Wells man set for trial over shooting death of his young niece
Andrew Huber Young, 22, is charged with murder in the May 2022 death of Octavia Jean Young. He also faces two counts of attempted murder and two counts of assault against his father and brother.
He has pleaded not guilty and his attorney, David Bobrow, has said that his client never intended to kill anyone. Huber Young didn't know Octavia was dead until after talking with police hours after the shooting, Bobrow said last fall.
Huber Young told police in a lengthy interview, hours after the shooting, that he was mad at his brother Ethan for stealing a T-shirt and threatening to destroy his hamster cage, according to an arrest affidavit by Maine State Police Detective Conner Walton.
"Andrew said that he aimed at Ethan's chest before shooting, but he claimed he didn't intend to kill Ethan," Walton wrote. "He claimed he wanted Ethan's respect. Andrew said he has an anger-control problem."
According to the affidavit, Huber Young told police the shooting took place at his parents' home following a fight with his brother that started when Huber Young noticed him wearing his T-shirt.
Even after Huber Young's parents told him to leave the house, he continued to fight with his brother over text messages while attending a Sea Dogs game in Portland. He eventually returned to the house and fired shots through a locked glass door using his father's pistol, Walton wrote. His father told police it was taken without his knowledge.
The prosecution's case relies heavily on what Huber Young told police.
Superior Court Justice Richard Mulhern denied Bobrow's request to throw the confession out last fall, after Bobrow argued police violated his client's rights by not telling him during the interview that Octavia was dead.
Those arguments will likely still be a major part of Huber Young's defense.
A pre-trial hearing Thursday in York County Superior Court offered a glimpse at the breadth of material jurors will be asked to consider. There are texts messages, 911 calls, crime scene photographs of bullet holes and shell casings, and a three-hour video of Huber Young at the police station — most of which Bobrow said his client spends sitting quietly, handcuffed to a bench while waiting for police to meet with him.
"It's context, judge," said Bobrow, who asked the judge to allow him to play the entire video for the jury. Bobrow suggested his client can be seen struggling several times to get comfortable. "Certainly the jury is entitled to see ... what he was exposed to."
Assistant Attorney General Leanne Robbin argued that for the jury "to sit there and watch a silent picture of him on a bench, it just seems like that's a waste of judicial resources and the jury's time."
Bobrow implied during the hearing Thursday that prosecutors did not include all of the texts exchanged between Huber Young and his brother before the shooting, but Robbin said prosecutors already shared all of their evidence with Bobrow before trial.
"We don't know which additional texts Attorney Bobrow wants us to put in," Robbin told the judge. "What we think we have identified are all the relevant communications within the time period."
Copy the Story Link
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
7 minutes ago
- CBS News
7 more former residents of Gabriel House sue Fall River assisted living facility after deadly fire
Seven former residents of Gabriel House, where a deadly fire occurred in July in Fall River, Massachusetts, have sued the residence and its owner, accusing them of negligence. They're also suing Fire Systems, Inc., the company in charge of inspecting the home's sprinkler system and fire alarms. Albert Almanza, Larry Ashworth, Muriel Boyce, Shirley Cambra, Lorraine Ferrera, Caroline Johnson and James Vicery were named as the plaintiffs in the lawsuit. All seven resided at the assisted living facility when the fire broke out, killing 10 people and injuring more than 30. The state fire marshal said the cause of the fire on Sunday, July 13, was accidental and that it was started either by someone smoking or the failure of a resident's oxygen device. In the lawsuit, they claim owner Dennis Etzkorn and his wife Karen knew that many residents used oxygen tanks and many also smoked cigarettes, even while being administered oxygen. "[Dennis and Karen Etzkorn] knew or reasonably should have known that smoking cigarettes while being administered oxygen constitutes an increased risk of fires and explosions," the lawsuit said, in part. The lawsuit also claims the Etzkorns should have known of the "limitations" of the residents, many of whom were of "advanced age" with limited mobility and medical conditions. According to the lawsuit, only two staff members were working the night of the fire. "Staff were untrained, unprepared and unequipped to carry out an emergency evacuation," said the lawsuit, in part. The plaintiffs also said Etzkorn allowed residents to install air conditioners that were too large for the windows and this made it difficult for firefighters to get to them. Fire Systems, Inc. is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit. They're accused of improperly installing and maintaining the fire alarms and sprinklers in the home. The night of the fire, the lawsuit said residents were not warned by the alarms of the fire and were trapped in their rooms "as a result of corridors filled with thick black smoke." Etzkorn previously said the sprinklers were tested five days before the fire. This is the third lawsuit filed by former residents of Gabriel House. One man filed suit on July 22 and three more residents sued on Aug. 1. The Etzkorns and Fire Systems, Inc. have yet to comment on this latest lawsuit.
New York Times
7 minutes ago
- New York Times
6 Men Are Killed in an Accident at a Colorado Dairy Farm
Six men were killed in an accident on a dairy farm in a rural town in northeastern Colorado, local authorities said on Thursday. The men's bodies were discovered after fire crews were called to a 'confined space rescue' at 6 p.m. local time on Wednesday near the farming town of Keenesburg, about 40 miles northeast of Denver, according to a statement from Tom Beach, chief of the Southeast Weld County Fire Protection District. Officials in Weld County, a large agricultural and oil and gas region, did not release the men's identities or any more information about where the men had been found or how they had died. Melissa Chesmore, a spokeswoman for the Weld County sheriff, said there was 'nothing criminal in nature.' Officials also did not identify the dairy farm where the accident happened, but property records and Colorado business records indicate it is the Prospect Valley Dairy. The business did not return calls for comment on Thursday. Farming is one of the deadliest jobs in the United States, and dairies can be especially treacherous for farmworkers. They can be crushed by livestock and machinery, suffocate in grain silos that store feed for livestock, or asphyxiate on gases given off by manure pits. An official with the Weld County coroner told CBS Colorado that gas exposure could be to blame in the deaths of the six men. In March 2021, an immigrant farmworker drowned at a different dairy farm in La Salle, Colo., after his truck pitched into a manure-storage lagoon. That led state lawmakers to intensify their efforts to pass farmworker-safety protections. Keenesburg is a fast-growing town with about 2,000 people, where farmers and ranchers raise beef, chicken and grains for distilleries, said its mayor, Aron Lam. He said most residents work in farming or the oil and gas industry, or commute to the Denver metro area. 'We're a very close-knit community,' he said. 'It's mostly just farm fields.'
Fox News
24 minutes ago
- Fox News
Rubio pauses worker visas for truck drivers after deadly Florida crash involving illegal immigrant kills 3
Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Thursday said "effective immediately" he would pause the issuance of worker visas for commercial drivers after an illegal immigrant truck driver allegedly caused a crash that killed three people in Florida. In a post on X, Rubio cited public safety for the move. "The increasing number of foreign drivers operating large tractor-trailer trucks on U.S. roads is endangering American lives and undercutting the livelihoods of American truckers," he wrote. Concerns about foreign workers driving commercial trucks began after Harjinder Singh, 28, who entered the U.S. illegally, was driving a commercial truck with a trailer on the Florida Turnpike in Fort Pierce when he allegedly attempted a U-turn in an unauthorized area. The turn resulted in the trailer jackknifing and colliding with a minivan, which left all three of the minivan's passengers dead, authorities said. Further scrutiny of Singh revealed that he didn't pass English and road tests before obtaining a commercial driver's license. He was granted a full-term commercial driver's license in Washington in July 2023, despite not being legally eligible. He was also given a limited-term commercial driver's license in California in 2024. California Gov. Gavin Newsom and officials with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) have been in a heated war of words with the Trump administration over Singh. This week, Newsom's press office said on X that Singh obtained a work permit during President Donald Trump's first term. Tricia McLaughlin, the DHS assistant secretary for public affairs, responded, saying Singh was denied in September 2020, under Trump, but was granted one in June 2021, under the Biden administration. Singh has been extradited to Florida from California to face three counts of vehicular homicide.
