Edinburgh Council 'must learn lessons' from probe into handling of Cammy Day complaints
Lessons 'must be learned' after the publication of a report spelling out the council's handling of sexual harassment allegations against former leader Cammy Day, according to city councillors.
The report found that Edinburgh council needed to improve its safeguarding measures, and that a 'prevalent' culture of hospitality needed to be looked at by the council.
But it found that council officers had acted appropriately in handling complaints made to them.
READ MORE: British couple try Chinese takeaway in America and spot one big difference
READ MORE: Edinburgh gang war continues in west as thugs torch taxi owned by dad of Mr Big's girlfriend
It also said that people who had complained about the behaviour of the former council leader experienced a 'significant perceived power imbalance' when making complaints about him.
Council leader Jane Meagher said the report was 'largely reassuring' – but that recommendations made in the report needed to be carried out 'swiftly and comprehensively'.
Kevin Dunion, former chair of the Standards Commission for Scotland, carried out the third party investigation that resulted in the report, which itself was commissioned by the council.
Mr Dunion's investigation came after recent and historic complaints about alleged sexual harassment by former Labour council leader Cammy Day came to light.
Councillor Day resigned in December 2024 soon after the first allegations were published in the press, and he was suspended from the Labour Party soon after.
Multiple Ukrainian refugees said Cllr Day had sent them unsolicited images and messages on social media, even after being asked to stop.
In one historic incident, which took place in 2010 and was reported in 2018, a then 15-year-old boy said he was sexually harassed online by Cllr Day.
Since his resignation, a police investigation into his behaviour has found no evidence of criminality, with the former leader claiming he is the target of a political witch hunt.
SNP group leader, Councillor Simita Kumar, said: 'It is imperative that lessons must be learned.
'A common thread throughout this report is that staff and complainants felt unable – or unwilling – to raise concerns due to the power and influence of the accused.
'We must establish better systems to support and protect those who come forward or the risk of abuse by those in positions of authority will persist.'
Mr Dunion's report found that leaks of information about alleged leaks by councillors had impeded the city's whistleblowing process.
Councillor Ed Thornley, leader of the Liberal Democrat group, said: 'I want to thank Kevin Dunion for his report and the work that's gone into it. He's highlighted several issues with the way the Council's processes aren't working correctly and the gaps in them.
'It's clear reading the report that where Council officers have been aware and informed, they acted appropriately and gave sound advice in line with the agreed processes. That is not the case for councillors.
'The two leaks of confidential information by councillors seriously undermine the integrity of the systems in place, and call into question the judgement of the individuals responsible.
'Such leaks represent a deliberate and blatant breach of the Councillors' Code of Conduct. The Lib Dem group will consider Mr Dunion's recommendations thoroughly over the coming days.'
Edinburgh Council's leader, Labour councillor Jane Meagher said: 'I want to thank Mr Dunion for leading this review, and for his report.
'While I'm largely reassured by Mr Dunion's findings about how recent complaints have been handled by officers, clearly, there are elements of this report which are of serious concern to us as elected members and we must act on his recommendations swiftly and comprehensively. I have already taken practical steps to begin to change the culture in the City Chambers.
'Our priority must be to nurture positive working relationships throughout the Council where colleagues feel able to speak up if something isn't right, they know and trust the channels open to them and they feel safe and supported in doing so.
'I'm fully committed to taking Mr Dunion's recommendations forward and, subject to approval by councillors next Thursday, look forward to agreeing concrete actions when officers bring a further report back in August outlining our proposed actions in response to Mr Dunion's recommendations.'
Independent councillor Ross McKenzie, who was part of the Labour group until 2023, said: 'It's now up to the Labour Party to decide whether they are comfortable with Cammy Day being a Labour councillor.
'The report contains details of an extraordinarily serious allegation made in 2018 and a pattern of sexual harassment allegations since.
'If Labour are serious about safeguarding then they will have conducted an exhaustive investigation into all of these allegations.'
Cllr Kayleigh Kinross-O'Neill, Edinburgh Green group co-convenor said: 'This report makes grim reading, and lays bare the council's completely inadequate response to multiple serious allegations of inappropriate behaviour against the former council leader.
"On behalf of the Green group, I want to apologise that the council has so badly let down alleged victims who have had the bravery to come forward. It is clear the council must address the recommendations in Mr Dunion's report and must make changes to council processes to ensure that alleged victims are never let down in this way again.'
'I want to thank Mr Dunion for the time and effort he has taken in preparing this detailed and comprehensive report.
"It is essential the council takes the time to address these recommendations and improves processes to ensure that all complaints against a councillor are properly investigated in future.
"The report makes clear there was a pattern of sexual harassment allegations which were not taken seriously or properly investigated.
"The council needs to both improve its processes, and also change its culture, to ensure this pattern of behaviour is never allowed to continue unchecked in future.'
The Dunion report will be considered by Edinburgh councillors at the next full council meeting on Thursday, 19 June, which can be viewed here.
Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
9 minutes ago
- Forbes
Brussels, Washington, And The Kremlin's Exports, Oil And Gas For War
Russia's President Vladimir Putin chairs a meeting on the state armament program for 2027-2036 at ... More the Kremlin. Given continued funding by gas exports to Europe, Moscow's economy may be able to support further conflict in Ukraine and beyond.(Photo by Gavriil Grigorov / POOL / AFP) (Photo by GAVRIIL GRIGOROV/POOL/AFP via Getty Images) A major Ukrainian drone operation dubbed 'Spiderweb', conducted on Sunday, June 1, damaged strategic bomber assets deep in Russia. The attack, combined with a strike against the multi-billion-dollar Kerch Strait bridge built after Moscow annexed the Crimea in 2014 to connect it to the Russian mainland, was a huge blow, both in image and in substance. However, it comes at a time when Russia's economic picture is quietly improving, and the offensive picking up steam, which has allowed Moscow to refuse to make any real progress on ceasefire talks despite U.S. President Donald Trump's best efforts. Financial improvement is excellent news for Russia's President Vladimir Putin, who is hellbent on outrunning economic decline at home and attaining victory on the battlefield. Money from energy sales continues to fill Russia's war chest, which is why now is the time for Washington and Europe to work together to turn off Moscow's spigot. Only by depriving the Kremlin of the funds needed to sustain the war can peace be restored at the battlefront. Unfortunately, things have been going in exactly the opposite direction during the first half of 2025. Despite sanctions, Russian gas exports to Europe through the Turkstream pipeline rose more than 10% from April to May, and Russia's oil and gas giant Gazprom posted an unexpected $8.4 billion Q1 profit, up from $7 billion in losses in 2023. On Tuesday, June 10th, the EU announced that it is working on a package of additional sanctions, lowering the price cap for Russian oil from $45 per barrel from $60, as well as banning the use of Russian banks by third countries and stopping any EU operators from being allowed to use Russia's Nord Stream pipelines. If the EU members approve these new proposed sanctions, they will certainly have an impact -- but this is by no means guaranteed. Slovakia and Hungary are two of the most pro-Russian regimes in the EU and have actively opposed sanctions on Russia. It may change, now that Prime Minister Viktor Orban of Hungary announced that Russia only understands the language of force. However, if Washington and Brussels cooperate to tighten the sanctions regime, this could be a game-changer and eventually force Moscow to negotiate. On the other side of the Atlantic, leaders in the United States are acting to decisively end Russia's benefit from its energy industries. The Sanctioning Russia Act of 2025, introduced by Senator Linsey Graham (R-SC), a Trump ally, contains measures to prohibit American entities from investing in or exporting to the Russian energy sector, impose a 500 percent tariff on Russian goods and services entering the and levy the same tariff on countries that sell, supply, transfer, or purchase oil, uranium, natural gas, petroleum products, or petrochemical products originating in Russia. These measures would serve the dual purpose of weakening Moscow's energy trade while putting pressure on states that hesitate to halt their purchases of Russian energy products, including the Europeans, if they fail to step up actively. Russia's economic turnaround through 2025 can primarily be attributed to surging energy exports. The Trump Administration's hesitancy to impose sanctions, despite Trump's willingness to threaten them, created room for this export surge. Without seeing sanctions ratchet up, and with rumors floating that sanctions might be lifted, more customers became willing to turn to Russia. Despite successful maneuver like Operation Spiderweb, a war economy fueled by oil and gas exports ... More still allows Russia to conduct large scale counterattacks, like that seen in Kyiv on June 6th. Russia's foreign currency reserves, once under pressure, as Moscow struggled to keep the ruble from imploding, have recovered, moving past their pre-war high of $630 billion to $680 billion. The Russian ruble made a strong recovery, becoming a top-performing currency of 2025 so far. The ruble has outperformed the Russian government's own budgetary projections with a 40% increase in value against the dollar, a jump of almost four times the next best-performing currency. While this can be attributed to increased domestic economic controls, rising oil prices, and continued exports, another factor may be the sustained trade and indirect financial flows from China, which has remained Moscow's most reliable economic partner. It isn't the entire EU that is importing Russian oil and gas, but a few key countries are more reliant on these imports than others. Hungary, Slovakia, and France were the largest importers in November 2024 with Austria and Spain rounding out the top five. Countries with pro-Russian leadership are not the only ones that have continued importing Russian energy. European governments that decry Russia's aggression continue to throw Moscow an economic lifeline due to their inability to find alternative energy sources. For now, Russian oil and gas are cheaper and more easily accessible despite sanctions, making them the primary solution for the energy security issues regularly experienced by the EU, like cold temperatures and lackluster wind generation. President Trump has also shaken the Europeans by using energy as a bargaining chip in trade negotiations, making some European countries realize that their reliance on the U.S. may be a vulnerability. This has, paradoxically, driven EU countries back towards Russia as an energy supplier—it remains to be seen whether they will reverse course and move in unison to stop funding Moscow's war. Europe's stance on Russia is only growing more divided, as the recent Polish election, which narrowly awarded right-wing candidate Karol Nawrocki the presidency, demonstrates, posing a further challenge for the EU. President Nawrocki has supported military aid to Ukraine but is against allowing it to join NATO, believing it could drag the alliance into conflict with Russia. The new Polish president's 'Eurosceptic' stance may lead to alignment with more pro-Russian leaders in Europe such as Hungary's Orban and Slovakia's Fico. The European Union has been far from united on sanctions regarding oil and gas exports since the invasion of Ukraine by Russia in early 2022. Despite sanctions, Russia's energy exports have proven more resilient than expected, thanks to strategic rerouting through the TurkStream pipeline and continued demand from nations unwilling or unable to pivot quickly. ISTANBUL, TURKEY - The TurkStream pipeline is a key avenue through which Russia continues to ... More transport gas to Europe. (Photo by Isa Terli/) The EU had set a goal of ending all Russian gas imports by 2027, but the road to that goal has been riddled with a lack of enforcement, exceptions, and relapses of reliance. While this plan sets a roadmap for measures to end energy dependence on Russia, it must be supported by baseload energy generation that will not fluctuate like solar and wind. The plan includes measures to reduce uranium and other nuclear energy imports from Moscow, but both individual states and the EU as a whole must focus on rebuilding a nuclear supply chain and stimulating domestic growth in nuclear power generation. Simply declaring long-term goals without follow-up and enforcement is ineffectual and undermines Europe's geostrategic credibility. Russia's 2025 economic gains demonstrate the need for sustained pressure and a united front that presses Moscow to the negotiating table. Despite impressive wins like the recent drone strike, allowing Russia to make economic gains, risks a weakening of Ukraine, and heightened Russian ambition looking toward the rest of the continent. The options seem clear—either the West moves to hit Russia in the pocketbook and press for a ceasefire and peace, or money will flow that allows Moscow to keep grinding on. While care must be taken not to destabilize the world economy and reignite inflation, a window of opportunity for cooperation is open now to help stop the bloodshed. And certainly, the world economy – including America's – will only suffer if Russia is emboldened to keep advancing aggressively in Ukraine and beyond.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel launches attack on Iran as the U.S. seeks a nuclear deal
Good morning, all. If you're making a Costco run, here are three things a food expert says everyone should be buying in bulk. Now, on to the news. Subscribe to get this newsletter in your inbox each morning. Israel launched large-scale airstrikes on Iran this morning, raising the risk of an all-out war between the adversaries, as President Trump urged Iran to reach a nuclear deal with the U.S. ahead of more talks on Sunday. The attack: It hit several structures, including Iran's main nuclear enrichment facility and missile sites, and killed top military officials. Iran launched over 100 drones in retaliation, which Israel said it was intercepting. It's unclear if any got through. [AP] Behind the move: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the strikes were meant to stop Iran from producing a nuclear weapon. The International Atomic Energy Agency said yesterday that Iran was not complying with its nuclear nonproliferation obligations. [USA Today] U.S. response: Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the U.S. was 'not involved' and urged Iran not to target U.S. interests or personnel. Iran said the U.S., as Israel's main supporter, would 'be held responsible' for 'Israel's adventurism.' [Time] 🏛️ Protests update An appeals court delayed a federal judge's order requiring Trump to return control of California's National Guard to Gov. Gavin Newsom. The lower court judge had ruled Trump's actions were 'illegal.' [ABC News] ➡️Air India miracle A British man was the sole survivor in the Air India flight en route to London that crashed in northwestern India yesterday. 'Thirty seconds after takeoff, there was a loud noise and then the plane crashed,' he said. [BBC News] 🩺New PFAS study A new study found that prenatal exposure to PFAS — the 'forever chemicals' commonly found in food, water and waterproof or stain-resistant items — could be linked to high blood pressure in teens. [CNN] 🏒 In their NHL era The Oilers overcame a three-goal deficit to beat the Panthers in overtime in Game 4 of the Stanley Cup Final, tying the series 2-2 and making for an exciting date night for Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. [Yahoo Sports] 🎬 A 'Spaceballs' sequel Mel Brooks revealed that he'll reprise his role as Yogurt in Spaceballs 2, the sequel to the 1987 cult classic. 'After 40 years we asked: 'What do the fans want?' But instead we're making this movie,' Brooks joked. [Hollywood Reporter] 🎬 Now in theaters: Dakota Johnson stars as a matchmaker opposite Pedro Pascal and Chris Evans in the much-hyped rom-com Materialists. (More on that below.) Watch the trailer. [People] 📺Now streaming: Julianne Moore and Sydney Sweeney are 'dynamite' in the 'riveting, nail-biting' thriller Echo Valley, which dropped on Apple TV+. [Deadline] ⚾ On the field, the Yankees and the Red Sox begin their second series in as many weeks at 7:10 p.m. ET on the MLB app. [SNY] 🏀 In the NBA Finals, the Thunder will try to even out the 2-1 series against the Pacers at 8:30 p.m. ET on ABC. They've done it before in these playoffs. [NBC Sports] ☀️ And don't forget to: Read your daily horoscope. Play the crossword. Check the forecast in your area. In 1983, the U.S. space probe Pioneer 10 became the first spacecraft to leave the solar system as it crossed the orbit of Neptune. (The artist's impression above shows it flying by Jupiter.) [AP] Yahoo Entertainment Reporter Kelsey Weekman, who saw Materialists, stopped by to give us a preview of the new movie. Kelsey: Dakota Johnson stars as Lucy, a matchmaker trying to help clients find love as she herself has to choose between Harry, a kind, rich new guy played by Pedro Pascal, and her fiery but chronically underemployed ex, John, played by Chris Evans. Kelsey: There's definitely romance and comedy, but it's more of a critique about how modern dating forces people to commodify themselves and their desires. It's brilliant, just like director Celine Song's last movie, Past Lives. Kelsey: Absolutely. I haven't gotten butterflies from a rom-com like this in a long time! Come for Pascal's charm and stay for Evans's instantly iconic monologue at the end. Matchmaking is having a moment: Not just in Materialists, but in real life too. Here's why. Alexa was celebrating her birthday at a restaurant when she learned the little boy at the table next to hers would be celebrating his own the next day. So she let him blow out the candles on her cake. 'I think that's now a core memory for both of us,' Alexa said of the now viral moment. [People] Have a great weekend. See you Monday! 💡 P.S. Before you go, your daily advice: Want to sleep better on your next flight? Creating a pre-sleep travel routine is one of a few ways to help cue your body to rest. [Southern Living] About The Yodel: The Yodel is a morning newsletter from Yahoo News. Start your day with The Yodel to get caught up on weather, national news, politics, entertainment and sports — in four minutes or less. Did you like this morning's newsletter? Subscribe to have it sent to you on weekdays. By signing up, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Secretary of state rejects DUP 'hapless' claim over legacy
The secretary of state has dismissed claims by the DUP that he is keeping victims and some parties "in the dark" over his government's plans to change how Troubles legacy cases are handled. Hilary Benn was responding to remarks by DUP leader Gavin Robinson, who described his approach as "hapless". London and Dublin have been in talks for some time about trying to find a joint way forward, with the two governments meeting on Thursday during the British-Irish Council to discuss the latest developments. Benn said he made "no apology" for working with the Irish government and others to try and reach a solution. The DUP said by Benn meeting Tánaiste (Irish deputy PM) Simon Harris, he had "dishonoured" victims who were concerned about the Irish government's own approach to dealing with the legacy of the past. Labour intends to retain a new legacy body set up under the legislation - the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR). A number of victims' groups have called for the ICRIR to be scrapped, arguing it is not sufficiently independent to investigate killings during Northern Ireland's decades-long conflict. Dublin maintains a legal challenge against the UK government over the legacy act, but Harris has said he believes a deal can still be reached to allow his government to drop that case. The DUP leader said: "Last night, Hilary Benn disgracefully continued his desire to satisfy the Irish Government, seeking their approval for his actions. "In meeting Simon Harris to negotiate next steps, he dishonours the countless victims in Northern Ireland that I have met over recent months who lament that whilst he may listen, he does not hear." He also accused Dublin of having a "scandalous approach" to legacy. "The Irish continue to ruthlessly defend their sovereign information, yet Hilary Benn concedes their unconstitutional role in determining how the UK deals with ours," said Robinson. "The Irish government have knowledge of and influence upon UK legacy plans, yet Northern Ireland victims, veterans and Parliamentarians are kept in the dark by the secretary of state without so much as a blush on his face." Speaking at the British-Irish Council, Benn said legacy remained "unfinished business" and that all politicians had a responsibility to find a way forward. "We are making good progress... the lesson indeed exemplified by the Good Friday Agreement is that we make most progress when we work together."
