Dinner parties, listening and lobbying. What goes on behind closed doors to elect a pope

Los Angeles Times

04-05-2025

ROME — Rome is bustling with jasmine blooming and tourists swarming. But behind closed doors, these are the days of dinner parties, coffee klatches and private meetings as cardinals in town to elect a successor to Pope Francis suss out who among them has the stuff to be next.
It was in this period of pre-conclave huddling in March of 2013 that Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor, the retired archbishop of Westminster, and other reform-minded Europeans began pushing the candidacy of an Argentine Jesuit named Jorge Mario Bergoglio. Their dinner-table lobbying worked, and Pope Francis won on the fifth ballot.
Cardinal Vincent Nichols may have inherited Murphy-O'Connor's position as archbishop of Westminster. But he's not taking on the job as the front-man papal lobbyist in these days of canvassing of cardinals to try to identify whom among them should be the next pope.
'We're of quite different styles,' Nichols said Friday, chuckling during an interview in the Venerable English College, the storied British seminary in downtown Rome where Nichols studied in the 1960s. 'Cardinal Cormac would love to be at the center of the party. I'm a little more reserved than that and a little bit more introverted.'
Nevertheless, Nichols, 79, provided an insider's view of what's going on among his fellow cardinal-electors, between meals of Rome's famous carbonara — as they get to know one another. They all descended on Rome to bid farewell to the pope and are now meeting informally before the start of the conclave on Wednesday.
Nichols says he is spending these days, before he and his fellow cardinals are sequestered, listening. The routine calls for cardinals to meet each morning in a Vatican auditorium to discuss the needs of the Roman Catholic Church and the type of person who can lead it. These meetings are open to all cardinals, including those over 80, while the conclave itself in the Sistine Chapel is limited to cardinals who haven't yet reached 80.
With the exception of an afternoon Mass — part of the nine days of official mourning for Francis — the rest of the day is free. Cardinals have been seen around town taking walks or eating out, trying to remain incognito.
Nichols said a picture of the future pope is beginning to emerge, at least in his mind, as cardinals look back at Francis' 12-year pontificate and see where to go from here.
'I suppose we're looking for somebody who even in their manner not only expresses the depth of the faith, but also its openness,' said Nichols.
Pope Benedict XVI named Nichols archbishop of Westminster in 2009, but he didn't become a cardinal until 2014, when Francis tapped him in his first batch of cardinals. Francis went on to name Nichols as a member of several important Vatican offices, including the powerful Dicastery for Bishops, which vets bishop nominations around the world.
'My experience so far, to be quite honest with you, is there's a lot of attentive listening,' Nichols said. 'That's listening to the people who might have an idea today of who they think is the best candidate, and I wouldn't be surprised if by Monday they might have changed their mind.'
Nichols said the picture that is emerging is one of seeing Francis' pontificate in continuity with the more doctrinaire papacies of St. John Paul II and Benedict XVI, and of appreciating the multicultural reality of the Catholic Church today. Francis greatly expanded the College of Cardinals to include cardinals from far-flung places like Tonga and Mongolia, rather than the traditional centers of European Catholicism.
Yes, divisions and disagreements have been aired. 'But I can never remember a time when Catholics all agreed about everything,' Nichols said. 'We're not a boys' brigade that marches in step.'
But he said he sensed that cardinals believe Francis' reforming papacy and radical call to prioritize the poor and marginalized, to care for the planet and all its people, needed further consolidating with another papacy.
'There's a sense that the initiatives that this man of such originality took, they probably do need rooting a bit more to give them that stability and evident continuity,' Nichols said. 'So that these aren't just the ideas of one person, one charismatic person, but they are actually consistently part of how the church reflects on humanity, our own humanity and our world.'
In his book 'The Great Reformer,' Francis' biographer Austen Ivereigh described the 2013 conclave and how Nichols' predecessor, Murphy-O'Connor, and other reform-minded Europeans seized the opportunity to push Bergoglio after it was clear the Italians were fighting among themselves over the Italian candidate.
'Team Bergoglio,' as these reform-minded cardinals came to be known, had tried to talk up Bergoglio in the 2005 conclave, but failed to get their man through after Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger's momentum grew and Bergoglio bowed out — leading to the papacy of Benedict XVI.
In 2013, with many too old to vote in the conclave, Team Bergoglio talked up the Argentine at dinner parties around Rome in the days before voting began. The aim was to ensure Bergoglio could secure at least 25 votes on the first ballot to establish himself as a serious candidate, the book said.
'The Great Reformer' recounts a dinner party at the North American College, the U.S. seminary in Rome, on March 5, 2013, to which Murphy-O'Connor and Australian Cardinal George Pell were invited and where the British cardinal talked up the qualities of a possible first Latin American pope.
'He held a number of these dinners, and I think there were a few of them involved, a few who had grown convinced that Bergoglio was what the church needed,' Ivereigh said Friday.
Nichols doesn't have any such calculations or preferred candidate, at least that he is willing to share.
'For me, it's no good going into a conclave thinking it's like a political election and I want my side to win. I'm not going to do that,' he said. 'I'm going to go in certainly with my own thoughts but ready to change them, to listen and maybe try and persuade others to change theirs too.'
Winfield writes for the Associated Press.