Degrowth and the reimagining of Indian agriculture
For the past 25 years, development professionals have attempted to find a solution for poverty and food insecurity in developing countries. The template used is akin to log frame matrices perfected by Western agricultural science. It included training farmers in developing countries to use high doses of agro-chemicals (input), resulting in increased yield (output), a rise in income (outcome), and food security (impact). This template became a norm in international development and has been prevalent since 1968, when William Gaud, then director of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), coined the slogan Green Revolution to describe a framework marked by the extensive use of hybrid seeds with connected fertilisers and chemicals for monoculture farming, which created an output of a huge increase in yield. Gaud borrowed the idea from Henry Ford's 1913 concept of assembly lines with specialised tasks for each worker, which reduced the time needed to produce a car from 12 hours to 90 minutes while reducing manufacturing costs. Soon, farms were transformed into 'factories in the field,' specialising in single-crop assembly lines.
This phenomenon of extracting as much as possible from the soil using modern science continued in the 1990s. The use of biotechnologies, as well as the growing of genetically modified crops resistant to pests and diseases, were introduced. The more recent years have witnessed the use of smart agriculture through digital technologies. The question that arises is whether such focus on growth has provided the expected results in India and the world. This brief explores the promise of a contrasting approach—i.e., transitioning from extractive, chemical-laden agriculture to a degrowth in agriculture; prioritising ecology over yield, and people over profits.
This paper can be accessed here.
This paper is authored by Shatadru Chattopadhayay, ORF, New Delhi.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
3 hours ago
- India Today
India's Stray Romance: Love, lies, rabies, solutions
India's love for its stray animals is the stuff of mushy stories, and the entire country is the theatre of this romance. Picture this: a cow, swarmed by flies, covered in mud, munches serenely on a plastic bag in the middle of a traffic jam while motorists chant 'gau mata ki jai' and drive past. Down the same road, a dozen dogs tear at garbage, fighting over bones tossed by a kind-hearted samaritan who will later tweet #BeKind, and post lugubrious in this drama laced with emotion, apathy plays the lead role, leaving the strays where they are, free to multiply and die. Compassion, though ready to burst through, always remains on the leash, or on social media.A Theatre of HypocrisyTake the cow, India's divine mother. Five million strays, per the 2019 livestock census. These aren't refugees from across the border—95 per cent belong to dairy farmers who let them roam, grazing on urban trash to cut feed costs, then milk them for profit. It's the ultimate hustle: zero fodder costs, maximum spiritual clout. The outcome: bellies full of plastic, intestines blocked, and streets choked with dung. Solution? Everyone shrugs: it's every Indian's mother, the other children will the dogs. Sixty million strays, the world's highest. That's nearly a medium-sized European country roaming on four legs. The math is simple: For a population of 1.4 billion it is just .042 dogs per head, or 1 dog per 23 numbers bite harder than they bark: 3.7 million annual dog bites; 36% of the world's rabies deaths belong to India; one child dies every four hours. Delhi alone, mid-2025: 35,198 bites, 49 deaths. The love here is lethal—the more we feed, the more they Without ResponsibilityIndia's animal policy is a circus where outrage is the headline act and accountability never shows up. Politicians milk cow bhakti into votes, urban elites turn dog rescues into Instagram content, and municipalities treat animal control like pothole repair—stuffed into last year's result? Both cows and dogs suffer, humans pay the price, and the 'mushy story' of India's love for strays ends in a tragicomic Supreme Court's 2025 plan to relocate Delhi's 1 million dogs has led to pan-India outrage, howls of 'genocide.' Concern for canines is justified–-dogs can't be herded in shelters that could turn into Auschwitz camps of death and decay. They deserve empathy, care and the right to rage without responsibility is a street dog chasing its own tail, or a cow mata arranging her own dinner—lots of noise, zero Power of CompoundingOne unsterilised female dog, producing two litters per year for six years, could result in thousands of descendants, assuming 6 puppies per litter, 80% survival rate, and subsequent generations reproducing at the same rate starting at age doesn't have to be this way. Eradicating polio was once called impossible. But vaccines, mass campaigns, and accountability deadlines made it possible. Stray management needs the same ruthlessness:Policy, Not PietyWant a fix? Here are a few cows: Mandatory registration of all cattle; fines and seizures if they're abandoned. Subsidised gaushalas tied to digital tracking of herd sizes. Fund them through a cow cess that actually goes to barns, not to politicians' barns of dogs: Mass sterilisation and vaccination drives—with GPS tagging, community volunteers, and strict completion targets. A District Dog Board with annual audits and penalties for officials who fudge data. Zero tracking = zero both: A 'Stray Animal Authority of India' with investigative powers, a fixed national roadmap, and reports every six months. Performance-linked funding, just as with Swachh it like the polio menace that we eradicated—rope in vets, NGOs and health workers. Run awareness the FixWhere's the money? Same place it always is when votes are at stake. India spends crores subsidising statues, rallies, and spiritual jamborees. A small dog tax per household, diversion of MP-MLA funds, panchayat money, CSR mandates, and state-allocated veterinary corps could bankroll sterilisation and shelters nationwide. Remember: one unsterilised female dog multiplies to thousands. A penny spent is thousands saved. Delay equals geometric Jaipur ModelThe Jaipur model, launched in 1994 by an NGO and Jaipur Municipal Corporation, is India's gold standard for humane stray dog control. Daily teams capture, operate, vaccinate and release dogs, costing Rs 800–Rs 2,200 each, funded by JMC and donors. Implementation stalls often, due to funding and resistance, but the programme continues despite hurdles, bringing down the population of strays, and cases of this model, scale it nationally, tie it to a digital dashboard. Make stray control a performance parameter for mayors and district The DogIndia can send rockets to the moon but cannot build kennels with roofs. We legislate holiness for cows while letting them inherit slow death by plastic. We hashtag dog love and then bury children bitten to death. That's not compassion—it's criminal negligence, dressed up with flowers, candlelight vigils and social media empathy is not bread crumbs (or plastic) on the street; it's policy with teeth. Without it, India's romance with strays will remain what it has always been: a love story written in blood, dung, and hypocrisy.(Sandipan Sharma likes to spin gripping tales on cricket, cinema, and history. When not scribbling, he dodges life's mundane bits by reading everything under the sun. He has been a journalist and author for 25-plus years. - Ends(Views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the author)Tune InMust Watch
The Wire
5 hours ago
- The Wire
Unpacking Privilege: The Other Side of Caste
The field of ethnography was originally deeply embedded in colonialism and the agenda of understanding and ruling the 'other', the colonised. Even today, in the Indian context, ethnography often involves the study of the 'other' – and marginalised communities are typically placed within this category. Ravikant Kisana's Meet the Savarnas: Indian Millennials Whose Mediocrity Broke Everything is an important contribution to the field of critical caste studies, aiming to reverse the gaze from the marginalised to the privileged castes. Through his ethnographic insights, he ventures into savarna culture and attempts to unpack the caste privileges of the so-called 'upper castes', which they refer to as 'merit'. Ravikant Kisana Meet the Savarnas: Indian Millennials Whose Mediocrity Broke Everything Penguin India, 2025 Throughout the book, the constantly recurring theme is two different cultures, rooted in the caste hierarchy. These differences translate into hierarchies of inferior and superior cultural complexes. The people from the non-savarana backgrounds are always pulled back into their original location by savarna peers, who pose as the gatekeepers of cultural legitimacy. The powerful metaphor of the 'glass floor' adds significant weight to Kisana's argument, suggesting that savarnas have access to all the switches on their floor that control the glass floor below – switching them on and off at their will. Interestingly, there are even conflicts among savarnas over who gets to control all the switches in the room. The author argues that the savarna gaze does not possess the capacity to understand peoples from below the 'glass floor' – their dietary practices, the level of poverty, caste privilege, advantage and exclusion. In sociological writings, and in the social sciences more broadly, the analysis of caste relationships has largely been viewed through the lens of oppression, while the nuances of privilege have been overlooked. Contrary to the existing literature on caste, this work investigates how caste privilege is inhabited and unpacks the mechanisms through which it is reproduced in the everyday lives of savarnas. The sites of this reproduction include premier educational institutions such as IITs and IIMs, as well as public institutions like JNU. Since these public institutions are required to implement reservations, they are not exclusively meant to protect the privileges of savarnas. With the introduction of OBC reservation, the earlier domination of savarnas has been further challenged by marginalised communities. Historically, since the colonial period, the formation of the middle class has largely been restricted to a few landed upper castes. Neoliberal reforms in the Indian economy were also largely well received by middle-class savarnas. C. J. Fuller and Haripriya Narasimhan, in their work Tamil Brahmans: The Making of a Middle-Class Caste, argue that Tamil Brahmans, traditionally perceived as a high-status caste, have transformed themselves into an urban middle-class group by successfully navigating modernity through investments in higher education, professional careers (primarily engineering) and global migration, showing how caste and class intertwine in contemporary India. Ravikant Kisana. If we look at the demographic composition of the middle classes in contemporary times, even after the emergence of marginalised middle classes such as the Dalit middle class through affirmative action, they continue to be largely dominated by the privileged castes. The question of accessibility to elite private institutions is tied to the issue of class privilege, Kisana's work argues. This interaction between class and caste provides a powerful theoretical basis for unpacking caste privilege. These private institutions have the capacity to prevent the entry of 'undesired' bodies into the campus. This stops the perceived 'infiltration' of 'others' – Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes – in these premier institutions. Interestingly, the proliferation of private institutions provides a new tier of elite exclusivity, earlier associated with public institutions. In a way, the formation of elite private institutions provides a shield for their exclusive caste privileges. In addition, marriage is another site through which caste privileges are reproduced. The central focus when talking about marriage as an important institution of society is savarna marriage – a key site for the cultural reproduction of the Brahmanical order within both the family unit and larger society. Even progressive, educated savarnas – those once rebellious during their college days – eventually end up negotiating with their families, Kisana highlights, recognising the cost of love in terms of family caste networks and privileges. This creates a performance of being progressive, which is deeply embedded in particular spaces, including educational spaces. These caste networks and privileges play an important role in shaping the structure of opportunities in contemporary India. To take advantage of such networks, one has to remain within the fold of the same caste group, and practicing endogamy is one way to do so. Dr B.R. Ambedkar also identified this aspect of caste as central to the maintenance of the caste system. He considered inter-caste marriage a radical social act, arguing that without it, we cannot annihilate caste. Understanding savarna culture provides insights and offers a different vantage point on how the world, which contrasts sharply with the culture of marginalisation. There are some limitations to Kisana's book, such as the tendency to understand things in binary terms and the suspicion surrounding his methodological approach – which he himself acknowledges. Nevertheless, it is a promising and necessary work, emerging at a crucial point in time. The author raises many uncomfortable but essential questions on behalf of millions of people. The book is written in a very lucid and accessible language, and every social science student, researcher or even a layperson who wants to understand the realities of caste in India should read it. Ravi Bharmouri is Research Scholar of Sociology at Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. This article went live on August twentieth, two thousand twenty five, at thirty-two minutes past twelve at noon.
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
India-Sri Lanka conclude naval exercise SLINEX-25, strengthen cooperation, sharpen operational readiness
The 12th edition of the Sri Lanka-India Naval Exercise (SLINEX-25) successfully concluded in Colombo, enhancing cooperation and interoperability between the two navies. The exercise featured harbor and sea phases, strengthening coordination and readiness. SLINEX-25 included goodwill events, training exchanges, and cultural visits, reinforcing the deep engagement and maritime cooperation between India and Sri Lanka. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The 12th edition of the Sri Lanka-India Naval Exercise SLINEX-25 ) successfully concluded on August 18, in the western seas off Colombo, as per an official statement by the Sri Lankan per the statement, "both the navies carry out a wide spectrum of operations across the ocean region to fulfill the nations' and regional maritime aspirations, these regular maritime exercises play a vital role in sustaining their operational readiness by enhancing its capabilities, advancing technology and sharpening professional skills."The annual SLINEX strengthened the cooperation and interoperability between the two navies, thereby reaffirming their shared commitment towards safeguarding security in the Indian Ocean per the official statement, during SLINEX-25, the Sri Lanka Navy was represented by the Offshore Patrol Vessels SLNS Vijayabahu and SLNS Sayura, while the Sri Lanka Air Force contributed a Bell 412 helicopter. The Indian Navy participated with the tanker-class INS Jyoti and the destroyer-class INS exercise had both harbor and sea phases, which strengthened the seamless coordination and readiness of the Indian and Sri Lanka naval statement further observed that on the sidelines of SLINEX-25, Dr Satyanjal Pandey, Deputy High Commissioner of India to Sri Lanka, embarked on the visiting Indian Naval Ships in Colombo. Also, the Indian High Commissioner, Santosh Jha, along with the Commanding Officers of the ships, honoured the fallen by placing floral tributes at the Indian Peace Keeping Force Memorial in per the statement, the Indian Navy personnel, "joined a series of goodwill events hosted by the Sri Lanka Navy, from training exchanges and friendly sports events to cultural visits and sightseeing tours, strengthening cooperation and friendship between the two navies".Snippets from the exercise were shared by the Indian Navy in several posts on in 2005, SLINEX is a bilateral naval exercise that has strengthened maritime cooperation between the two nations over two decades. SLINEX aims at enhancing interoperability, maritime cooperation and exchanging best practices while jointly undertaking multi-faceted maritime previous edition of SLINEX was conducted at Visakhapatnam, India, from December 17 to 20, SLINEX maritime exercise exemplifies the deep engagement between India and Sri Lanka, which has strengthened cooperation in the maritime domain in consonance with India's policy of Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions MAHASAGAR.
