Council seeks recovery of legal fees after $2.4m lawsuit against it dismissed
Photo:
LDR / Kate Judson
A man who unsuccessfully tried to sue Masterton District Council for $2.4 million must now pay the council about $20,000 for its legal fees.
Leon Sheeran was on a swing at Masterton's Margaret St Reserve in late 2019 when the chain snapped and he fell, damaging his tail bone.
He claimed his injury affected his ability to work as a truck driver, his sleep, and his mental health.
Although the injury was covered by ACC, almost four years later he turned to the courts, claiming Masterton District Council had neglected its duties under the Local Government Act.
He sought $2.4 million for lost earnings but the claim was not permissible under the ACC Act, which barred people from suing for personal injury, and the judge dismissed the case.
A recent court judgement showed the council had sought almost $43,000 from Sheeran to recover legal costs but Judge Andrew Skelton ruled the council was instead entitled to recover costs of about $20,000.
Sheeran, who was appealing the dismissal of his original case, sought a stay of execution of the costs order pending the outcome of his appeal, but this was declined.
In his ruling, Judge Skelton said the council and its ratepayers would be adversely affected by any stay of execution in that "the recovery of costs will be delayed, possibly for some time".
"The council and ratepayers have had to bear the costs of this proceeding since 2023 and are now having to bear the further costs of responding to Mr Sheeran's appeal," Judge Skelton said.
He said Sheeran had "contributed unnecessarily" to the time and expense of the proceeding.
"In particular, Mr Sheeran was advised by the solicitors for the council and the court that his claim for compensatory damages for personal injury would likely be dismissed or struck out," he said.
"It was explained to Mr Sheeran that his claim is barred by s 317(1) of the Accident Compensation Act 2001, but he continued to pursue the claim.
"Mr Sheeran also apparently failed to follow my direction that he should obtain legal advice on his claim, including whether his claim should be amended to seek exemplary damages.
"I also explained that he should consider carefully whether he should be pursuing any claim against the council because of the likely cost consequences."
- LDR is local body journalism funded by RNZ and NZ on Air
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Man pleads guilty over 'coward punch' that killed Daniel Nganeko
Daniel Nganeko. Photo: Supplied A man has pleaded guilty to manslaughter over an unprovoked attack outside a rugby clubroom in Taranaki. Daytona Thompson fatally punched Daniel Nganeko last month. A big court gathered outside the High Court at New Plymouth for today's hearing, many wearing white t-shirts bearing the image of Nganeko and the slogan "March for Daniel, March for Change". Lawyers for 22-year-old Thompson asked that a restorative justice conference be considered. He was remanded in custody until his sentencing in October. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Victim's dad among those calling for coward punch law to be fast tracked
Te Uraura Nganeko speaks at the rally at the Tukapa Rugby Club where his son was fatally assaulted. Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin About 200 people have gathered at a march calling for the introduction of new coward punch law to be fast tracked. Te Uraura Nganeko, who is the father of Danile Nganeko, spoke to the crowd who gathered at the Tukapa Rugby Club where his son was fatally assaulted. He told them Daniel's death in such circumstances should be the last. Some of those taking part were wearing white T-shirts bearing Daniel's image. Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin After the rally they began marching to the New Plymouth courthouse. There Daytona Thomas is expected to plead to charges of manslaughter for causing Daniel's Nganeko's death. Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin Another of those taking in the march is Ben Leng who spent a week in a coma after being blindsided by "sort of a coward's punch" by a New Plymouth bouncer last December. Leng said emergency surgery in Wellington saved his life. "Flip of the coin really, it could've gone either way, and I'm definitely lucky. And it's a few things that are keeping me positive, and that's one of them, that I'm still here." The bouncer, Taylor Watkins, was sentenced to 12 months' home detention and ordered to pay 15-thousand dollars in reparations. Leng is among those calling for tougher penalties for one-punch attacks. Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin In June, Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith said the government would legislate to ensure coward punches were treated as a specific offence and sentences reflected the gravity of the crime. "We know how dangerous they are. People can be killed or suffer lifelong brain injuries, yet perpetrators often receive lenient and insufficient sentences," he said. The new legislation would include: The legislation fulfils part of National's coalition agreement with New Zealand First. Goldsmith aimed to introduce the Bill before the end of the year, and have it passed into law before the next general election.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
'Organised crime is organised. We are not', ministers told
Guns, drugs and cash seized by the police during operations in Christchurch and Auckland in 2023. Photo: Police / supplied A ministerial advisory group is calling for a nationwide information sharing network, or "data lake", along with a new sharing framework to help combat organised crime. The group says government agencies typically avoid the risk of sharing secure data, but a more proactive sharing approach could help target crime groups. They want a tech company to build the new "data lake" - a secure platform that would allow agencies like police and Customs to share the data they already collect with each other, in a usable format. It would automatically reformat encrypted data to make it standardised and usable by enforcement agencies, and would be hosted in a secure government-controlled cloud platform with data partitioned to ensure only those with appropriate clearance could access it. Artificial intelligence could also be used, helping identify patterns across things like financial transactions, travel records, corporate structures, and identity data to potentially help map criminal networks, match people with aliases, and provide real-time alerts. "This architecture can be scalable, privacy-conscious, and legally compliant. It creates a future-proof platform for secure and governed information sharing, enabling agencies to act with a unified view of organised crime," the report said. Ministerial advisory group chair Steve Symon says information needs to get to the right places. Photo: RNZ / Nick Monro Chair Steve Symon told RNZ most of the data involved was already collected by various government agencies, so it would mostly be a tool to help use that data to find international criminals. "We don't want a situation where we we open up the floodgates of information sharing, but we do want to make sure the information is getting [to] the right places," he said. "Whether that be information by Customs about travel movements or information held by the companies office about companies or how companies have been registered, there's a variety of different pieces of information that are currently held by government agencies. "The idea of the data lake is to bring together those bits of data that might assist with tackling organised crime, and then have some oversight in terms of who can access that data and for what purpose." The group found government agencies typically avoided data sharing, as it was seen as risky - what the report described as an "extreme level of risk aversion" - but this needed to be changed to keep up with organised crime making more use of technological advances. "Organised crime is organised. We are not," the report said. The group had looked at potential costs of getting a data lake set up, he said, but that was all subject to commercial sensitivities and he refused to give an estimate. "There have been discussions and we have been aware of an approach that might be made, but we can't discuss it because, of course, we don't want to prejudice the outcome of those discussions. "It is a difficult one for me to answer without prejudicing the communications that the government would have to have with a provider like Microsoft." He said the decision on whether to proceed given the potential cost would be made by the government. A 150 kilogram haul of cocaine seized by Customs in Tauranga last month. Photo: Customs NZ/Supplied He said the group wanted to strike a balance between privacy and the rise of organised crime in New Zealand, which it had highlighted in another report in March - pointing to rising drug use showing up in wastewater testing and increasing levels of cyber fraud. The group also wanted more cooperation with other countries - particularly Pacific Islands - and with businesses like airports, ports, banks and telecommunications companies for tracking things like fraud and drug smuggling. Symon said he saw first-hand the extent of the drug problems affecting Fiji a couple of weeks ago on a trip with Associate Police Minister Casey Costello. "A lot of those drugs are destined for New Zealand or Australia ... there is a lot of information, a lot of data we could use and work with them to share, to help them in their fight which wouldn't be a significant privacy concern for New Zealanders." The group also suggested government agencies working more closely with the private sector - businesses - in specific high-risk areas - like an airport having problems with baggage handlers . He said in that example, information shared between the airport, the private businesses working within the airport, and enforcement authorities could identify things like when staff had called in sick but their access cards were still being used. "We see it in border areas such as airports, our sea ports, we also see it in high-risk in industries such as banks and telcos in the respect that they hold critical data which would be relevant to the fight against organised crime." The report noted that businesses wanted to be involved, and would benefit from being able to avoid effects of organised crime, like fraud. "That is the carrot ... there also needs to be a stick - a legislative mechanism for requiring the less than willing segment of the private sector to come to the table." The group suggested making the failure to report certain suspicious activities to the police commissioner an offence. Other suggestions for cooperating with businesses included creating dedicated liaison roles within Customs, police and other relevant agencies to deal with the groups involved in the data sharing, as well as encouraging the establishment of organised crime prevention roles within businesses themselves. Another option would be an "organised crime supply chain rating system" which would rate and accredit businesses based on their organised crime resilience and information sharing maturity, to encourage good behaviour. A haul of more than three tonnes of cocaine intercepted from a vessel in the Pacific Ocean in 2023. Photo: NZ Police / Supplied Symon said the aim would be to ensure zero data breaches. "We're not naive. There have been occasions where for example police officers have accessed [data] for inappropriate reasons and those have been publicised and dealt with, but what we are talking about here is data held by enforcement agencies. "The benefit of a data lake would be that you would have that information held in one repository, and you could have controls and information about who accesses that data and when, and have a electronic paper trail." He acknowledged there were risks with sharing sensitive data with an AI tool, but said the options for protecting that data would need to be examined in commercial negotiations. The report also called for a minor legislative change to the Privacy Act which would aim to simplify the process of information sharing between agencies. It would mean that when information was shared for the purposes of tackling organised crime, the agency requesting the data would be held responsible, rather than the agency providing the data. "This would simplify the process, ensure that the relevant belief is held by a person who holds sufficient information to make that belief properly informed and it would transfer the privacy risk from the provider to the requestor (usually an enforcement agency)," it said. If the model proved workable and valuable, however, it could be expanded. "If there is success with that sharing, and we can show the public and the gain public confidence in the way we're approaching it, then it's certainly something where you could explore going further," Symon said. The report highlighted a plan to also set up a new legal framework to help support more data sharing. "Under current settings, there is no clear and transparent framework that authorises the sharing of sensitive information with private sector partners," the report said. "For example, in the border security space, there is no clear and transparent framework that enables the two-way sharing of sensitive information between Customs and private sector partners such as operators of Customs Controlled Areas and other supply chain partners." The framework would: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
