My cousin died from cancer after doctors downgraded her urgent referral – we need medical reform now
TRAGIC LOSS My cousin died from cancer after doctors downgraded her urgent referral – we need medical reform now
A TEENAGER died from cancer after doctors downgraded her urgent referral because of her age, her devastated family claims.
Isla Sneddon, 17, passed away on March 2 after a six-month battle with the disease.
The schoolgirl, of Airdrie, first sought help at 14 for painful breast lumps, which were dismissed as benign fibroadenoma in July 2022.
By June 2024, her condition worsened, and GPs suspected cancer, issuing an urgent referral for biopsies.
But the breast clinic downgraded Isla's referral from 'urgent' to 'routine' due to her age, relatives say.
In September 2024, a fast-spreading sarcoma was found on the lining of her heart, which had already spread to her heart, lungs, and lymph nodes.
Her devastated parents, Mark and Michelle, were told Isla had between six and 12 months left to live.
Isla's cousin Mairi McGhee has launched a petition demanding that the Scottish Government treat cancer suspicions in children with the same urgency as adults.
They're also calling for a review of paediatric guidelines to prevent more tragic cases.
Mairi told The Herald: 'We want to make clear that all of the care that Isla received from the doctors and nurses was fantastic.
'The problem we found was that if that referral in June had been placed on a doctor's desk without an age on it, and Isla was seen as urgent, then we could be in a really different place.
'Isla could still be here, she could have had longer.'
The family is also calling for mandatory follow-ups for downgraded referrals, training for clinicians to spot early signs of cancer in children, and a formal review into paediatric diagnostic delays.
New £4 spit test 'can help detect breast cancer in five seconds from a single drop of saliva'
Scotland has one of the highest under-18 mortality rates in Western Europe, with around 45 young people dying every year.
Mairi continued: "We can't see how we can possibly move on.
"It feels like we have been in limbo since the day she died.
"This has been horrific. Even though Isla was given six to 12 months, we all had a lot of hope.
"Isla was determined to the very end, putting on her wig and eyelashes when she got up in the morning.
"She got six months and two days. Her mum and dad bought her prom dress and she was really looking forward to it but she is obviously not going to be there.
"Isla was responding well to chemotherapy. She just took it all in her stride.
"On the day that Isla died, we didn't expect her to die that day. She was unwell with a bit of a cough and doctors thought it may be viral but days later she died.
"It was so quick and unexpected. We didn't expect to not walk back out of the hospital with her."
Scottish Labour's deputy leader slammed Isla's tragic case as 'a scandal' and said her family had been 'badly failed'.
She added: 'Lessons must be learned to ensure no more lives are needlessly lost like this. There must be a review into how cancer referrals for young people are handled so everyone gets the lifesaving treatment they need.'
At FMQs, she challenged First Minister John Swinney to ensure cancer suspicions in children are treated with the same urgency as adults.
Swinney said he would raise the issue with the health secretary and 'pursue it in relation to clinical guidance'.
A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: 'Our thoughts are with the family of Isla on their loss.
'The Scottish Referral Guidelines for Suspected Cancer have been developed to support primary care clinicians to identify those with symptoms suspicious of cancer and identify those who require urgent assessment by a specialist. These guidelines have recently been reviewed with input from clinicians and cancer charities to ensure they are evidence based and help support early identification of cancer.
'To support this a new primary care cancer education platform – Gateway C – was launched on 30 April 2024 in NHS Scotland, supported by NHS Education for Scotland. Gateway C provides innovative, and tailored information to support earlier cancer diagnosis efforts and enable effective decision-making.
'This free online platform is accessible to all primary care clinicians including pharmacists, dentists, and optometrists.'
The petition launched by Isla's family has garnered more than 25,000 signatures.
It can be found here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
10 hours ago
- The National
Risk of cancer death drops by 11.1 per cent to record low
Statistics published by Public Health Scotland (PHS) have shown an 11.1% reduction in mortality rates since 2013, from 333.7 per 100,000 diagnoses to 296.8 per 100,000 in 2022. The data, published on Tuesday, showed the death rates from the illness are the lowest on record since 1998. READ MORE: Chemical company fined £100k after worker suffers 'serious burns' Health Secretary Neil Gray said: 'It is encouraging to see the risk of dying from cancer in Scotland is at a record low. This is down to the hard work of NHS staff, improved treatment options, and people reporting their symptoms at an earlier stage. 'We are determined to further improve cancer survival, reduce waiting times and provide excellent, equitably accessible care right across Scotland.' Due to Scotland's ageing population, 69% of all cancer-related deaths recorded in 2022 were individuals aged 70 or older. 'We are taking action to improve the awareness and earlier diagnosis of cancers, including expanding our Rapid Cancer Diagnostic Services and our investment of more than £14 million towards cancer waiting times this year', Gray continued. 'Reducing health inequalities is a clear ambition for this government. Cutting smoking rates is key to tackling lung cancer incidence in areas of deprivation – our world-leading tobacco control measures are helping us in our goal of a Tobacco-Free Scotland by 2034.' MSP for Rutherglen Clare Haughey welcomed the figures, praising the work of NHS staff and action taken by the Scottish Government to improve both treatment options and early detection initiatives. 'One death from cancer is one too many but these figures are welcome and show the real progress we are making to improve cancer survival under the SNP Government', Haughey said. READ MORE: Ayrshire trust in race to raise £200k for community ownership of B-listed church 'The fact that the likelihood of dying from cancer is at its lowest level on record is testament to the incredible work that staff in our NHS do throughout Scotland every day. 'The SNP is determined to go even further to improve cancer survival across Scotland by taking action to improve awareness and earlier diagnosis of cancers. This includes expanding our Rapid Cancer Diagnostic Services and investing more than £14 million to reduce cancer waiting times this year. 'Whilst other parties continually talk down our NHS, the SNP is getting on with the job of improving and extending lives by investing to tackle health inequalities and improve health outcomes for people right across Scotland.'
The Herald Scotland
11 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cancer deaths up although risk of dying from disease falls to new low
Cancer deaths in Scotland have risen over a 10-year period, despite figures showing the risk of dying from the disease is at the lowest on record. New data showed that the European Age Standardised Rate (EASR) for cancer deaths – which set out the risk of dying from the disease – fell to 296.8 per 100,000 population for 2022. That is down by 2.9% on the previous year, with a decrease of 11.1% compared to 2013, with the EASR now at the lowest it has been in data that goes back to 1998. However, figures published by Public Health Scotland showed that between 2013 and 2022 cancer deaths rose by 3.2%, from 15,764 to 16,265. This increase 'largely reflects an increase in the proportion of older age groups within the population, and the fact that cancer is more common among older people', the report from Public Health Scotland said. READ MORE: In 2022, more than two-thirds (69%) of all cancer deaths were in people aged seventy and over, the figures showed. Meanwhile four cancers – lung, bowel, breast and prostate – accounted for almost half (46%) of cancer deaths in that year, the report added. Lung cancer remained as the most common cause of cancer deaths, with a total of 3,925 people dying as a result of this in 2022 – almost a quarter (24.1%) of all cancer deaths that year. The report also found that in 2022 cases of cancer were almost a quarter (23.9%) higher in the most deprived parts of Scotland than they were in the least deprived communities – and mortality rates were 78% higher in the poorest areas. Public Health Scotland said that 'mortality reflects the combined effects of increased risk and poorer survival from cancer in more deprived areas'. The report also noted that while overall cancer death rates have declined for both men and women since 2012, there had been 'notable increases' for some forms of the disease. Liver cancer deaths have risen by 15% amongst men and by 20% amongst women over the period 2013 to 2022. However, Public Health Scotland said; 'Nearly half (49%) of liver cancer cases are preventable through lifestyle changes such as reducing obesity, smoking, alcohol consumption, and preventing viral liver infections.' Labour health spokesperson, Dame Jackie Baillie, said it was 'deeply worrying that the number of cancer deaths in Scotland has risen over the course of a decade'. She added that these deaths include 'an alarming increase in the number of men dying from cancer, with a rise of 5% between 2013 and 2022.' Dame Jackie said the Scottish Government was 'moving too slowly on its commitment to introduce lung cancer screening'. She further insisted: 'SNP ministers must also act urgently to improve waiting times for cancer treatment as almost a third of patients referred to the NHS in Scotland are waiting longer than the 62-day target to start treatment.' Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton said the figures showed that 'cancer patients cannot depend on this SNP Government'. Hitting out at SNP ministers the Liberal Democrat said: 'In Scotland, more people die of lung cancer than any other form of disease. Survival rates aren't much better than what they were in the 1970s. 'International studies show Scotland falling behind with cancer care. The SNP's failure to roll out a national lung cancer screening programme is another example of that.' He added: 'My party wants to see the government ending their dithering and making a full rollout of this screening programme a top priority. 'We know there isn't a moment to lose when it comes to getting cancer patients life-saving interventions.' However Health Secretary Neil Gray said: 'It is encouraging to see the risk of dying from cancer in Scotland is at a record low. 'This is down to the hard work of NHS staff, improved treatment options, and people reporting their symptoms at an earlier stage.' He added: 'We are determined to further improve cancer survival, reduce waiting times and provide excellent, equitably accessible care right across Scotland.' The Health Secretary said the Scottish Government is 'taking action to improve the awareness and earlier diagnosis of cancers, including expanding our Rapid Cancer Diagnostic Services and our investment of more than £14 million towards cancer waiting times this year'. He also stated: 'Reducing health inequalities is a clear ambition for this government. 'Cutting smoking rates is key to tackling lung cancer incidence in areas of deprivation – our world-leading tobacco control measures are helping us in our goal of a Tobacco-Free Scotland by 2034.'
The National
11 hours ago
- The National
Scottish chemical company fined £100k after worker burned
A 23-year-old man was permanently scarred from burns from a steam hose at Omoa Works in Newarthill, which is owned by Dundas Chemical Company (Mosspark) Limited. He suffered burns across his back and other areas of his body as he attempted to clean a process water tank on October 23, 2019. READ MORE: Two charged after alleged 'gangland firebombing' of Edinburgh taxi firm The large rendering plant in Newarthill processes animal waste and food industry waste to produce proteins, fats and oils used in the chemical, fuel and feed industries. The man was instructed to clean the process water tank during a nightshift (pictured), and was provided pressure washers and a steam hose for cleaning. The steam hose was heavy and difficult to move, so the man and a colleague took it in turns to hold it, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said. The pair stopped to take a break after some time, before his colleague went on to carry out other duties. The 23-year-old man finished cleaning the process water tank on his own. He did so with the aid of a small cherry picker, attaching the steam hose to its basket and raising it to the correct height. It was at this point that the steam hose and nozzle spun round and steam began flowing into the cherry picker directly towards him. The man quickly turned his back to prevent his face from being burned, while manipulating the nozzle of the hose away from him and lowering the basket of the cherry picker. He then ran to one of the site's deluge showers to cool his burn injuries. The man was taken to hospital with steam burns to multiple parts of his body, which have left permanent scars. READ MORE: easyJet launches new route from Scottish airport to major European capital A HSE investigation found that the nozzle which was fitted to the steam hose was unsafe, as it did not have a trigger or other mechanisation to allow its user to control the flow out of the nozzle. HSE also said that the mixing valve and set-up which supplies hot water for cleaning purposes was "not maintained in an efficient working order or in good repair". The investigation found that supervisors at the site were aware that the mixing valve was passing steam but no action was taken to investigate the issue or prevent it from happening. The company did not hold any records associated with the maintenance of the valve, hose, or nozzle, the HSE found. Dundas Chemical Company (Mosspark) Limited pleaded guilty to breaching section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. The company was fined £100k at Hamilton Sheriff Court on Monday. Commenting, HSE inspector Ashley Fallis said: 'Had a safe system of work been in place then this incident would not have happened. 'The lack of appropriate risk assessment, method statements, training and supervision for both the maintenance team who installed the valve, and the operators tasked with using the system, led to a situation where those involved were unaware of risks or simple control measures. 'This catalogue of failures resulted in a young man sustaining very serious burns, to which he still bears the scars to this day. 'We will not hesitate to take action against companies that fail to protect their employees.'
