Human remains found in Spain caves were victims of cannibalism — but by whom?
The site was first excavated about 25 years ago when archaeologists found human remains dating back to the Neolithic period and Middle Bronze Age.
Now, analysis of the bones found that not only were the people that called the cave home likely killed, but their bodies were then stripped, cooked and eaten, leaving only chewed bones in the wake.
At least 11 individuals have been found as victims of cannibalism from a collection of hundreds of bones dating to around 5,700 years ago, researchers from the Catalan Institute of Human Paleoecology and Social Evolution and the University of Rovira i Virgili said in an Aug. 7 news release.
The group includes at least four adults, two juveniles and three children, two of which were under the age of 7, according to a study published Aug. 7 in the peer-reviewed journal Scientific Reports. The ages of two individuals could not be determined.
Some of the bones had 'signs of butchery' including percussion marks and peeling, but were also found to be burned or polished, a sign that the bones and meat on them had been cooked, according to the study.
Most notably, crushing marks with longitudinal cracks and specific patterns of damage suggest 'human chewing,' researchers said.
All of the individuals were local to the region, researchers said in the release, and had been eaten in a very short time period. They may have even been consumed in just a matter of days.
Cannibalism has been observed in some communities as a ritual or in times of extreme starvation, but in those cases, the human remains aren't consumed so quickly, according to the release.
'So, several traits of the El Mirador assemblage are consistent with a similar interpretation. These include the short-term depositional episode coinciding with the final Neolithic occupation phase, the interruption of livestock-related activities, and the cave's functional shift, from pen to funerary space, in the subsequent Chalcolithic period,' according to the study.
'Together, these features lend weight to the hypothesis of 'warfare cannibalism,' in which the victims, likely a nuclear or extended family, may have been killed in a single event by a neighboring or external group.'
Researchers said they didn't find explicit evidence of fatal injuries on the remains of the 11 people, but that it doesn't invalidate the possible cause, as many life-ending injuries do not leave marks on the bone.
While nearly one thousand years apart, this isn't the first time cannibalism has been observed in the El Mirador cave.
A previous case was identified from the Bronze Age, about 4,600 years ago, but the new study shows it was a practice in the area much earlier, according to the release.
The researchers suggest the cave gives a snapshot look at violence at the end of the Neolithic, a period driven by extreme instability as cultures moved from foraging to farming, according to the study.
'High population pressure, competition over resources and interactions between indigenous Mesolithic groups and incoming Neolithic farming communities often resulted in violent confrontations of varying scale,' researchers said.
El Mirador cave is in the Atapuerca Mountains of north-central Spain.
The research team includes Palmira Saladié, Francesc Marginedas, Juan Ignacio Morales, Josep María Vergès, Ethel Allué, Isabel Expósito, Marina Lozano, Patricia Martín, Javier Iglesias-Bexiga, Marta Fontanals, Roser Marsal, Raquel Hernando, Aitor Burguet-Coca and Antonio Rodríguez-Hidalgo.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
I'm a physicist who studies fossils, and I recently discovered preserved blood vessels in the world's largest T. rex
Despite the fact that much of the current research in paleontology focuses on trying to find traces of organic remains in fossils, dinosaur DNA has unfortunately never been recovered. A lot of what we know about dinosaurs comes from preserved bones and teeth that are dug out of the ground. These hard tissues alone, however, are limited in the information they provide. Soft tissues are extremely rare in the fossil record, but can help provide a much more life-like reconstruction of ancient life. This includes things like muscles and ligaments, pigments or even skin (like scales or feathers), which contain detailed information on how dinosaurs lived and what they looked like. Another interesting soft tissue that can be found in bones are blood vessels. My research team and I discovered blood vessels preserved in a Tyrannosaurus rex fossil, and our findings were recently published in Scientific Reports. As an undergraduate physics student at the University of Regina, I joined a research team using particle accelerators to study fossils. There, I first discovered blood vessels in a bone from a T. rex using advanced 3D models. It's been nearly six years since that moment; I am now working on my PhD where I use my background in physics to advance analysis techniques in fossil research. An extraordinary specimen The vessels were found in a remarkable T. rex specimen nicknamed Scotty. Held in the Royal Saskatchewan Museum's collection in Canada, Scotty is the largest T. rex ever unearthed. The fossil also remains one of the most complete specimens of T. rex. Scotty appeared to have had a rough life 66 million years ago; many of the recovered bones appeared to have injuries, possibly due to a fight with another dinosaur, or disease. One bone in particular, a section of rib, features a large partially healed fracture. In general, after bones experience a traumatic event like a fracture, there is a huge increase in the activity of blood vessels in the affected area as part of the healing process. We believe this is what was found in Scotty's rib: an extensive network of mineralized vessels that we were able to examine using reconstructed 3D models. Revolutionizing paleontology research When analyzing fossil bones, there are two main challenges. The first is how to examine the interior of the bones without damaging the fossil. And second, the bones are very large and can be quite dense due to the fossilization process, where minerals replace and fill in original organic materials. At first, we thought we could perform an computed topography (CT) scan of the bone, similar to what is used for medical purposes, which allows imaging of bones without damaging them. While this solves the first problem, the second problem means that a conventional medical CT machine is not nearly powerful enough to penetrate the dense bone. For our examination, we used synchrotron light, special high-intensity x-rays. These are produced at select particle accelerator labs, and allow us to investigate microstructures such as blood vessels in the bone with ease. Synchrotron x-rays can also be useful for chemical analysis. We found the vessels were preserved as iron-rich mineralized casts, a common form of fossilization, but in two distinct layers. This layering is due to the complicated environmental history that led to the exceptional preservation seen in Scotty's rib. Written in blood vessels By analyzing blood vessels produced by an incompletely healed fracture, we can hopefully learn how T. rex healed, helping speculation on how Scotty was able to survive after sustaining injuries. This could lead to evolutionary information comparing the vessel structures seen in Scotty to other dinosaur species, as well as modern relatives to dinosaurs like birds. The results may also help future fossil exploration by guiding scientists to target bones that show signs of injury or disease, potentially increasing the chances of discovering more vessels or other types of preserved soft tissues. With cross-disciplinary research and novel applications of advanced technologies, there is so much potential to recreate the past lives of dinosaurs like never before. This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit, independent news organisation bringing you facts and trustworthy analysis to help you make sense of our complex world. It was written by: Jerit Leo Mitchell, University of Regina Read more: An exquisitely preserved egg reveals what birds have inherited from dinosaurs Thirty years after Jurassic Park hit movie screens, its impact on science and culture remains as strong as ever – podcast Big head, small arms: A newly discovered gigantic dinosaur evolved in a similar manner to Tyrannosaurus rex Jerit Leo Mitchell receives funding from Mitacs Accelerate and the Sylvia Fedoruk Centre for Nuclear Innovation.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Ancient animal bones unlock clues about Bronze Age plague
Thousands of years before the Black Death killed one-third of Europe's population in the 14th century, a mysterious and prehistoric form of the plague spread throughout Eurasia. This prehistoric pathogen that is only known from ancient DNA samples ran rampant about 5,000 years ago, ultimately vanishing from the archeological record about 2,000 years later. Called the Late Neolithic Bronze Age (LNBA) plague lineage, scientists have long been puzzled about where the strain came from. Now, we are close to an answer. For the first time, archeologists and anthropologists have identified this ancient plague in an animal: a 4,000-year-old domesticated sheep excavated in present-day Russia. The plague appears to have infected both humans and sheep that spread from a wild animal source, just like the bubonic plague. The increased sheep herding in the area during the Bronze Age brought humans into closer contact with the animals and may have led to the spread of this disease. The findings are detailed in a study published August 11 in the journal Cell and reveal that sheep played a role in this disease spillover. Plague origins Most illnesses that infect humans today have a zoonotic origin. At some point in time, they jumped from an animal to a human in a process called a spillover event. For example, migratory birds were the original reservoir for flu and ebola that spilled over from bats. Many of the infectious diseases caused by these pathogens emerged within the last 10,000 years. That timing overlaps with the domestication of livestock and pets. Studying the pathogen that arises from ancient animals using the DNA left behind offers a way for scientists to investigate the emergence of human infectious disease in the past and can inform modern spillover events. Plague is one of the most deadly zoonotic diseases in history. It is spread by the fleas living on rats, and has killed millions of people throughout history. However, the older LNBA lineage that first began to spread 5,000 years ago is genetically distinct from the more well-known Black Death from the 14th century. It infected human populations for close to 3,000 years before it vanished. Interestingly, LNBA lineage lacks the key genetics for fleas to transmit the plague-causing bacterium Yersinia pestis transmission that are found in other historic and modern plague strains. Since it does not spread via fleas like the bubonic plague, another animal was likely involved. But which animal? 'One of the first steps in understanding how a disease spreads and evolves is to find out where it's hiding, but we haven't done that yet in the ancient DNA field,' study co-author and doctoral candidate Ian Light-Maka, said in a statement. 'We have over 200 Y. pestis genomes from ancient humans, but humans aren't a natural host of plague.' Ancient teeth and livestock To figure out how the infection persisted and spread over thousands of years in Eurasia, an international team of researchers studied the bones and teeth of Bronze Age livestock that were uncovered at an archeological site called Arkaim. The site in present-day Russia was once occupied by the Sintashta-Petrovka culture, who were known for innovations in cattle, sheep, and horse husbandry. At the site, they identified a 4,000-year-old sheep that was infected with the same LNBA lineage of Y. pestis that was infecting people at the time. 'Arkaim was part of the Sintashta cultural complex and offered us a great place to look for plague clues: they were early pastoralist societies without the kind of grain storage that would attract rats and their fleas – and prior Sintashta individuals have been found with Y. pestis infections. Could their livestock be a missing link?' added study co-author and University of Arkansas anthropologist Taylor Hermes. Back in the lab, the team compared the ancient Y. pestis genome from the sheep with other ancient and modern genomes. The sheep Y. pestis genome was a very close match to one that had infected a human at a nearby site at around the same time. 'If we didn't know it was from a sheep, everyone would have assumed it was just another human infection – it's almost indistinguishable,' said study co-author and Harvard University archeologist Christina Warinner. According to the team, this indicates that both humans and sheep were being with the same population of Y. pestis. But were the sheep infecting humans in some way or vice versa? Archaeological and comparative approaches could provide some answers to that puzzle. In parts of the world where Y. pestis is still endemic, sheep can become infected if they come in direct contact with carcasses of infected animals including rodents. Rats and mice are natural reservoirs of the pathogen and local plague outbreaks can arise in humans if infected sheep are not properly butchered or cooked. This type of scenario could have spread LNBA plague in prehistoric times, linking human and sheep infections. 'The Sintashta-Petrovka culture is famous for their extensive herding over vast pastures aided by innovative horse technologies, and this provided plenty of opportunity for their livestock to come into contact with wild animals infected by Y. pestis,' added Warinner. 'From then on it is just one more short hop into humans.' The speed of spread Despite the new findings, some major questions remain unanswered. It is still unclear exactly how the pathogen traveled hundreds of miles in relatively short periods of time, as this distance was too far for sick humans or terrestrial animals to travel at the time. It is also not clear which wild animal the domesticated sheep caught the bacterium from. 'We can show that the ancient lineage evolved under elevated pressure, which is in contrast to the Y. pestis still found today,' Felix M. Key, a study co-author and genomicist at the Max Plank Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology added. 'Moreover, the ancient sheep as well as human infections are likely isolated spillovers from the unknown reservoir, which remains at large. Finding that reservoir would be the next step.' However, the search for pathogens in ancient animal remains is only just beginning. Archaeological digs both past and present can produce tens of thousands of animal bones. Archaeologists could potentially dig into the bones from past excavations to look at what ancient pathogens lurk inside. 'I think there will be more and more interest in analyzing these collections,' said Key. 'They give us insights that no human sample can.' Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
The deficiency causing you tiredness and brain fog – and the foods to fix it
The importance of eating enough calcium for our bones and teeth is well-understood. The same is true for omega-3 fatty acids and a healthy brain. Yet, there's a little-known trace mineral which holds a great amount of power when it comes to our health. We only need a tiny amount of it each day, yet its impact on our bones, immune system and brain is mighty. This all-important trace mineral is copper. A recent study in Scientific Reports found that a copper-rich diet was linked to improved cognitive function in adults aged 60 and over in the United States. Whilst a copper deficiency (also known as hypocupremia) is rare, it can be debilitating. Ensuring we eat enough copper is undoubtedly important – so how much of it do we need, what are the signs of deficiency and what can we eat to boost our intake? Skip to: Why copper is important for our health Causes of a copper deficiency Signs of a copper deficiency 10 foods high in copper Copper supplements FAQs Why copper is important for our health 'Copper is an essential and important trace mineral for our bodies which is often overlooked,' says Dr Naila Aslam, a GP at Central Health London. We need small amounts of copper to function properly, yet our bodies can't produce it – which means we must get it from our diet. It plays a key role in 'energy production within cells, immune system function, red blood cell synthesis, the formation of collagen and healthy bones, and brain development,' Aslam explains. Both copper and iron play an important role in the formation and production of red blood cells. In fact, iron actually needs copper to be properly used in the body, Aslam explains. If the body doesn't have enough copper, iron absorption and utilisation can be impaired, potentially leading to anaemia. This is because ceruloplasmin, a copper-containing protein, is crucial in binding iron to transferrin, the protein that transports it in the bloodstream to various cells. 'Our body is very capable of maintaining the right balance of copper and iron,' Aslam says. According to UK dietary guidelines, we need 1.2mg of copper a day. Generally, that amount is easily achievable from a well-balanced diet, Aslam says. 'Copper deficiency is pretty rare as an isolated event and it's difficult to diagnose because the symptoms are vague and overlap with other conditions,' she adds, however, 'there are certain conditions and risk factors that are more commonly associated with a deficiency'. Causes of a copper deficiency 'One of the most common places we see a copper deficiency is if someone has had stomach surgery – so a gastric bypass or a gastrectomy,' says Clare Thornton-Wood, a specialist registered dietitian. This is because 30 to 40 per cent of dietary copper is typically absorbed throughout the gastrointestinal tract, particularly in the duodenum in the small intestine. After certain bariatric surgeries, food bypasses the duodenum, resulting in significantly reduced copper absorption. People with coeliac disease or inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) may also be deficient in copper 'because they often have problems with absorbing their nutrients' as a result of small intestine damage and inflammation, Thornton-Wood explains. Excessive zinc intake – often from supplements – can also prevent the absorption of copper. Zinc is vital for immune support and skin health and UK guidelines state that men need 9.5mg a day, whilst women need 7mg a day. However, if you consume too much zinc, 'it can cause a copper deficiency, because zinc competes with copper for absorption in the gut,' Aslam explains. Fortunately, this is fairly rare as most over-the-counter supplements are 10 to 15mg. Higher strength supplements may cause a problem if taken for a long period of time. These are sometimes recommended for people 'with concerns about skin, hair loss or a confirmed deficiency,' Aslam explains. You may experience a zinc deficiency if you have certain gastrointestinal difficulties such as coeliac disease, other malabsorption conditions, or are healing from severe burns. However, most people consume enough zinc from a well-balanced diet. Copper deficiency can also be caused by Menkes disease (a rare inherited genetic disorder), Thornton-Wood says. It's caused by a defect in the ATP7A gene, which plays a vital role in the transportation of copper. As a result, the brain and other parts of the body don't get enough copper, while it builds up in the small intestines and kidneys. Affected individuals exhibit low copper levels in the blood which can lead to a range of neurological problems. Back to index What are the signs of a copper deficiency? The symptoms of a copper deficiency can overlap with other conditions, Aslam says. However, common signs include: Persistent fatigue 'On the NHS, we don't routinely test for copper,' Aslam says. 'However, if you come to me after gastric surgery, have other risk factors or you're taking supplements and still complaining of fatigue, I would likely test for copper.' Several rodent studies have found that copper deficiency may also cause anaemia, because of copper's important role in iron absorption. 'Copper deficiency can therefore present as iron deficiency anaemia,' Aslam explains. Numb fingers and toes A copper deficiency can present with neurological symptoms and may mimic a B12 deficiency, Aslam says. 'Symptoms include numbness in your fingertips and toes or a tingling sensation in your legs, hands and feet.' This is because copper plays a role in maintaining nerve health and function. A 2022 case report in Cureus details a 50-year-old woman with copper deficiency who has extreme weakness, numbness and tingling in her arms and legs. Difficulty with balance Copper plays a crucial role in maintaining a healthy nervous system. When copper levels are low, it can disrupt the signals between the brain and body, leading to difficulties with coordination and balance. People with copper deficiency may also find it harder to walk properly because of this. Weakened bones Copper is crucial for bone health because it's involved in collagen synthesis and the activity of enzymes that help minerals attach to bone protein. Therefore, a deficiency can make bones more fragile. In fact, an analysis of eight studies including over 2,000 people found that those with osteoporosis had lower levels of copper than healthy adults. Frequent sickness People who are often unwell may have a copper deficiency because copper plays an important role in maintaining a healthy immune system. When copper levels are low, your white blood cell count may drastically decrease, compromising your ability to combat infection and sickness. This has been found in multiple studies where copper deficiency has dramatically reduced the production of neutrophils – white blood cells which act as the body's first line of defence. Memory problems As the recent study in Scientific Reports highlights, copper plays an important role in brain function and development. Whilst the study states that the relationship between copper and cognitive function is complex and not yet fully understood, the researchers found an association between copper intake and enhanced brain health. This may be a result of copper being used by enzymes to help supply energy to the brain. Back to index Which foods are high in copper? It's entirely possible to consume enough copper from your diet each day, whether you're a carnivore, vegetarian or vegan, Thornton-Wood says. Here are some of the richest food sources, according to Wilson's Disease Support Group UK: Back to index Should you take copper supplements? Both Aslam and Thornton-Wood agree that – generally – copper supplementation isn't necessary. 'If you have a balanced diet and no underlying medical conditions, you can absorb a good amount of copper without needing any extra supplementation,' Aslam says. 'It's in such a wide range of foods that everyone should be able to get enough copper from their diets, even if they're vegan or vegetarian,' Thornton-Wood adds. In a recent preclinical study at the University of Sydney, researchers used a special supplement to restore copper levels in the brains of mice, which helped to reverse Parkinson's-like symptoms by repairing a key protective enzyme. While on the surface, this presents a strong argument for taking copper supplements for the possible cognitive benefits, Aslam urges caution. 'This research doesn't mean people should take copper supplements,' she says, 'as the treatment used was a targeted drug, not regular copper, and it hasn't been tested in humans yet.' If someone has a diagnosed deficiency, is a gastric bypass patient, or has IBD, then a doctor 'would do the necessary testing to find out their copper levels, rather than just blindly recommending supplementation,' Aslam says. FAQs Does copper deficiency cause weight gain? There's no direct evidence of copper deficiency leading to weight gain, Aslam says. However, as it leads to significant fatigue, an increased risk of infection and numbness in parts of the body, 'people with a copper deficiency may be less inclined or able to exercise and maintain a healthy lifestyle and nutrition, so weight gain may be an indirect impact,' she says. What blocks copper absorption? If you consume too much zinc, this can block copper absorption because the two minerals compete for absorption in the gut, Aslam explains. Excessive fibre intake can potentially reduce the absorption of copper too, Thornton-Wood says. 'This is because fibre can bind to minerals like copper, making them less available for absorption,' she explains. Can you consume too much copper? Consuming too much copper can cause copper toxicity, which can have unpleasant and potentially serious side effects, Aslam says. These include nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, stomach pain, headaches, tremors and – in more severe cases – liver and kidney damage, as it can accumulate in these organs, she explains. However it's important to note that it's very rare to eat toxic amounts of copper through a regular diet. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
