Massive Edinburgh infrastructure plan approved despite concerns
A new scheme to prioritise Edinburgh infrastructure projects has been approved by councillors, despite some of them holding concerns over several issues.
The new City Mobility Plan aims to determine which projects the city will prioritise working on in the next decade.
Officers recommended that councillors accept a priority list which saw 73 projects approved to go ahead, and 61 others paused – with most either not having been started yet or having already been paused before the plan's release.
Labour councillor Stephen Jenkinson, who convenes the Transport and Environment Committee, heralded the plan, saying the time to take action was now, and that it is a 'a necessary piece of work.'
But some councillors raised concerns over the priority list, questioning the system used to select projects to carry out or pause and the geographic distribution of projects.
Infrastructure projects were scored on a matrix which judged elements of each, such as cost effectiveness and benefit for public transport – but some projects with higher scores were paused, while others with lower scores were approved.
Liberal Democrat councillor Kevin Lang said: 'Coming into this committee meeting, I feel like I had two fundamental issues with this report. Now I feel like I'll leave with three.
'The first is around what has been quite a complex scoring matrix. I don't think it's an unreasonable question to ask, [why do] you get a project scoring 20 paused when a project with 10 is proceeding?
'My second worry is around deliverability. I completely admire and respect the optimism that exists. Let's be frank, this is a council that can take three years to change a speed limit and six years to put in a speedbump.'
Lang's third concern was about developers' compliance with section 75 orders, which involve developer contributions to infrastructure projects.
Earlier in the meeting, a council officer said that most projects were continued or paused based on their score, but that some broke from this pattern due to extenuating circumstances, such as projects being eligible for certain bespoke funding.
The Liberal Democrat group had lodged an amendment calling on the report to be paused, giving councillors and officers more time to look at it.
Meanwhile, the Conservative group put forward their own list of projects to be continued and paused, using different scoring criteria.
Conservative councillor Neil Cuthbert, representing Colinton/Fairmilehead, asked officers: 'It does feel like a report for lovers of spreadsheets. Just looking at the different projects, I don't think it's any surprise that the ward with the most projects is the city centre.
'The wards with the second and third most projects are Forth and Almond. I don't want to go through the list, but Colinton/Fairmile is at the bottom of the list. There's two [projects].
'I wondered if there's any comments about why there does appear to be quite a disparity in a lot of different areas?'
Council officer Sheila Paton said: 'This is a long legacy and history of projects that have come forward over the years. We haven't deliberately tried to exclude any geographical areas, as I'm sure you can imagine.
'In terms of the focus on the city centre, we have a sense of how much of the proposed ten year programme would potentially be dedicated to the city centre.
'And we feel like it's in proportion with how complicated the city centre is, how important it is.'
Interim Executive Director of Place Gareth Barwell added: 'This list here hasn't added new schemes. This is officers broadly trawling through the commitments of this committee.
'A lot of these are actions we've inherited due to growth and development.'
The SNP group put forward an amendment adding three projects to the 'proceed' list, while the Green group wanted to see council officers begin looking at a congestion charge in the capital as a possible infrastructure funding source.
At a vote, seven councillors supported a joint Labour, SNP and Green position, while two supported the Conservative position and two supported the Liberal Democrat position.
Cllr Jenkinson said: "I'm really pleased that we've agreed this bold programme for our city. Prioritisation allows us to work smarter with the resources we have available - making sure we have a clear and achievable path to achieving our objectives.
"This programme follows the successes of major infrastructure projects such as Trams to Newhaven and active travel projects including the City Centre West to East Link (CCWEL), Roseburn to Union Canal and Leith Connections.
"This is an extensive piece of work which allows the City Mobility Plan to be agile, and able to adapt in the future as necessary."
Three projects were added to the list after amendments by political groups, and a fourth was added pending further work on how to fund it.
Among these was the Causey project, which seeks to turn the traffic island at the junction of West Crosscauseway and Buccleuch Street into a public events space.
The project, which campaigners have spent over a decade seeking funding for, was added to the priority list as a result of an SNP amendment.
The group also got the Portobello Town Centre project, which seeks to widen footways and reduce road traffic in the area, and a new cycle link over the bypass near Heriot Watt, over the line.
An amendment by the city's Labour administration, meanwhile, got approval for the funding of more toilets for bus drivers at the ends of routes, pending finding a funding source.
Cllr Jenkinson said: 'The project which I've identified as part of my amendment is a very particular project. It is currently marked for pause, but just for this financial year.
'The topic itself of provision of bus driver toilets at key locations, which are predominantly the terminuses for buses, is a very important one.
'Personally, and I hope the committee will agree, that it's a project that, once the uncertainty around funding is clarified, is unpaused.'
Graeme Smith, an industrial officer for Unite, which covers Lothian Buses, said: 'Access to a toilet at work is a basic right so it is important that the Council gets this right for our members in passenger transport.
'This is a matter of health and safety. It is also an equalities issue, more acutely impacting workers who are older, pregnant or have a health condition.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
30 minutes ago
- ITV News
UK economic growth slows to 0.3% in second quarter of the year, latest figures show
The UK economy grew by 0.3% between April and June, according to the latest figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS). It's a reduction from the 0.7% growth reported in the first quarter of the year. However, the latest figures are an improvement on some economists' predictions, who were estimating growth could be as low as 0.1%. Growth in the latest quarter was driven by increases of 0.4% in services and 1.2% in construction, while the production sector fell by 0.3%, the ONS said. The ONS also noted that some activity was brought forward to February and March, ahead of stamp duty changes in April and announced US tariff changes, which could have contributed to the slowed growth. ONS director of economic statistics Liz McKeown said: "Growth slowed in the second quarter after a strong start to the year." "The economy was weak across April and May, with some activity having been brought forward to February and March ahead of stamp duty and tariff changes, but then recovered strongly in June." "Across the second quarter as a whole, growth was led by services, with computer programming, health and vehicle leasing growing." The latest figures showed the UK economy grew by 0.4% in June, a welcome boost after the economy contracted by 0.1% in both April and May. The chancellor accepted there was more to do when it came to improving people's living standards. Chancellor Rachel Reeves said: "Today's economic figures are positive with a strong start to the year and continued growth in the second quarter. "But there is more to do to deliver an economy that works for working people." "I know that the British economy has the key ingredients for success but has felt stuck for too long." "That is why we're investing to rebuild our national infrastructure, cutting back on red tape to get Britain building again and boosting the national minimum wage to make work pay." "There's more to do and today's figures only fuel my ambition to deliver on our plan for change." Shadow Chancellor Mel Stride, who referred to Reeves as an "economic vandal" on X, accused the chancellor of failing in her role and "taxing your future to fund her failure." Speaking on Thursday morning, he claimed the slowing rate of growth was a result of Labour's tax increases on businesses and repeated the Conservative's claim that further tax rises are inevitable in the chancellor's autumn budget. Today's 0.3% growth figures match the rise seen during the same period under the Conservatives. The slowdown in the economy could increase the likelihood of further interest rate cuts by the Bank of England after last week's reduction to 4%. However, the chancellor has been relying on accelerating growth to help fund future government spending plans.
New Statesman
an hour ago
- New Statesman
Rachel Reeves' route to recovery
Photo by. Has some of the gloom about the UK economy been overdone? Rachel Reeves certainly thinks so. This morning's release by the Office for National Statistics suggests that GDP grew by 0.3 per cent in the second quarter of this year, a period which saw the introduction of the National Insurance rise and the imposition of tariffs by Donald Trump. That's down from 0.7 per cent in the first quarter but far ahead of City forecasts of 0.1 per cent. These numbers mean that the UK remains the fastest-growing G7 economy so far this year – comfortably surpassing the US – and, as a Reeves aide points out, that per capita growth in 2025 has matched that in 2024 (a period that the Conservatives have long insisted represented a golden inheritance for Labour). 'Nigel Farage wants you to think that the economy's broken, Rachel rejects that premise,' they say of the government's main opponent. To justify this argument, the Chancellor's team also cite consistent real wage growth, five interest-rate cuts – with mortgage rates below 5 per cent for the first time since Liz Truss's mini-Budget – and three trade deals: with the world's largest economy (the US), the world's fastest-growing economy (India) and the UK's largest trading partner (the EU). A daunting Budget – expected in November – lies ahead, but No 11 isn't regretting its decision to pour cold water on last week's projections that the Chancellor faces a £50bn black hole. For Reeves, the task is clear: to maintain economic recovery and turn that into political recovery (the government's net approval rating this week fell to a record low of -55). 'In the same way she galvanised Whitehall around the growth agenda back in January, she wants to do the same again in the autumn,' an ally says. The Chancellor, who is preoccupied by the UK's dismal productivity performance since the 2008 crash, has ordered officials to draw up a second planning bill to speed up infrastructure projects such as airports, roads, green energy schemes and data centres. Mindful of the UK's enduring regional imbalances, Reeves will also confirm the revival of Northern Powerhouse Rail, an east-west connection linking Liverpool to Hull (and potentially encompassing Leeds, her home constituency, Bradford and Sheffield). There is 'nothing progressive or Labour', the Chancellor has said privately, about 'one area of the country being easier to live in than others'. Another theme on Reeves' mind this summer, as work begins on her conference speech, is 'contribution' (the Labour buzzword of the moment). An economy that is too unbalanced and unfair, she believes, means people are working hard but getting too little back. The challenge for Reeves is to find new ways of changing this – and ensuring that Labour wins some political credit. This piece first appeared in the Morning Call newsletter; receive it every morning by subscribing on Substack here Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe Related
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Teesside recycling centre opens reuse shop to reduce waste
A new shop has opened at a recycling centre to allow people to buy second-hand items in an effort to help the Teesside Reuse Shop has opened at Tees Valley Household Waste and Recycling Centre in Haverton Hill, near Billingham, which is used by both Stockton-on-Tees and Middlesbrough local authorities said the shop would help hit their net-zero and recycling Labour councillor Peter Gavigan said too many appliances and household items were "simply thrown away long before the end of their useful life". Stockton-on-Tees Borough Council's leader, Labour's Lisa Evans, said the shop would help the environment while offering "residents a practical way to save money and bag a bargain". The reuse shop was opened at a ribbon-cutting ceremony attended by representatives from both will be run by Suez Recycling and Recovery UK and was opened as part of its contract extension to run the site until regional director Steve Patterson said: "The shop is an example of how we can all play our part in reducing waste and creating value for our communities." Follow BBC Tees on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
