Loan company exploited social grant beneficiaries, high court rules
The high court in Johannesburg has declared that it is unreasonable to offer social grant beneficiaries insurance for disability and retrenchment if they are already disabled or unemployed.
An insurance product offered by credit provider JDG Trading included cover for disability and retrenchment. But disabled and unemployed clients, mostly social grant beneficiaries, would never be able to make a claim for disability or retrenchment.
The court ruled recently that this exploited social grant beneficiaries who took out loans from JDG Trading and infringed on their constitutional right to social assistance.
JDG Trading offers loans to social grant beneficiaries for household goods and furniture. Customers are required to insure the loans, and can purchase insurance from JDG Trading directly or another provider.
Because JDG Trading's insurance bundle included cover for disability and retrenchment, and many of its clients are already disabled or unemployed, the National Credit Regulator took JDG to the National Credit Tribunal, arguing that the insurance policy was unreasonable and against the National Credit Act.
The National Credit Tribunal ruled in favour of JDG and the regulator — whose mandate is to promote and support the development of a fair, transparent, competitive, sustainable, responsible, efficient and effective consumer credit market — then took the matter to the high court.
The regulator argued in court that by offering cover for retrenchment and disability to unemployed or disabled people, JDG made customers assume a risk that was unreasonable. JDG was using these customers, who could not fully benefit from the policy, to subsidise others who could, the regulator argued.
Rights group Black Sash, represented by the Centre for Applied Legal Studies, joined as a friend of the court. It argued that the insurance policy particularly affected social grant beneficiaries and therefore infringed on the constitutional right of access to social security and social assistance. Black Sash submitted expert evidence from an actuary to demonstrate the impact on customers.
But JDG Trading argued that its policy was not unreasonable because consumers were not obliged to sign up for its insurance and were free to obtain the insurance elsewhere.
JDG Trading argued that the regulator and Black Sash had taken a 'paternalistic approach' and failed to provide any evidence of consumers who misunderstood the policy's provisions at the time they signed up or had been deceived.
It said its product was affordable and convenient, thereby enabling greater access to credit.
Johannesburg high court judges Shaida Mohamed and Khashane Manamela agreed with Black Sash and the regulator that the policy was unreasonable.
The consumers in this case belonged to a marginalised group who are dependent on social grants for their existence, the judges said. Because the insurance policy was offered to the consumer at the point of sale it was unlikely they had time to consider it properly.
JDG Trading had conceded that this class of consumers could never have made use of the policy and therefore it was clear they were cross-subsidising younger consumers who could benefit from the policy.
Pensioners would not knowingly sign up for a disadvantageous policy, the judges said.
There was no option to exclude the disability or retrenchment cover from the bundle.
By placing an unfair burden on a vulnerable segment of society, the insurance product was at odds with the goals of the National Credit Act, which aimed to make credit more accessible and combat inequitable and discriminatory practices to this end, the court said.
The appeal was therefore upheld with each party to pay their own costs.
This story was first published by
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
13 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Nkosana Makate ‘still resilient' as ConCourt overturns billion-rand ruling in battle with Vodacom
In a scathing judgment, Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga described the nearly 20-year legal battle between Nkosana Makate and Vodacom as 'unending litigation' and slammed the Supreme Court of Appeal for multiple errors in its February 2024 ruling, which would have awarded Makate billions for his Please Call Me idea. When Nkosana Makate walked into the corridors of the Constitutional Court on Thursday, 31 July, where Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga was set to deliver his final ruling from the bench, he was in high spirits, hopeful that the court would finally bring an end to his battle with telecommunications giant Vodacom, a fight that had gone on for almost 20 years. Hours later, the court delivered another blow for Makate as it unanimously referred the matter back to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) and instructed that a new panel of judges reconsider the case. Delivering a scathing judgment, Madlanga described the almost two-decade legal saga as an unending litigation and said the SCA made several errors in its February 2024 judgment, which would have seen Makate net at least R9-billion. That ruling has now been set aside. 'The Supreme Court of Appeal failed to provide adequate reasons for its judgment and disregarded or was unaware of certain material acts and issues before it,' Madlanga said. WATCH | The Constitutional Court has unanimously ruled in favour of Vodacom, setting aside the 2024 SCA decision that ordered the company to pay Nkosana Makate between 5% and 7.5% of the revenue earned from the service over 18 years. The matter will now return to the SCA. — Nonkululeko Njilo (@Nkulee_Njilo) July 31, 2025 The SCA had ruled that Makate was entitled to be paid 5% to 7.5% of the total revenue of the Please Call Me (PCM) product from March 2001 to the date of judgment, plus interest. This Constitutional Court had previously ordered Vodacom to pay him 'reasonable' compensation, which led Vodacom to offer R47-million. The R9-billion determined by the Supreme Court of Appeal would have 'devastating consequences' for the mobile-network operator, its employees and its investors, Johannesburg-based Vodacom said in its papers. 'Forever resilient' Speaking to journalists after the judgment, Makate said: 'We expected a different decision but we have to abide by the court's decision. We will go to the SCA and it must just relook at the case and provide us with a judgment that will then stand the test.' Asked whether he felt disappointed by the legal system – after years of back-and-forth in his dispute with Vodacom over compensation for the call-back service idea he presented to the company's product development team while working in its finance division in the 2000s – Makate said: 'I think they could have finalised the matter. We still had a hearing at the high court which they could have gone to as well and then ignored the SCA completely.' Makate said he remained resilient and was confident that justice would ultimately be served: 'I am still resilient, I will forever be.' While the case has proven to be financially and emotionally costly, Makate said he would explore all avenues available to him. 'We will do what we have to do,' he said. It was the second time the case was heard by the ConCourt. In 2016, the court affirmed that Makate was the inventor of Please Call Me and ordered Vodacom to enter into good-faith negotiations with him to determine reasonable compensation. However, compensation talks between Makate and Vodacom have been acrimonious as he accused the company of deliberately withholding information about the lucrativeness of Please Call Me. In 2020, the High Court in Pretoria made a similar ruling as it ordered Vodacom to play open cards and disclose financial records relating to the Please Call Me service, including the revenue it has generated for the telecommunications giant. This was considered a victory for Makate, who used the financial records to determine the settlement that Vodacom could shell out for his idea that gave rise to the service. DM
Mail & Guardian
14 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Reserve Bank cuts interest rates to 7% in widely expected decision
Reserve Bank governor Lesetja Kganyago The Governor Thursday's cut was the second consecutive one this year. The announcement was delivered against the backdrop of global uncertainty as the tariffs announced by US President Donald Trump are set to kick in on 1 August. South Africa will be faced with a 'The United States paused tariff increases in April, but that pause expires tomorrow, and many countries do not yet have new trade deals,' Kganyago said. Global oil prices have also fluctuated due to the conflict in the Middle East, while the tariffs will affect trade costs with other countries. Economists have also said it will affect local growth but the governor said the global economy has shown 'resilience' in the face of these tariffs. 'To date, global economic activity has been broadly resilient to these stresses. The world growth outlook is largely unchanged from our last meeting. But there are risks that permanently higher tariffs, or adverse geopolitical developments, could cause more disruption to the global economy than we have seen so far this year.' The Reserve Bank revised its economic growth prospects for South Africa downward on the back of the tariffs, and the slow growth reported during the first quarter of 2025, which was only 0.1%, and in line with its earlier expectations. 'Along with an assumption of higher US tariffs on South Africa, this has caused us to mark down our 2025 growth forecast. The economy's underlying growth trend remains low, mainly due to persistent supply-side problems, for instance in logistics,' Kganyago said, adding that high uncertainty and low business confidence was also affecting productivity in the country. The Reserve Bank is, however, cautiously positive about growth picking up in the coming years, supported by ongoing structural reforms, he added. South Africa's 'The South African Reserve Bank has been more cautious than some of its global peers, but this cut suggests that inflation is now firmly anchored and opens the door for a more flexible approach going forward,' said Maarten Ackerman, the chief economist at Citadel. 'This move signals that the [South African Reserve Bank] is comfortable with the inflation trajectory and is willing to provide support to the economy, as long as price stability remains intact.' The Reserve Bank has also been considering scenarios where the 'It is important to sustain this progress and to minimise uncertainty about the longer-term objectives of monetary policy,' Kganyago noted. 'Therefore, the [monetary policy committee] now prefers inflation to settle at 3%. In line with this, we have decided to aim for the bottom of our inflation target range, of 3 to 6%.' 'We welcome the recent moderation in inflation expectations and would like to see expectations fall further. This would expand policy space and make our framework more robust to shocks. We will use forecasts with a 3% inflation anchor at future meetings.' Kganyago told a media briefing that the central bank had not received confirmation from the finance ministry on the decision to lower the target range. 'The South African Reserve Bank will also continue working with the national treasury to complete target reform and achieve permanently low inflation,' he added. Ackerman said there was a probability of at least one more interest cut before the end of the year. 'Beyond that, we expect the Reserve Bank to pause and reassess the data, particularly inflation trends and global developments,' he said.
Mail & Guardian
15 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Rooted and rising: Retang Phaahla on winning the Veuve Clicquot Bold Woman award
To a tea: Retang Phaahla, winner of the Veuve Clicquot Bold Woman Award On a crisp Johannesburg evening lit by candlelight, champagne bubbles and ancestral whispers, Retang Phaahla stepped onto the Veuve Clicquot Bold Woman Award stage with the quiet poise of someone who has carried a vision through soil and storm. Her acceptance was tender, unforced. She did not shout her victory. Instead, she let it rise like the steam from a freshly brewed cup of her signature Tepane tea. The award, established in 1972, is not just a global celebration of female entrepreneurship, it's a mirror to Madame Clicquot herself, a pioneering widow who, in the early 1800s, took over her late husband's wine business and turned it into a champagne empire. It recognises contemporary women who, like Madame Clicquot, lead with audacity, innovation and purpose. In South Africa, where history and heritage run deep, Phaahla's win was more than a nod to her business acumen. It was a triumph of legacy, community and reclamation. Phaahla is the co-founder and CEO of Setsong Tea Crafters, a purpose-led company rooted in the indigenous knowledge systems of the Bapedi people of Sekhukhune in Limpopo. Together with her mother, and now her brother, she has transformed ancestral know-how into a global-facing wellness brand and done so with radical reverence for the land and the people who have always known its value. 'I'm still soaking it all in,' she says, her voice soft yet unwavering. 'To take that brave step as an entrepreneur, to build something out of Indigenous knowledge … this award is validating. It reminds me that the work we're doing is not just important, it's necessary.' For Phaahla, boldness is not loudness. It is not ego. It is choosing to lead with purpose, especially when the path is uncharted. She did not set out to build a tea empire. In fact, she thought she was simply helping her mother formalise a small idea, a humble act of service from daughter to mother. But soon, she realised that she was standing on sacred ground. The teas they were experimenting with — Tepane (black bush tea) and Diya (red root tea), held more than flavour. They held memory, wisdom, healing. 'These plants have been used for over a hundred years in our community,' she says. 'Long before laboratories. Long before packaging. Our elders knew their value and how they supported immunity, digestion, hormonal balance. When we finally did lab testing, the results affirmed everything our people had always known.' The affirmation didn't end in the lab. It echoed into boardrooms and buyers' meetings, into supermarket shelves and online carts. Today, Setsong is stocked at Food Lover's Market nationwide, several Spar stores in Pretoria and Johannesburg and is completing its listing with Dis-Chem. You can also find it on Takealot, Makro online and Setsong's own e-commerce platform. Setsong's main production site is not in an industrial estate or office park. It's on inherited land in Sekhukhune, where seven rondavels once stood — built by Phaahla's grandfather and used by generations of family members. When she and her mother began building their tea business, they didn't have the capital to construct a modern facility, so they did what many entrepreneurs are afraid to do — they used what they had. 'We renovated the rondavels into food-safe tea-processing units,' she explains. 'Each one now serves a purpose in our value chain, from drying and blending to packaging and dispatch. 'Outside, they look like traditional rondavels but, inside, they meet all industry standards.' It is a perfect metaphor for Setsong's approach which is modern sophistication wrapped in ancestral dignity. The rondavels are referred to as the 'tea village', where young villagers walk barefoot between pieces of modern stainless-steel equipment, working with the leaves their grandmothers once brewed at dawn. The transformation hasn't only been infrastructural. It's been social. Setsong is a registered social enterprise — 49% of it is owned by two local cooperatives — ensuring that the benefits of the business flow directly back to the community. Her mother continues to be the heart of that social arm. 'She's a community builder at heart,' Retang says proudly. 'She ensures that we remain rooted in our values and in sustainability, upliftment and legacy. That has allowed me to focus on innovation, market growth and scaling the business.' It's a mother-daughter partnership that's less about hierarchy than harmony. And, with her brother on board handling legal and governance, the family's vision is evolving into a multi-generational force. What sets Setsong apart isn't only its origin story or its social architecture. It's Phaahla's ability to listen — really listen to her customers. 'As a Millennial, I knew we needed to meet modern consumers where they are,' she says. 'People want wellness solutions that feel good and taste good.' So, she went into her kitchen and began infusing tradition with innovation. Today, Setsong offers a wide range of flavoured brews — lemon, ginger and berry Detox Tea; orange, ginger and turmeric Calming Tea, strawberry and fennel Sleepy Tea and orange spiced Immunity Tea, to name a few. And all of it starts with the base of Tepane or Diya, deeply rooted in African soil and wisdom. In a market saturated with luxury wellness brands, Setsong offers something different — a product that is aspirational without being extractive, luxurious without losing its soul. 'Consumers are increasingly seeking out brands that have a conscience,' Phaahla says. 'They want to know that their money is supporting something meaningful. 'That's where our social model aligns perfectly with our brand.' It's a careful balancing act, to scale while staying grounded. But Retang believes the two are not opposites. They are partners. 'We divide the roles intentionally. My mom safeguards the soul. I drive the scale.' Now that the champagne toasts have settled and the bold woman trophy sits on her shelf, Phaahla is focused on growth. Setsong is expanding into more local and international markets, including the hospitality and corporate sectors. But she's also thinking beyond products. On their farm, they've launched tea tours, immersive experiences for tourists to witness the story behind the brew. And personally? 'I'm working on myself as a businesswoman,' she says. 'I'm excited for the mentorship opportunities that come with this award. There's always more to learn and powerful women to learn from.' When I ask her which tea to recommend for my diabetic mother, she doesn't hesitate. 'Go for the Red Root Calming Tea, the one with orange, ginger and turmeric. It helps with blood sugar and turmeric helps bind glucose.' She says it with the conviction of a healer and the finesse of a CEO. In a world that often asks women to choose between being soulful and being strategic, Phaahla has chosen both — and that is truly bold.
