John Ivison: Carney's Canada advances terrorists, not Mideast peace

Ottawa Citizen

5 days ago

Article content
These policy errors have created the very real prospect of mass starvation. Research from Hebrew University indicates that flour prices have increased 80-fold. Even Donald Trump has said that there is 'real starvation' in Gaza.
Article content
Israel has responded by announcing changes to aid operations: more air-drops of pallets of food; 'pauses' in combat operations for 10 hours a day in populated areas; and the opening of humanitarian corridors to provide secure routes for United Nations agencies.
Article content
But it is all too late.
Article content
Three-quarters of Israelis want an end to the war (if Hamas releases all 50 remaining hostages — of whom only 20 are thought to be still alive).
Article content
They are increasingly aware Israel is becoming a pariah to many.
Article content
Public opinion across the West is largely united in opposition to Israel. A new Gallup poll this week suggests only one-third of Americans support the Jewish state, down 10 points from last September, while six in 10 disapprove. Earlier polls indicate similar levels of support in Canada.
Article content
Article content
Hamas, which has called on all nations to follow France's lead, must be delighted.
Article content
As veteran Israeli journalist Nadav Eyal told the Call Me Back podcast, Hamas has always tried to convince the world that Gaza is the victim of its own genocide, in pursuit of the legitimacy it needs for nationhood. Those efforts have proven to be in vain until now, when the facts on the ground have lent credence to such claims.
Article content
'This was always the project of Yahya Sinwar (the late former Hamas leader) — that only through violence would the state be born, through sacrifice and jihad,' he said.
Article content
There is a very good reason why for 75 years, Canada has insisted on the establishment of a Palestinian state as part of, but not before, a negotiated two-state solution: it is intended to be an incentive to bring the Palestinians to the table.
Article content
Former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon raised the possibility of Palestinian statehood two decades ago, on condition that the Palestinians demilitarize and give up on claims of 'the right of return' to Israel.
Article content
While it is true that the two-state solution is dead for now, and that no talks between the two sides have been held since 2014, in time the prospects for a lasting peace may improve.
Article content
It makes no sense to have pre-emptively handed over a bargaining chip that could increase the chances of a lasting resolution.
Article content
Canada's backing for Palestinian statehood would not make it a reality. The U.S. remains firmly opposed and will wield its veto on the Security Council at the United Nations.
Article content
But momentum is growing. In the last UN vote in May 2024, 143 countries voted to recognize an independent Palestine (Canada abstained).
Article content
It was not clear what anyone was recognizing. Did it include East Jerusalem as capital of the new country? Did it grant legitimacy to the Fatah government in the West Bank or Hamas in Gaza?
Article content
The only certainty is that Hamas wants a one-state solution from 'the river to the sea.'
Article content