DACA recipient detained at Alligator Alcatraz, attorney says. ‘We don't know why'
Attorney Phillip Arroyo said his client, whom he isn't identifying out of fear of retaliation, arrived in the United States from Mexico when he was a minor. The man, now in his early 30s, has legal status through the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, according to the attorney.
Arroyo said his client was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement after a 'misunderstanding' during a traffic stop. He was sent to Alligator Alcatraz on Friday and remains at the facility, Arroyo said.
Considering his client's legal status, Arroyo told the Herald he's confident he will be able to get an immigration bond. But if that fails, the attorney said he is prepared to file a federal civil rights lawsuit seeking his client's release.
'The narrative is that only violent criminals are being sent to Alligator Alcatraz,' Arroyo said. 'We don't know why [he was sent there] because he has legal status.'
The man, Arroyo said, was arrested on a charge of driving without a valid driver's license. However, he did have a valid driver's license at the time of the traffic stop, Arroyo said, and prosecutors are reducing the misdemeanor to a civil citation.
Attorney Josephine Arroyo, who is also representing the man, told the Orlando Sentinel that he was issued a citation last year that was mailed to an address where he no longer lived. That led to his arrest when he was pulled over in Orange County.
The man's family paid a bond to release him from jail, but he was then detained by ICE, Arroyo told the Herald. He was held at the Orange County jail when his family and attorney lost contact with him.
His loved ones didn't hear from him for days, Arroyo said, until he called his brother from the Everglades, where the state of Florida has been detaining migrants caught up in President Donald Trump's mass-deportation campaign. Only one of three phones in his cage pod works, according to Arroyo, who said he was able to speak with his client on Tuesday for the first time.
During their conversation, Arroyo said his client described poor conditions at the facility: The food was rotten. The toilets were flooded with excrement. The air conditioning broke, and detainees had to swat away mosquitoes in the sweltering heat. He said he wasn't allowed to shower for four days.
Similar complaints have been reported by other detainees. But Stephanie Hartman, a spokesperson for the state Division of Emergency Management, told the Herald Wednesday evening that the allegations about the conditions of the facility were 'completely false' and that Alligator Alcatraz 'meets all required standards and is in good working order.'
The state has invited state and federal lawmakers to tour the facility on Saturday.
Arroyo said he tried to set up an attorney visit but was told by Alligator Alcatraz officials that there was 'no information' about a visitation policy.
'Apart from the horrors in that facility, the lack of access to an attorney is troubling to me,' he said. 'It's a Sixth Amendment violation.'
Hartman said detainees do have access to phone and video calls with their attorneys, and has told the Herald that visitations could be arranged upon request. She didn't confirm whether lawyer calls are being recorded or monitored, and did not respond to questions about how visitations can be arranged.
Miami Herald staff writer Ana Ceballos contributed to this report
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
‘We don't deserve this.' Women held in limbo at ICE's downtown S.F. center awaiting bed space
Three women who were detained by federal immigration officers at court Wednesday were held overnight inside the Immigration and Customs Enforcement's downtown San Francisco field office and remained there Thursday afternoon because there were no available beds at migrant detention facilities, one of the women and her attorney told the Chronicle. The 27-year-old Colombian woman from San Jose said in an interview she was held overnight in a cell on the sixth floor of 630 Sansome St., along with two other women who were also detained on Wednesday afternoon at the U.S. Department of Justice's San Francisco Immigration Court. She described the room as a small space with a toilet, a bench, a thin mattress and a small window where she could see officers standing outside. ICE representatives did not immediately respond to questions about the woman's arrest and detention. The Chronicle is not naming her, per its anonymous source policy, due to her fears of retaliation. The women are among many immigrants who have been held at the San Francisco ICE field office in recent weeks while officials make arrangements to transfer people to detention centers, said Jessica Yamane, an immigration attorney with Pangea Legal Services and Santa Clara County's Rapid Response Network. Some have been held for days, she said, a source of additional trauma as they already face uncertainty over what will happen to them. Yamane said ICE representatives told her that the woman was being held at the field office because there were no available beds at migrant detention facilities. Detained migrants from the Bay Area are typically transferred to detention centers in Southern California. Immigration attorneys and advocates have reported overcrowding and deteriorating conditions at ICE detention facilities across the country. An ICE representative told NPR that 'some ICE facilities are experiencing temporary overcrowding due to recent increases in detention populations' and implementing measures to manage capacity. ICE typically places immigrants in holding cells in its field offices for a few hours at a time before transferring them elsewhere, but there have been reports of longer stays and overcrowding in these facilities as well. Yamane said the overnight detentions at the 630 Sansome St. building reminded her of when immigration officials used the upper floors of the building as a detention center for Chinese immigrants post-World War II. 'It's been the same mechanism of terror through detention that have broken people's spirits for generations,' she said. On Thursday afternoon in a cold visitation room, the Colombian woman told the Chronicle through a glass window that plainclothes ICE officers arrested her as she exited a courtroom at 100 Montgomery St. around 3:30 p.m. on Wednesday. An asylum seeker, the woman said she had just attended her first courthouse appointment, where the judge rescheduled her appointment for October because she didn't have an attorney. 'Everything was going well. I didn't see any risk because the judge gave me another date,' she said. Two men identified themselves as ICE agents, handcuffed her and walked out the building through a back door, she said. They forcefully pushed her into an unmarked car and told her they were taking her to the ICE field office, she said. 'They were hurting me,' she said, tears falling down her cheeks. 'I hadn't done anything wrong.' She was placed in a cell with two other women. During the interview with the Chronicle, an immigration official walked into the visitation room to drop off a meal — a bean and cheese burrito, a breakfast bar and bottled water. She said ICE officials have not told her where she will be sent. 'They're treating us like criminals,' she said. 'We don't deserve this treatment. We are just trying to do the right thing.' She said she flew to Mexico and crossed the U.S. border in December 2022, fleeing violence she experienced in her hometown of Bogota. In the U.S., she moved in with her boyfriend in San Jose and worked at a local restaurant and delivered food via UberEats with her partner. Their dream, she said, was to save enough money to open their own auto repair and body shop. 'It's a dream that I don't know will happen now,' she said.
Los Angeles Times
3 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
A DACA recipient made a wrong turn at the border. Now he faces deportation
Erick Hernandez-Rodriguez said he took the wrong freeway exit and accidentally crossed over into Mexico from San Diego. Now the U.S. government says he 'self-deported' and illegally tried to re-enter the U.S. He has been detained and is slated for deportation to El Salvador, a country he has not lived in since he was 14. Hernandez-Rodriguez, 34, was in the U.S. under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival program, or DACA, which grants work permits and deportation protections to certain immigrants brought to the U.S. as children. But Hernandez-Rodriguez is currently in a detention facility in Otay Mesa, slated for expedited removal. His wife is expected to give birth in California to their second child before the end of the month. The federal government is not showing any leniency in his case, according to his attorney Valerie Sigamani. Hernandez-Rodriguez works part-time as an Uber driver and was trying to drop off a passenger near the border but missed his exit. He then drove into Mexico, but when he tried to circle back into California, he was arrested. Sigamani estimates he was out of the U.S. for less than 30 minutes. Hernandez-Rodriguez's status under DACA provided some protection to undocumented immigrants in the past, but that has changed under the Trump administration. 'DACA does not confer any form of legal status in this country,' Department of Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. 'Any illegal alien who is a DACA recipient may be subject to arrest and deportation.' Sigamani said her client's DACA status should show that Hernandez-Rodriguez had been working in the U.S. and not trying to sneak in. 'It seems like at this moment, there isn't that much mercy towards people who make mistakes,' she said. 'I would hope that CBP agents would still understand and know that this is an accident, that this person didn't intend to abandon their claims, but they are a good person, and they accidentally exited the U.S.' His story was first reported by NBC News. California is home to about 150,000 DACA recipients. The Hernandez-Rodriguez case is the latest example of the Trump administration's hard-line immigration policies. Ahead of his second term in office, Trump said he would 'work with Democrats on a plan' to help DACA recipients remain in the country. But once elected president, Trump quickly moved to end DACA. The program narrowly survived when the Supreme Court ruled in 2020 that his administration had done so improperly. A case that challenges DACA's legality is expected to reach the Supreme Court, where some legal experts predict the conservative majority may strike it down. In early June, Javier Diaz Santana, 32, another DACA recipient, was detained while working at a car wash. Despite explaining his situation, he was taken to a federal detention facility in Texas and granted bond by an immigration judge. In a handwritten declaration to the court and provided to The Times by his attorney, Hernandez-Rodriguez said he was working as a rideshare driver on May 31 and picked up some fares after a soccer game ended in Los Angeles. He followed his GPS directions and it told him he was approaching his exit from the freeway, but he missed it. He tried to get off at the next exit, but it was blocked by police due to a car accident. He thought he would have another chance to turn around, but then he was in line to cross the U.S./Mexico border in San Ysidro. 'I asked some Mexican officers and I explained to them what had happened,' Hernandez-Rodriguez said in his declaration. 'They told me that they would help me so I could get back in.' The officers directed him to the border, but he still was lost. He spoke to American officials at the border and showed them his DACA documentation, and they let him through one checkpoint. His attorney said he had a picture of his employment authorization document that legally allows him to work in the U.S. According to his declaration, border officials then asked him to park his car and go into an office to check in with border officials. They took his fingerprints, Sagamani said, and put Hernandez-Rodriguez in a room with three border officers. One of the officials said he could go back into the U.S. if he paid them $800, according to his declaration and his attorney. Sagamani said that the officials were asking for a bribe. Hernandez-Rodriguez said he didn't have the money. 'They told him, 'You can call somebody and ask them for the money and then they can give it to us,'' Sigamani said. When it was clear that he could not pay them, another official handcuffed him and took him into custody, Sigamani said. In a statement, McLaughlin said, 'Erick Hernandez Rodriguez, an illegal alien from Mexico, self-deported and then tried to illegally re-enter the U.S. On June 1, 2025, CBP officers arrested Rodriguez as he tried to illegally cross the southern border.' Hernandez-Rodriguez is originally from El Salvador, not Mexico, according to a copy of his tourist visa. In response to the claim that a border official asked Hernandez-Rodriguez for a bribe, McLaughlin said, 'CBP takes all allegations of misconduct seriously, investigates thoroughly, and holds employees accountable when policies are violated. This matter has been referred to the CBP Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) for review.' On July 14, an immigration judge ordered Hernandez-Rodriguez to be removed from the country after considering a credible fear determination, a screening process given to asylum seekers who may face persecution in their home country based on their race, religion or political opinion. Hernandez-Rodriguez said he is worried that he will be singled out for discussing his political beliefs. The court considered testimony and evidence submitted, but Sigamani said that her client did not get to speak with the judge. 'They're not even letting him see a judge,' Sigamani said. 'I think that's intentional.'
Axios
5 hours ago
- Axios
Noncriminal ICE arrests surge in Washington, Oregon and Alaska
More than half of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrests last month in Washington, Oregon and Alaska involved people with no criminal charges or convictions — a sharp increase from recent norms, newly obtained data shows. Why it matters: The numbers illustrate a major shift that came soon after the Trump administration tripled ICE's arrest quota. Zoom in: In June, people without criminal charges or convictions made up an average of 53% of daily ICE arrests in the area covered by the agency's Seattle field office (Oregon, Washington and Alaska). That's up from 28% in April, before the quota increase. The average number of daily arrests for those with charges or convictions also increased in June, but not to the same degree. How it works: The data was obtained by the UC Berkeley School of Law's Deportation Data Project via Freedom of Information Act requests, and is based on seven-day trailing averages. Zoom out: As of June 26 — the most recent data available — ICE was reporting a nationwide average of 930 arrests per day, about 42% of which involved people without charges or convictions. The big picture: The spike in non-criminal ICE arrests came despite the Trump administration's claimed focus on criminals living in the country illegally. And it happened just after the Trump administration told ICE to arrest at least 3,000 people daily, up from 1,000. Context: Being in the U.S. illegally, such as by overstaying a visa, is a civil, not criminal, violation. What they're saying: Malou Chávez, executive director of the Northwest Immigrant Rights Project, told Axios the only way for ICE to meet its new quota is to arrest people who have no criminal backgrounds. That's "creating so much fear" locally — even among immigrants who aren't undocumented, she said. "The reality is they are going after anyone who they see as a potential person they can place in deportation proceedings," Chávez said. The other side: Department of Homeland Security assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin disputed reports that ICE isn't targeting criminal immigrants, telling Axios by email that some people labeled "non-criminals" are "actually terrorists, human rights abusers or gang members — they just lack a U.S. criminal record."
