British Air India families are sent the WRONG bodies: Grieving loved ones are returned caskets with unknown passengers inside
Bereaved families are suffering fresh heartache because the remains of their loved ones were wrongly identified before being flown home.
Relatives of one victim had to abandon funeral plans after being informed that their coffin contained the body of an unknown passenger rather than their family member.
In another distressing case, the 'commingled' remnants of more than one person killed in the crash were mistakenly placed in the same casket.
They had to be separated before the internment could go ahead last weekend.
The shocking blunders only emerged when Inner West London coroner Dr Fiona Wilcox sought to verify the repatriated Britons' identities by matching their DNA with samples provided by the families.
Tonight, a top-level inquiry into the scandal is underway in London and India, and Prime Minister Keir Starmer is expected to raise concerns with his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi on his state visit to Britain this week.
Though two instances of mistaken identity have so far come to light, there are fears that more such errors could have been made, leaving families under a shadow of uncertainty.
Pictured: Debris at the site of a plane crash near Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport
Pictured: Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, the sole survivor of the Air India flight 171 crash
Pictured: Thick black smoke billowing from a residential area after Air India flight 171 crashed in Ahmedabad
Of the 261 people who died when Air India flight 171 lost power and crashed, seconds after leaving Ahmedabad for London Gatwick, 52 were returning Britons.
And while some victims were either speedily cremated or buried in India, in accordance with their religious beliefs, aviation lawyer James Healy-Pratt, who represents many of the British families, says the remains of at least 12 have been repatriated.
Mr Healy-Pratt was enlisted to uncover the full facts behind the catastrophe - caused when the Dreamliner's fuel supply was either intentionally or accidentally switched off, according to a preliminary report - and fight for compensation in the courts.
But this week he is investigating the botched identification process.
'I've been sitting down in the homes of these lovely British families over the last month, and the first thing they want is their loved ones back,' he told the Mail.
'But some of them have got the wrong remains and they are clearly distraught over this. It has been going on for a couple of weeks (and) I think these families deserve an explanation.'
Though the family who received 'commingled' remains had been able to have them separated and hold a funeral service, he said, the second set of relatives - whom he called Family X - had been left 'in limbo'.
'Family X have no-one to bury because it was the wrong person in their casket. And if isn't their relative, the question is, who is it in that coffin? Presumably it's another passenger and their relatives have been given the wrong remains.
Pictured: People carrying the body of a victim from the crash site after Air India flight 171 crashed in Ahmedabad
Pictured: The Air India flight 171 stuck on the side of the building after the crash
Pictured: The aftermath of the Air India plane crash. Within three days the remains of virtually all the victims were believed to have been found, although the 1500C heat had burnt most beyond recognition
'The coroner also has a problem because she has an unidentified person in her jurisdiction.'
The lawyer is now trying to establish the precise chain of events in the recovery and identification process, beginning when the bodies were pulled from the jet's smouldering wreckage and ending when they reached Britain.
It will be no easy task. For arriving in India in the aftermath of the disaster on June 12, grieving British families were incensed by the chaotic ground operation and immediately recognised the danger of misidentification.
One relative criticised the 'lack of transparency and oversight in the identification and handling of remains', and there were calls for a British-run ID unit to be flown in.
'Our loved ones were British citizens. They deserved better in life. They certainly deserved better in death,' was one embittered refrain.
The operation to recover remains began soon after the plane crashed into a medical hostel and houses near Ahmedabad airport. It was led by local recovery teams from Ahmedabad's police and fire departments and the state disaster response force.
They used sniffer dogs and hi-tech search equipment and were aided by local volunteers who sifted the twisted, smouldering metal with their hands.
Within three days the remains of virtually all the victims were believed to have been found, although the 1500C heat had burnt most beyond recognition. Others were mutilated or fragmented by the force of the impact.
Pictured: Rescue workers at the site of the crash. The repatriation of Britons killed in the Air India disaster has been horrifically bungled, the Daily Mail can reveal
Pictured: Ambulances waiting to transfer the dead bodies of victims from the hospital complex in Ahmedabad on June 14, 2025
It meant that many families received their remains from the Civil Hospital in Ahmedabad - which served as the central ID hub - in a plastic container, rather than a coffin.
Relatives were asked to supply DNA samples to be used as identification but in the most severe cases they had to be matched against dental records.
Families could only rely on officials to carry out the process accurately and label the containers correctly.
'Nobody looked at the remains. We weren't allowed to,' said Altaf Taju, from Blackburn, whose London-based parents Adam, 72 and Hasina, 70, perished along with their son-on-law Altafhusen Patel, 51.
'They just said, "This is your mother or father", and gave us a paper label with an ID number on it. We had to take their word for it. It's horrific that this could have happened, but what could anyone do?'
Mr Taju was told of the mix-up by a police liaison officer. He takes comfort from the fact that his parents and brother-in-law were not involved in the confusion because they were buried quickly, in India, to comply with their Muslim faith.
By June 28, Indian authorities claimed DNA tests had conformed the identities of all 260 fatalities. Those victims flown back to Britain were transported by Air India, though some families complained of unnecessary delays and lack of information from the airline.
Approached by the Mail, Dr Wilcox said it would be inappropriate for her to comment.
Pictured: A policeman and medics transferring bodies of victims onto an ambulance after the Air India Flight 171 crash
Pictured: Debris at the site of a plane crash near Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport in Ahmedabad
Mr Healy-Pratt added: 'On the known evidence, the chain of custody of these lost loved ones was unacceptably poor.
'We are investigating the causes of those failures and demanding answers on behalf of these deserving British families.
'We await formal responses from Air India, and their emergency response contractors - Kenyons International Emergency Services.
'The families are also directly in contact with their MPs, the FCDO and the offices of the Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary- ahead of Premier Modi's visit to London this week.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
22 minutes ago
- The Independent
Team breaking scams ‘spell' stops £3.5m going to criminals in first half of 2025
A fraud prevention team set up to 'break the spell' on victims has stopped £3.5 million of funds getting into the hands of criminals in the first six months of this year. Santander UK's specialist Break the Spell team intervenes in situations where it is suspected that customers are being tricked and manipulated by scammers such as romance and payments fraudsters. Victims of crimes such as romance fraud can end up being highly manipulated by a complex web of stories. They may also be discouraged by criminals from speaking to anyone or encouraged to lie if their loved ones or their bank ask them what is happening. Santander's specially-trained team, which uses behavioural psychology, encourages people to open up and supports them, for example by signposting them to further sources of support such as Citizens Advice and the Samaritans, depending on the circumstances. Cases may be referred to it when there are 'red flags' with payments that people are attempting to make. Referrals may also be made from branches. Michelle Pilsworth, head of fraud and customer experience, said the crime dealt with by the team 'is a particularly horrible and cruel crime'. She told the PA news agency that the team supports people who have been tricked into sending money to people they believe they are in a relationship with, as well as people who have been tricked into believing they are helping organisations such as the police or HM Revenue and Customs. Ms Pilsworth said: 'The reason it's complex is the level of social engineering… a quick call is not going to 'break the spell'.' She continued: 'We have to work a long time with them to try and help them see that that is a spell that they're under.' Ms Pilsworth said the team was set up to help understand what fraud victims are going through and to 'work with them'. In some cases, victims may be starting to have their own doubts about a fraud following an initial call from the bank, by the time they are contacted by the Break the Spell team. 'Quite often they will say by that point: 'Yes, it doesn't sound right, I've had time to think',' Ms Pilsworth said. 'At that point we will break the spell and we will educate them and stop the payment, protect the funds, all that good stuff.' But for some people, further intervention may be needed, she said, which could be via calls or branch visits. Staff work to build trust with the customer over time. As the customer explains to staff what they have been told, seeds of doubt in the customer's mind may then start to emerge, for example if they recall that they were expecting to meet the romance scammer but they did not turn up. Ms Pilsworth said: 'We get them to realise what's happening to them. And then, it's all about support, how do we support that person.' Scammers will often try to regain their victim's trust, and so for some people, changing their phone number is a way to stop contact. Some scammers may even pretend that they can help victims recoup funds they have already lost. 'Many colleagues keep customers for days, weeks, sometimes months, because it's a long process,' said Ms Pilsworth. Sometimes people may feel embarrassed or angry, but Ms Pilsworth said: 'We say: 'Look, this can happen to anybody, from the work we've done we can see this happens to anyone'.'
The Independent
22 minutes ago
- The Independent
Mapped: London's knife crime hotspots revealed
Knife crime in London has surged by nearly 60 per cent in the past three years, new analysis has revealed. The West End is the capital's knife crime hotspot, accounting for one in every 15 knife attacks in London, the report from the Policy Exchange think tank said. The research found that in 2024, one small area of around 20 streets in London's West End near Oxford Circus and Regent Street had more knife crime than nearly 15 per cent of the rest capital combined. Across the UK, knife crime recorded by the police decreased by 1 per cent in the year ending March 2025 to 53,047 offences, compared to the previous year, which saw 53,685 offences. The Metropolitan Police, which is the force for most of London, accounted for 31 per cent of all knife crime across England and Wales in 2024. There were 108 knife crime offences in the highest hotspot in the West End, which was more than the 716 'safest' areas combined. This area includes Oxford Circus and parts of New Bond Street, Oxford Street, Regent Street and Piccadilly Circus. These areas, known as Lower-layer Super Output Areas (LSOAs), are geographical areas which comprise of comprise a resident population of between 1,000 and 3,000 people. The top 200 LSOAs for knife crime within London reported 3,615 knife crimes in 2024, according to Policy Exchange. The report recommended that the Met Police should introduce a 'zero tolerance' approach in the top 20 knife crime hotspots. Officers in these areas would conduct 'very high volumes' of stop and searches, it suggested. It also recommended that permanent live facial recognition systems should be deployed in each of the top knife crime hotspots in London, with officers deployed at peak times. David Spencer, a former Met detective and author of the report, said: 'The only approach which will both work and be recognised by the public as working is a 'zero-tolerance' approach to crime and criminals – particularly in those locations where crime is rife.' Most knife crime offences in London are robberies, official statistics show, with mobile phones a key target. Of the 16,789 knife crime offences committed in 2024, 62 per cent (10,346) of these were robberies. Earlier this year, The Independent revealed there were at least 83,900 phone theft offences recorded across the country in the 12 months to July last year – almost double the 45,800 five years previously. The figures obtained from 29 forces show the Metropolitan Police dealt with more than three-quarters of all mobile phone thefts (64,224) last year, followed by Kent Police (1,722), South Yorkshire Police (1,577) and Lancashire Police (1,467). Commander Hayley Sewart, lead for knife crime at the Metropolitan Police Service, said: 'Tackling violent crime is our top priority and every month across London we are making over 1,000 more arrests than we were last year - with knife-related crime (16 per cent) and robbery (13 per cent) both falling significantly. 'We are putting more officers in neighbourhoods than ever before, using our stop and search powers to take 17,500 weapons off the streets over the past four years, and deploying new technology and data-driven tactics to bring offenders to justice.' A spokesperson for the mayor of London said: 'Nothing is more important to the mayor than keeping Londoners safe and he is determined to continue leading from the front to build a safer London for all. 'Thanks to the hard work of the Met Police and partners, homicides, gun crime with lethal barrel discharges, knife crime with injury and burglary are all down since 2016 and last year teen murders were the lowest they've been in over a decade.' 'Record funding from the mayor and an enhanced approach to neighbourhood policing in the West End has led to personal robberies falling by 20 per cent and violence with injury reducing by 25 per cent in the last year. 'The mayor is determined to build on this progress – his record £1.16bn funding has secured 935 police officers and he has worked closely with the commissioner to increase the number of police officers on the beat in the West End, plus additional police officers working in new or enhanced town centre teams in hotspot areas.'
BBC News
22 minutes ago
- BBC News
Pensioner's hotel scalding death could have been prevented
The death of a pensioner who was fatally scalded after being trapped in a Perthshire hotel room bath could have been avoided, an inquiry has Hunter died at the Pitlochry Hydro in 2019 after being trapped in the bath, while guests and emergency services tried to smash in the door.A fatal accident inquiry (FAI) found that the failure of safety components in the unmaintained bath tap caused Mr Hunter to accidentally discharge scalding water into the bath in which he was hotel is under new ownership following the collapse of Specialist Leisure Group in 2020. Mr Hunter's family said the judgement was "the most difficult thing we have ever had to read".His son Keir previously described the 90-minute effort to rescue his father as "a horror story." Efforts to help the 75-year-old from Eaglesham, East Renfrewshire, were hampered by the door opening outwards and being bolted from the John MacRitchie ruled that Mr Hunter's death could have been avoided if there had been annual maintenance of the bath tap and "a more formal analysis of guest complaints about the discharge of excessively hot water in the hotel bathrooms."The sheriff said: "These defects on the balance of probabilities contributed to the death and the accident resulting in the death of Mr Hunter. "It is reasonable to infer that the lack of, not just annual, but any maintenance of the tap and its components did in fact contribute to the death."The sheriff added that the fitting of a bathroom door lock release, operable from the bedroom, would have allowed emergency access to the bathroom to remove Mr Hunter from the water and could also have prevented his inquiry heard that all bathrooms at the hotel with outward-opening doors have now had their locks removed completely. Mr Hunter was staying at the hotel with his wife Janice at the time of the incident in December was found to have suffered third-degree burns to 83% of his body after fire crews finally managed to break down the inquiry heard that a Health and Safety Executive investigation found that the mixer tap in the bathroom was more than 30 years temperature control was "very sensitive", and it did not satisfactorily isolate the hot water when the cold water shut inquiry heard that a number of complaints about the controls, high temperatures, "boiling hot" showers or lack of cold water were recorded in the hotel maintenance log in the nine months leading up to Mr Hunter's death. In a joint statement issued by Thompsons Solicitors Scotland, Mr Hunter's son Keir and his daughter Kimberley said: ''The sheriff's judgement is the most difficult thing we have ever had to read."It describes in full detail our dad's excruciating and drawn-out final moments but also shines a light on the fact that his death could and would have been avoided had the hotel used qualified maintenance staff and had the most basic of maintenance regimes in place for its hot water supply."The fault which caused our father's death had been complained about by many previous guests and was well known to the the hotel management. "They ignored these warnings."
