as cyber attacks would have the potential to bring transport, comm12unications, finance and supply chains to a dead halt.
However, I suspect these common-sense suggestions will be ignored by our political masters
Andrew Ferrier, West Launceston, Tas
THE FORUM
Researching bias
The Pew Research Centre polling has upset my assumption that almost no one in Australia would approve of Trump's presidency (' Australians on Trump: dumb, dangerous and dishonest ', 12/6. It is depressing, for example, to think that 28 per cent of Australian men have confidence in Trump. But probably fair enough. It confirms my own sampling. I don't have much confidence in 28 per cent of Australian men.
Bronwen Murdoch, South Melbourne
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
3 hours ago
- West Australian
Israel under attack as Iran launches retaliatory strikes with explosions heard in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem
Iran has launched retaliatory air strikes at Israel, with explosions heard in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, the country's two biggest cities, following Israel's biggest-ever military strike against Iran. Air raid sirens sounded across Israel as authorities urged the public to take shelter. Missiles were seen over Tel Aviv's skyline, with the military saying Iran had fired two salvos. The US military has helped shoot down Iranian missiles that were headed toward Israel, two US officials said on Friday. In the Tel Aviv area, Israel's ambulance service said five people were treated for shrapnel injuries. Live footage of Tel Aviv showed what appeared to be a missile hitting an urban area. A critically injured woman was admitted to Beilinson Hospital in nearby Petah Tikva, a hospital spokesperson said. Iranian state news agency IRNA said Iran launched hundreds of ballistic missiles at Israel after Israel blasted Iran's huge Natanz underground nuclear site and killed its top military commanders. Israel's military said Iran fired fewer than 100 missiles and most were intercepted or fell short. 'A limited number of buildings were affected, some of them as a result of shrapnel from the interception operations,' the Israeli military's Arabic-language spokesman Avichay Adraee said in a post on X Israel said its strikes were the start of 'Operation Rising Lion'. Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei accused Israel of having started the strikes and initiating a war. US President Donald Trump said it was not too late for Iran to halt the bombing campaign by reaching a deal on its nuclear program. As evening fell on Friday, Iranian media reported explosions on the northern and southern outskirts of Tehran and at Fordow, near the holy city of Qom, a second nuclear site which had been spared in the first wave of attacks. Air defences were activated across Tehran and explosions could be heard in Isfahan. Israel's military said it was striking Iranian missile and drone launching sites, and had struck another nuclear site in Isfahan. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the Israeli campaign was aimed at defeating an existential threat from Iran, invoking the failure to halt the Holocaust in World War II. Israel's operation 'will continue for as many days as it takes to remove this threat,' he said in a TV address. 'Generations from now, history will record our generation stood its ground, acted in time and secured our common future.' In a phone interview with Reuters, Trump said it was not clear if Iran's nuclear program had survived. He said nuclear talks between Iran and the United States, scheduled for Sunday, were still on the agenda although he was not sure if they would take place. 'We knew everything,' Trump said of the Israeli attack plans. 'I tried to save Iran humiliation and death. I tried to save them very hard because I would have loved to have seen a deal worked out,' Trump said. 'They can still work out a deal, however, it's not too late.' Earlier, Trump posted on Truth Social: 'Iran must make a deal, before there is nothing left.' Israel's National Security Adviser Tzachi Hanegbi said military action by itself would not destroy Iran's nuclear program but could 'create the conditions for a long-term deal, led by the United States' to get rid of it. Two regional sources said at least 20 Iranian military commanders were killed, a stunning decapitation reminiscent of Israeli attacks that swiftly wiped out the leadership of Lebanon's once-feared Hezbollah militia last year. Iran also said six of its top nuclear scientists had been killed. Among the generals killed on Friday were the armed forces chief of staff, Major General Mohammad Bagheri, and the Revolutionary Guards chief Hossein Salami. Major General Mohammad Pakpour, swiftly promoted to replace Salami as Guards commander, vowed retaliation in a letter to the Supreme Leader read out on state television: 'The gates of hell will open to the child-killing regime.' Iranians described an atmosphere of fear and anger, with some people rushing to change money and others seeking a way out of the country to safety. Iranian media showed images of destroyed apartment blocks, and said nearly 80 civilians were killed in attacks that targeted nuclear scientists in their beds and wounded more than 300 people. Israel said a missile fired from Yemen - whose Houthi militia are one of the last remaining Iranian-aligned groups still able to fire at Israel - had landed in Hebron in the occupied West Bank. The Palestinian Red Crescent said three Palestinian children were wounded by shrapnel there. Israel said that Iran had launched about 100 drones towards Israeli territory on Friday but Iran denied this and there were no reports of drones reaching Israeli targets. The United Nations Security Council was due to meet on Friday at Iran's request. Iran said in a letter to the Council that it would respond decisively and proportionally to Israel's 'unlawful' and 'cowardly' acts. Israeli officials said it may be some time before the extent of damage to the underground nuclear site at Natanz is clear, where Iran has refined uranium to levels some countries have long said are suitable for a bomb rather than civilian use. Iran has long insisted its nuclear program is for civilian purposes only. — with AAP
Canberra Times
5 hours ago
- Canberra Times
Police should be obliged to do more on mental health
The risk of a Chinese invasion of our shores, which, let us be frank, is the sole reason for AUKUS protection, is vanishingly small. China's thousands of years' track record of never having sought to conquer other lands is reassuring. There has always been China, and beyond China were barbarians. A great defensive wall was built to keep them out.
Sydney Morning Herald
5 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Trump applauds Israeli strikes, says Iran now has ‘second chance' to make a deal
Washington: US President Donald Trump says Iran has a second chance to negotiate a nuclear deal and stave off 'even more brutal' attacks being planned by Israel in coming days, as Tehran began its retaliation by firing ballistic missiles at Israeli cities. Trump was conducting a meeting of the National Security Council in the White House Situation Room on Friday, Washington time, following Israel's 'pre-emptive' strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities and top government personnel the night before. In a series of short phone interviews with US media, Trump indicated he was fully aware of Israel's operations in advance, and said Iran must make a deal that forbids it from developing a nuclear weapon 'before there is nothing left'. 'We knew everything,' Trump told Reuters of Israel's attack plans. 'I tried to save Iran humiliation and death. I tried to save them very hard because I would have loved to have seen a deal worked out. They can still work out a deal, however. It's not too late.' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also said the US had been informed about the strikes in advance. He and Trump have spoken and were expected to remain in regular contact, according to the White House. Loading On his TruthSocial account, Trump said he gave Iran a 60-day ultimatum two months ago to 'make a deal' that would restrict them from developing a nuclear weapon. 'They should have done it! Today is day 61. I told them what to do, but they just couldn't get there. Now they have, perhaps, a second chance!' he wrote. The president's comments indicated greater support for Israel's actions than a terse initial statement from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio in the immediate aftermath of the strikes on Thursday night, US time – which expressed neither support for nor condemnation of Israel and stressed that the US was not involved.
