Sean McGovern's lawyers question legality of his extradition
Lawyers for Sean McGovern (39), who is charged with murder and directing a criminal organisation, have raised a concern about the legality of his extradition to Ireland from the United Arab Emirates last week.
Olan Callanan BL, for McGovern, today told the three-judge, non-jury Special Criminal Court that Michael Staines solicitors office will issue a letter to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) imminently, putting them on notice of an application.
Mr Callanan asked the court to set a date for a hearing. He added: "The fundamental concern is the legality, the propriety and the process which surrounded his arrival in Dublin."
On 29 May 29 last, when Mr McGovern arrived in Dublin and was first brought before the court, Mr Callanan said he was reserving his position on the legality of the process and the jurisdiction of the non-jury court.
Sean Gillane SC, for the DPP, told the court that a first book of evidence relating to the charges against McGovern will be ready by the end of July. The DPP will update the court on a second book of evidence at a later date.
Mr McGovern viewed today's proceedings via video-link from prison. He spoke only to confirm that he could hear what was being said.
Ms Justice Karen O'Connor agreed to set a date for hearing McGovern's application on Wednesday, 18 June. McGovern will again appear by video-link rather than in person.
The court set a date in late July for service of the book of evidence.
An Irish Air Corps Casa 295 plane took McGovern from Dubai to Dublin last week, stopping off in Larnaca in Cyprus and Marseille in France to refuel.
He landed at Casement Aerodrome in west Dublin, before gardai brought him before the Special Criminal Court where he was charged with five offences.
Mr McGovern, with a previous address at Kildare Road, Crumlin, Dublin 12 is charged with the murder of Noel Kirwan on 22 December, 2016 at St Ronan's Drive, Clondalkin in Dublin.
He is also charged with directing the activities of a criminal organisation in connection with the same murder between 20 October, 2016 and 22 December, 2016.
He is charged with directing the activities of a criminal organisation in connection with the surveillance of James Gately in preparation for the commission of an indictable offence between 17 October, 2015 and 6 April, 2017.
Another charge alleges that between 20 October and 22 December, 2016 he contributed to or participated in activity intending or being reckless as to whether such activity would facilitate a criminal organisation in the murder of Mr Kirwan.
He faces a similar charge of facilitating a criminal organisation in a conspiracy to murder James Gately.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Gardaí dangle '$15m reward' to turn Kinahan's cartel lieutenants
The garda hierarchy is dangling the US $15m reward, and a new life in the US federal witness programme, to coax Kinahan cartel lieutenants to give information leading to the prosecution of its leaders. On Monday, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris and deputy commissioner Justin Kelly called on cartel associates to have a 'really good think' about their future lives as further extraditions from the UAE increase in likelihood. The warning follows the first extradition from the Middle-Eastern state of an Irish national back to Ireland when senior cartel lieutenant Sean McGovern was sent back home to face gangland charges. At a joint US-Ireland launch in Dublin in April 2022, American authorities offered a combined $15m reward for information leading to the prosecution of Daniel Kinahan, his brother Christopher, and their dad and cartel founder, Christy. Mr Harris said: 'I'd like to point out [to] the other senior lieutenants in the Kinahan organised crime group who are now facing justice or who are now imprisoned, the sanctions and the rewards still stand. "There's $15m there of reward money through the federal law enforcement authorities of the US, so that is still in play. "I just want to remind other members of the gang the perilous position they are now in, that ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them and are fixed on bringing them, all of them, to justice.' He said the leaders should be afraid. 'Serious life choices' "They should be worried now for a number of years," Mr Harris said. "All of them should be worried and thinking about the choices, the serious life choices that are now ahead of them in respect of what to do over the coming months.' Mr Kelly said that a couple of years ago, when he was assistant commissioner of operations and security, both he and the Garda Commissioner said gardaí would be 'relentless', adding that the extradition of Mr McGovern was 'absolute evidence' of that. He said that, at one point, there were 47 members of the cartel in jail. He called on Kinahan lieutenants to have a 'really good think' about what choices they make in the coming months. One experienced security source said that Mr McGovern's extradition "has spooked" some of the cartel figures. Separately, the Garda Commissioner said suggestions that gardaí should have used a cadaver dog capable of detecting human remains at the home of Tina Satchwell when she went missing in 2017 would form part of a review he had ordered. Richard Satchwell was given a life sentence for the murder of his wife in 2017. Her remains were found in a deep grave under the stairs in October 2023. Last weekend, justice minister Jim O'Callaghan indicated that probably a cadaver dog should have been used in 2017. Reacting, Mr Harris said: 'We want to review all those decisions back in 2017, but what I know from the reporting that I've seen is that the suspicion was that harm had been caused to Tina Satchwell but there was no suspicion that her body was actually there.'
Sunday World
14 hours ago
- Sunday World
Garda chief warns Kinahan leadership they ‘should be worried' after Sean McGovern's extradition
CARTEL CRACKDOWN | Drew Harris also said that a $15 million reward from the US government leading to the jailing of the crime group's leadership is 'still in play' Sean McGovern Drew Harris also said that a $15 million reward from the US government leading to the jailing of the crime group's leadership is 'still in play' for other gang members who cooperate with authorities. McGovern (38), from Crumlin, was removed back to Ireland and appeared before the Special Criminal Court last month charged with a number of offences including murder and directing a crime gang. The Kinahan group's leadership, including brothers Daniel and Christopher Jnr, remain in Dubai while the Director of Prosecutions (DPP) is continuing to review an investigative file on them. The Garda chief said that 'a lot of things which were said couldn't be done, have been done' following significant talks with officials in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). 'They should be worried, but they should have been worried now for a number of years, because this huge effort, huge investigative effort, an international effort, has gone into the investigation of the overall Kinahan organised crime gang,' she said. 'A lot of things which said couldn't be done, have been done, so following on from the sanctions, the work then that we've undertaken with the UAE, and the work that specifically we've undertaken then with the police in Dubai, has been very fruitful. 'They have been very active partners with us in terms of investigation, providing us information, and obviously then UAE authorities have worked to support the extradition, and we see an individual then extradited back to Ireland to face justice here, and that's the correct thing to do.' Mr Harris, speaking at Garda Headquarters this morning, also said that a $15 million reward remains in place and referenced other senior lieutenants of the Kinahan gang who are now either facing justice or sanctions. 'So that is still in play as well, and I just want to remind others in the Kinahan organised crime gang of the perilous position that they're now in, that ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them, and we are fixed on bringing them all to justice,' he said. 'So, all of them should be worried, and they should be thinking about the choices, serious life choices that are now ahead of them, in respect of what to do over the coming months. Our work with the Dubai police obviously carries on.' Sean McGovern News in 90 Seconds - 09 June 2025 Mr Harris also said he couldn't talk about specific investigative files but that the Garda Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau is continuing active investigations alongside Europol, the UK's National Crime Agency, and US federal law enforcement. Deputy Commissioner Justin Kelly said that events in recent weeks showed that gardaí have been relentless in their pursuit of transnational crime gangs. 'I think it's really important as well that everybody knows that there's other transnational organised crime groups outside the Kinahan OCG, and exactly the same for those, it doesn't matter where in the world they are, if there are charges here, we will seek to have them extradited back to Ireland,' she said. The Deputy Commissioner also said that offering witness protection to junior gang members who cooperate is part of the strategy. 'Some of these people need to have a really good think, they have some serious life choices they can make,' he said. "The rewards are in place, they've been well publicised around the Kinahan organised crime group. But even beyond that, there are people that are involved in organised crime, and they need to see what the results of that is. We have absolutely dismantled two of the organised crime groups here in Dublin. 'At one stage we had 47 members of one group in jail. So, if you make those life choices and you want to become involved in this, what is the reality facing you is the full force of the state is against you.'
Irish Examiner
18 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kinahan cartel leaders 'should be worried' after extradition of senior lieutenant
The Garda Commissioner said the leaders of the Kinahan cartel in Dubai 'should be worried' after senior lieutenant Sean McGovern was extradited from there to Ireland to face gangland charges. Drew Harris urged members, both junior and senior, in the cartel — who are either at large or in jail — to think about whether or not to help gardaí in their efforts to bring the leaders to justice. Mr Harris was commenting on the transfer over a week ago of McGovern — seen as the right-hand man of cartel leader Daniel Kinahan — by gardaí and military pilots from Dubai. He was brought to the Criminal Courts of Justice to be charged with directing and facilitating an organised crime group and with a Kinahan-Hutch feud murder. Speaking in Garda Headquarters in Phoenix Park, Mr Harris said the leaders, who are still in Dubai, should be in fear they will be next. 'Yes, they should be worried," he said. "They should have been worried now for a number of years because there's huge investigative effort and international investigative effort has gone into the Kinahan organised crime gang.' He said a lot of comments of what 'couldn't be done have been done' and a legal extradition had happened. Mr Harris said because of the cooperation of police in Dubai and legal authorities in the UAE, 'we've seen an individual extradited back to Ireland to face justice here'. Mr Harris reminded other members of the cartel they are in a bind, but there are options for them, in terms of cooperating with gardaí. He said: 'I'd also like to point out too, the other senior lieutenants in the Kinahan organised crime group, who are now facing justice or who are now imprisoned, the sanctions and the rewards still stand — there's $15m there of reward money through the federal law enforcement authorities of the US, so that is still in play. I just want to remind other members of the Kinahan organised crime gang the perilous position they are now in, that ourselves and other law enforcement are fixed on them and are fixed on bringing them, all of them, to justice. 'So, all of them should be worried and thinking about the choices, the serious life choices that are now ahead of them in respect of what to do over the coming months.' Deputy Commissioner, Security, Governance and Strategy, Justin Kelly said a couple of years ago, when he was Assistant Commissioner, Operations and Security, both he and the commissioner had said gardaí would be 'relentless', and the extradition of McGovern was 'absolute evidence' of that. He said the 'exact same' applied to other transnational crime gangs. Referring to the Kinahan cartel, he said at one point there were 47 members of it in jail. Mr Kelly also called on Kinahan lieutenants to have a 'really good think' about what choices they make in the coming months.
