Trapping social media influencers: ISI's strategy to weave an espionage-cum-propaganda network
Investigations into Pakistan's Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) latest modus operandi of espionage have revealed a concentrated effort to invite, entice, and then co-opt social media influencers through a variety of lures to build a web of informers among the community.
Speaking to The Indian Express, a senior official said the cases of Hisar-based YouTube channel operator Jyoti Malhotra and Ropar-based Jasbir Singh, who also ran a YouTube channel, are not isolated, and are part of a well-planned operation by ISI to increase its reach through the twin aims of collecting information and spreading propaganda.
Central intelligence agencies and the Punjab Police have been unravelling the spy network which was cultivated by several officials based in the Pakistan High Commission in New Delhi. Two staff members of the High Commission have already been thrown out of India after the government declared them persona non grata.
'ISI has been using a variety of tools to reach out to social media influencers not only in Punjab but across the country in order to weave an espionage-cum-propaganda network, which works out in favour of Pakistan. The first step is to invite the influencers of various platforms like YouTube, Instagram, X, Snapchat, etc, to the get-togethers of the Pakistan High Commission, and then offer them visas to visit Pakistan,' the official said.
Once the influencer travels to Pakistan, the next step of the operation kicks in, under which enticements may be offered by way of cash and kind, including the honeytrap method, which would be used to coerce them into doing their bidding. 'It is a slow process, and often multiple visits are encouraged to Pakistan, and the confidence level in ISI operatives who are working under cover is gradually built up. When the target knowingly or unknowingly makes a false step and falls into their clutches, they close the trap, making it difficult for the influencer to back out,' the official said.
Pakistan's efforts to entice Indian YouTube channel operators for espionage stem from a combination of strategic, geopolitical, and tactical motives. Leveraging social media influence for soft power and propaganda is boosted by the reach and credibility. YouTubers, especially those with large followings (Jasbir Singh with 1.1 million subscribers and Jyoti Malhotra with 377,000–381,000 subscribers), have significant online influence. Their content can shape public perceptions, making them valuable for projecting pro-Pakistan narratives or countering anti-Pakistan sentiment in India, say investigators.
By encouraging influencers to create content like 'Indian Girl in Pakistan', as seen in the case of Jyoti Malhotra, Pakistan aims to portray a positive image, potentially softening public opinion in India or globally. This aligns with 'soft power' strategies to influence narratives subtly while gathering intelligence. Influencers can also play a vital role in covert operations as they are less likely to arouse suspicion compared to traditional spies, as their travel vlogs and cultural exchanges appear innocuous, providing a cover for espionage activities.
ISI has also been found to be exploiting the financial vulnerabilities of influencers, as most YouTubers rely on views, sponsorships, or external funding. Pakistani operatives offer financial rewards, sponsored trips (like Malhotra's visits to Pakistan in 2023), or other incentives to lure influencers, exploiting their need for content and revenue.
Intelligence officials say that in the wake of Operation Sindoor and heightened India-Pakistan tensions, ISI likely seeks real-time intelligence on Indian military movements, cantonment details, and strategic operations, especially in border states like Punjab.
'Punjab's proximity to the India-Pakistan border makes it a focal point for espionage. YouTubers travelling in these regions can inadvertently or deliberately gather and share information about troop deployments, infrastructure, or security arrangements, which can be vital to the enemy who wants to collect granular data,' another official said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
22 minutes ago
- Indian Express
CLAT 2025 Topper: Meet Saksham Gautam; a humanities student with a love for Math
At a time when the counselling process of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) UG is underway, with the second merit list out and the third expected by June 20, The Indian Express caught up with the CLAT 2025 exam topper, Saksham Gautam. A humanities student from Delhi Public School, Faridabad, Gautam also aced his boards with a stunning 98.6 per cent. Speaking to this publication, Gautam shared his preparation strategy, mindset, and advice for future aspirants. Inspiration to choose law For Gautam, the decision to pursue law was rooted in both intellectual curiosity and a deeper civic aspiration. 'I began looking beyond Engineering and Medical as early as Class 7,' Gautam said, noting that despite coming from a family of engineers, STEM never quite clicked for him. 'Social Sciences, especially English and History, fascinated me. By Class 9 and 10, law emerged as a compelling avenue,' he added. He also emphasised his interest in public engagement. 'I don't want a corporate job. Many of our national leaders and freedom fighters were lawyers. Even in UPSC, law graduates have a good selection ratio,' he explained, hinting that public service remains a long-term option. Balancing CLAT with Class 12 boards 'It was challenging to balance CLAT with Class 12 boards,' Gautam admitted candidly. While attending regular school, he simultaneously prepared for CLAT with Legal Edge by Toprankers in Delhi. 'Prioritisation was key. If CLAT demanded more time, school took a backseat and vice versa,' he said. He began serious preparation in Class 11 by keeping 2-3 hours daily for CLAT. 'In 12th, I didn't track hours. I followed a task-based schedule. My goal was to complete all tasks by night,' he added. Challenging sections Reading comprehension, Gautam said, was 'one of the most demanding aspects of CLAT' since the exam is heavily passage-based. 'I wasn't an avid reader, so developing reading habits – especially newspapers and long-form articles – was hard at first,' he said. Logical Reasoning also posed challenges. 'Critical reasoning is dominant in CLAT. Being thorough with assumptions, arguments, and conclusions is essential,' he said, recommending consistent practice and attention to previous year questions. Speaking on Legal Reasoning, Gautam busted a common myth: 'You don't need to be legally literate. Familiarity with current legal developments is more important than rote learning legal jargon.' Importance of mock tests and coaching 'Mocks are non-negotiable. They show where you stand and how to adjust your preparation. CLAT changed drastically post-2020, so being aware of evolving patterns through mocks is crucial,' the CLAT topper said. While Gautam strongly benefited from coaching, he emphasised its purpose. 'Coaching doesn't make you successful – your effort does. What coaching gives is structure, discipline, and mentorship,' he said, noting that Legal Edge provided helpful material and guidance, particularly in General Knowledge. 'Mentorship, for me, meant someone analysing my mock scores, helping identify weak areas, and showing how to work on them,' he added. Tips on staying focused Addiction to social media, Gautam revealed, was his biggest challenge during preparation. 'I was distracted in Class 11 and even into 12th. The turning point was admitting to myself that it was hurting my preparation,' he shared. Deleting apps and seeking his parents' and teachers' supervision helped him regain control. 'Distractions will vary, but the first step is honest acceptance,' he said. Advice for future aspirants 'Start reading newspapers, editorials, anything,' he advised. 'Focus on improving reading speed and comprehension. Simultaneously, begin basic maths: percentages, averages, ratios,' Gautam added. He also urged aspirants not to ignore maths. 'Many fear it irrationally. But CLAT maths is of Class 8-9 level. You must tackle it. Maths and GK are game-changers in top ranks,' he said. Delay in CLAT results Calling the five-month delay in publication of CLAT results from December 2024 to May 2025 'distressing', Gautam said uncertainty was the real burden. 'At one point, it seemed the counselling process had been pushed indefinitely. Aspirants shouldn't be the ones suffering due to others' errors,' he said. The road ahead Gautam has not yet committed to a legal specialisation but is keeping his options open. 'College will help me figure that out,' he said. He's currently reading Dr B R Ambedkar's Annihilation of Caste and prefers spending leisure time walking or talking to friends rather than engaging in sports. In his words, 'CLAT may be unpredictable, but with consistency, mentorship, and self-discipline, it's absolutely conquerable.'
New Indian Express
39 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Spy case: Punjab YouTuber's remand extended by two days, police find 150 Pakistani numbers in his contact list
CHANDIGARH: A court in Mohali extended the police remand of Punjab YouTuber Jasbir Singh by two days. Singh was arrested on June 4 on charges of spying for Pakistan's ISI. Police said they found around 150 suspicious Pakistani numbers on Singh's contact list in his mobile phone. Singh was produced before the local court in Mohali on Saturday after his three-day police remand ended. The state police sought a seven-day remand but the court granted them two more days of custody, said Singh's counsel. A senior police official said Singh had met the Lahore-based Nasir Dhillon on three trips to Pakistan after they connected as fellow vloggers. Police are investigating the role of Dhillon and his potential links to Pakistani intelligence. He reportedly helped facilitate Singh's visa and visits. Police officials suspect that Singh might have deleted sensitive data from his mobile phone before his arrest. A forensic examination of the device is underway to recover any communications with Pakistani handlers. Singh's ties with other suspected operatives Haryana-based YouTuber Jyoti Malhotra and Shakir 'Jutt Randhawa', a Pakistani intelligence officer, are also being investigated.
Indian Express
43 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Solving Crime: How a woman's murder probe led Karnataka cops to a ‘Drishyam'-inspired crime that stayed hidden for 5 years
In 2013, the Malayalam film Drishyam, with its intricate plot of a man outwitting the police and covering up a murder, captivated audiences across India. But for a man in Karnataka, the film served as a blueprint for murder—a crime that went unnoticed until a routine missing person case in 2024 unravelled his web of deception. On August 12, 2024, a man named Balaraju walked into the Magadi police station with a worried expression. His friend Lalitha, a beautician from Madanayakanahalli on the outskirts of Bengaluru, had vanished without a trace. Known to many as Divya, the 30-year-old had been living separately from her husband, Umesh, for two years, raising their five-year-old son alone while pursuing divorce proceedings. The police later learnt that Lalitha's marriage to Umesh, a travel agency employee, had crumbled under the weight of his alcohol addiction. Her active Instagram presence was a source of constant suspicion for Umesh, who was convinced she was having an affair. The couple's separation had been bitter. That August evening, Umesh had called Lalitha to discuss the divorce, Balaraju told the police. Umesh suggested they meet near the Basavanna temple close to Magadi to discuss matters 'amicably', he allegedly said. Lalitha agreed, but sensing something amiss, she shared her live location on WhatsApp with Balaraju's wife, Uma, before she left, borrowing a two-wheeler from him. The live location that Lalitha shared told a chilling story. In the FIR, Balaraju said that at 6.17 pm, Lalitha's location signal ended abruptly near Honnapura Lake. When Uma tried calling Lalitha and Umesh, neither answered. At 8.12 pm, Balaraju told the police, Umesh returned the borrowed two-wheeler, claiming he had accompanied Lalitha and put her on a bus home. But 19 minutes later, at 8.31 pm, Umesh allegedly called Balaraju confessing that he had killed Lalitha and begged him not to tell anyone. Twelve minutes after that, he allegedly made another desperate call, pleading with Balaraju to delete the WhatsApp live location that had been shared, as per the FIR. Balaraju and Uma immediately alerted the police. Following the digital trail left by Lalitha's shared location, the police found her body buried in a forest. Umesh was arrested. So was an alleged accomplice, Kiran Kumar—a man who seemingly had no motive for the murder. What transpired later left the police shocked. During questioning, the police asked Kiran about his family. His response was allegedly matter-of-fact: his wife Pooja had eloped with another man a decade ago, leaving him to raise their seven-year-old daughter alone, he told the police. However, Inspector Giriraj G Y, who was leading the investigation, was puzzled by certain aspects of Umesh's crime. 'Why would Umesh bring his wife all the way from Madanayakanahalli to Magadi to kill her?' he remembers wondering. 'He could have done it anywhere close to his place.' When pressed, Umesh allegedly revealed that choosing the remote location had been Kiran's idea. This detail sparked Giriraj's curiosity about Kiran's background, especially since no family members had visited him after his arrest. The breakthrough came when a constable contacted Kiran's mother-in-law, Gowramma, who lived in Tavarekere, Bengaluru. When asked about her daughter Pooja, Gowramma's story differed from Kiran's narrative, the police said. She said Pooja had disappeared five years ago—not 10—and that Kiran had filed a missing person's complaint with Magadi police. A quick check of police records, however, revealed that no such missing complaint had ever been filed. When confronted with this discrepancy, Kiran allegedly claimed he had come with two friends to file the complaint. The police tracked down these alleged friends, who categorically denied accompanying Kiran to any police station. Faced with evidence of his alleged deception, Kiran's carefully constructed story began to collapse. Under intense interrogation, he allegedly confessed to a murder in Hujugallu village in Ramanagara district that had remained hidden for five years. Kiran's confession revealed a chilling parallel to the Mohanlal-starrer Drishyam that had allegedly inspired his crime. On May 1, 2019, following fights with his wife, Pooja, he strangled her to death, the police said. Taking inspiration from the film's protagonist, George Kutty, he buried her body in a forest near Magadi, creating an elaborate cover story about her eloping with another man, the police added. To maintain his deception, Kiran allegedly prepared a fake police complaint, which he would show to Gowramma whenever she inquired about the investigation's progress. Over time, Pooja's family's questions became less frequent, allowing Kiran to believe he had gotten away with murder. The story took an even more bizarre turn when Kiran revealed how Drishyam 2 also allegedly influenced his actions. Two years after the murder, forest department officials began digging trenches in the area to prevent elephants from entering nearby villages. Fearing his crime might be discovered, Kiran took inspiration from the sequel, he allegedly told the police. He allegedly secretly excavated Pooja's remains, burnt the bones and teeth, and reburied them at a farm. Like the movie's protagonist, he believed destroying evidence would eliminate any possibility of detection, the police said. On August 26, 2024, based on Gowramma's complaint, the police registered a murder case against Kiran. He led investigators to the burial site, where forensic experts and Tahsildar Sharath Kumar oversaw the excavation. The burnt bones and teeth were recovered and sent for DNA analysis, with samples from Gowramma taken for comparison. The Magadi police later filed charge sheets in both murder cases. Though Umesh and Kiran are out on bail, a police officer said that there was sufficient scientific evidence to prove the murders.
